‘Sheridan's arguments are very, very wrong,' says Sophie Toscan du Plantier family in shock new claims as film premieres
They also fear a new movie inspired by the
Advertisement
6
Ian Bailey was arrested over Sophie's murder at her holiday home
Credit: AFP
6
Sophie was murdered on December 23, 1996, near Schull in Co Cork
Credit: PA
6
Jim Sheridan's new film, Re-Creation, premiered in New York earlier this month
Credit: Getty
Jim Sheridan's new film, Re-Creation, premiered at the Tribeca Film Festival in New York earlier this month.
He said that it was not intended to cause any distress to the Toscan du Plantier family, adding: 'I'm not trying to upset them, I'm not trying to do anything to them.'
Advertisement
But he says there's not a 'shred of evidence' against
The 39-year-old had suffered brutal injuries in a gruesome killing that shocked both Ireland and France.
The
A French court convicted Bailey in absentia in 2019, but he was never extradited over there after the High
Advertisement
Sophie's uncle Jean-Pierre Gazeau insists he does not want to react to everything Sheridan says.
But in an interview with The Irish Sun, Jean-Pierre said on one occasion he spoke to Sheridan, who told him about a 'scenario' and he insisted it was 'complete fantasy.'
He explained that the problem with Sheridan's movie is that it will be watched by many people not aware of the evidence against Bailey.
Jean-Pierre told us: 'Many people are going to listen to him, agree with him, but without any deep knowledge of the investigation file.
'A LOT OF CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE'
'There was a very high level of circumstantial evidence against Bailey. There is no direct proof like DNA, but there is a lot of circumstantial evidence.
Advertisement
'I think, to some extent, we cannot at all agree with the current behaviour of Jim Sheridan.'
Two investigations remain ongoing in Ireland, one by a local team of
Jean-Pierre went on: 'Jim Sheridan has his own opinion. Of course, we completely disagree. We disagree about the fact he's made a movie while there are still investigations continuing in Ireland.
'There are two teams, you know, and they are really doing a lot of work. So I think the most reasonable attitude would be to wait.
'We heard arguments given by Sheridan many times, which are wrong, totally wrong.'
Advertisement
Jean-Pierre pointed towards the interviewing of Sophie's estranged husband Daniel and also that a witness in the case, Marie Farrell, had not been called over for the French proceedings.
Ms Farrell claimed that she saw Bailey at Kealfadda Bridge near the murder scene on the night in question. But she later retracted statements given to gardai.
'IT'S NOT TRUE'
Jean-Pierre added: 'When Jim Sheridan says that Daniel Toscan du Plantier was never interviewed by the Gardai, it's not true.
'He went to Ireland to be interviewed by the Gardai in 1998, so it's completely wrong.
'Another example is when he says that during the French trial, the French justice had to invite Marie Farrell to give her statement. It was the role of the defence to invite her as a witness. So it's completely wrong.'
Advertisement
Jean-Pierre explained that, to 'some extent', the question of who killed Sophie was solved in 2019 at the French trial.
But he insists it was the 'responsibility' of Bailey himself and Irish authorities to extradite him to defend himself in fresh proceedings.
He said: 'If Bailey had been expelled to come to France, he would have had the right of a new trial with a full defence.'
Sheridan said the new movie, which stars Aidan Gillen and Colm Meaney, will reveal new info about Sophie's death.
6
Sophie's uncle Jean-Pierre Gazeau insists he does not want to react to everything Sheridan says
Credit: PA
Advertisement
6
Sheridan said the new movie, which stars Aidan Gillen and Colm Meaney, will reveal new info about Sophie's death
Credit: PR Handout image
6
Sophie was murdered at the house in 1996
Credit: Arthur Edwards / The Sun
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sunday World
2 hours ago
- Sunday World
Belfast man missing for over two weeks found alive in Paris
It's understood Robert Kincaid is currently receiving treatment at a medical facility in the French capital A Belfast man who had been missing for over two weeks has been found alive in Paris, his family has confirmed. It's understood Robert Kincaid is currently receiving treatment at a medical facility in the French capital. The 38-year-old, from the Tullycarnet area, was due to arrive in Dublin on the evening of July 17 but never boarded his flight. Robert Kincaid News in 90 Seconds, Friday August 1 The oil rig worker was returning from a stint working at a west African site in Benin and was set to board his connecting flight from Charles De Gaulle airport in Paris. On Friday the family confirmed that Robert had been found by emergency services. In a statement to Belfast Live, Robert's brother Louis said: 'Rab has been found by emergency services and is requiring ongoing emergency treatment. While he is not out of the woods yet, we are just glad he is alive. "As a family, we would ask for privacy in the time ahead as we deal with the situation.' In a post on Facebook, DUP leader Gavin Robinson said the news was a 'massive relief' for the family. "I've been with the Kincaid family this afternoon,' he said. 'They are delighted Robert has been found and are incredibly grateful for the public interest and community support. 'They would now appreciate privacy as they reunite with their son.' Louis and a family friend flew to Paris on Wednesday to meet with British officials and assist in the search. Ahead of the trip, he told this newspaper his last known point of contact was a video call with a friend made from a bar in the airport. He said: 'I think he was in the airport bar having a chat basically. As far as I'm aware, there was nothing bad said, there was nothing suspicious said.' A friend video-called Robert again, although a stranger answered the phone instead. 'It looked like [they were in] a tin corrugated roof building. They basically said the phone [battery] was on 0% in broken English,' Louis explained. The second and final call made to Robert's phone was picked up by a woman, but the caller was unable to make out what was said before the line was cut off. 'He doesn't have any contacts in France, but he is a very sociable person, he would make friends with anyone,' his brother added.
