Drug trafficker gets death sentence commuted after President Tharman grants clemency, Singapore News
Tristan Tan Yi Rui, 33, was sentenced to death in February 2023 after he was found guilty of trafficking 337.6g of methamphetamine. His conviction and sentence were upheld by the Court of Appeal.
In response to queries from The Straits Times on Friday (Aug 15), the Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA) said that on Aug 14, President Tharman Shanmugaratnam, on the advice of the Cabinet, granted a pardon to Tan.
The statement said the Cabinet was advised that the sentence imposed on Tan was legally sound.
"Nevertheless, a recommendation was made to grant clemency to him because of the specific facts and circumstances of the case," said MHA.
The statement said Tan was arrested as part of a Central Narcotics Bureau (CNB) operation which involved the arrest of several other subjects.
One of the other subjects arrested in the operation, who was tried separately on a capital charge, eventually received a non-capital sentence.
"The Cabinet decided to advise the grant of clemency to Tan to reduce the disparity in their respective outcomes," the MHA said.
The statement added: "Clemency is an exceptional power that is exercised as an act of executive grace."
The Constitution provides that the President may, on the advice of the Cabinet, grant a pardon, reprieve or respite of the execution of the sentence, or remit the whole or any part of the sentence, penalty or forfeiture imposed by law.
In cases involving death row prisoners, a sentence of death may be commuted to a sentence of imprisonment or fine or both, said MHA.
The statement did not identify the subject who was given a non-capital sentence.
Tan was arrested on Sept 27, 2018, by CNB officers in Tampines.
He was behind the wheel of his car, a white Volkswagen, while another man was in the front passenger seat.
The officers found 499g of a crystalline substance in a packet, which was analysed and found to contain not less than 337.6g of methamphetamine.
The prosecution contended that Tan intended to traffic in the drugs. It relied on evidence showing that he had made arrangements with his drug supplier, known to him as "Hari", to take possession of the drugs.
This included messages found on a mobile phone which involved negotiations with Hari regarding the sale and handover of the drugs.
The defence argued that Tan did not know the nature of the drugs nor intended to traffic in them.
Tan said the drugs were bought by members of Hari's group, and that he had merely been acting as a driver for the man who was tasked to collect the drugs.
Tan testified that he was a regular drug user and that Hari sometimes gave him drugs for free in exchange for favours such as ferrying Hari's friends around in his car.
He said the mobile phone was left in his car by one of Hari's friends.
In convicting Tan, the High Court found that he was the sole user of the mobile phone, had actual knowledge of the nature of the drugs and had failed to rebut the presumption of possession for the purpose of trafficking.
In imposing the mandatory death sentence, the judge said Tan's role was not limited to that of a courier. Moreover, the prosecution did not certify that he had substantively assisted the CNB in disrupting drug activities, which could allow him to be given a life sentence and caning instead of the death penalty.
Tan was represented by lawyer Ramesh Tiwary.
[[nid:721030]]
This article was first published in The Straits Times . Permission required for reproduction.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
2 days ago
- Straits Times
Over 280 vapes seized, more than 640 people checked in one night by police, HSA in anti-vape raids
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox Of the 640 people checked during raids a day earlier, 115 people aged 17 to 61 years old were caught for vape-related offences. SINGAPORE - More than 280 e-vaporisers have been seized after the authorities raided pubs, bars and KTV lounges islandwide on Aug 15. In all, more than 640 people were checked by officers from the Singapore Police Force, the Health Sciences Authority (HSA), and other agencies, including the Central Narcotics Bureau (CNB). HSA said on Aug 16 it will be working with the Singapore Nightlife Business Association (SNBA) to remind patrons to report vaping activities to the authorities. In that statement, HSA said of the 640 people checked during raids a day earlier, 115 people aged 17 to 61 years old were caught for vape-related offences. They included five who were caught with suspected etomidate vapes, or Kpods. The Aug 15 raids come a day after MOH and HSA said more than 100 people were being investigated for vape offences. ST PHOTO: AZMI ATHNI HSA said eight vape pods suspected to contain etomidate were confiscated. The Aug 15 raids come a day after the Ministry of Health (MOH) and HSA said more than 100 people were being investigated for vape offences, amid an intensified crackdown against Kpods. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore 5 new walking trails allow hikers to explore heritage sites and win supermarket vouchers World Trump advises Ukraine's Zelensky to 'make a deal' with Russia after meeting Putin World Did Putin just put one over Trump at the US-Russia summit on Ukraine? Singapore Nowhere to run: Why Singapore needs to start protecting its coasts now Life Meet the tutors who take O-level exams every year to create a 'war mate' bond with their students Life Switching careers in middle age and beyond: How these Singapore professionals did it Opinion Revitalise nightlife? Let's get the crowds out first Asia 11,000 properties without power after 4.9-magnitude quake strikes near east coast of Australia The media was invited to witness the raids at a club and karaoke lounge along Coleman Street, off North Bridge Road. CNB officers were also spotted conducting their own investigations. There were five officers, including one who was holding onto a metal briefcase, but they did not speak to the media. After rounding up the patrons at the first outlet, a man and a woman who were suspected Kpod users were separated and questioned by HSA officers in different rooms. Both were silent when the media arrived and turned away from the cameras. At least 13 vape devices, all in different colours and sizes that looked like pens and highlighters, were seized from the pair and laid out on tables in front of them. Some of the vapes seized by the authorities during the Aug 15 raids. ST PHOTO: AZMI ATHNI At the second club, HSA officers questioned a group of three men and a woman after nine vape devices were found on them. The vapes also came in a myriad of colours. Superintendent of Police (Supt) Esther Koh, head of operations at Central Police Division, said: 'We will continue to work with other agencies to clamp down on illicit activities and support HSA's efforts to crack down on the use of e-vaporisers.' On working with SNBA, HSA said signages will be prominently displayed warning patrons that vaping is illegal. HSA added nightlife businesses have been urged to deny entry to those found with vape devices, or vaping. The signage will also feature a QR code linked to HSA's online reporting portal, allowing patrons and staff to report vaping offences. HSA's chief executive officer, adjunct professor (Dr) Raymond Chua, said: 'Working with industry partners like SNBA helps strengthen ground-level deterrence and is an important part of HSA's strategy to combat illegal vaping. 'Vaping has no place in daily life, including Singapore's nightlife entertainment scene. All nightlife establishments should work with us to keep their venues vape-free and report any illegal activities to the authorities.' On Aug 3, The Straits Times reported on a pervasive vaping culture within clubs in Singapore. Despite bag checks, many young patrons were spotted puffing on their devices on the dance floors inside the clubs. The Aug 15 raids come after Home Affairs Minister K. Shanmugam had said on July 30 that officers from his ministry will be seconded to support HSA in enforcement efforts. These will include the supervision, treatment and rehabilitation of etomidate abusers. He added that as an interim measure, the Ministry of Home Affairs will list etomidate as a Class C drug under the Misuse of Drugs Act (MDA), while they continue to support MOH as it decides on further legislative actions to take against Kpod offenders. Etomidate is currently classified as a poison and regulated under the Poisons Act. Under this law, abusers face only a fine. Sellers face possible jail time of up to two years. Once etomidate is listed as a Class C drug, users can be subjected to supervision and mandatory participation in a rehabilitation programme or committed to drug rehabilitation centres, like what drug abusers undergo. Repeat offenders can be jailed for at least a year. More severe penalties will apply to those selling, distributing or importing these devices, including imprisonment of up to 20 years and caning. Etomidate is meant for use only during medical procedures. When vaped, etomidate enters the lungs directly, potentially triggering spasms, breathing difficulties, seizures and even psychosis. On Aug 13, a 41-year-old Singaporean man pleaded guilty to producing etomidate-laced pods for sale, making it the first conviction for Kpod-related offences in court. To report vaping-related offences, call the HSA reporting hotline on 6684-2036 or 6684-2037 from 9am to 9pm daily, including on public holidays. The public can do so online at If you have a story to share about vapes, e-mail us at stnewsdesk@
AsiaOne
2 days ago
- AsiaOne
3 Singaporeans arrested over suspected drug offences, children found in units during raids, Singapore News
