
‘You have to ruffle feathers': a history of controversial jeans adverts
Critics have interpreted the campaign as promoting eugenics, defenders have taken the backlash as evidence of so-called 'woke' culture in the extreme and scrutinising it has taken on the trappings of a cottage industry. 'Clocking in for my shift at the Sydney Sweeney American Eagle opinion factory,' the journalist Hunter Harris wrote on her Substack.
It comes in a long line of provocative jeans adverts, some objectively controversial or offensive, others more subjectively so.
A 1973 campaign from Jesus Jeans that featured the slogan 'you shall have no other jeans before me' sparked discussion for its use of religiosity to sell clothes. The Italian anti-consumerist film director Pier Paolo Pasolini even wrote an essay on the subject in which he said the slogan 'takes the form of a nemesis – although unintentionally – that punishes the church for its pact with the devil'.
A series of 1980s Calvin Klein jeans adverts raised hackles for their use of young female models in sexually suggestive guises. 'You know what gets between me and my Calvin's? Nothing,' mused a 15-year-old Brooke Shields in 1980, in a video directed and shot by Richard Avedon.
In another Calvin Klein campaign from 1995, which was criticised for alluding to child exploitation, models including Kate Moss were filmed as they undid their jeans and were asked: 'Are you nervous?'
'Calvin made millions,' said Allen Adamson, an author and branding expert. 'He was the first one to really understand that buzz and controversy and being disruptive could sell denim.' The Shields campaign was reportedly a huge success, with many customers going into shops to ask for the 'Brooke Shields jeans'.
Levi's also has a history of setting tongues wagging. The famous Nick Kamen ad from the 80s, in which he strips down to his underwear in a laundrette so he can wash his 501s, turned the straight male gaze of most mainstream ads on its head by making the object of desire a male model. According to the fashion historian Tony Glenville: 'It was massive and made it even into spoofs on comedy shows. It made a huge impact on sales and jeans sales generally.'
Levi's made its mark again in 1995 with a campaign in which the Filipino-American fashion designer Zaldy, sitting in the back of a New York taxi in drag, seems to shock the sweaty, lecherous driver ogling her by shaving her chin mid-drive. Landing at a time when there was a lack of LGBTQ+ representation in advertising, the Advertising Standards Authority reportedly came close to banning it.
According to the retail marketing expert Catherine Shuttleworth, campaigns designed to turn heads evolve from a need to 'cut through'. 'Good advertising creates cut through, and when it comes to advertising for clothing, it's really hard to grab people's attention,' she said.
Cutting through in the social media age is arguably much harder than before given the fragmentation of media. Adamson said: 'It's very expensive to reach consumers through traditional media, so you need social media to break through,' especially to reach younger consumers.
Sign up to Fashion Statement
Style, with substance: what's really trending this week, a roundup of the best fashion journalism and your wardrobe dilemmas solved
after newsletter promotion
But given the fact that 'no one shares anything ordinary on social media,' it needs to be bold. 'People only share something extraordinary or different or offensive,' he said. 'To really get talked about on social media, you have to ruffle feathers.'
For jeans this is particularly important. 'The basic challenge is that they've been around forever', said Adamson. 'There is little to no product difference. People can talk about the fit or the stitching. It's basically denim.'
Glenville agreed: 'Sometimes the actual jeans can be a bit dull. It's packaging within the advertising, it's styling and narrative that sells them.'
More so than in the past, the market for denim is also saturated. 'The denim market in America is ginormous,' said Shuttleworth. 'You've got to do something that makes you stand out from the pack. And so I think a lot of those companies will take risks.'
Even going as far as to get your ad banned might be a good thing, she said. 'By getting it banned, everybody talks about it [but] if you get it wrong, suddenly you could have a long-term problem where people boycott your products.'
For Adamson, the worst possible scenario for fashion advertising is that 'no one notices or no one cares'.
