Convicted paedophile calls residential school abuse claims ‘rubbish'

Times

08-07-2025

A convicted paedophile described allegations of abuse at a residential school as a 'load of rubbish' during evidence he gave to the Scottish Child Abuse Inquiry.
The inquiry is investigating abuse in residential settings including boarding schools, religious establishments and foster care.
The former teacher, referred to as Evan, gave evidence on Tuesday via videolink from prison, where he is serving an eight-year sentence for sex offences.
The rapist was jailed at the High Court in Edinburgh in 2021 for seven offences against five girls aged 12 to 16.
Three of these occurred while he was a teacher at Ovenstone Residential School in Pittenweem, Fife, in the 1980s — though the girls were not pupils there. Ovenstone was a school for children with behavioural and emotional problems.
The man was given anonymity by the Scottish Child Abuse Inquiry (SCAI) and was referred to as Evan.
He was asked about three convictions of rape and sexual assault on the school premises, but denied the crimes had occurred, the inquiry heard.
The former teacher repeatedly answered 'No comment' to allegations of violence and sexual assault made by the father of a pupil, and branded it a 'load of rubbish', the inquiry heard.
Giving evidence, Evan described Ovenstone as 'the end of the line' for pupils he described as 'castaways', and recalled 'a little village school', praising the 'caring attitude' of staff he worked with in the Fife fishing village.
Evan said: 'It was our job to reintegrate children into mainstream schools and society.'
He denied general allegations of abuse, and said he was unaware of allegations of abuse during his time at the school.
However, he replied 'No comment' to a string of allegations of violence.
Ruth Innes KC, counsel for the inquiry, said: 'I'm going to ask you about allegations made against you [by a pupil's father]. Did you ever grab [the pupil] by the back of the head?
'Did you ever hit his head on a desk? Did you ever slam the lid of the desk down on his hands?
'Did you ever press your finger into his forehead making him bend his head back? Whilst doing that did you shout in his face?
'Did you ever hit him with a pool cue? Did you ever sexually assault him with a pool cue?'
After replying 'No comment', Evan said: 'This has been investigated. All my lawyer said is to say 'no comment'. I am finding it very difficult, because that list is a load of rubbish.'
Lady Smith, the inquiry chairwoman, said: 'It's a matter of fairness that the questions are given to you.'
Evan said: 'I'm sorry it's just so frustrating, that I can't unload myself to you. Obviously I've got to do what my lawyer tells me to do.'
Innes asked Evan if he had physically disciplined, physically assaulted or sexually assaulted any pupils — all of which he denied.
She said: 'We know about the convictions and they did not involve any children attending Ovenstone. Did you commit any similar offences against any child at Ovenstone?'
Evan said: 'No.'
Innes said: 'Some of the offences in respect of which you were convicted took place at the time you were teaching — and in one case, on the premises. How was it you were able to commit the offences and not be detected?'
Evan said: 'No comment on that.'
Innes added: 'How was it you were able to commit those offences at Ovenstone and it not be detected?'
Evan said: 'Quite simply because it never happened.'
He described pupils as 'fragile' and 'castigated', the inquiry was told.
Evan denied any awareness of staff abusing pupils, or peer group abuse, but said that there was a lack of training on child protection.
He said: 'If children were being bullied, we cut that off very quickly, because these children were fragile in many ways.'
He added: 'The six years I spent at Ovenstone were the happiest of my life. We built a playground; the kids developed emotionally and physically. I look back on it with fond memories. I've still got kids who are in touch with me.'
The inquiry continues.