BBC needs to get a grip quicker after controversies, Ofcom chief says
Dame Melanie Dawes said the corporation had "some own goals" over its handling of the punk-rap duo's performance last month and a documentary about Gaza that was withdrawn in February.
At Glastonbury Bob Vylan led a chant of "death, death to the IDF [Israel Defence Forces]" and made other derogatory comments.
The BBC previously issued an apology to viewers, especially the Jewish community, and promised to take action to "ensure proper accountability".
Reports into both broadcasts are expected to be published soon.
The review looking into the broadcast of Gaza: How to Survive a Warzone is due to be published next week, Dame Meanie said. The programme was pulled by the BBC after a link between its 13-year-old narrator and Hamas emerged.
Speaking on the BBC's Sunday With Laura Kuenssberg programme, Dame Melanie said: "I think it's very frustrating that the BBC has had some own goals in this area, with the Gaza documentary and then with the Glastonbury coverage, and it does start to erode public trust and confidence.
"I think I would say that, above all what frustrates me and others, is that when these things go wrong it can take a long time for the BBC to see that something's happened when everybody else was there within a matter of hours.
"So I would say to the BBC I think they need to get a grip quicker, get these reports and investigations concluded sooner, otherwise there is a real risk of a sort of loss of confidence in the BBC, which is a shame."
On the review into the Gaza documentary, a BBC spokesperson said findings will be published as soon as possible, adding: "It is vital that this work is done as quickly as possible, but it must also be thorough and follow a proper process."
The BBC is also expected to answer a series of questions asked by Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy over the Bob Vylan performance.
In a letter to Director General Tim Davie, Nandy asked him to explain by 14 July the broadcast delays, staffing, decisions making, contingency plans and the next steps.
The BBC also said it will no longer broadcast live performances deemed "high risk" - as Bob Vylan had been assessed - and its director of music, Lorna Clarke, also reportedly stepped back from her day-to-day duties.
Did BBC's focus on one potential Glastonbury controversy miss another?
Police launch criminal investigation into Bob Vylan and Kneecap Glastonbury sets
Asked on the programme whether Dame Melanie had faith in the BBC leadership, she replied: "I think it is a tough job at the top of the BBC.
"I think the [BBC] Board and senior team need to get a bit quicker at recognising when something has gone wrong and get a grip of the actions that they need to take or there is going to be a real risk that the BBC loses confidence in what it delivers for the public.
"We are going to have to see over the next week, I think we are expecting the Gaza report early in the coming week. We have asked a lot of questions about the Glastonbury coverage, the BBC has got a lot on its plate that it needs to address.
"I think it is important to also recognise that they do deliver a very high-quality job for the public usually, but it is these own goals that are very frustrating they need to be quicker to get on to, quicker to grip and quicker to put right."
Transport Secretary Heidi Alexander told the programme the BBC needed "to do a rapid investigation of what has happened in relation to the Glastonbury incident".
She said: "They need to do it thoroughly because at the end of the day the BBC needs to maintain the trust of its audience."
Shadow home secretary Chris Philp said Bob Vylan was "inciting violence and hatred" and suggested the BBC should be prosecuted for broadcasting the footage.
"There should be an investigation and if, in the police's opinion, the Crown Prosecution Service's opinion, there is a reasonable prospect of conviction then it should be taken to court.
"That's the right process and they should go through that, for sure. There's no exemption just because it's the BBC."
Bob Vylan dropped from Manchester music festival
Starmer criticises 'appalling' Bob Vylan IDF chants
Bob Vylan coverage should have been pulled, BBC says
Chief rabbi attacks BBC for airing 'vile Jew hate' at Glastonbury
Bob Vylan: Who are the controversial rap-punk duo?
