Indigenous Group Wins Land Claim Over Slice of Metro Vancouver
The Cowichan have aboriginal title to a section of riverbank in the city of Richmond, according to the 863-page ruling published Friday. Interests of the government of Canada and the city in the area alongside the Fraser River outlined in black on a map attached to the ruling 'are defective and invalid,' the judge said.
The court found that in 1846, when the British Crown asserted sovereignty in what is now British Columbia, the Cowichan 'sufficiently and exclusively' occupied a village, its surrounding lands and a strip of submerged lands in what is now Richmond.
Grants later made by the British to others 'unjustifiably infringe' on the Cowichan land title, according to the ruling, which also recognizes the Cowichan descendants' right to fish part of the Fraser River. The plaintiffs called it a 'historic victory.'
Many Indigenous groups in what became Canada signed treaties with the British Crown, predominantly during the 18th and 19th centuries.
That isn't the case in British Columbia, where the lower mainland has some of Canada's most expensive land. Many areas of the province are subject to legal and political disputes.
'I fully expect it'll become a very important precedent,' said David Rosenberg, senior litigation counsel for the plaintiffs, adding that he understood the land affected to be about 750 to 800 acres.
Owners' rights for some 120 properties in the affected area will not change 'except if they come to do something with the property that requires Crown authorization,' Rosenberg said by phone. Property sales by owners who have used the Crown land title system may end up requiring Cowichan consent, he said.
Rosenberg, who represented the Tsilhqot'in Nation in a 2014 Supreme Court case which reinforced Aboriginal rights, said he expects the case will be appealed and may not be resolved for years.
The Cowichan descendants' claim was opposed in court by Canada, British Columbia, Richmond, the Vancouver Fraser Port Authority and two other Indigenous groups — the Tsawwassen First Nation and the Musqueam Indian Band.
Richmond said the decision is under legal review. The Musqueam said they are 'devastated' in a statement, while the Tsawwassen First Nation said they are reviewing the decision with legal counsel. A Port Authority spokesman said the agency is reviewing the decision.
British Columbia Premier David Eby said his attorney general will consider grounds for possible appeal and the province will also seek resolution through out-of-court negotiations with the First Nations.
'Owning private property with clear title is key to borrowing for a mortgage, economic certainty, and the real estate market,' and the province remains committed to upholding that 'this foundation of business and personal predictability, and our provincial economy, for Indigenous and non-Indigenous people alike,' Eby said.
More stories like this are available on bloomberg.com
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Economic Times
23 minutes ago
- Economic Times
Iran says IAEA official to visit for talks, no access to nuclear sites planned
Synopsis A senior U.N. nuclear watchdog official is scheduled to visit Iran for discussions on Monday, according to Iran's Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi, but no visits to nuclear sites are currently planned. Reuters A senior official from the U.N. nuclear watchdog will fly to Iran for talks on Monday, but no visit to nuclear sites is planned, Iran's Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi said on Sunday. Since Israel launched its first military strikes on Iran's nuclear sites during a 12-day war in June, inspectors from the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) have been unable to access Iran's facilities, despite IAEA chief Rafael Grossi stating that inspections remain his top priority. Iran has accused the agency of effectively paving the way for the bombings by issuing a damning report on May 31, which led the IAEA's 35-nation Board of Governors to declare Iran in breach of its non-proliferation obligations. Iran, which denies seeking nuclear weapons, said it remained committed to the nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT). "Negotiations with the IAEA will be held tomorrow to determine a framework for cooperation," Araghchi said on his Telegram account. "A Deputy Director General of Grossi will come to Tehran tomorrow, while there are no plans to visit any nuclear sites until we reach a framework." Last month, Iran enacted a law passed by parliament suspending cooperation with the IAEA. The law stipulates that any future inspection of Iran's nuclear sites by the IAEA needs approval by Tehran's Supreme National Security Council.
