Explained: Federal Prosecutor Maurene Comey fired - was it for 'botching' Epstein-Maxwell and Diddy cases?
Maurene Comey
, the federal prosecutor who helped convict
Ghislaine Maxwell
and recently prosecuted Sean "Diddy" Combs, has been fired by the
Trump administration
.
The Justice Department has not issued an official explanation, though the dismissal letter cited Article II of the Constitution.
Her role in the Epstein and Maxwell prosecutions has drawn renewed attention amid a public dispute over unreleased Epstein files.
Critics suggest her firing is politically motivated, due to her family connection to former FBI director James Comey.
Legal experts and prosecutors warn the move undermines
prosecutorial independence
and risks politicising
SDNY
.
Who is Maurene Comey?
Maurene Comey was an Assistant US Attorney in the Southern District of New York (SDNY), widely regarded as the most influential federal prosecutor's office in the country. She is the daughter of former FBI director James Comey, who was fired by Donald Trump in 2017.
Comey built a reputation for managing high-profile cases involving sexual exploitation, public corruption, and white-collar crime. Her career highlights include:
Ghislaine Maxwell trial (2021–22)
: Comey helped secure Maxwell's conviction on multiple counts related to the sexual exploitation of minors. She had been involved in the Epstein probe from the outset.
Sean "Diddy" Combs trial (2025)
: Comey prosecuted Combs on sex trafficking and racketeering charges. The jury acquitted him of the most serious counts but convicted him on a lesser prostitution-related charge.
She was also a lead attorney in Epstein-related matters and represented the DOJ in civil litigation seeking to block disclosure of certain investigative records, citing risks of harassment to victims and witnesses.
Why Was She Fired?
While the Justice Department has declined comment, several factors appear to have contributed to her abrupt removal:
1. Fallout from the Combs Trial
The mixed verdict in the Combs case reportedly sparked frustration in the Trump administration.
Although Comey secured a conviction, the acquittals on major charges were viewed internally as a prosecutorial failure. Independent observers, however, noted the case's legal complexity and the difficulty of securing trafficking convictions.
2.
Political Targeting
and the Epstein Fallout
Comey's firing came just days after renewed controversy over the Epstein investigation. President Trump has come under fire from supporters for refusing to release Epstein-related files.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
An engineer reveals: One simple trick to get internet without a subscription
Techno Mag
Learn More
Undo
In response, he claimed without evidence that materials were 'concocted' by his political enemies—including former President Barack Obama, Joe Biden, and James Comey.
Although there is no direct link between the firing and Comey's involvement in the Epstein-Maxwell cases, legal experts say the timing strongly suggests a political motive. As recently as 2024, Comey filed declarations defending DOJ's decision not to unseal Epstein records, arguing that doing so would harm potential retrials and risk victim harassment.
3. A Wider Pattern at SDNY
Comey's firing is part of a broader shake-up of SDNY:
In
February 2025
, eight prosecutors—including acting US Attorney Danielle Sassoon—resigned after the DOJ dropped corruption charges against New York Mayor Eric Adams.
In
April
, Matthew Podolsky stepped down under pressure, paving the way for Trump to appoint Jay Clayton as interim US Attorney.
Wednesday's dismissal of Comey is the most high-profile removal to date. Colleagues say she was informed by letter citing Article II and held an impromptu meeting with the co-chief of the Public Corruption Unit to share the news. She was reportedly escorted out with quiet respect from fellow prosecutors.
Why It Matters
The removal of a veteran prosecutor without a clear explanation—and during ongoing litigation involving her past cases—has raised serious alarms across legal circles.
Precedent of Politicised Firing
: Once rare, such terminations have become more common under Trump's second term, eroding norms around civil service protection.
Damage to Prosecutorial Independence
: SDNY is known for its independence in prosecuting political figures, corporate crimes, and sensitive public corruption cases. The replacement of career professionals with political loyalists raises fears of selective enforcement or non-enforcement.
Implications for the Epstein Files
: Comey's past efforts to shield sensitive investigative material from public release, citing victim protection, are now being cast in a political light. With her departure, the DOJ could potentially revisit those positions under new leadership.
FAQ
Q. Was Maurene Comey fired because of her father, James Comey?
There is no official confirmation, but Trump's long-standing animus toward James Comey, combined with Maurene Comey's role in politically sensitive prosecutions, suggests the name alone may have made her a target.
Q. Did the outcome of the Diddy trial contribute to her firing?
Yes. While the prosecution secured one conviction, the acquittals on more serious charges were viewed unfavourably within the administration.
Q. Is this part of a wider purge?
Yes. Her dismissal follows a series of resignations and removals at SDNY, marking a consolidation of influence over one of the most powerful US Attorney's offices.