Irish Examiner
4 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Lies spread on social media led to attack on man in Limerick
An Afghan man was assaulted in Limerick after baseless claims were spread about him on social media. The 64-year-old man received injuries, including a broken nose, in the attack in early July, following claims online that he had been behaving inappropriately towards children, a claim which was later debunked by gardaí. Analysis of the online discussions around the incident, conducted jointly by the Hope and Courage Collective and Doras, shows how social media, racial profiling and co-ordinated vigilante activity led to the attack. The man, who is seeking international protection in Ireland, was harassed, filmed, and publicly identified before the assault following a fabricated Facebook post which accused him of inappropriate behaviour towards children. Within hours, the claim was pushed across TikTok, Instagram and X with one video reaching over 249,000 views. On July 1, he was surrounded and assaulted in public, sustaining a broken nose and later relocated for his own safety. Self-proclaimed 'community watch' groups filmed the man, circulated his image and framed the assault as a 'citizen's arrest". The report's authors say that "despite multiple reports, violent content remained online". 'This was not a one-off incident. It is the result of a disinformation network that uses fear and racism to justify violence,' said Edel McGinley, Director of Hope and Courage Collective, which monitors far right activity. What we're seeing is the rise of co-ordinated vigilantism in Ireland, hiding behind the language of community safety. In the days prior to the attack, the victim was harassed in a local park, and filmed, with footage posted to social media. A false allegation began on the afternoon of Sunday, June 29, when a woman uploaded a photo of the man alongside a fabricated story. This led to a member of the self-styled "community watch" group Sinne Na Daoine calling on the "men of Limerick" to "protect its own". By the following day, a prominent Irish far right account on X claimed in a post that a 'Muslim was cat calling children in People's Park' and said the slow Garda response was 'pushing society into vigilantism'. The post was viewed 190,400 times before being deleted. After the original post was circulated, a group confronted the Afghan man and called the Gardaí while filming, but the man walked to the station himself for his own safety. Later, a video showing him leaving the station was misrepresented as a 'citizen's arrest'. 'This man was seeking safety in Ireland and instead found himself at the centre of an online disinformation campaign that turned violent,' said John Lannon, chief executive of the migrant support group, Doras. He was treated with suspicion, fear, and hostility simply because of how he looked. The report found that the victim was later re-identified and harassed again in a different city. The authors of the report said that "what is evident in this case is that the Irish far right uses neutral incidents to frame a false and dangerous narrative that is used to justify profiling, harassment and violent assault". Ms McGinley said that disinformation is amplified online and called on European Commissioner Michael McGrath to intervene. 'As a matter of urgency we need to tackle the toxic recommender system that pushes hate and disinformation into people's social media feeds. People should be able to have control of what they see, not companies, driven by profit."
The Irish Sun
4 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
PSG star Achraf Hakimi facing rape charge after ‘inviting woman he met on Instagram back to family home'
PSG star Achraf Hakimi is reportedly facing trial for rape after allegedly inviting a woman over to his home near Paris. Prosecutors have signed a final indictment requesting the 26-year-old to be charged in criminal court. Advertisement 2 Achraf Hakimi is reportedly facing trial for rape Credit: AFP 2 Hakimi has denied the allegations and claims it's a plot against him Credit: AFP If convicted, the Moroccan national faces up to 15 years in prison. The case stems from an alleged incident on February 25, 2023. According to After a month of exchanges, he reportedly ordered her an Uber to his home in Boulogne-Billancourt while his wife and children were away on holiday. Advertisement Read more on Hakimi Once inside, the woman claims Hakimi kissed her mouth and breasts through her clothes, despite her protests. She alleged he then assaulted her without consent. According to her account, she managed to push him away with her foot before fleeing and texting a friend to pick her up. She went to a police station the same day to 'make a statement of rape,' though she initially declined to file a formal complaint. Advertisement Most read in Football Messages she later provided to investigators reportedly showed her distress following the encounter. Achraf Hakimi shows what he is made of at PSG training On March 3, 2023, Hakimi was charged with rape by an investigating judge and placed under judicial supervision after being held in custody. He has consistently denied the allegations. The footballer, currently holidaying in Advertisement 'The truth is that when you are successful and things are going well, you become an easy target for certain people and that taught me that you can't trust many people around you,' Hakimi said this January in a interview. 'They wanted to blackmail me and that's why we filed a complaint and it's going well. The justice system handled things rather well.' His lawyer, Fanny Colin, slammed the prosecution's latest move. 'These requisitions are incomprehensible and senseless in light of the evidence in the case,' she told Le Parisien. Advertisement 'It establishes the plaintiff's lies, particularly through the psychological assessments conducted on her. 'Achraf Hakimi and I remain as calm as when the proceedings began. 'If these requests were to be followed, we would obviously pursue all avenues of appeal.'
