logo
Africa's first telco data credit score aims to bring the ‘invisible' into the financial fold

Africa's first telco data credit score aims to bring the ‘invisible' into the financial fold

Daily Maverick6 hours ago

TransUnion and Chinosis have teamed up to create Africa's first telco data credit score and bring millions of 'invisible' Africans into the financial fold.
Just 13% of South African adults have a credit card, which is a small fraction of the population participating in the financial ecosystem.
Financial service providers rely on a rigid credit scoring framework to gauge whether someone is a viable borrower. This results in a huge pool of people who operate outside this view, stranded in a financial blindspot.
A partnership between TransUnion and Chenosis, an MTN Group technology venture, aims to change this status quo. The two companies are set to launch Africa's first phone data-based scoring system by Thursday, 3 July.
A new lens for old blindspots
The continent's financial ecosystem mirrors its colonial borders: fragmented, exclusionary and sometimes slow to evolve.
'Exclusion is part of the African narrative,' said Lee Naik, TransUnion CEO, reflecting on his own roots in Chatsworth, an Indian township in KwaZulu-Natal, where he grew up under apartheid.
'When I say I can feel what it means to be disconnected from the broader ecosystem, it's literally how I grew up,' he said.
Africa has more than 350 million people who are disconnected from the financial system, and yet more than 510 million are subscribed to mobile services.
'For many Africans, for many South Africans, we feel disconnected. Having access to mobile telephony isn't the answer in itself,' Naik said. 'We all want to be heard. We all want to be seen. We all want to be known. The question is, does telco data allow us to do that?'
Your phone is a financial mirror
The scoring system parses numerous signals – how frequently a phone is used, phone number stability and phone swapping, to name a few – to piece together a view of financial activity.
'A mobile device is not just a device. It helps you get a view of the reflection of how a person lives,' said Waheem Amra, head of product and platform at Chenosis.
If you look at someone's recharge pattern, for instance, it might give you insights into how they earn and manage their money, Fatgie Adams, TransUnion's head of credit risk solutions, said.
Another metric taken into account is sub-tenure, which is how long you've had your mobile device, along with how long you've had a phone number, he explained. If you've gone through six phone numbers in a short period, it signals something different than someone who sticks with their number, he explained.
'We don't just collect this data. We aggregate it over time so it's physically sound. We transform it and structure it and pass it on to a translator.'
Amra explained that the group of people this system aims to aid are not financially inactive. The problem is rather that traditional credit scoring systems can't see how they spend their money.
Tackling financial exclusion
According to Naik, about 16 million South Africans remain excluded from the financial system and another four million are underserved.
The new scoring system aims to bring these people into view by interpreting financial behaviour previously dismissed.
'Are we adequately and accurately assessing these individuals for their creditworthiness?' Adams asked. 'Or are we merely declining them because they don't look like the borrowers of the past?'
The system has implications beyond individual borrowers. Providing financial products to small businesses employing between one and five people can act as a way to address unemployment in the continent, Naik said.
How does this affect you?
Ease of access to credit: If you're a South African with a meagre or non-existent credit profile, this scoring system could help you borrow money.
An opportunity to progress: Better credit means lower borrowing costs, a chance to move from the informal to the formal financial sector, and a path towards financial stability.
Financial independence: Access to loans can empower you to pursue goals, like starting a business, improving your home or sending your children to school.
Small business growth: Small enterprises can use this scoring to access funding and employ more people.
Privacy, consent and trust
Of course, accessing phone data brings responsibilities. TransUnion says that consent, compliance with the Protection of Personal Information Act and scalable trust are all baked into this system.
'Before any data can be transferred we get consent from the customer, but they can also opt out of it,' Amra said. 'It's a transparent process where the customer is completely in control.'
Every confirmation of consent is also time-stamped and audited, adding another layer of oversight to assure both consumers and lenders that the data is fair and transparent.
A precedent for Africa
In trialling this scoring approach with major South African lenders, the two companies found that 1.9 million previously 'invisible' people fell into view, a 35% improvement in predicting credit performance and a 20% drop in bad debt.
Today, TransUnion operates in eight African markets. The goal is to expand this system to all 54 countries on the continent and onboard more telcos, Naik said.
The telco data score isn't meant to replace traditional credit scoring, but to get a more complete picture of an individual, Amra said. 'We didn't just create a product, we created a new capability for the industry.' DM