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
24 minutes ago
- Yahoo
John Torode confirms he is man accused of racism in Gregg Wallace report
MasterChef presenter John Torode has confirmed he is the subject of an allegation of using racist language that was upheld as part of a review into the behaviour of co-presenter Gregg Wallace. The report, commissioned by MasterChef production company Banijay UK and led by law firm Lewis Silkin, found 45 out of 83 allegations against Wallace were substantiated, alongside two standalone allegations made against other people, including one for using racist language. In a post on Instagram, Torode confirmed he was the person alleged to have used racist language but said he had 'no recollection of the incident' and was 'shocked and saddened' by the allegation. His statement said: 'Following publication of the Executive Summary of the investigation into Gregg Wallace while working on MasterChef, I am aware of speculation that I am one of the two other individuals against whom an allegation has been upheld. 'For the sake of transparency, I confirm that I am the individual who is alleged to have used racial language on one occasion. The allegation is that I did so sometime in 2018 or 2019, in a social situation, and that the person I was speaking with did not believe that it was intended in a malicious way and that I apologised immediately afterwards. READ MORE: Welsh star of 28 Years Later tipped to be Hollywood's 'next big thing' READ MORE: Jeremy Clarkson's new advert banned from all TV, radio and cinemas 'I have absolutely no recollection of any of this, and I do not believe that it happened. However, I want to be clear that I've always had the view that any racial language is wholly unacceptable in any environment. I'm shocked and saddened by the allegation as I would never wish to cause anyone any offence.' Reports in The Sun said Torode had been asked to leave the show and claim he had mental health issues following the allegation. A BBC insider said they do not recognise this. It comes after Wallace said he was 'deeply sorry for any distress caused' and that he 'never set out to harm or humiliate' in the wake of the report, which included one allegation of 'unwelcome physical contact' that was upheld. In November 2024, the show's production company, Banijay UK, announced that Wallace, 60, would step away from his role on MasterChef while historical allegations of misconduct were investigated. In a statement to the PA news agency, he said: 'For eight months, my family and I have lived under a cloud. Trial by media, fuelled by rumour and clickbait. None of the serious allegations against me were upheld. I challenged the remaining issue of unwanted touching but have had to accept a difference in perception, and I am deeply sorry for any distress caused. It was never intended.' The report found that the 'majority of the allegations against Mr Wallace (94%) related to behaviour which is said to have occurred between 2005 and 2018', with only one allegation substantiated after 2018. It also concluded that the 'majority of the substantiated allegations against Mr Wallace related to inappropriate sexual language and humour', adding that 'a smaller number of allegations of other inappropriate language and being in a state of undress were also substantiated'. The report noted that during the course of the investigation, which was over a seven-month period, Wallace was diagnosed with autism spectrum disorder, and said that the findings should be viewed in the context of his neurodiversity. In his statement, Wallace added: 'I'm relieved that the Banijay report fully recognises that my behaviour changed profoundly in 2018. Some of my humour and language missed the mark. I never set out to harm or humiliate. I always tried to bring warmth and support to MasterChef, on screen and off. 'After nearly 20 years on the show, I now see that certain patterns, shaped by traits I've only recently begun to understand, may have been misread. I also accept that more could have been done, by others and by myself, to address concerns earlier. 'A late autism diagnosis has helped me understand how I communicate and how I'm perceived. I'm still learning.' He praised the show's production company, Banijay, saying they had 'given me great support, and I thank them'. The former greengrocer added: 'There will be more casualties if the BBC continues down this path, where protecting its legacy matters more than protecting people. For my part, with full legal support, I will consider my next move.' Banijay UK said that 'Wallace's return to MasterChef (is) untenable' following the number of sustained allegations. Patrick Holland, chief executive of Banijay UK, said that while the report 'makes for uncomfortable reading', it also provided 'valuable insight to ensure that going forward everyone working on our productions feels safe and supported, and that inappropriate behaviour is quickly and professionally dealt with'. The BBC also said it has 'informed' Wallace that it has 'no plans to work with him in future', adding in a statement: 'This behaviour falls below the values of the BBC and the expectations we have for anyone who works with or for us. Although the full extent of these issues were not known at the relevant time, opportunities were missed to address this behaviour, both by the production companies running MasterChef and the BBC. We accept more could and should have been done sooner.' The BBC also addressed the future of a series of MasterChef filmed last year which has not yet been aired, saying it had not made a final decision on broadcasting it. Last year, a BBC News investigation revealed a string of allegations of inappropriate sexual comments and alleged inappropriate behaviour against Wallace by 13 people who worked with him across a range of shows over a 17-year period, including former Newsnight host Kirsty Wark. A statement from Wallace's lawyers at the time said that it 'is entirely false that he engages in behaviour of a sexually harassing nature', as reported by BBC News. Ahead of the official publishing of the external review, Wallace claimed in an Instagram post on July 8, which appears to have been taken down, that he had been cleared of the 'most serious and sensational accusations' against him.
