Inter Kashi named as I-League champions after CAS ruling against Churchill Brothers
Churchill Brothers drop to second despite leading the table
ISL promotion awaits, but league's future remains in limbo
Inter Kashi have officially been declared the 2024–25 I-League champions after the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) ruled in their favour, overturning the AIFF Appeal Committee's earlier decision that had handed the title to Churchill Brothers.
With the verdict, Inter Kashi's final tally climbs to 42 points, putting them above Churchill Brothers on goal difference and earning them direct promotion to the Indian Super League. It marks a stunning end to one of the most tightly contested and drama-filled I-League seasons in recent memoryâ€'and a historic achievement for a club playing its first top-tier campaign. The yellow card that started the saga
The controversy stemmed from Inter Kashi's 2-1 loss to Namdhari FC on January 13. Weeks later, Kashi alleged that Namdhari had fielded Brazilian midfielder Cledson Carvalho da Silva, who had accumulated three yellow cards and should have been suspended for that match.
The AIFF Disciplinary Committee initially ruled in Kashi's favour and awarded them three points. But confusion erupted when Namdhari claimed the player wasn't listed as suspended on the official AIFF portal. The ruling was paused on March 27, and the matter snowballed into a season-defining dispute.
When the AIFF Appeal Committee stepped in, it reversed the earlier decision and reinstated the original match result. That verdict meant Churchill Brothersâ€'who had finished with 40 pointsâ€'were named provisional champions, while Inter Kashi, with 39, dropped to second. The CAS appeal timeline: Two wins from Lausanne
Unwilling to let the decision stand, Inter Kashi took the matter to the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) in Switzerland. They first appealed the AIFF Appeal Committee's rulingâ€'and won. CAS restored the three points from the Namdhari match, taking Kashi's total to 42, pushing them ahead of Churchill Brothers.
However, even after the ruling, the AIFF had not officially named Inter Kashi as champions. So the club returned to CAS with a second appealâ€'seeking formal confirmation of their title win.
On July 18, CAS issued a clear directive: 'The AIFF shall forthwith declare Inter Kashi FC as winner of the I-League 2024–25 season.'
With that, Churchill Brothers drop to second place, and Real Kashmir and Gokulam Keralaâ€'both ending with 37 pointsâ€'round off what was one of the most tightly fought seasons in recent I-League history.
By logic and precedent, Inter Kashi now earn promotion to the Indian Super League. But here's the twist: the ISL itself faces an uncertain future. With the roadmap for league integration and promotion still murky, and discussions ongoing between the AIFF and stakeholders, Kashi's hard-fought triumph feels slightly muted. They've won the warâ€'but for now, the battlefield beyond remains foggy.
Inter Kashi have officially been declared the 2024–25 I-League champions after the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) ruled in their favour, overturning the AIFF Appeal Committee's earlier decision that had handed the title to Churchill Brothers.
With the verdict, Inter Kashi's final tally climbs to 42 points, putting them above Churchill Brothers on goal difference and earning them direct promotion to the Indian Super League. It marks a stunning end to one of the most tightly contested and drama-filled I-League seasons in recent memoryâ€'and a historic achievement for a club playing its first top-tier campaign. The yellow card that started the saga
The controversy stemmed from Inter Kashi's 2-1 loss to Namdhari FC on January 13. Weeks later, Kashi alleged that Namdhari had fielded Brazilian midfielder Cledson Carvalho da Silva, who had accumulated three yellow cards and should have been suspended for that match.
The AIFF Disciplinary Committee initially ruled in Kashi's favour and awarded them three points. But confusion erupted when Namdhari claimed the player wasn't listed as suspended on the official AIFF portal. The ruling was paused on March 27, and the matter snowballed into a season-defining dispute.
When the AIFF Appeal Committee stepped in, it reversed the earlier decision and reinstated the original match result. That verdict meant Churchill Brothersâ€'who had finished with 40 pointsâ€'were named provisional champions, while Inter Kashi, with 39, dropped to second. The CAS appeal timeline: Two wins from Lausanne
Unwilling to let the decision stand, Inter Kashi took the matter to the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) in Switzerland. They first appealed the AIFF Appeal Committee's rulingâ€'and won. CAS restored the three points from the Namdhari match, taking Kashi's total to 42, pushing them ahead of Churchill Brothers.
However, even after the ruling, the AIFF had not officially named Inter Kashi as champions. So the club returned to CAS with a second appealâ€'seeking formal confirmation of their title win.
On July 18, CAS issued a clear directive: 'The AIFF shall forthwith declare Inter Kashi FC as winner of the I-League 2024–25 season.'