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

MTI liquidators hit a snag in the UK courts
MTI liquidators hit a snag in the UK courts

The Citizen

time40 minutes ago

  • The Citizen

MTI liquidators hit a snag in the UK courts

You're out of time, says court – but liquidators reissue claims against investors. It's beginning to look like the liquidators are engaging in high-risk, expensive litigation where the prospects of success appear slim. Picture: Adobe Stock UK-based investors in collapsed bitcoin scam Mirror Trading International (MTI) briefly celebrated a victory when a UK court struck out the liquidators' claims, with costs, in their attempt to recover funds. From the court papers it appears that the liquidators and their UK solicitors, Farrer & Co, were responsible for making the error that resulted in the strike out. Interestingly, Farrer & Co, is the same firm that represents the British royal family. During proceedings the liquidators made it clear that the UK application was issued to ensure that the claims were not 'time-barred' under SA prescription law – meaning they still had time to press their claims against the UK investors. That appears to have backfired. Under SA prescription law, a claim of this nature expires after three years unless 'interrupted' in that period, such as by the serving of summons on the debtor. The lawyers representing the liquidators identified 9 April 2024 as the potential date for time-barring under the SA Insolvency Act. This is three years after the date they claim to have obtained the 'back office' database from Maxtra Technologies, the Indian software company that developed and hosted the MTI database. ALSO READ: MTI kingpin Johann Steynberg reportedly died in Brazil Series of errors The UK application was issued on 9 April 2024. However, Farrer & Co only served the application on the respondents on 5 August 2024. During court proceedings it transpired that the delay in serving the application resulted in a breach of the rules governing the service of claims in insolvency proceedings. In the UK court, it was argued by investors that the application was served out of time. The court agreed and struck out the liquidators' claim with costs. The UK court also rejected the liquidators' request for an extension of time to serve the application, as such an extension would be prejudicial to the respondents due to prescription. It also dismissed the liquidators' request to admit the evidence of their South African counsel on the basis that he was not an independent expert. A series of basic errors therefore appears to have been made by the liquidators and their legal team, resulting in significant costs being incurred by and awarded against the liquidators. ALSO READ: Mirror Trading International liquidators claim R4,6 billion from 18 masterminds Investor offer accepted – or not? Prior to these proceedings being launched in the UK, one investor attempted to settle the matter with an offer more than six times his investment. The offer was made to Farrer & Co in March 2024. In correspondence filed with a South African court in April 2024 the offer was reported to have been accepted by the liquidators. However, Farrer & Co only communicated acceptance of the offer to the investor in August 2024 – by which time the likely prescription deadline had passed and the offer was no longer on the table. Despite this, Moneyweb understands the liquidators continue to instruct Farrer & Co. Identical proceedings (to those that were already booted by the UK court) were reissued on 8 November 2024 and served on the respondents on 19 December 2024. A legal expert contacted by Moneyweb believes the re-issued proceedings in the UK are now highly likely to be 'time-barred' by the SA Prescription Act. ALSO READ: Made some money off Time for Mirror Trading International? It's time to pay up Slim chance of success If the UK respondents registered with MTI in their own names, the liquidators' claims should be time-barred three years after they received the back-office database from Maxtra Technologies. In the UK court papers the liquidators clearly indicated that they had received the back office database on 9 April 2021. Consequently, any proceedings issued after 10 April 2024 are highly likely to be out of time. At this point it is beginning to look like the liquidators are engaging in high-risk, expensive litigation where the prospects of success appear to be very small. Are they acting in the best interest of creditors?' Moneyweb reached out to the liquidators for comment but had not received a reply at the time of publication. An 'MTI Creditors Group' is in the process of being established for concerned investors at mtiactiongroup@ This article was republished from Moneyweb. Read the original here.

