Zohran Mamdani said NYPD shouldn't respond to domestic violence calls in resurfaced podcast interview
The 33-year-old democratic socialist said that the NYPD shouldn't respond to domestic violence calls due to fears of 'escalation' by New York's Finest in a 2020 interview on the Immigrantly podcast, as first reported by the Washington Free Beacon.
'If somebody is surviving, going through domestic violence – there are so many different, different situations that would far better be handled by people trained to deal with those specific situations as opposed to an individual with a gun who has received quite a limited amount of training in general, but also in regards to these specific situations,' the Queens pol said.
Advertisement
While on the Immigrantly podcast in 2020, Democratic mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani said the NYPD shouldn't be responsible for responding to domestic violence calls.
Matthew McDermott
Mamdani also noted that the NYPD shouldn't similarly respond to situations involving homeless people on the train or jaywalking due to fears of 'escalation' that could have fatal results.
The candidate ran successfully for state Assembly in 2020, years before his Democratic Party primary victory in the crowded mayoral race last month.
Advertisement
'We find so many people who are having a mental breakdown, or people who are just trying to sleep on the train, or people who are just suffering through something in their lives,' Mamdani said in the podcast.
'And instead of receiving a helping hand they were shot, they were Tased, they were killed.'
The resurfaced clip reveals Mamdani saying, 'there are so many different, different situations that would far better be handled by people trained to deal with those specific situations,' in regards to handling domestic violence.
Advertisement
Mamdani's campaign platform advocates for a new $1 billion Department of Community Safety that would respond to mental health crises and other situations usually handled by the police.
A representative for the campaign did not respond to a request for comment.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Los Angeles Times
24 minutes ago
- Los Angeles Times
By scrapping bid for California governor, Harris boosts White House prospects -- if she runs
By closing one door, Kamala Harris has left another ajar. Running for California governor in 2026, which she ruled out Wednesday, would almost certainly have precluded another run for the White House in 2028 — something Harris explicitly did not rule out. There were significant hurdles to attempting both. To have any chance of being governor, Harris would have almost certainly had to have sworn off another presidential bid, convincing California voters that the state's top political job was not something she viewed, blithely, as a mere placeholder or springboard to the White House. There also would have been the practical difficulty of running the nation's most populous state, a maw of endless crises and challenges, while at the same time pursuing the presidency. No California governor has ever done so successfully, though several tried. Harris' much-anticipated decision, announced in a written statement, was not a huge surprise. Unlike others — Pete Wilson, Gray Davis, Arnold Schwarzenegger, to name a few — Harris has never burned with a fever to be California governor. She had a clear shot at the position in 2016, but opted instead to run for the U.S. Senate, in part because the role seemed like a better launching venue for a try at the White House. Privately, several of those closest to Harris questioned whether she had much appetite to deal with the myriad aggravations of being governor — the stroking and hand-holding of recalcitrant lawmakers, the mind-numbing drafting of an annual budget, the endless march of disasters, both natural and man-made. Not least, many wondered whether Harris would be content returning to the small stage of Sacramento after traveling the world as vice president and working in the rarified air of politics at its peak. There is every possibility that Harris will retire from public life. Sean Clegg, a long-time Harris adviser, noted the Democrat has spent more than two decades in elected office. 'I think she's interested in exploring how she can have an impact from the outside for a while,' Clegg said. For her part, Harris said she looked forward 'to getting back out and listening to the American people [and] helping Democrats across the nation who will fight fearlessly.' Doesn't sound like life in a cloister. If Harris did run for president, she'd start out as a nominal front-runner, based on her universal name recognition and deep nationwide fund-raising base — advantages no other contestant could match. But she won't scare away very many opponents; the Democratic field in 2028 will most likely be a large and expansive one, as it was the first time Harris ran for president in 2020. (And notably crashed and burned.) Charlie Cook, who has spend decades as a nonpartisan political handicapper, said he would view Harris 'as a serious contender, but no more so than a handful of other people would be.' Normally, Cook went on, her status as the party's most recent vice president would give her a significant, if not overwhelming, edge. 'But I think the desire/need to turn the corner and get some separation from Biden probably strips away any advantage that she would have,' Cook said. Harris got a small taste of the Biden burden she could carry in the 2028 campaign when two of her prospective gubernatorial rivals — former Los Angeles Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa and former Health and Human Services Secretary Xavier Becerra — suggested she was complicit in covering up Biden's mental and physical frailties. 'She could say she didn't know,' Villaraigosa taunted in a May interview. 'They can't prove that she did. But last time I looked, she had lunch with him pretty regularly ... She had to have seen what the world [saw] over time and particularly in that debate. The notion that she didn't? Come on. Who's going to buy that?' A strategist for one potential presidential rival suggested Democrats were eager to turn the page on Biden and, along with him, Harris. 'There's a lot of respect for her taking on the challenge of cleaning up Biden's mess in 2024,' said the strategist, who asked to remain nameless to avoid compromising an as-yet-unannounced candidate. 'But I think it's going to be a hard sell. She lost to Donald Trump who was convicted of 34 felony counts and run out of D.C. in shame. There is some blame there for his return.' Should Harris make a third try for the White House, it raises the intriguing possibility of facing her fellow Californian, Gov. Gavin Newsom, who has been effectively running for president for the past several months. The two, who came up together in the elbows-out world of San Francisco politics, have had a decades-long rivalry, sharing many of the same donors and, once upon a time, the same set of strategists. If the two ran, it would be the first time since 1968 that a pair of major Californians faced off for their party's presidential nomination. That year, Gov. Ronald Reagan made a late, failed attempt to overtake Richard Nixon, the former vice president and U.S. senator from California. At it happened, Nixon had waged an unsuccessful 1962 run for California governor after leaving the White House. While that failure didn't stop him from eventually winning the White House, it certainly didn't help. In fact, Nixon left California and moved to the East Coast, taking a job at a white-shoe law firm and using New York City as his political base of operations. Harris' announcement Wednesday promised 'more details in the months ahead about my own plans.' She said nothing about relocating or leaving California behind.
