Lucy Letby: Who to Believe? review — a rigorous look at the evidence
Lucy Letby: Who to Believe? (BBC1) was an impressive, rigorous attempt to cut through the noise and the maze of information and take a calm, dispassionate look at the evidence. This is the third programme that the journalists Judith Moritz and Jonathan Coffey have made about Letby, as well as writing a book, and their proficiency showed when they were interviewing medical experts and Letby's new defence barrister Mark McDonald who, along with an international panel of experts, asserts that not only is there no evidence against Letby, there is no substantial evidence that any crimes took place. There are plausible, alternative explanations for the babies' deaths, they say.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
23 minutes ago
- BBC News
Man admits murder after homeless assault victim died years later
A man who was jailed 12 years ago for brutally assaulting a homeless man has now admitted murder after his victim died of injuries related to the 2012 Ellis, 36, received a 12-and-a-half year sentence in August 2013 for causing grievous bodily harm with intent to Igor Pavlov in Whitworth Park in Rusholme, Pavlov died aged 52 on 3 July 2023 while Ellis was still serving his original Manchester Crown Court he admitted the new charge of murder and will be sentenced on 27 August. In the original trial the prosecution said Ellis's attack was an "act of senseless violence" which caused the victim life-threatening injuries and left him with "very severe" brain damage and needing specialist care court heard Ellis had gone to the park after a family argument and hit Mr Pavlov repeatedly with an "unknown" object as he sat on a Pavlov suffered a fractured skull which left him in a coma for Frances Birch said: "The final, devastating consequences of Anthony Ellis's brutal attack on Igor Pavlov came more than a decade after the event - but the Crown Prosecution Service was determined to bring Ellis to book for murder all the same."The strength of the evidence, including medical evidence around the cause of Mr Pavlov's death, meant Ellis had no option but to admit murdering Mr Pavlov."Ellis now faces a lengthy prison sentence for his senseless act of violence, which has ultimately robbed a man of his life."Our thoughts remain with those who knew and cared for Mr Pavlov." Listen to the best of BBC Radio Manchester on Sounds and follow BBC Manchester on Facebook, X, and Instagram. You can also send story ideas via Whatsapp to 0808 100 2230.
BBC News
23 minutes ago
- BBC News
Austin Ironside: Man charged with murder after death in Aberdeen
A man has appeared in court charged with murder of a 25-year-old man who was fatally injured in Ironside was taken to Aberdeen Royal Infirmary after emergency services were called to Skene Street on Sunday 3 August. He died two days Adams, 46, appeared at Aberdeen Sheriff Court where he was charged with murder and made no plea and was remanded in custody.
Sky News
44 minutes ago
- Sky News
Men jailed after kidnapping pregnant mum and threatening to cut her fingers off
Three men have been jailed after kidnapping a pregnant mother from outside her north London home and threatening to cut her fingers off, police have said. Audi Johnson, 35, Ahmad Ghiasi, 26, and Nicholas Mitchell, 55, were members of a London-based gang that was contracted to carry out the abduction in Enfield on the morning of 10 May last year, the force added. The 36-year-old victim, who has not been named, was bundled into the back of a white Ford Transit van before being blindfolded and bound at the wrist with cable ties by the gang as they sped away. They then fired questions at her about her partner where one of them threatened: "If you lie to me I'm gonna kick the baby out your stomach." The men later made a series of phone calls to her partner as they threatened to cut off her fingers if he did not quickly carry out their demands for money and valuable jewellery, the Metropolitan Police said. Johnson, Ghiasi and Mitchell were found guilty of conspiracy to kidnap last month after a six-week trial at Kingston Crown Court. Mother will 'never be the same again' The victim said she has not been able to go home since the traumatic ordeal and spent the rest of her pregnancy sleeping on her sister's couch. In her impact statement, she told the court: "The incident ruined my life. I will never be the same person again. I am having to start my life all over again. "I will forever have fear and paranoia as part of my life now. I didn't deserve to be a victim of what happened to me. And to top it off, it was all made so much worse by being pregnant. "This will always be something that will be part of my pregnancy, which is meant to be a happy experience, and will always be something that is a part of my daughter." The victim was kidnapped as she waited for a cab to take her to a personal training session with her mother and sister. She was walking along the curb close to her home when she was suddenly grabbed and thrown into the back of the van. Despite being blindfolded and bound at the wrist, when the woman was left alone in the van she managed to escape before flagging down a cab and travelling to the safety of her mother's house. A police spokesman said the Met's Flying Squad responded to the crime immediately. They tracked the van using CCTV and located the vehicle the same night the woman managed to escape. DNA evidence, fingerprint impressions and mobile phone data were used to identify the suspects. The police said Johnson, of Cranberry Close, Northolt, had pleaded guilty to conspiracy to kidnap and was sentenced to five years and four months. Ghiasi, of Fourth Avenue, Luton, was sentenced to seven years for conspiracy to kidnap.