Everyday items in South Africa cost R1 808 more than a year ago
Everyday items in South Africa cost R1 808 more than a year ago

IOL News

timean hour ago

  • IOL News

Everyday items in South Africa cost R1 808 more than a year ago

Oils and fats prices increased 5.6% year-on-year, while the price of fruits, nuts, and vegetables jumped between 10.3% and 13.5% year-on-year. Despite this positive trend, the compounding nature of inflation means that prices for essential goods continue to rise each month. According to Statistics South Africa's latest inflation report for May 2025, the consumer price index stands at 2.8% year-on-year, a notable improvement from the 5.2% recorded a year prior. The cost of living in South Africa has shown signs of slowing, with an annual decline of 2.4 percentage points; however, average monthly bills have still increased by 2.6% from May of last year, resulting in an additional R21 000 in annual expenses for households. Based on a basket of goods the average South African may be spending their money on each month, and taking compounding into account against the base price, every day items cost R1 808 more than a year ago. This is based on the most recent prices for this year, and doesn't take cost variations into account. Even without historical price data on items such as DSTV Compact Plus not being readily available, the increase amounts to R21 702 over the year. And that's allowing for lower price hikes of one item offsetting the increase in others. It's worse if you smoke or drink – those items on average went up year-on-year by 4.3%. If your weekend party stash of drink cost R1 000 last May, it went up by R43. That, based on advertisements from liquor stores, is worth almost half the cost of a six pack of beer.

SA's new labour migration policy — critics doubt its effectiveness, say it does not strike a balance
SA's new labour migration policy — critics doubt its effectiveness, say it does not strike a balance

Daily Maverick

time6 hours ago

  • Daily Maverick

SA's new labour migration policy — critics doubt its effectiveness, say it does not strike a balance

