Andy Robertson says Man United didn't give Scott McTominay respect he deserved
Andy Robertson thinks that Scotland teammate Scott McTominay will have proved a lot of people wrong after a stunning season with Napoli. (Image: Craig Williamson - SNS Group)
The decision to allow Scott McTominay to leave Manchester United last summer for a measly £25m may not have provoked a huge outcry among the club's fanbase (though there were definitely dissenting voices) but the call looked more and more ridiculous with every goal the midfielder banged in as he led Napoli to the Serie A title.
His stunning success in Italy alongside Scotland teammate Billy Gilmour has been quite the rejoinder to his doubters, with fans of the Red Devils now in almost total consensus that their club made a huge error in allowing their academy product to slip from their grasp.
Advertisement
For his captain at international level, though, Scotland skipper Andy Robertson, it has been hugely satisfying to watch. McTominay, in his book, simply didn't get the respect that he deserved while he was at Old Trafford, and now he has proved it beyond all doubt.
'I think he went over there with a point to prove,' Robertson said.
'I think he wanted to prove Man Utd wrong and prove people in the Premier League wrong. And he's went over there and done that pretty successfully.
(Image: Giuseppe Maffia - SNS Group) 'That's credit to him, credit to his attitude and his determination to be the best version of himself. Now he's a king over there.
Advertisement
'At Man Utd he probably lacked getting that run of games consistently, he was in and out and things like that. He probably didn't get the respect he deserves.
'Then he goes over there, puts in a magnificent season and fair play to him, to end it with the league title.
Read more:
'Scott is a winner, we see that every day in training because he sets standards, looks after himself. He talks to the young lads and tries to give off his experience.'
Robertson has been delighted to see the way that McTominay and Gilmour have been embraced by their now adoring public in Naples, and thinks the experiences they have picked up in Italian football can only be a benefit to Scotland too.
Advertisement
Though, there is one adornment to McTominay's personality from his time in Italy that he could live without.
'He's started speaking to us in Italian on the pitch!' he said.
'I watched the [final] game, saw his goal and reaction was special.
'It's impossible to overlook Billy because he's been excellent since we went over there as well. But McTominay has taken it to a whole new level, he was voted the best player in the league.
'It was special for the both of them. Billy was talking about how if he goes out in Naples he can walk about a bit more freely, while Scotty is surrounded.
'It's a massive club, a big fanbase. We played them a couple of times in the Champions League and it's not an easy place to go.
Advertisement
'Everyone knows how passionate their fans are so for them to love one of ours, it's pretty special for Scotland too.
'They love Billy too so credit to the both of them for going over there, being successful and winning the trophy.
'Even before he was at Napoli, his standard for Scotland was unbelievable. He's getting better and better as well - he's taken it to a whole new level.
'Scotty now knows a different way of playing in Italian football and that can only help us.'
That goes too for the rest of the players involved in a mini-Scottish invasion of the continent, with Robertson in no doubt that their skillsets in both a technical and mental sense will have benefitted from the exposure to varying styles of football and different ways of life.
Advertisement
'We have seen Scott and Billy go [to Italy], we've seen Lewis Ferguson go there, Aaron Hickey, Che Adams,' he said.
(Image: Giuseppe Maffia - SNS Group) 'We've got Max Johnston playing abroad as well and when players move abroad, they see a different way of playing and a different lifestyle.
'That can only help the young lads coming through and I wouldn't be surprised if they're thinking they want to go and try it.
'That's credit to lads for stepping out of their comfort zone.'
As well as McTominay and Gilmour winning the Scudetto this season, Ferguson captained Bologna to the Coppa Italia, Johnston won the Austrian Bundesliga with Sturm Graz, while Robertson himself tucked another English Premier League winners' medal into his collection.
Advertisement
That success too will, Robertson reckons, help instil a winning mentality into the Scotland side, and help in moments where the stakes are high.
'I said two or three years ago, when lads were qualifying for Champions League and winning leagues up here,' he said.
'Quite a few of the lads were doing well in the Championship, so I felt it was good for us because it can only help if people are used to lifting trophies.
'When you have that feeling of celebrating it can only help because it grows and grows the more you do it.
'I feel the more people we have with that winning mentality, playing in finals and playing in the final match of the season when you have to win, then it can only help us when things get high pressure for Scotland.
Advertisement
'This season has been a pretty good one on that front, lads have played in high-pressure games, won titles and won trophies.