Yahoo
25 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Nadiya Hussain describes brutal BBC exit for the first time
Nadiya Hussain has spoken out on her BBC exit for the first time, claiming she felt that her TV career had been a "tickbox exercise". She claimed of her experiences with the BBC: "The second you don't fit the neat little box, there'll be no space for you. I don't fit that space any more." The baker and TV cook found fame after winning The Great British Bake Off in 2015 and went on to present a number of cooking shows at the BBC, as well as publishing recipe books. But in June, she released a statement on social media saying that she hadn't been recommissioned, adding: "As a Muslim woman, I work in an industry that doesn't always support people like me or recognise my talent or full potential." Now, Hussain has given her side of the story to Paul C. Brunson for his We Need To Talk podcast, where she also claimed to have made complaints about her treatment on unnamed shows which she says were ignored. Elsewhere, she opened up on how uncomfortable she felt walking into the Bake Off tent for the first time, her experiences with the publishing industry, and being bullied and abused during childhood. Hussain gave an account of her exit from the BBC after 10 years of making cooking shows with them, as well as a series of Remarkable Places to Eat co-hosted with Fred Sirieix. She said that she had learned to keep her TV personality "unbiased and neutral", but said: "I am not neutral. I have opinions. I have things to say." The Bake Off winner claimed: "They'll (BBC) keep you until you're of no use to them. I think that's what happened. I had lots of reasons but no definitive 'this is the reason we're not recommissioning your show'. My show got great ratings every year. I can't see why there's a reason my show wasn't recommissioned." View this post on Instagram A post shared by Nadiya (@nadiyajhussain) She continued: "My husband and I always spoke about it and he just said, 'there's going to be a point where they're not going to need you anymore. They have a neat little box and the second you don't fit the box… there'll be no space for you.' "I suppose I don't fit that space any more, and I'm not comfortable in boxes anyway. I prefer glass ceilings to smash through. I suppose there's no space for me and I'm kind of alright with that." In June, Hussain posted a video on social media where she explained that she had not been recommissioned by the BBC and that she hadn't always felt the industry was a supportive place for a Muslim woman. A BBC statement at the time read: "After several wonderful series, we have made the difficult decision not to commission another cookery show with Nadiya Hussain at the moment." However, she claimed to Brunson that the "back and forth" with the BBC over how to announce her exit had suggested something quite different. She said one email had read: "This is a proposed statement, I think Nadiya should say 'I no longer want to do my show on the BBC because I'm focussing on different projects'. I said, 'That's not the truth, though. I do not OK that statement and I'm not going to put that out.'" Read more: Nadiya Hussain 'won't always be grateful' after BBC axing (BANG Showbiz, 2 min read) BBC cancels Nadiya Hussain's cooking show (BANG Showbiz, 2 min read) Nadiya Hussain says BBC dropped her after 10 years for no 'definitive' reason (The Independent, 3 min read) Hussain has now chosen to work without an agent or team, saying: "I wanted to start from scratch as if I had won Bake Off ten years ago when I had nobody but myself, my husband and my instinct. It's been the most freeing thing to know every decision I make is my own and no one gets to filter me.I will figure it out and find a space where I'm welcome. It might not be in this industry and I'm OK with that." She also made allegations about her treatment on various shows, claiming that she had made complaints that had not been acted on. She told how feedback on one series had requested that she stop wearing jumpers because they made her appear larger, and explained why she had not pushed back. "I