With that, Churchill Brothers drop to second place, and Real Kashmir and Gokulam Keralaâ€'both ending with 37 pointsâ€'round off what was one of the most tightly fought seasons in recent I-League history.
By logic and precedent, Inter Kashi now earn promotion to the Indian Super League. But here's the twist: the ISL itself faces an uncertain future. With the roadmap for league integration and promotion still murky, and discussions ongoing between the AIFF and stakeholders, Kashi's hard-fought triumph feels slightly muted. They've won the warâ€'but for now, the battlefield beyond remains foggy. Join our WhatsApp Channel
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
Hamid's goal takes East Bengal into Durand Cup quarters
1 2 Kolkata: Moroccan newcomer Hamid Ahadad scored on debut as East Bengal FC subdued high-flying Namdhari FC 1-0 at the Salt Lake Stadium on Wednesday, becoming the first team to advance to the quarterfinals of this year's Durand Cup. The all-important goal came in the 68th minute when Namdhari goalkeeper Niraj Kumar missed the flight of a corner kick taken by another red-and-gold debutant Miguel Ferreira and Hamid — who replaced Greek forward Dimitrios Diamantakos seven minutes earlier — headed it home and send home fans in the stands into rapture. While Namdhari finished their Group A engagements with two wins and one loss, Oscar Bruzon's team — also on six points now — assured itself of topping the group by dint of head-to-head superiority and qualifying for the knockout stage with a game in hand. You Can Also Check: Kolkata AQI | Weather in Kolkata | Bank Holidays in Kolkata | Public Holidays in Kolkata Indian Air Force and South United FC — other two teams of the group — are already out of the knockout race with one point each. Wednesday's scoreline, however, barely reflected true narrative of the contest. Not only did East Bengal miss a chance to win by a much bigger margin, it could have also easily been a more remarkable debut for Miguel, who rejoined the Spanish coach Bruzon following their successive stint with Bangladesh's Bashundhara Kings. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Free P2,000 GCash eGift UnionBank Credit Card Apply Now Undo The Brazilian attacker was denied by the post not once, but thrice, in the first half itself. That East Bengal enjoyed almost 70% of possessions and Namdhari finished the game without having a shot on goal told a whole different story. Namdhari came into the match with back-to-back wins. But Bruzon started with four foreigners — Miguel, Saul Crespo, Diamantakos and Mohamad Rashid — in a move aimed at gaining early ascendancy. They duly started on the front foot, dominating the proceedings with consummate ease but their search for early goals failed to bear fruit. Miguel represented the team's attacking aspirations, hitting the post with his left-footed scorcher from 22 yards in the 21st minute. The Brazilian came calling again soon, but his two headers were denied by the woodwork again. Dominating with possession but without luck, Bruzon signalled Hamid to get ready and the Moroccan came, saw and changed the complexion of the game. Namdhari — who focused mainly on defending in numbers — tried to find a route back into the contest using their Brazilian striker Cledson Degol and Ghanaian defender Lamine Moro in set-pieces. But Bruzon introduced another debutant, Argentine defender Kevin Sibille, and Souvik Chakrabarti to ensure that their passage to the knockouts was not queered.
News18
7 hours ago
- News18
Durand Cup 2025: East Bengal Edge Past Namdhari To Move Closer To Knockouts
Last Updated: East Bengal FC beat Namdhari FC 1-0 in the Durand Cup with Hamid Ahadad's debut goal. East Bengal leads Group A with six points, dominating possession despite Namdhari's defense. East Bengal FC took a significant step towards qualifying for the knockout stages of the 134th Durand Cup with a hard-fought 1–0 victory over a determined Namdhari FC in a Group A clash at the Vivekananda Yuba Bharati Krirangan on Wednesday. Making his debut for the Red and Golds, Moroccan forward Hamid Ahadad came off the bench to score the decisive goal in the 68th minute, marking a memorable first appearance. The win was East Bengal's second in as many matches, taking them to the top of Group A with six points and a healthy goal difference of +6. Head coach Oscar Bruzon rang in four changes from their opening fixture, handing starts to goalkeeper Prabhsukhan Singh Gill, Brazilian midfielder Miguel Figueira, Greek striker Dimitrios Diamantakos, and winger Bipin Singh. Namdhari FC, still reeling from suspensions, made two forced changes. Skipper Akashdeep Singh returned to bolster the defence, while Manish Chaudhary was included in the attack in place of the suspended Manbir Singh. From the outset, East Bengal dominated possession and pinned Namdhari deep inside their half. However, goalkeeper Niraj Kumar