Three Singaporean men were arrested by Central Narcotics Bureau (CNB) for suspected drug offences on Aug 14 in separate operations. CNB said in a news release that a 36-year-old man was arrested for suspected drug trafficking in a residential unit around Bukit Batok West Avenue 9. About 892g of methamphetamine, also known as Ice, and 100 nimetazepam, or Erimin-5, tablets were seized, and his wife and four young children, aged between one and eight years old, were present at the scene. Around the same time, a 41-year-old man was arrested for suspected drug trafficking offences in a residential unit near Jalan Kayu, and CNB officers seized about 158g of Ice and 9g of MDMA, or Ecstasy. Earlier that day, a 42-year-old man was arrested in his residence near Tampines Street 86 for suspected drug offences. Drug paraphernalia was discovered under the coffee table in the living room, where his 10-year-old daughter was also present. [[nid:721123]] "CNB will continue our operational tempo to take down drug offenders. We take seriously any situation where individuals, especially children, are exposed to drugs and are subjected to unsafe environments," said Deputy Assistant Commissioner Chang Gim Fook, Deputy Director (Operations) of the Intelligence Division. If found guilty of trafficking more than specific amounts of drugs, such as 250g of methamphetamine, a person may face the mandatory death penalty. [[nid:721408]] drimac@
AsiaOne
2 days ago
- AsiaOne
Drug trafficker gets death sentence commuted after President Tharman grants clemency, Singapore News
SINGAPORE — A man who was on death row for drug trafficking has had his death sentence commuted to life imprisonment after succeeding in his petition for clemency, which is rarely granted. Tristan Tan Yi Rui, 33, was sentenced to death in February 2023 after he was found guilty of trafficking 337.6g of methamphetamine. His conviction and sentence were upheld by the Court of Appeal. In response to queries from The Straits Times on Friday (Aug 15), the Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA) said that on Aug 14, President Tharman Shanmugaratnam, on the advice of the Cabinet, granted a pardon to Tan. The statement said the Cabinet was advised that the sentence imposed on Tan was legally sound. "Nevertheless, a recommendation was made to grant clemency to him because of the specific facts and circumstances of the case," said MHA. The statement said Tan was arrested as part of a Central Narcotics Bureau (CNB) operation which involved the arrest of several other subjects. One of the other subjects arrested in the operation, who was tried separately on a capital charge, eventually received a non-capital sentence. "The Cabinet decided to advise the grant of clemency to Tan to reduce the disparity in their respective outcomes," the MHA said. The statement added: "Clemency is an exceptional power that is exercised as an act of executive grace." The Constitution provides that the President may, on the advice of the Cabinet, grant a pardon, reprieve or respite of the execution of the sentence, or remit the whole or any part of the sentence, penalty or forfeiture imposed by law. In cases involving death row prisoners, a sentence of death may be commuted to a sentence of imprisonment or fine or both, said MHA. The statement did not identify the subject who was given a non-capital sentence. Tan was arrested on Sept 27, 2018, by CNB officers in Tampines. He was behind the wheel of his car, a white Volkswagen, while another man was in the front passenger seat. The officers found 499g of a crystalline substance in a packet, which was analysed and found to contain not less than 337.6g of methamphetamine. The prosecution contended that Tan intended to traffic in the drugs. It relied on evidence showing that he had made arrangements with his drug supplier, known to him as "Hari", to take possession of the drugs. This included messages found on a mobile phone which involved negotiations with Hari regarding the sale and handover of the drugs. The defence argued that Tan did not know the nature of the drugs nor intended to traffic in them. Tan said the drugs were bought by members of Hari's group, and that he had merely been acting as a driver for the man who was tasked to collect the drugs. Tan testified that he was a regular drug user and that Hari sometimes gave him drugs for free in exchange for favours such as ferrying Hari's friends around in his car. He said the mobile phone was left in his car by one of Hari's friends. In convicting Tan, the High Court found that he was the sole user of the mobile phone, had actual knowledge of the nature of the drugs and had failed to rebut the presumption of possession for the purpose of trafficking. In imposing the mandatory death sentence, the judge said Tan's role was not limited to that of a courier. Moreover, the prosecution did not certify that he had substantively assisted the CNB in disrupting drug activities, which could allow him to be given a life sentence and caning instead of the death penalty. Tan was represented by lawyer Ramesh Tiwary. [[nid:721030]] This article was first published in The Straits Times . Permission required for reproduction.
