Brewing tension in Nagarhole as tribals allege eviction amid FRA dispute
A fresh controversy is brewing in the Nagarhole Tiger Reserve as the Forest Department and tribals are engaged in a tense standoff over land rights, forced evictions, and the dispute over the implementation of the Forest Rights Act (FRA).
The triggering point for the current standoff is the entry of about 150 tribals from the nearby villages into their ancestral land on Monday to assert their rights to the forests and the construction of the sacred altar for their deities.
But on Tuesday, the Forest Department officials, staff members, and the police reached the place and thwarted their attempts, which have escalated the simmering discontent among the tribals over their forcible eviction decades ago and the failure of the authorities to recognise their claims under the FRA despite providing documents.
The Jenukurub leaders from Karadikallu argued with the officials to point out that they have waited for three months after furnishing the documents, and it is the Forest Department that has exceeded the notice period within which the rights are to be settled.
Sources said that such attempts to forcibly enter the tiger reserve to assert rights would be perceived as encroachment as the claims are yet to be recognised.
However, the tribals argued that their constitutional rights are being ignored. 'The FRA does not grant new rights — it affirms our existing ones. This is our homeland,' said J.A. Shivu, president of the Karadikallu forest rights committee and leader of the Nagarhole Adivasi Jammapale Hakku Sthapana Samiti.
S. Sreekanth of Development through Education said the tribals were not constructing an RCC structure but an altar made of materials like wood, etc., to worship the deity. Hence, the Forest Department's action was condemnable as it amounted to hurting the religious sentiments of the tribals.
He said that despite the recent instruction of Chief Minister Siddaramaiah during his visit to the hamlets in H.D. Kote that tribals should not be disturbed, the atrocities by the authorities continue unabated.
Activists have demanded a review of the tribals' claims rejected by the Forest Department and an early recognition of their rights. Mr. Sreekanth said that if the issue is allowed to escalate without a peaceful resolution, it would reflect badly on Chief Minister Siddaramaiah, as his directives are being flouted by the officials.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Stampede Case: No action against RCB, DNA till June 12, A-G assures HC as Judge hears pleas for relief
The Karnataka High Court posted for June 12, Thursday, petitions from the Royal Challengers Sports Limited, the franchise of RCB and the event manager DNA Entertainment Network praying for quashing of the FIR filed against their executives in connection with the June 4 stampede outside of Chinnaswamy stadium in Bengaluru that claimed 11 lives and left scores of others injured. Justice SR Krishna Kumar posted the case to hear for interim relief after eliciting an assurance from Advocate General Shashi Kiran Shetty that the government would not take any precipitative action against the petitioners till the matter was heard at the next date. The A-G also informed the court that RCB and DNA invited people to the celebrations at the stadium though they had no permission to hold the event at the stadium. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like I lost my wife, now my son is in danger, please help him! Donate For Health Donate Now Undo The Judge is now seized of three petitions arising from the same FIR registered at Cubbon Park police station on June 5 and transferred to the CID . The Court has already granted relief from police arrest for two office-bearers of the Karnataka State Cricket Association (KSCA). The police have already arrested four senior executives, including RCB marketing head Nikhil Sosale, and the Advocate General said they are under the remand. The court is also hearing separate petitions from Sosale and others seeking relief. The RCB counsel argued before the court that the City Police carried out the arrest on orders from Chief Minister Siddaramaiah who had no role in this after the case had been handed over to the CID. A political leader cannot order an 'arrest' which is at the discretion of the investigating officer, he said. Live Events HEARING ON STAMPEDE The state government is expected to submit a status report before a division bench of acting chief justice V Kameshwar Rao and Justice CM Joshi on June 10, Tuesday, when it resumes hearing on the tragedy. The HC has taken up suo motu cognizance of the ghastly stampede caused during the IPL victory celebrations of the RCB. Quite a few public-spirited people have moved the high court seeking justice in the case. Chief Minister Siddaramaiah will on Tuesday leave for Delhi to meet up with the AICC leadership to explain the developments around the tragedy and his administration's handling of the crisis including the steps taken like suspension of officers for dereliction of duty.
Hans India
an hour ago
- Hans India
Senior Bengaluru Police Officer Challenges Stampede-Related Suspension At Administrative Tribunal
Additional Commissioner of Police Vikash Kumar has filed a petition at the Central Administrative Tribunal challenging his suspension by the Karnataka government following the tragic stampede at Chinnaswamy Stadium that resulted in eleven fatalities during Royal Challengers Bengaluru's victory celebrations. The legal challenge questions the validity of the disciplinary measures imposed by state authorities, specifically examining whether proper procedural protocols were observed before issuing the suspension directive. The tribunal is expected to schedule hearings for the case in the immediate future. Kumar was part of a comprehensive suspension order affecting multiple senior police personnel after the June 4 catastrophe outside Bengaluru's M Chinnaswamy Stadium during RCB's IPL championship festivities. The mass casualties prompted swift administrative action from the state leadership. Following a Cabinet session on June 5, Chief Minister Siddaramaiah announced immediate suspensions covering several key police officials, including Bengaluru Police Commissioner B Dayananda, the stadium security chief, Assistant Commissioner of Police, central Deputy Commissioner of Police, Cubbon Park police station chief, and the police housemaster responsible for the area. Sources indicate the celebration event proceeded on Wednesday, despite police recommendations to postpone the felicitation until Sunday to ensure adequate security arrangements and effective crowd management. The timing decision has become a focal point in the investigation into the preventable tragedy. The suspended officials have garnered significant support from various quarters, including former police officers, political organizations, citizens' groups, and online communities who have rallied behind the affected personnel, particularly Police Commissioner B Dayananda. The Indian Police Foundation, representing numerous retired Indian Police Service officers, formally appealed to Chief Minister Siddaramaiah requesting immediate withdrawal of suspension orders against three IPS officers, including Commissioner Dayananda. Their intervention highlights concerns within the law enforcement community about the administrative response. The retired officers' statement emphasized that crowd turnout substantially exceeded all projections, creating unprecedented logistical challenges that overwhelmed police resources despite their dedicated efforts. They argue the suspensions represent unfair scapegoating and have requested urgent reconsideration of the punitive measures. The tribunal challenge represents the first formal legal response to the government's disciplinary actions, potentially setting a precedent for how accountability is determined in crowd control failures. The case will likely examine whether individual officers can be held solely responsible for systemic failures in event management and crowd safety protocols.