was always made to feel like my trophy was just going to get taken away from me, because I felt like I always had to be grateful for the opportunity that I was given. A Muslim who was relatable. The people's Muslim. The people's person of colour. The digestible version of myself. Gratitude should not sit on your face like a muzzle, and that's what it felt like, I felt muzzled." She added: "When you complain, you're considered a nuisance. They protect the men in our industry, and they make excuses for men." Hussain continued: "In every job that I've done, I've felt I look back and think they just needed to look diverse. They had the Muslim - tick. They had the person of colour - was all a tickbox exercise until they didn't need me any more." Hussain also detailed two experiences that had hugely affected her, although she did not name a particular show, broadcaster or TV star. She said: "I filed a complaint with a very big breakfast show. They were mocking a recipe out of my book. I can almost guarantee if a Jamie Oliver or James Martin was on there, they would not sit at the end of the show and mock a recipe out of their book." The recipe had been for "chaat in a bag", which the show had suggested sounded like "s*** in a bag". Hussain called the comments "really distasteful and really hateful... deeply disrespectful" but said that the show had refused to apologise. Hussain also added that she had been "quite badly bullied" by a man that she had worked with, to the point that she had such a bad panic attack that she wet the bed. She said that she had filed a complaint with the show they worked on, but that nothing happened. "I've walked on sets and heard I'm not working if she's working. I'm not working with her," she added. Yahoo UK contacted the BBC for comment on all of the claims made, although the BBC was not directly mentioned in connection with Hussain filing complaints, and the "very big breakfast show" was not named. A BBC spokesperson told Yahoo UK: "After several wonderful series we have made the difficult decision not to commission another cookery show with Nadiya Hussain at the moment. Nadiya remains a much valued part of the BBC family, and we look forward to working together on future projects." The star also spoke about feeling like her voice didn't matter when her idea for a book about parenting children with two cultures was turned down by a publisher, and said that when she published her book Rooza with recipes for Ramadhan, various brand partnerships dried up. Hussain spoke about feeling uncomfortable as the only Muslim woman on her series of Bake Off, recalling: "I walked into the tent and was like, 'oh great'. I know that feeling, I know what it's like to be me and to walk into a room of people who all feel familiar to each other, but I felt like the alien...I stuck out like a sore thumb, and I felt different." She added: "My whole life I've constantly shrunk myself to make everyone else feel comfortable. So even when I was in that tent, I would speak, but I would try so hard not to sound like I was from Luton. I was like, sound as not bilingual as possible. Pronounce your Ts. Speak slowly. Say every word properly. I'm thinking that while trying to bake, while being judged." "I want to say that I stepped away feeling like my self-worth was at its best and I felt amazing," she continued. "But what happened to me so quickly after winning Bake Off was that I fell into a career I never expected to have and didn't want. Winning Bake Off did not prepare me for the cesspit that it is to be in the public eye. Hussain told how at one point production staff had to live in her family home with her as she had received death threats, and she had to have panic buttons installed. But she said that her TV work had been important, saying: "I didn't know how important it was to be the voice for the voiceless." She added of her children: "I tell them, 'elbows are going to work 10 times harder for 10 times less than everyone else.' I know because I have worked 10 times harder than others in my industry for 10 times less." Paul C. Brunson's We Need To Talk podcast is available to stream now.