Mint
25 minutes ago
- Mint
Netanyahu Defends Gaza Plan Condemned at Home and Abroad
(Bloomberg) -- Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu defended his plan for a military sweep against the final Hamas strongholds in Gaza, calling it the best available option for recovering hostages while safeguarding his country's long-term security — an argument that's met vocal opposition at home and abroad. After talks on a third ceasefire stalled in July, the Netanyahu government on Friday authorized an advance on Gaza City. Israeli forces had previously skirted the area for fear that hostages believed to be held there could be hurt or lost in the chaos of combat. Though the army has yet to mobilize the reinforcements required to roll into action, the plan has drawn condemnation from foreign powers already upset at a hunger crisis besetting Palestinians in Gaza, after Israel cut off aid between March and May in a bid to sideline Hamas. The US, by contrast, has indicated readiness to back its Middle Eastern ally. There's also been recrimination in Israel, where polls for months have shown a majority prefer a negotiated deal to recover all hostages, even if it means winding down the war with Hamas still standing. Relatives of the hostages are calling for a general strike to protest the latest plans. At the other end of the political spectrum, far-right coalition parties are grumbling that the proposal, which Netanyahu says will defeat Hamas once and for all, doesn't go far enough. 'Our goal is not to occupy Gaza. Our goal is to free Gaza — free it from Hamas terrorists,' Netanyahu told foreign reporters at a briefing on Sunday. 'Contrary to false claims, this is the best way to end the war.' In previous statements during the 22-month-old conflict, Netanyahu suggested victory was imminent. He struck a more cautious note on Sunday, declining to give a detailed timeline for advances on Gaza City and, later, on central townships that have also largely been spared incursions. The operations would be 'fairly quick' and prevent Israel getting into a war of attrition with Hamas holdouts, he said. Twenty of the hostages, mostly taken during the Hamas incursions into Israel in October 2023, are believed to be still alive. Hamas has threatened to execute them rather than see them rescued. Their relatives also worry about the risk they could be killed in crossfire once new assaults ramp up. 'The move that I'm talking about, I think, has a possibility of getting them out,' Netanyahu said. Doubling down on his rejection of allegations that Israel has been deliberately starving Gazans, Netanyahu said the 'exact opposite' was true. While acknowledging 'deprivation' in parts of the coastal enclave, he said aid is now reaching its 2 million civilian residents. In contrast, the UN's World Food Program says a quarter of Gazans are on the brink of famine. Hamas authorities say the daily number of trucks entering in the past two weeks, since restrictions on aid deliveries were relaxed by Israel, has averaged 100, far below the 600 the group demands. Still, black market food prices, a measure of scarcity, are dropping. Sugar, at $8.76 a kilo ($3.97 per pound) is about 10 times cheaper than a few days ago. A kilogram of flour costs $3.50 to $4.38, a recent steep decline although still far above the pre-war price of $0.88. Several Western countries, lamenting the protracted conflict, have pledged to recognize a Palestinian state. Germany, historically Israel's most important European ally, intends to stop supplying the Netanyahu government with arms for use in Gaza. Netanyahu said his German counterpart, Chancellor Friedrich Merz, had 'buckled under the pressure' of what he called false media reports and pro-Palestinian groups. 'We will win the war with or without the support of others,' he said. Most Israelis don't want any remnant of Hamas in Gaza nor a Palestinian state to arise there or in the West Bank, Netanyahu said. Hamas, which is committed to the Jewish state's destruction and blacklisted as a terrorist group in much of the West, has sounded undeterred by Netanyahu's plan. 'The weapons of resistance are a legitimate right as long as the occupation remains,' Hamas official Osama Hamdan told Al-Araby TV, reiterating the group's refusal to disarm as demanded by Israel for an open-ended truce. 'The resistance will continue until the establishment of an independent, sovereign Palestinian state.' --With assistance from Alisa Odenheimer, Ethan Bronner, Fares Akram and Fadwa Hodali. (Updates with more comments from Netanyahu, other details throughout.) More stories like this are available on
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Recognise pourakarmikas like Class I, II officers, says Aravinda Malagatti
Mysuru: Former Karnataka Sahitya Academy chairman and noted writer Aravinda Malagatti on Sunday called for greater recognition for pourakarmikas, stating that symbolic gestures like foot-washing ceremonies (pada puja) are not enough. Speaking at the inauguration of a painting exhibition on freedom fighters by artist UG Mohankumar Aradhya, Malagatti said pourakarmikas deserve recognition on par with Class I and Class II officers. The event, held at Kalamandira Suchitra Art Gallery, was organised in collaboration with Kannada Sahitya Kala Koota and Karnataka State Backward Classes Awareness Forum, as part of the Independence Day celebrations. Malagatti urged the state and central govts to treat pourakarmikas with dignity. "Even if they cannot be paid on par with Class I employees, they should at least receive salaries on par with Class II employees," he said. He noted that although the department of Kannada and culture published three volumes on freedom fighters, many unsung heroes — both from the pre-and post-Independence periods — were overlooked. "There is a need for further research to bring their stories to light," he said. "Many participated in the freedom struggle, with some even engaging in battles against the British, while others contributed in some other ways, such as disrupting the British communication lines by cutting telephone wires," he said. He suggested that uncovering and documenting these small stories would ensure their place in history. Legislative council member D Thimmaiah stated that freedom fighters should be remembered year-round, not just during Independence Day. "We are free today as a result of the independence they brought us," he said. Mysuru City Corporation deputy commissioner GS Somashekar presided over the event. Kannada Sahitya Kala Koota president M Chandrashekhar and Karnataka State Backward Classes Awareness Forum president KS Shivaramu and others were present. Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays , public holidays , and current gold rates and silver prices in your area.