NDTV
an hour ago
- NDTV
"Cops Being Made 'Fall Guys'": Ex-Police Officers To Siddaramaiah On RCB Stampede
Retired police officers urged Karnataka's Chief Minister to revoke the suspension of Bengaluru Police Commissioner B Dayanand and others over a deadly stampede at an IPL victory rally, pointing out an inquiry to establish fault has not been completed. Bengaluru: Retired senior police officers have urged Karnataka Chief Minister Siddaramaiah to revoke the suspension of Bengaluru Police Commissioner B Dayanand, his deputy, and three others over the stampede last week at a rally to celebrate the Royal Challengers Bengaluru 's IPL win. They have pointed to Mr Dayanand's "unblemished record of service and integrity" and said the five suspended police officers had been "victimised" and made "fall guys" while those "whose haste and over-enthusiasm, and reluctance to take a stand, contributed to the tragedy... managed to get away". Two open letters have been addressed to the Congress leader, one of which also refers to "tacit support of the (state) government" in allowing the rally to be held despite police warnings. The first was from 30 high-ranking ex-cops, including ex-CBI chief DR Karthikeyan and Satish Sahney and Dr KK Paul, the former Police Commissioners of Mumbai and Delhi respectively. The second was from the Indian Police Foundation, a multi-disciplinary think tank currently led by RS Mooshahary, the former Meghalaya Governor and ex-Director-General of Assam Police. What 30 Ex-Cops Said In their letter the 30 ex-cops pointed out Bengaluru Police had "expressed reservations" about the celebratory rally. The local police station, i.e., the Cubbon Park Police Station and senior police officers had pointed to the "lack of time to prepare for the humongous crowds..." The city police, the 30 ex-cops wrote to the Chief Minister, "conveyed in writing... the danger of acceding to the request to organise a function hours after the final..." and advised the government and the cricket bodies to defer the programme by four days, i.e., June 8. "... appears no written directions were given to the police (to) overrule their objections. The organisers, meanwhile, kept inviting fans... professional advice of police officers was not heeded, and the organisers went ahead, presumably with tacit support of the government." "The consequences of disregarding professional police advice are there to see..." the 30 ex-cops wrote, pointing out also that a judicial panel's report is to be filed within a month and that it would be "fair and proper to take action only after the findings are known..." What Police Foundation Think Tank Said The second letter, from the IPF, was in a similar tone, but also warned the state government that suspension of the senior cops, before the judicial inquiry is complete, risks demoralising other police personnel and "undermining institutional integrity". "Large public events... especially when held at such short notice... require coordinated efforts by multiple civic, administrative, and political agencies. To isolate the police for punitive action, while other stakeholders escape scrutiny, distorts the reality of shared responsibility..." The IPF called for the reinstatement of Mr Dayanand and other suspended cops, who have also been backed by the former's predecessor, Bhaskar Rao, who told NDTV the sacking was "unacceptable". "Dayanand and his team safeguarded the city... he has been bulldozed." READ | What Kiran Bedi, Ex-Top Cop Bhaskar Rao Said On Suspension, Stampede Mr Rao also blamed the Chief Minister and his deputy, DK Shivakumar, for the situation, saying their eagerness to be associated with the winning RCB team led to precautions being ignored. Eleven people were killed and 47 injured in the stampede at the Chinnaswamy Stadium, in connection with which four people, including a senior RCB employee, have been arrested. VIDEO | The state government has been accused of mismanagement in this matter, which has also spawned a political slugfest between the Congress and the opposition Bharatiya Janata Party. 'No Time To...': NDTV Reviews Cops' Letter On Sunday NDTV accessed a letter from Deputy Commissioner of Police (Vidhan Soudha) MN Karibasavana Gowda to the Department of Personnel and Administrative Reforms. This was written on June 4, a day after the IPL 2025 final and the Bengaluru team's historic win. Mr Gowda had warned against holding any victory event at the Vidhan Soudha, where victorious team members were to meet the Chief Minister. He said "lakhs of cricket fans" would be drawn to the event and that it would "create security challenges due to a shortage of officers/staff..." The victory rally itself was therefore to be held at the stadium, which cannot hold more than 35,000 people. By 3.30 pm on the fateful day there were an estimated two lakh people around the stadium. Another 50,000 were reportedly trying to force their way inside. The crowd rush triggered the stampede, authorities have said. The families of those killed have been awarded financial compensation, by the state and the RCB team, while those who were injured have been told medical expenses will be covered.