produced a sensational performance to keep the favourites at bay. In the ninth minute, he rushed off his line to deny Diamantakos, and minutes later cut off a dangerous low cross from Bipin Singh to thwart a clear chance. Midfielder Mohammed Rashid tested him with a fierce shot in the 17th minute, before Miguel Figueira rattled the post twice—once from distance and again with a header. In the 39th minute, Niraj denied Saul Crespo from close range before watching Miguel hit the crossbar yet again with a thunderous header. Despite wave after wave of East Bengal attacks, Namdhari's deep defensive setup—anchored by their keeper's brilliance—kept the game goalless at halftime. Substitute Ahadad Breaks the Deadlock East Bengal resumed the second half in similar fashion, searching relentlessly for the breakthrough. After another saved effort from Diamantakos and a rare Namdhari chance that Dharmpreet Singh fired wide, Bruzon made a tactical switch—bringing on Hamid Ahadad in the 61st minute. The Moroccan wasted no time making his mark. In the 68th minute, Miguel Figueira swung in a corner which Niraj misjudged, allowing Ahadad to head in unchallenged at the far post. East Bengal continued to press for a second goal, but Namdhari remained compact, avoiding further damage. With the win, East Bengal moved to six points from two matches and remain firmly in control of their knockout destiny. Namdhari, who have also registered two wins in three games, remain in contention with six points and a goal difference of +3. They can still progress as one of the two best second-placed teams. (with PTI inputs) About the Author Siddarth Sriram First Published: August 06, 2025, 23:35 IST
NDTV
8 hours ago
- NDTV
Durand Cup: Debut Goal From Hamid Ahadad Seals Crucial Win For East Bengal
East Bengal FC moved a step closer to securing a knockout berth at the 134th Durand Cup with a narrow 1-0 win over a resilient Namdhari FC in a tightly contested Group A match on Wednesday. Moroccan forward Hamid Ahadad, making his debut for the Red and Gold brigade, came off the bench to score the decisive goal in the 68th minute at the Vivekananda Yuba Bharati Krirangan, handing East Bengal their second consecutive win of the tournament. Head coach Oscar Bruzon made four changes to his lineup from their previous match, handing starts to goalkeeper Prabhsukhan Singh Gill, Brazilian midfielder Miguel Figueira, and Greek striker Dimitrios Diamantakos and Bipin Singh up front. Namdhari's Harpreet Singh, meanwhile, made two enforced changes, bringing in skipper Akashdeep Singh in defence and Manish Chaudhary in attack, as suspended defender Manbir Singh missed out. The match kicked off with East Bengal taking immediate control, camping in the Namdhari half and creating chance after chance, only to be denied repeatedly by an inspired performance from goalkeeper Niraj Kumar. In the ninth minute, Niraj was quick off his line to deny Diamantakos, and minutes later, intercepted a dangerous ball from Bipin Singh meant for Saul Crespo. The barrage continued, with Mohammed Rashid's powerful 17th-minute strike forcing another save, before Miguel Figueira struck the post twice in quick succession, once with a long-range effort and once with a header. A Crespo attempt from a Mahesh freekick in the 39th was again stopped by Niraj on reflex, before Miguel hit the crossbar a third time with a bullet header in the 42nd minute. Despite relentless pressure, Namdhari's deep defensive block held firm and the score remained 0-0 at half time, thanks in large part to Niraj Kumar's heroics and a bit of good fortune. East Bengal resumed the second half in similar fashion, dominating possession and looking for the breakthrough. Diamantakos had a weak shot saved in the 52nd minute before Namdhari's Dharmpreet Singh fired wide in their only real chance in the opening exchanges of the second half. Sensing the need for a spark, Bruzon brought on Hamid Ahadad for Diamantakos in the 61st minute. The Moroccan made an instant impact just seven minutes later, when Miguel Figueira's corner found him unmarked at the far post. Niraj misjudged the flight of the ball, and Ahadad nodded home with ease to break the deadlock and open his account for the club. The win saw East Bengal top Group A with six points and goal difference of 6 from two matches, while Namdhari remain in contention with two wins from three (six points and GD of 3), as two best second place teams in the group stage will make it to the quarterfinals. ITBP hold Punjab FC to a goal-less draw In the day's other match, in Assam's Kokrajhar, ITBP held Punjab FC to a goal-less draw in a Group D contest at the SAI Stadium. Punjab FC were wasteful in front of goal, failing to convert their chances as ITBP showcased resilient defending to secure a hard earned point. Both teams have four points from two matches and will now face Bodoland FC in their remaining group stage matches.