Q. What happens to Epstein-related investigations now?
With Comey gone and DOJ signalling that no client list exists, further federal action appears unlikely. Her departure removes a key figure who had previously defended maintaining file secrecy.
Q. Has the DOJ or White House issued a response?
No. Both have declined to comment. Trump has said publicly that Epstein 'was never a big factor' and described the controversy as a distraction created by 'past supporters.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
36 minutes ago
- Time of India
Kim Jong Un's sister dismisses South Korea's peace proposals, calls it 'miscalculation'
North Korea has no interest in any policy or proposals for reconciliation from South Korea, the powerful sister of its leader Kim Jong Un said on Monday in the first response to South Korean liberal President Lee Jae Myung 's peace overtures . Kim Yo Jong , who is a senior North Korean ruling party official and is believed to speak for the country's leader, said Lee's pledge of commitment to South Korea-U.S. security alliance shows he is no different from his hostile predecessor. Explore courses from Top Institutes in Please select course: Select a Course Category CXO Leadership Cybersecurity Finance Product Management Operations Management MCA Management Others Data Science Healthcare Digital Marketing Public Policy Data Science Technology PGDM others Degree Artificial Intelligence Design Thinking healthcare MBA Project Management Data Analytics Skills you'll gain: Operations Strategy for Business Excellence Organizational Transformation Corporate Communication & Crisis Management Capstone Project Presentation Duration: 11 Months IIM Lucknow Chief Operations Officer Programme Starts on Jun 30, 2024 Get Details Skills you'll gain: Digital Strategy Development Expertise Emerging Technologies & Digital Trends Data-driven Decision Making Leadership in the Digital Age Duration: 40 Weeks Indian School of Business ISB Chief Digital Officer Starts on Jun 30, 2024 Get Details Skills you'll gain: Customer-Centricity & Brand Strategy Product Marketing, Distribution, & Analytics Digital Strategies & Innovation Skills Leadership Insights & AI Integration Expertise Duration: 10 Months IIM Kozhikode IIMK Chief Marketing and Growth Officer Starts on Apr 7, 2024 Get Details Skills you'll gain: Technology Strategy & Innovation Emerging Technologies & Digital Transformation Leadership in Technology Management Cybersecurity & Risk Management Duration: 24 Weeks Indian School of Business ISB Chief Technology Officer Starts on Jun 28, 2024 Get Details "If South Korea expects to reverse all the consequences of (its actions) with a few sentimental words, there could be no greater miscalculation than that," Kim said in comments carried by official KCNA news agency. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Tan Tao A: Unsold Furniture Liquidation 2024 (Prices May Surprise You) Unsold Furniture | Search Ads Learn More Undo Lee, who took office on June 4 after winning a snap election called after the removal of hardline conservative Yoon Suk Yeol over a failed attempt at martial law, has vowed to improve ties with Pyongyang that had reached the worst level in years. As gestures aimed at easing tensions, Lee suspended loudspeaker broadcasts blasting anti-North propaganda across the border and banned the flying of leaflets by activists that had angered Pyongyang. Live Events Kim, the North Korean official, said those moves are merely a reversal of ill-intentioned activities by South Korea that should never have been initiated in the first place. "In other words, it's not even something worth our assessment," she said. "We again make clear the official position that whatever policy is established in Seoul or proposal is made, we are not interested, and we will not be sitting down with South Korea and there is nothing to discuss." There has been cautious optimism in the South that the North may respond positively and may even show willingness to re-engage in dialogue, particularly after Pyongyang also shut off its loudspeakers, a move Lee said was quicker than expected. Still, Lee, whose government is in the midst of tough negotiations with Washington to avert punishing tariffs that President Donald Trump has threatened against a string of major trading partners, has said U.S. alliance is the pillar of South Korea's diplomacy. "Through efforts in the areas of politics, economic security and culture, we will strengthen the South Korea-U.S. alliance that was sealed in blood," Lee said in remarks commemorating the anniversary of the Korean War armistice on Sunday. North Korea also marked the anniversary which it calls victory day with events including a parade in Pyongyang, although state media reports indicated it was at a relatively lesser scale compared to some previous years. The two Koreas, the United States and China, which are the main belligerents in the 1950-53 Korean War, have not signed a peace treaty.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Setback to lenders: NCLT replaces RP in Anil Ambani's loan guarantee case
