How adopting a subscription fundraising model could future-proof your mission

Business Journals

15-07-2025

The surge of subscription-based businesses has revolutionized consumer behavior—from wardrobe overhauls with Stitch Fix to professional pet waste removal from DoodyCalls, today's consumers are hooked on convenience, favoring 'click it and forget it' services.
What if your nonprofit could tap into that same mindset? What if you could apply the success of the subscription model to your fundraising efforts and build a more sustainable, predictable revenue stream through recurring giving?
We're all familiar with the demise of video retail giant Blockbuster—now a cautionary tale about resisting change. Once a dominant force in home entertainment with more than 9,000 stores across the United States, the company clung to outdated models like in-store rentals and hefty late fees. Its failure to adapt to the rapidly evolving digital landscape and embrace on-demand, subscription-based services ultimately alienated customers and led to its downfall. Meanwhile, Netflix recognized this as an opportunity to rewrite the rules of customer engagement. The result? A $400 billion shift in the entertainment industry and a global realignment of consumer expectations.
As consumer behavior has shifted toward subscription-based convenience, nonprofits have a chance to rethink how they engage supporters. Recurring giving offers a sustainable way to build loyal donor relationships and create long-term impact.
Why subscription giving works
Subscription models are no longer a budding concept but rather a proven strategy for businesses seeking long-term success—and they hold the same promise for nonprofits.
One of the most compelling advantages for the organization is the generation of recurring revenue. Unlike traditional fundraising, which can be seasonal or sporadic, subscription models can provide nonprofits with a more steady revenue stream that enables more accurate budgeting, long-term planning, and operational continuity.
The subscription economy, or the trend of businesses shifting to subscription-based business models, was valued at a whopping $3 trillion in 2024, up from estimates of around $2 trillion in 2023. This rapid growth reflects a global shift in how people prefer to engage with services—and increasingly, how they're willing to give.
Now with increased access to innovative online fundraising software, encouraging and accepting recurring donations has become a realistic option for nonprofit organizations of all sizes. Whether creating a recurring giving program from scratch or strengthening and growing an existing one, the benefits of a recurring giving model are game-changing:
Predictable Income: Monthly giving creates a steady revenue stream, making it easier to plan budgets and allocate resources more efficiently.
Stronger Donor Relationships: Recurring donors are often more loyal, staying engaged with your mission over time.
Reduced Fundraising Pressure: Instead of constant fundraising appeals and scrambling for one-time donations, your team can focus on delivering impact.
Lower Acquisition Costs: It's more cost-effective to retain a recurring donor than to acquire a new one.
Higher Lifetime Value: Donors who give monthly typically contribute more over time than those making one-time contributions.
For the donors, the appeal is all about convenience. People have already grown accustomed to the ease of automated payments, whether for entertainment, meal kits, or paying a bill—recurring giving aligns with their existing habits. Once someone signs up, there is no check to write, no decision fatigue—just steady support for a cause they care about. The nonprofit sector has an opportunity to capitalize on a proven business model.
Reimagining donor engagement
Subscription giving is more than just a payment model, it's an opportunity to create a stronger emotional connection between your organization and its supporters. When donors opt into a recurring program, they become part of a community. They're not just giving money; they're investing in sustained impact.
Much like how Netflix offers a curated user experience to keep subscribers engaged, nonprofits can use this as an opportunity to deepen trust through consistent communication, storytelling, and overall donor stewardship—implementing meaningful touchpoints that reinforce why a donor's ongoing support matters.
A smarter way forward
Recurring giving isn't just a smart fundraising strategy; it's a way to future-proof your mission.
In today's landscape, attention spans are short and competition for potential donor dollars is high. And as with any shift in strategy, this requires thoughtful planning, clear messaging, and delivering a donor experience that feels personal and rewarding. But the potential returns, in terms of both financial stability and mission impact, are well worth the effort.
By embracing this model, your nonprofits have an opportunity to redefine what it means to give and to build a community of supporters who share the same focus and commitment to your mission.
Listen, then advise. That's what makes Miller Kaplan one of the top 100 certified public accounting firms in the United States. Established in 1941, Miller Kaplan has been providing audit, accounting, tax, business management, contract compliance, information security, risk advisory, industry metrics, and consulting services, to individuals, businesses, fiduciaries, and tax-exempt organizations for more than 80 years. Visit millerkaplan.com for more information.