Adam: Was Chandra Arya right all along to court India's Modi?
Article content
The case remains under investigation by the RCMP, and Sikhs around the country see Carney's invitation as a betrayal. But the irony of Modi's visit may not be lost on former Nepean Liberal MP Chandra Arya.
Article content
Article content
Article content
His nomination for the Nepean riding in the April federal election was revoked for, among other things, alleged ties to India, including a controversial meeting with Modi in 2024. (And of course, Carney then ran in Nepean and won). Now that the Liberal government's posture toward Modi has changed, it raises interesting questions. If I were Arya, I'd be wondering why I lost my seat for trying to maintain ties to Modi, when Carney is now rolling out the red carpet to the very same Indian prime minister.
Article content
Arya, a three-time Liberal MP, was first disqualified from running in the party's leadership race. The party did not explicitly explain why Arya's nomination was blocked, but said that candidates could be disqualified if they were deemed to be 'manifestly unfit for the office of leader of the party' due to 'public statements, past improper conduct, lack of commitment to democracy, or other reputational or legal jeopardy.' The inference was that Arya had behaved improperly, but the decision raised eyebrows because the MP had never been publicly accused or cited for misconduct over his decade-long career. Then the other shoe dropped, as the Liberal party revoked his nomination in Nepean without any publicly stated reason, paving the way for Carney's run.
Article content
Article content
Article content
Arya's troubles began last year when, amid deteriorating diplomatic relations between Canada and India following the Nijjar assassination, and allegations of Indian government involvement, the MP travelled to India and met with Modi. It was no doubt an inopportune time to travel there, and the visit was disavowed by Global Affairs Canada. After that, it was not difficult to connect the dots and come to some understanding of why Arya fell out of favour with Liberal party. Indeed, multiple reports suggested that Arya's fate was sealed by that visit.
Article content
Article content
But if Arya was punished for his ties to India, including the meeting with Modi, how does it look now with the Indian prime minister jetting to Canada at Carney's invitation, meeting with the Canadian prime minister, and discussing the resumption of diplomatic relations broken at the height of the Nijjar killing. Remember, Modi is the man who leads a government accused of masterminding a campaign of violence in Canada, including assassination of a Canadian citizen, and yet the prime minister is happy to embrace him.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Toronto Star
an hour ago
- Toronto Star
Canada didn't push for plastic production cap in talks on global treaty
OTTAWA - Canadian officials negotiating a global treaty on plastic pollution at the United Nations say they didn't push other countries to adopt a cap on plastic production. The sixth round of talks wrapped up in Geneva today without consensus on a legally-binding international treaty.
Winnipeg Free Press
an hour ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Canada didn't push for plastic production cap in talks on global treaty
OTTAWA – Canadian officials negotiating a global treaty on plastic pollution at the United Nations say they didn't push other countries to adopt a cap on plastic production. The sixth round of talks wrapped up in Geneva today without consensus on a legally-binding international treaty. The negotiations started in 2022 and Canada has been instrumental in bringing countries to the table, having hosted the fourth round of talks in 2024. In a technical briefing today, Environment Canada officials said they know that many countries are opposed to a production cap — so Canada didn't press the issue. Reuters reported last week that the United States was circulating a memo to other countries urging them to reject any treaty which imposes limits on plastic production and plastic chemical additives. Canadian officials said Friday that they saw no such memo. This report by The Canadian Press was first published Aug. 15, 2025.
Global News
2 hours ago
- Global News
Conservatives call for inquiry into ‘appalling' government spending on Canadian ISIS women
The Conservatives are calling for an inquiry into the government's 'appalling' expenditures on Canadian ISIS women returning home from Syria. A letter signed by Tory MPs on Friday asked the Standing Committee on Public Safety and National Security to convene immediately to deal with the matter. The move came after Global News reported that declassified documents showed Ottawa spent at least $170,000 on the women and their children. The money paid for costs incurred when eight women who had travelled to Syria to join the Islamic State returned to Canada with their kids in 2022 and 2023. Expense reports released under the Access to Information Act showed business class flights, stays at a Marriott hotel, room service, junk food and alcohol. Among the expenses, which were for both the families and government staff, was a $95 wine tab, $24 sandwiches and purchases of chips, chocolate bars and Timbits, as well as a $2,800 catering fee for a banquet. Story continues below advertisement 'The fact that these items were purchased for those detained as alleged terrorists is appalling in itself,' the MPs wrote in a letter addressed to committee chair Jean-Yves Duclos. Get daily National news Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy 'With Canadians lining up in food banks in record numbers and struggling with housing costs, the Liberal government must answer for why they spent $170,000 on lavish costs to repatriate reported ISIS criminals.' View image in full screen Expense reports released under Access to Information Act on costs of repatriating Canadian ISIS women and their kids. Global News The letter, obtained by Global News, said the opposition was 'calling for the committee to be immediately recalled to launch a full inquiry into this matter.' Under parliamentary rules, if four members of a committee, representing at least two political parties, request a meeting, the clerk must do so within five days. The Bloc representatives of the committee would have to sign on before it would prompt a meeting. Story continues below advertisement Global News requested details on the costs of the repatriations under the Access to Information Act two years ago. The department did not release any materials until Aug. 7, 2025. Even then, they do not cover the full costs associated with the repatriation. Global Affairs Canada said it was still consulting with a foreign government about releasing those. The women were living in B.C., Alberta, Ontario and Quebec when they travelled to Syria and Iraq to live under ISIS rule. All were eventually captured when ISIS fell to U.S.-backed Kurdish fighters and an international coalition that included the Canadian Forces. The federal government agreed to bring the women and children back to Canada after their families launched a case in the Federal Court demanding their return. In a statement to Global News, Global Affairs declined to answer questions about its expenses or disclose the full costs associated with repatriating the Canadians. 'While we cannot comment on specific expenditures related to the operation, Global Affairs Canada assumed certain immediate costs to support the safe return and well-being of the women and children repatriated to Canada,' it said.
