SC upholds Kerala HC's order quashing govt move on Medical Education Corpus Fund
The corpus fund had been formed by remitting a portion of the fees collected from Non-Resident Indian (NRI) students to the State Government.
The Supreme Court ruled that such funds should instead be retained by the self-financing institutions themselves, which are entitled to utilize them for subsidising BPL students' education.
A Bench, comprising Justices Surya Kant and Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh, affirmed that the Kerala High Court was right in setting aside government order passed on June six, 2018.
'The self-financing medical colleges are entitled to retain the fees transferred to the State for the creation of the 'corpus fund' substantially for the purpose of subsidizing the fees charged to BPL students admitted to those colleges,' the Court stated.
The issue stemmed from a directive issued by the Kerala Admission and Fee Regulatory Committee, mandating that a corpus fund be created from a portion of the NRI student fees to subsidize BPL students' education.
KMCT Medical College had challenged this before the High Court after the Committee, in February 2018, increased NRI fees from Rs 15 lakh to Rs 20 lakh, directing that Rs five lakh be set aside for the corpus fund and remitted to the State.
During the pending litigation, the State issued a government order on June six, 2018, validating this directive.
However, the High Court ruled that while the Committee could fix fees under Section 8 of the Kerala Medical Education Act, 2017, it had no authority to redirect a portion of such fees for any other purpose.
The Court directed that corpus funds already collected be transferred back to the respective colleges, to be held in separate accounts and used solely for aiding economically weaker students.
This led to cross-appeals before the Supreme Court by the State, self-financing colleges and NRI students.
Citing P A Inamdar versus State of Maharashtra (2005) and Islamic Academy of Education vs State of Karnataka (2003), the Court clarified that while the State may design subsidy mechanisms, the Admission and Fee Regulatory Committee lacks statutory authority to create such corpus funds.
'There is nothing discernible in Section 8A of the 2017 Act that permits the Committee to divert or dictate the utilisation of a part of the fees,' the Bench noted.
The Court emphasized that any initiative to support economically weaker students must come through appropriate legislation by the State.
The Supreme Court ordered that the corpus fund amounts be returned to the respective colleges within three months. These institutions must maintain a separate account for the corpus fund and utilize it strictly for subsidizing fees of BPL students. Any BPL student who paid more than the subsidized amount is entitled to a refund or fee adjustment in future years.
However, the Court clarified that NRI students are not entitled to refunds from the corpus fund, and any pending fees as approved by the Committee must be paid in full within three months.
Senior Advocate Jayanth Muth Raj appeared for the Appellants (colleges), while Senior Advocate V Chitambaresh represented the Respondents.
The appeals by the State of Kerala and NRI students were dismissed.
Appeal by the self-financing medical colleges was allowed in part.
The State and Admission Committee may seek account statements from colleges to verify compliance with the judgment.
The Supreme Court has reinforced the autonomy of private medical institutions within the legal framework and reiterated the principle that statutory bodies must function within the bounds of their legislative mandates.
UNI SNG SS
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
DPR submitted for Peroorkada Mental Health Centre revamp
Thiruvananthapuram: The long-awaited modernisation of Peroorkada Mental Health Centre took a major step forward, with the submission of a detailed project report (DPR) worth Rs 90.15 crore to Kerala Infrastructure Investment Fund Board (KIIFB) for approval. The plan has already received administrative sanction and marks the first phase of redevelopment under the institution's comprehensive master plan. The DPR will be submitted to the govt within five months to ensure that the foundation stone of the new building is laid during the current state govt's tenure. Prepared by HLL Infra Tech Services Ltd. (HITES), a subsidiary of Mini Ratna public sector enterprise HLL Lifecare Ltd, the DPR includes a wide range of facilities aligned with modern mental health policies. The first phase will see the construction of new buildings for OP block, IP block, administration block, behavioural ICU, a sewage treatment plant, power substation, a kitchen, power laundry, internal road renovations, compound wall and overall campus beautification. The proposed built-up area for this phase is 13,452 sq m. This is one of the oldest mental health institutions in the country. As part of preparing DPR, the development team visited National Institute of Mental Health and Neurosciences (NIMHANS) in Bengaluru to study contemporary best practices. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Could This NEW Collagen Blend Finally Reduce Your Cellulite? Vitauthority Learn More Undo "The facilities currently in place were built for an outdated model of care. This revamp is aimed at aligning the institution with the latest national mental health policy," said V K Prasanth, MLA, while presenting the DPR before the hospital development committee. "This DPR envisions not just better infrastructure, but a transformation of mental healthcare delivery. The people of Thiruvananthapuram and beyond deserve a facility that meets 21st-century standards," he added. District collector Anu Kumari, hospital superintendent Dr Divya, committee members, and representatives from HITES attended the presentation meeting. Approval from KIIFB is expected to fast-track the implementation process. Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays , public holidays , and current gold rates and silver prices in your area.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Food quality testing labs in Vizag, Tirumala to start operations next month
Visakhapatnam: The Andhra Pradesh govt is setting up five food quality testing laboratories across the state, with two of them, in Visakhapatnam and Tirumala, expected to begin operations next month. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now The laboratories are part of a larger initiative to ensure food safety and protect the health of citizens, particularly devotees visiting Tirumala. The state govt has invested Rs 86 crore in the five laboratories, which will be equipped with advanced equipment to test food samples. The laboratory in Tirumala is being set up in a 12,000 square foot building provided by local authorities near the flour mill. Equipment worth approximately Rs 19 crore is being installed to conduct food sample tests. The laboratory will test samples of all types of food items and operate 24/7 with necessary staff. Until now, food samples were sent to neighboring states for quality testing, but with the new laboratory, samples will be tested locally. Health minister Satya Kumar Yadav said that the govt is prioritizing the healthy lifestyle of its citizens and that the laboratories will play a crucial role in ensuring food safety. The laboratories will help to prevent incidents of food adulteration, which had affected the sentiments of devotees in the past. The government has taken a decision to set up a special state-level laboratory in Tirumala to ensure the health of devotees. The Visakhapatnam laboratory will also be ready for operation by the end of next month, with basic equipment already in place and the final stages of bringing in all necessary equipment underway. The state government is also upgrading the Ongole and Eluru public health laboratories with Rs 13 crore and advanced equipment. A purchase order for the equipment has also been issued, and the govt has sanctioned Rs 6.5 crore for each lab. Meanwhile, state-level food laboratories are coming up in Guntur, Tirupati, and Kurnool. There is already a regional food laboratory in Kurnool, which will be upgraded to state level, and a new building will be constructed.
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
Bitten and ignored: 2 years after HC order, victims await relief
Panchkula: Nearly two years after the Punjab and Haryana high court directed the deputy commissioner to form a committee for compensating dog bite victims, neither has the committee been formed nor has any compensation been disbursed till date. Deputy commissioner Monika Gupta told TOI, "In this regard, the Haryana government has to make a policy as the budget is also to be decided. We have written to the government. Once the policy is made, the committee will be set up and the compensation will be given." In Nov 2023, the HC ruled that victims should receive a minimum of Rs 10,000 per tooth mark and Rs 20,000 per 0.2 cm of wound where flesh has been pulled off. However, the order has yet to translate into any actual compensation. Sunit Singla, chairman of the dog bite committee, municipal corporation, confirmed, "Not even a single dog bite victim was given compensation after the HC's order. The MC has to give it after the DC-formed committee sends the approved list to us. But no names were sent to us by the committee yet." MC councillors also expressed concern over the lack of public awareness about the committee and its role. SK Nayar, president of the Citizens Welfare Association, said, "The high court has already issued directions to ensure safety from stray dogs. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like American Investor Warren Buffett Recommends: 5 Books For Turning Your Life Around Blinkist: Warren Buffett's Reading List Undo With the rise in bite cases, it is essential for the local administration in Panchkula to act promptly in public interest." Mukesh Malhotra, a Sector 25 resident, shared his ordeal: "I was bitten for no fault of mine and have five stitches, but there is no compensation. I wrote to the MC and the Haryana Human Rights Commission, but nothing happened." Frustrated by the delay, Panchkula mayor Kulbhushan Goyal had earlier announced a plan to provide immediate medical relief and compensation at five community centres. The proposal included stationing doctors, nurses, and vaccines, along with Rs 10,000 compensation per tooth mark. However, five months later, the plan remains unimplemented. Meanwhile, the MC's sterilisation campaign, which had been halted earlier, has recently resumed. Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays , public holidays , and current gold rates and silver prices in your area.