It's too early to know what the Sweeney ad's impact on direct sales will be, but it's clear that people noticed and cared, andit doesn't seem to have been bad for business. American Eagle shares climbed 23% in a week, even as commentators began to move on to the next: a Levi's ad in which Beyoncé wears a blonde wig and red lipstick moved the conservative commentator Megyn Kelly to take umbrage and Piers Morgan to accuse the singer of 'culturally appropriating' Marilyn Monroe.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Demi Lovato's full-circle moment: Fans insist 'she's in her best era yet' after reuniting with Joe Jonas with glowing new look following THAT 2010 plane fight on Jonas Brothers tour which led to her famous breakdown
's career went full-circle over the weekend as she reunited with her ex-boyfriend Joe Jonas following her plane fight on the Jonas Brothers tour in 2010 which ultimately led to her famous breakdown. Fans are obsessing over newly-married Demi's glowing new look, insisting she's 'in her best era yet' after overcoming addiction battles, a devastating break-up in 2021 and a nervous breakdown in 2011. Demi, 32, sent fans wild when she made a surprise cameo and performed songs from Disney Channel movie Camp Rock with Joe, 35, Kevin, 37, and Nick, 32, as the musical trio kicked off their 20th anniversary tour in New Jersey at MetLife Stadium. But as well as the iconic reunion, Demi's remarkable transformation has been the talk of the town ever since she graced the stage. Fans say Demi has 'never looked and sounded better' while also noticing how 'happy and healthy' she appeared. One fan said it was 'emotional' to see Demi look 'so happy, in tune with herself and just healing nicely', after a string of hardship. The tweet read: 'After everything demi has been through, and after being a fan of hers for so long, it is so f****** emotional to see her so happy, so in tune with herself, and just healing nicely. she deserves the absolute world'. Other fans added on X: 'Demi making new music, in peace with herself and her past, reunited with the jonas, looking amazing, in love... WHAT A TIME TO BE A LOVATIC', 'Hearing demi lovato singing "I'm exactly where I'm supposed to be" in 2025 being the best and happiest version of herself is everything I ever wanted and needed btw', 'i will always be so endlessly proud of demi. she's truly healed and nothing and no one can ever take that away from her. it's the most beautiful thing in the whole world to witness', 'demi lovato 's new era has officially started', 'I HAVE NO WORDS, THIS IS HER BEST ERA SINCE BTW, I AM SHAKING OMG'. Demi previously opened up about her mid-air altercation with a back-up dancer on a plane and her decision to finally seek help for self-harming, multiple eating disorders and bipolar in 2011. The singer, who was 19 at the time, entered rehab for 'emotional and physical issues' after she punched Alex Welch in the face while on tour with The Jonas Brothers. One fan said it was 'emotional' to see Demi look 'so happy, in tune with herself and just healing nicely', after a string of hardship 'I just felt like she betrayed me,' Demi told America's Elle magazine in 2011, 'That's the bottom line.' But it was ultimately a turning point for the Disney personality. 'When you punch someone on a plane, enough is enough,' she said. The singer revealed she turned to drink and drugs as a pre-teen because she had been 'bullied and was looking for an escape'. The former child star told how she would regularly steal alcohol from her stepfather through her teenage years, before turning to cocaine when she was 17, which she 'loved too much'. Demi was sober for six years from the age of 20 to 26, but suffered a near-fatal overdose in 2018, causing her to be legally blind and brain damaged, after having a heart attack and three strokes while in hospital. And 15 years later, Demi returned to the stage with her ex Joe and his bandmates to mark her incredible transformation. Demi captioned a reel of the pair together, 'For the history books,' tagging into the post her ex Joe, who went on to have two daughters with ex-wife Sophie Turner, 29 - Willa, four, and Delphine, two. The Cool for the Summer songstress since May has been married to musician Jordan Lutes, 34. Jutes marks Lovato's second engagement after ending her first engagement to four-time Daytime Emmy nominee Max Ehrich in 2020 after six months of dating. In 2021, she said her short-lived engagement to Ehrich, who popped the question after four months of dating, gave her a 'false sense of security.' 'I really had myself fooled, because it was the safe and expected thing,' she told Entertainment Weekly. 'Obviously I cared deeply about the person, but there was something inside of me that was like, 'I have to prove to the world that I'm okay.' 'I just don't need an object on my finger to make me feel like I've got my s**t together,' she noted. 'It looks like stability, but it doesn't mean that it is. And I don't actually grow through stability. I find that I like living not in chaos or crisis, but in fluidity.' Demi met Max in March 2020 and they began quarantining together immediately, got engaged that July, and then abruptly split in September. Three years later, Demi, who identifies as non-binary, revealed that she decided to re-adopt she/her pronouns in addition to they/them pronouns. 'I constantly had to educate people and explain why I identified with those pronouns. It was absolutely exhausting,' Demi told GQ Hype Spain. 'I just got tired. But for that very reason I know that it is important to continue spreading the word.' Lutes did not mind seeing his wife reunite with her ex-boyfriend onstage, as he showed support for his spouse via multiple Instagram posts. Lutes did not mind seeing his wife reunite with her ex-boyfriend onstage, as he showed support for his spouse via multiple Instagram posts In the thread of the comment section adjacent to Lovato's reel, Lutes posted three hysterical emojis and four emojis of clapping hands, signalling his love for Lovato amid the high-profile outing. Lutes also took to Instagram Stories to say that he 'couldn't be more proud' of his spouse. Lutes captioned a clip of his wife heading to the stage to perform: 'I love you soooo much baby.'


The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
Why Malin Akerman connects her Hunting Wives character to Melania Trump
Malin Akerman revealed her character Margo in Netflix 's new drama The Hunting Wives was inspired by Melania Trump. Akerman's character, a wealthy housewife, sees her expectations shift when her husband pursues a career in politics, mirroring Melania Trump's public trajectory. The series, an adaptation of May Cobb's 2021 thriller, follows Sophie (Brittany Snow) as she moves to East Texas and becomes involved with a group of socialite housewives. Akerman described Margo as a 'survivor' whose actions are driven by necessity to advance her personal agenda. The Hunting Wives has recently seen a surge in viewership, ranking highly on Netflix's top 10 most-watched series.


The Independent
2 hours ago
- The Independent
Chloe Malle is reportedly the frontrunner to succeed Anna Wintour at Vogue
Chloe Malle is reportedly the frontrunner to succeed Anna Wintour as the new head of editorial content for U.S. Vogue. Malle, currently a Vogue editor and daughter of Candice Bergen, is in the final stages of interviews with Condé Nast executives. The selection process has narrowed down to a few candidates, with the new editor expected to start before New York Fashion Week in September. Anna Wintour announced in June that she would step down as Vogue's editor-in-chief after 37 years. Wintour will retain her roles as Condé Nast's global chief content officer and Vogue's global editorial director, continuing her influential presence in the fashion industry.