New York Post
24 minutes ago
- New York Post
Nutjob spotted in NYC with ‘long rifle' actually had paintball gun — but he's still under arrest
The career criminal seen casually carrying what appeared to be a long rifle around a Bronx neighborhood was actually carrying a paintball gun — but he'll still face criminal charges, police sources said Wednesday. Rodney Lance, 42, was seen strolling around the Mount Eden area around 12:30 p.m., holding the apparent firearm in his left hand while carrying a backpack, according to cops and a photo obtained by The Post. The shocking sighting briefly caused a nearby school to be placed on lockdown a day after a madman with an AR-15 style rifle stormed into a Midtown skyscraper and killed four people, cops said. 3 Rodney Lance, 42, was allegedly toting what appeared to be a rifle around a Bronx neighborhood Tuesday afternoon, sparking an NYPD investigation. Obtained by NY Post Lance was arrested about two hours later by the NYPD's Emergency Service Unit inside an apartment building on Nelson Avenue near the Edward L. Grant Highway, cops said. The weapon – which sources said was an air pistol, specifically some kind of paintball gun – was found in the building after cops executed a search warrant. Lance was charged with criminal possession of a weapon, menacing and harassment, authorities said. 3 The weapon was determined to be some kind of paintball gun, sources said. Citizen Law enforcement sources initially said Lance, a known 'emotionally disturbed' person, had more than 70 prior arrests on his record – a total that likely includes cases that have since been sealed. The NYPD officially tallied 40 previous arrests for Lance. In his most recent prior bust, Lance allegedly tried to burglarize a residential building on Judge Street near Devoe Street in East Williamsburg July 21, cops said. 3 Lance was charged with criminal possession of a weapon, menacing and harassment, cops said. Google Maps He broke in through the window, using a screwdriver, but fled empty-handed, authorities said. The latest scare came just a day after gunman Shane Tamura, 27, stormed a Manhattan building — home to Blackstone and NFL headquarters — and opened fire with a rifle around 6:30 p.m., killing four people before turning the gun on himself. Among the victims were NYPD Officer Didarul Islam, whose wife is pregnant with their third child; Blackstone executive and mother of two, Wesley LePatner; security guard Aland Etienne; and Julia Hyman, a management associate at building owner Rudin Management.
New York Post
24 minutes ago
- New York Post
NYC primary that included dead voters' ballots is finally decided, but criminal probe swirls
A winner was finally certified in a hotly Brooklyn City Council primary marred by the revelation that ballots had been cast for dead voters — but a criminal investigation will continue. The city Board of Elections certified George Sarantopoulos as the winner of a Republican Party primary over GOP chairman Richie Barsamian on Tuesday after an expose by The Post that showed accusations of voter fraud that included the revelation absentee ballots were cast for at least two dead voters. A third voter said he hadn't voted but received a 'cure notice' that is sent to voters when their ballots contain errors such as a missing signature. Advertisement 4 George Sarantopoulos, Republican candidate for city council. George Sarantopoulos / Facebook The Brooklyn District Attorney's office is now probing the claims, according to sources. Elections officials uncovered two alleged incidents of voter fraud — the dead voters as well as 22 ballots that were discovered during the manual recount that could not be attributed to specific voters. Advertisement 'In a small Republican primary, unlike a mayoral contest, there were multiple ballot irregularities — including two absentee ballots who were casting for people who are deceased, and obviously the one person who was a living voter who did not vote at all,' Sarantopoulous said. 4 Voters feed their ballots into scanners during the first day of early voting at the Brooklyn Museum on Saturday, June 14, 2025 in New York City. Michael Nagle 'We can't let this stand,' he added. 'Democrats, Republicans and independents. We all need to know that we have a system we can trust. Period full stop.' Barsamian, who has the power to appoint BOE workers as chair of borough's Republican Party, did not respond to repeated requests for comment. Advertisement Sarantopoulous ultimately beat Barsamian by a mere 16 votes to challenge Democratic nominee Kayla Santosuosso in November. 4 The Brooklyn District Attorney's office is now probing the claims, according to sources. George Sarantopoulos / Facebook 'Hot take: we shouldn't count ballots cast by dead people and shouldn't certify election results until we know the scale of the fraud involved. Voters deserve nothing less,' Santosuosso said in a statement. The winner of the general election will replace Councilman Justin Brannan, who will reach the end of his term limit at the end of this year. Advertisement The BOE maintains it has been thoroughly transparent throughout the recount process. 4 Brooklyn Republican Party Chairman Richie Barsamian attends a small protest outside a vacant lot at 2481 McDonald Avenue on Sunday, April 6, 2025. Luiz C. Ribeiro for New York Post 'We have completed a comprehensive and transparent review of all valid ballots, including a full hand count,' BOE Deputy Executive Director Vincent Ignizio said in a statement. 'The outcome of the race has remained consistent at every stage,' Ignizio said. 'In accordance with New York State Election Law, all valid votes have been properly counted. 'Our responsibility now is to certify the results and proceed with preparations for the general election in November. Any specific allegations of fraud will be handled appropriately by the District Attorney's office.'