In a new policy white paper, the government makes several far-reaching proposals to restrict the employment of foreign citizens. Critics warn that instead of protecting jobs, the policy will do damage. South Africa has finally put forward a coherent plan to manage labour migration. The White Paper on National Labour Migrant Policy, which the Cabinet approved on 29 May, marks the government's first comprehensive attempt to define who gets to work here, and under what conditions they will be allowed to do so. It arrives as the unemployment rate remained stubbornly high at 32.9% in the first quarter of 2025. In this climate, political pressure to prioritise South African jobs has grown, as evidenced by rising xenophobia and misinformation about migrant numbers, the white paper states. Immigrants made up 8.9% of employed workers in 2022, largely in sectors where local participation is low, such as construction, agriculture, logistics and informal trade. The proposed policy is trying to prioritise South African workers while acknowledging regional and sectoral reliance on foreign labour. Whether it succeeds is another matter. 'What might create South African jobs in the short term may ultimately harm the country's ability to recruit skilled workers, attract investment and promote trade,' said Professor Loren Landau, a migration researcher based at Oxford University and the University of the Witwatersrand. The policy is designed to inform proposed amendments to the Employment Services Act (ESA), with the aim of imposing stricter control on how foreign nationals are hired in South Africa. The crux of the reform is sector-specific quotas that will cap the number of foreign nationals employers can hire in certain industries and occupations once the amendments have been passed by Parliament. 'Internationally, the practice of reserving the right of occupational choice is not uncommon in democracies,' said Sashin Naidoo, employment law lawyer at Cliffe Dekker Hofmeyr. Employers will also need to prove that no suitably qualified South African was available for the job, submit a skills transfer plan and pay foreign and local workers on par. The ESA did not set out the practical requirements for these skills transfer plans, said Taryn York, senior associate employment lawyer at Cliffe Dekker Hofmeyr. 'However, it does say the minister may make regulations setting out these requirements.' Failure to comply could result in fines of up to R100,000, a prospect that has employers on edge. 'Although a drive to increase em­­ployment of local workers is admirable, the task of skills transfer and upskilling of employees should not also be placed at the feet of the private sector,' said Jaco Swart, national manager of the National Employers' Association of South Africa. The proposed changes will introduce more uncertainty for migrant workers. Mandla Masuku, president of the Migrant Workers Union of South Africa (Miwusa), said most migrants were not in the country by choice but because of unforeseen circumstances in their home countries. 'Some have been here for many years,' Masuku said. 'They've got families, they've got properties. If they are going to be affected by these policies, it is not going to affect them alone.' He also raised concerns that migrants might not fully grasp how the policy would be enforced or what their rights would be under a new system. When quotas clash A legal showdown may be brewing between the Employment Equity Act and the ESA. Although recent proposed amendments to the former included sectoral transformation targets, the ESA's amendments go a step further, granting the minister of labour the authority to impose hard quotas on the hiring of foreign nationals. 'We've got these two pieces of legislation, one having a quota and one having a sector target,' said Imraan Mahomed, director of employment law at Cliffe Dekker Hofmeyr. 'There is already existing authority in the Constitutional Court that has found that the imposition of quotas is unconstitutional. 'The minister distances himself from any consideration that sectoral targets are quotas. It's not going to be a sectoral target in relation to foreigners, it's going to be a quota. I suspect there's going to be a legal challenge when it comes to these quotas.' The policy is presented as a dual-purpose tool: to promote local employment and safeguard migrant rights. As with most of the government's ambitions, the execution is where reality starts to wobble. 'The government has typically based its policies on a relatively poor reading of the true economy or the impact of immigration on it,' Landau said. 'While dramatically underestimating the positive impacts of immigration, it dramatically overpromises on its capacity to regulate labour conditions and migration.' Masuku, too, was sceptical of the policy's effectiveness. 'I suspect that it will be just another policy that is there, maybe for the purpose of proving a point to citizens. But, in terms of practicality, I don't think it will have a huge impact.' Swart echoed these doubts: 'The issue is not that employers are unwilling to appoint South African citizens, it is simply that the skills are not locally available, a consequence of a failed education system. 'The current proposal does not strike a balance, nor will it assist the unemployment crisis or ensure a skills transfer in the country.' A regional vision One of the policy's more progressive features is its regional outlook. It aligns with AU and Southern African Development Community frameworks and proposes the introduction of SADC visas, which are intended to ease cross-border work and allow for portable social protections. Lee Masuku, senior associate lawyer in employment law at Cliffe Dekker Hofmeyr, said these would include a special work visa in the SADC region, special traders' visas and SADC small and medium enterprise visas. The policy also calls for updated labour agreements with neighbouring states like Zimbabwe, Lesotho and Mozambique, but Landau views these gestures as superficial. 'The existing policies may or may not reshape the labour market, but they do send a clear message to the region that South Africa is now more unilateral than ever. Given how much of its market is regional… this will likely hurt business and job creation,' he said. The policy also largely ignores where most migrant workers actually operate: in the informal sector, undocumented and unprotected. Asked whether the policy protected informal migrant workers, Landau answered: 'Simply put, no.' He added that it lacked mechanisms that recognise or protect the humanity and labour rights of migrant workers outside formal employment. Masuku warned further that employers might exploit undocumented migrants more if fewer legal work routes existed. For all its talk of order and oversight, the white paper admits that the policy is based on sparse and outdated data, and promises a better information system. The scattering of administrative data, the policy's lack of alignment to international standards, missing indicators and minimal use of both administrative and statistical data by policymakers are some of the key challenges the white paper identifies. 'A more robust reading of the regional economy which includes informal trade, fast fashion, small and unregistered business development in and through South Africa might suggest that national employment and regional obligations are complementary, not at odds,' Landau said. York gave a warning to employers operating in the agriculture, hospitality, tourism and construction sectors, saying they should prepare for the introduction of quotas on hiring foreign nationals. According to Masuku, Miwusa has a close re­­lationship with the labour union federation Cosatu and consulted with it to better understand the policy. 'We must work together to ensure that workers, regardless of their nationality, are not [negatively] affected by these kinds of policies,' he said. DM This story first appeared in our weekly Daily Maverick 168 newspaper, which is available countrywide for R35.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store