NEW DELHI: In a setback to lenders, the National Company Law Tribunal has removed Jitender Kothari as the resolution professional (RP) in an insolvency case related to Anil Ambani 's personal guarantee to SBI for a loan to Reliance Communications . NCLT appointed Prashant Jain as the new RP. In Sept 2016, Ambani had given a personal guarantee for a Rs 1,385-crore loan, which was retrospectively classified as an NPA effective late Aug 2016. Kothari was appointed RP in Aug 2020. A few days after his appointment, the RP sought multiple details from Ambani, including details of a case in a British court. The insolvency action had been challenged in Delhi HC and the SC. In May 2021, the RP filed his report in NCLT, recommending admission of company petition for insolvency resolution despite Ambani's lawyer seeking more time, citing restricted mobility due to Covid. A few days later, Ambani's lawyer wrote that the RP can only seek information from SBI. Meanwhile, the businessman's writ petition in SC was tagged along with one Surendra Jiwarajka, which was finally decided in Nov 2023. Ambani has accused the RP of "acting in undue haste and denying him fair and proper opportunity" to provide information. Besides, the RP is accused of exceeding the mandate under IBC in seeking "unrelated information". The RP denied the charges and SBI supported it, while arguing that the matter had been pending with NCLT for a long time and the case was being delayed. In its order on July 15, the benchsaid that in light of Covid-related disruptions, Ambani should have been given "a fair opportunity" to provide information to the resolution professional. "Instead, we note that the RP didn't even wait for adjudication of his application pending before this Tribunal seeking relaxation of 10 days' timeline and a cross application of the applicant before this Tribunal requiring more time in view of Covid restrictions. " "Though, we do not find any negligence or explicit bias on part of the RP in this case, however, we are of considered view since the insolvency resolution process after commencement has to be run in close coordination of debtor and RP," it said. Stay informed with the latest business news, updates on bank holidays and public holidays . AI Masterclass for Students. Upskill Young Ones Today!– Join Now
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Trump claims Thailand-Cambodia ceasefire 'an easy one', as he 'settled' India-Pakistan conflict
Following a major fallout after his attempted use of the trade leverage in reaching a ceasefire agreement between Thailand and Cambodia, US President Donald Trump on Sunday (local time) stated that he was optimistic about brokering the peace deal between the Southeast Asian nations, describing the talks as "an easy one," compared to his past claims of resolving the India-Pakistan conflict. Speaking to reporters during his meeting with European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, Trump reiterated his commitment to using economic pressure to end the ongoing border war between the two Southeast Asian nations. Explore courses from Top Institutes in Please select course: Select a Course Category Artificial Intelligence MBA Product Management PGDM MCA Project Management Design Thinking Technology Leadership others Data Science Management Data Science Cybersecurity Public Policy Digital Marketing Degree CXO Others Healthcare healthcare Data Analytics Operations Management Finance Skills you'll gain: Duration: 7 Months S P Jain Institute of Management and Research CERT-SPJIMR Exec Cert Prog in AI for Biz India Starts on undefined Get Details "We're dealing with Thailand, and we do a lot of trade with Thailand and with Cambodia, and yet I'm reading that they're killing each other. You know, they're fighting. They're in a war. And I say this should be an easy one for me because I've settled with India and Pakistan and Serbia and Kosovo were going at it," Trump said. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like It's Not To late To Check For This Refund Worth Up To £4,172* Refundo Learn More As per Al Jazeera, Cambodia and Thailand, earlier in the day, accused each other of launching artillery attacks, just hours after Trump said both countries had agreed to hash out a ceasefire. The attacks on Sunday came after both sides said they were willing to start talks to end the fighting over their border dispute after Trump spoke to their leaders late on Saturday. Live Events Bangkok and Phnom Penh are engaged in a territorial dispute dating back over a century, when colonial-era France first demarcated the border between them, CNN reported. He recounted calling the Prime Minister of Cambodia and the acting Prime Minister of Thailand, asserting, "I said we're not going to make a trade deal unless you settle the war... And I spoke to both of the Prime Ministers, and I think by the time I got off, they wanted to settle now." Trump drew confidence from his mediation efforts, particularly citing the India-Pakistan conflict, which he claimed was "really getting ready to go at it." Trump was referencing the recent India-Pakistan conflict in May, where he had claimed credit several times for brokering a ceasefire between the two nuclear nations, using trade as leverage. The conflict erupted after 26 civilians were killed in the April 22 terror attack in Pahalgam, after which India retaliated through precision strikes under Operation Sindoor, targeting terrorist infrastructure in Pakistan and Pakistan-occupied Jammu and Kashmir (PoJK). However, according to Indian officials, it was Pakistan's Director General of Military Operations (DGMO) who contacted their Indian counterpart to request an end to hostilities, following which the ceasefire was then agreed upon. "Getting those things settled if I can do it and if I can use trade to do that, it's my honour," he added, reflecting his belief in trade as a diplomatic tool. Four days after the worst fighting in more than a decade broke out between the Southeast Asian neighbours, the death toll stood above 30, including 13 civilians in Thailand and eight in Cambodia. Over 200,000 people have also been evacuated from border areas in the two countries, authorities said, as per Al Jazeera.