Yahoo
38 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Tim Davie condemns ‘serious racist term' used by John Torode
BBC director-general Tim Davie has condemned the 'serious racist term' used by presenter John Torode, after it was announced his contract on MasterChef will not be renewed. Australian-born Torode, 59, started presenting MasterChef alongside Gregg Wallace in 2005. On Monday night, Torode confirmed he was the subject of an allegation of using racist language that was upheld as part of a review carried out by law firm Lewis Silkin into the alleged behaviour of his co-presenter Wallace. In an interview with BBC News on Tuesday, Davie said he saw the situation as an opportunity for the corporation to 'reset'. He said he was not directly involved with the matter but was told about the recommendation not to renew Torode's contract and was 'happy that the team were taking action'. He went on: 'It's really important that we are taking this seriously. It's a reset where we make sure that people are living up to the values we expect across the board.' Asked exactly what Torode said, Davie replied: 'I'm not going to give you the exact term, because I think, frankly it was serious racist term, a serious racist term, which does not get to be acceptable in any way, shape or form.' A statement from production company Banijay UK released earlier said: 'In response to John Torode's statement, it is important to stress that Banijay UK takes this matter incredibly seriously. 'The legal team at Lewis Silkin that investigated the allegations relating to Gregg Wallace also substantiated an accusation of highly offensive racist language against John Torode which occurred in 2018. 'This matter has been formally discussed with John Torode by Banijay UK, and whilst we note that John says he does not recall the incident, Lewis Silkin have upheld the very serious complaint. 'Banijay UK and the BBC are agreed that we will not renew his contract on MasterChef.' The Lewis Silkin report, commissioned by Banijay UK, found 45 out of 83 allegations against Wallace were substantiated, alongside two standalone allegations made against other people, including one for using racist language. Torode confirmed on Monday night he was the person alleged to have used racist language but said he had 'no recollection of the incident' and was 'shocked and saddened' by the allegation. A BBC spokesperson said: 'John Torode has identified himself as having an upheld allegation of using racist language against him. 'This allegation – which involves an extremely offensive racist term being used in the workplace – was investigated and substantiated by the independent investigation led by the law firm Lewis Silkin. John Torode denies the allegation. 'He has stated he has no recollection of the alleged incident and does not believe that it happened. He also says that any racial language is wholly unacceptable in any environment. 'The BBC takes this upheld finding extremely seriously. We will not tolerate racist language of any kind and, as we have already said, we told Banijay UK, the makers of MasterChef, that action must be taken. 'John Torode's contract on MasterChef will not be renewed.' Davie insisted MasterChef does have a future with the broadcaster beyond 2028, when its current deal runs out, while presenting the corporation's 2024/2025 annual report earlier on Tuesday. Davie said: 'I absolutely think it does (have a future), I think a great programme that's loved by audiences is much bigger than individuals. 'It absolutely can survive and prosper, but we've got to make sure we're in the right place in terms of the culture of the show.' Downing Street has said it 'utterly condemns' any instance of racist language after the allegation made against Torode was upheld. 'When it comes to racism (it) clearly has no place at the BBC or anywhere in society, and we utterly condemn any instances of racist language or abuse in the strongest possible terms,' Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer's official spokesman said. 'And it's obviously up to the BBC, who are operationally independent from Government, to take forward any necessary next steps.' It comes after the BBC addressed the future of a series of MasterChef filmed last year, which has not yet been aired, on Monday, saying they had not made a final decision on broadcasting it. A spokesperson for the corporation said: 'We know this is disappointing for fans of the show and those who took part, and at the appropriate time Banijay UK will consult further with the amateur contestants.' The MasterChef upheaval comes as the BBC faces scrutiny over the Gaza: How To Survive A Warzone documentary which, after a review, was found to have breached the corporation's editorial guidelines on accuracy. The corporation has also been criticised over its coverage of Glastonbury, particularly the live stream of punk duo Bob Vylan's set, during which singer Bobby Vylan, whose real name is reportedly Pascal Robinson-Foster, led crowds in chants of 'death, death to the IDF (Israel Defence Forces)'. In 2022, Torode was made an MBE in the Queen's Birthday Honours, for services to food and charity. He became a familiar face to TV audiences in 1996 as the resident chef on ITV's This Morning, before joining MasterChef alongside Wallace when it was known as MasterChef Goes Large.