'That can only help us going forward, and more people will come up as well. The more who are playing in big games, when it comes to us needing to win a big game for Scotland in a qualifier, a play-off game or whatever, then we're a bit calmer because we have that experience.
'That's crucial for us going forward.'
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
41 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Roma to add five reinforcements this summer
Roma to add five reinforcements this summer Roma are planning to strengthen the roster at Gian Piero Gasperini's disposal. The Italian technician was officially announced on Friday, with Roma ready to begin working on the upcoming summer transfer window. Advertisement According to La Gazzetta dello Sport, Gasperini has been clear in his discussions with Roma's top management as for the technical demands for this offseason. The newspaper claims Gasperini has asked for five reinforcements, four of which could be starting in his line-up. Roma are likely to pursue the following positions: a centreback; a right-back; two midfielders; and a striker to pair with Dovbyk.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Report: Newcastle Chasing Premier League Winger Again
Newcastle Eyeing Anthony Elanga in Fresh Transfer Move Newcastle United have reignited their interest in Nottingham Forest winger Anthony Elanga, according to recent reports from Sky Sports. With Eddie Howe keen on bolstering his attacking options, the Magpies have reportedly made initial contact with Forest over the possibility of securing Elanga's services this summer. Photo IMAGO Renewed Interest from Eddie Howe Eddie Howe's admiration for Elanga is well-documented. Sky Sports journalists Keith Downie and Lyall Thomas confirmed that the Newcastle manager had previously attempted to bring the winger to St James' Park on Deadline Day last summer. Although a deal failed to materialise then, Howe clearly sees Elanga as a pivotal part of his attacking plans. Impressive Season at Forest Elanga proved instrumental for Nottingham Forest during the last campaign. His six goals and 11 assists in 38 Premier League appearances highlight his significance in Forest's commendable run, ultimately securing them qualification for the UEFA Europa Conference League. With three years left on his current contract, Forest will not let the 23-year-old leave easily, especially given his contributions since joining from Manchester United in July 2023. Transfer Competition and Strategy Elanga is among four top winger targets identified by Newcastle. Securing his signature, however, could be complicated, as Forest will undoubtedly demand a substantial fee given his recent performances and contractual situation. The pursuit indicates Newcastle's intent to continue strengthening their squad after recent investments and improvements under Howe's guidance. Newcastle's Ambitions Clear The renewed attempt to sign Elanga sends a clear message about Newcastle's ambitions for the upcoming season. Adding a talent like Elanga, who offers pace, creativity, and consistent attacking threat, would considerably boost their chances of competing at higher levels domestically and possibly in Europe in the near future. Advertisement As negotiations potentially unfold, Newcastle supporters will hope the club's persistence pays off. Anthony Elanga could be exactly the kind of exciting, young talent to further elevate the Magpies. Our View – EPL Index Analysis As a Newcastle supporter, hearing about our renewed interest in Anthony Elanga is genuinely exciting. Eddie Howe clearly values players with energy, speed, and versatility, and Elanga ticks all these boxes. He showed immense promise at Forest last season, helping them clinch European football—something Newcastle fans desperately want to see return to St James' Park regularly. While Elanga might not be the biggest name in the Premier League, his consistent assists and goals tally demonstrate the potential we urgently need in wide areas. Moreover, signing a player who excelled at a club like Forest sends a positive message about our ambition. It shows we're not just interested in star names but focused on effective, quality signings who can immediately enhance the squad. However, it's crucial we act decisively this time. Missing out on him last summer was frustrating, and Newcastle must now show they're serious contenders in the market. Elanga's ability to thrive under pressure at Forest suggests he'd handle the expectations at Newcastle well. Let's hope our management secures this promising talent swiftly, reinforcing our squad ahead of what promises to be a thrilling season.


New York Times
2 hours ago
- New York Times
Jean-Clair Todibo is here to stay at West Ham – expect more front-foot defending
Jean-Clair Todibo stood forlornly, then gazed towards the technical area as he removed the white taping from his wrist. Moments earlier, he had grimaced in the direction of the West Ham United bench, having felt pain in his lower leg. The 25-year-old defender was consoled by team-mates but headed towards the tunnel knowing another spell on the sidelines awaited him. Advertisement It came during a chastening 4-1 away defeat against Manchester City on the first weekend in January. He had aggravated a previous calf problem and would be out this time for nearly six weeks. Todibo showed glimpses of his quality following his arrival on a season-long loan from French side Nice in August, a deal which carried an obligation to buy. But following the news that West Ham have now completed the signing of the centre-back on a five-year contract for £32.9million (€39m; $44.4m), doubts over his fitness linger. Todibo, who won two caps for France in 2023, made 27 Premier League appearances last season, 20 of them starts, but was substituted off on 11 occasions. Following Graham Potter's appointment as coach in January, the Frenchman was one of his preferred defensive options. Todibo, who had interest from Juventus and Newcastle United last summer before his move to the London Stadium, mostly featured alongside Maximilian Kilman in the middle of a back four but also played in a three-man defence. His ball-carrying ability is his strength but lapses in concentration and his aerial presence still require work. That said, his arrival at West Ham was considered a coup in a window that saw the departures of fellow central defenders Nayef Aguerd and Kurt Zouma on season-long loans to Real Sociedad in Spain and Saudi Arabia's Al Orobah respectively. Todibo made his debut in August's opening-weekend home loss against Aston Villa as a late substitute but West Ham's then head coach Julen Lopetegui only introduced him to the starting XI gradually. A player once signed by Barcelona at age 19 came off the bench again at Crystal Palace the following weekend, started the Carabao Cup win over Bournemouth but got replaced at half-time and was then an unused sub in the next three league matches against City, Fulham and Chelsea. He did not make his first Premier League start until the 1-1 draw away to Brentford on September 28, six weeks after signing. Advertisement A mitigating factor behind his slow start was the fact he did not have a proper pre-season, featuring in Nice's friendlies against Lausanne (July 10) and Leganes (July 19) but not playing for them again as the move to West Ham gathered pace. 'I'm happy because the club gave me the time to get fit,' Todibo told the club's website after his first full 90 minutes that day in west London. 'It took me a bit of time to come back well. The game is more intense in the Premier League than in Ligue 1, more intense than all the leagues in the world, I think. Today I'm not 100 per cent, but I think I'm going to improve more with time, and have a good impact in the team.' However, the forthcoming months were laced with frustration. As a result of his calf injury, the centre-back missed games against Leicester City (December 3), Bournemouth (December 16), Villa (in the FA Cup, January 10), Fulham (January 14), Palace (January 18), Villa again (January 26) and Chelsea (February 2). Todibo did then offer encouragement as far his his fitness was concerned, starting 12 of the final 13 league fixtures from the middle of February. In an attempt to address the muscular difficulties that stunted his momentum, Todibo travelled home to France in January to get a second opinion from his private doctor of eight years. A scan revealed issues with his lower limb. His path to truly winning over the West Ham fans starts this summer. When fully fit, Todibo is capable of being a solid performer, someone whose skillset aligns with Potter's preferred style of play. He was admired by Nottingham Forest and Manchester United, and had trials with both before joining Toulouse from Les Lilas, an amateur club in the Paris area, at age 16 in summer 2016. Over the past nine years, Todibo has developed into an aggressive defender. The graphic below, which looks at his 'true' tackles — a combination of tackles won, tackles lost, and fouls conceded while attempting a tackle per 1,000 opposition touches — gives an indication of how often he likes to leave a mark when the opposition have the ball. Todibo ranked eighth among centre-backs with 900+ minutes of Premier League game time in this metric last season, while his true-tackle win rate of 73 per cent is also very high — which suggests he often backs that front-footedness up by escaping from a challenge with the ball more often than not. A weaker side of his game, however, is the ball in the air — though he is 6ft 3in (192cm), only nine Premier League centre-backs with 900-plus minutes last season won a lower proportion of their aerial duels. But, similar to his central-defensive colleague Kilman, there are no concerns with Todibo's passing ability. He is a strong ball-carrier and when in possession, rarely opts to go long. Having said that, there is scope to be more expansive with his varied passing range; around 8.5 per cent of Todibo's passes last season were progressive — just 11 top-flight centre-backs look forward with their passes less often. Dubai is Todibo's preferred destination when in search of rest and relaxation during the off-season. He is spending quality time with loved ones but is intent on avenging those debut-year setbacks and helping his new parent club return to previous heights. 'In France, we say 'Rome ne s'est pas faite en un jour', which is like the saying 'Rome wasn't built in one day', because it takes time,' Todibo told West Ham's website in April. 'The manager (Potter) came and the situation was difficult, and we need to build something. We just need more time with this manager, because when you have the positives in the game, the result is going to come. 'There is no rush. You don't have to rush. I think if you want to be smart and productive, you should work for it. It's more like this and we prepare for the next season — because next season has to be big.'