UK PM Starmer wins vote in parliament on welfare reform
Force another concession from the government
Reforms criticised for being 'Dickensian'
By Andrew MacAskill and Elizabeth Piper
Lawmakers voted 335 to 260 in favour of the reforms to change some rules for people to claim certain disability and sickness benefits.
A year after winning one of the largest parliamentary majorities in British history, Starmer has seen his personal approval ratings collapse and been forced into several policy reversals by his increasingly rebellious lawmakers.
'Welfare reform, let's be honest, is never easy, perhaps especially for Labour governments,' work and pensions minister Liz Kendall told parliament.
Starmer came into office last year promising his big parliamentary majority would bring an end to the political chaos that defined much of the Conservative Party's 14 years in power. But the revolt over the welfare bill underlines the difficulty he has pushing through unpopular decisions.
The government had initially hoped to save 5 billion pounds ($6.9 billion) a year by 2030 by tightening rules for people to receive disability and sickness benefits.
But after the government conceded to pressure from its lawmakers, it said the new rules would now apply only to future applicants, not to the millions of existing claimants as had been proposed. Analysts estimated the savings would likely be closer to 2 billion pounds.
In the run-up to the vote, ministers and party enforcers known as 'whips' had been locked in frantic last-ditch lobbying of undecided members of parliament to try to win their backing.
In a further last-minute concession to rebels during a debate on the changes, the government backed down on implementing tougher eligibility rules for a key benefit payment until a review into the welfare system had been completed.
Rachael Maskell, one of the leading Labour rebels, called the cuts 'Dickensian' and said they 'belong to a different era and a different party'.
Debbie Abrahams, the head of the work and pensions committee, called the plans a 'dog's breakfast'. Paula Barker, another Labour member of parliament, called the attempt to pass the plans 'the most unedifying spectacle that I have ever seen'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
5 hours ago
- IOL News
Celebrating 85 years of Ela Gandhi
Peace activist, former social worker and parliamentarian, Ela Gandhi, has been chosen to be part of an eminent persons group to guide and champion the National Dialogue later this year. Image: Nadia Khan HAVING been at the helm in the fight for peace and social justice in South Africa, Ela Gandhi's journey serves as an enduring reminder of the power of personal commitment to social change and the profound impact of dedicated activism. Childhood Gandhi, who celebrated her 85th birthday yesterday (Tuesday), said her journey to becoming a peace activist, social worker and later a parliamentarian, started from humble beginnings. She grew up in the Phoenix Settlement in Inanda, which was established by her grandfather, Mahatma Gandhi. He initially came to South Africa to work on a legal case for a merchant in 1893. Ela Gandhi, the youngest of three children, was born on July 1, said her father, Manilal, uncle Harilal, and grandmother, Kasturba Gandhi, joined her grandfather in South Africa in 1897. Gandhi, who was the only woman and Mewalal 'Mewa' Ramgobin (far right) during a placard demonstration on the stairs of the Durban City Hall in 1958. Image: Supplied 'My father was about 4 or 5 years old when they came to South Africa. His two other siblings were born here. However, my grandfather, who had a beautiful house in Beach Grove, returned to India a few years later. When he came back to South Africa, he set up his law practice in Johannesburg. 'However, they later moved to Durban and my grandfather started the newspaper, Indian Opinion. It was during this time that my grandfather became involved in politics and activism. When he first came here he was 24, and thought because he was a lawyer it was a high status symbol. 'Over time all that changed, and he began to realise there was no such thing as status. Everybody has dignity and we should ensure that we treat everyone with dignity, no matter what they do. He also began to look at equality among all people, particularly African people,' she said. Gandhi said in 1904 her grandfather bought the land in Inanda, known as the Phoenix Settlement. She lived there with her father; mother Sushila, and two elder siblings, Sita and Arun Manilal, who have since passed on. 'My grandfather moved the printing press to the settlement. My father, who did not have a formal education as my grandfather, believed the British schooling system was not suitable and was 'brainwashing' children. He later became the editor. Gandhi (centre) with,from left, Asha (daughter), Arti (daughter), Kidar (son) and Neervana (daughter-in-law). Image: Supplied 'However, my father and his siblings were taught at home. When my grandfather returned to India, my parents continued to run the newspaper.'Gandhi said in 1947, when she was 7 years old, she met her grandfather during a visit to India. 'We visited the (Gandhi) Sevagram Ashram where my grandfather was living at the time. We stayed with him in the ashram for about three months.' Gandhi said she had fond memories of growing up in the settlement which was damaged during the 1985 Inanda Riots. It has since been restored and is now a national heritage site. 'There were a lot of residents around us, including the indentured labourers. Over the years, many people lived on the settlement, either to work in the newspaper printing business or to volunteer. I remember we used to gather every evening and say prayers. The prayers were always interfaith. We also learnt the prayers of all faiths.' Gandhi was awarded an honorary doctorate from the Lincoln University in the United Kingdom. Image: Supplied Education Gandhi said she attended the Inanda State-aided Indian School at age 10. 'The school was a wood-and-iron structure with pit toilets. One had to walk through the sugar cane fields for more than a kilometre. My parents said I did not like the school and I got tired with the long walk. My father also said: 'You don't have to go to school to learn. Look at me, I am an editor because I taught myself. There are many ways of learning.' 'But, in actual fact, they did not want to send me to school as they also thought, like my grandfather, that I would be brainwashed. But I insisted on going to school like the other children. However, while I was at home, a British lady who lived with us and helped my father with the press, taught me to read and write. After a while, a teacher from the school came to our home in the afternoons to teach me. It was only when I was 10 years old that I started Standard 4 (Grade 6) at the school. They tested me to see if I could read and write, which I did, so I didn't have to start at Class 1,' she said. Gandhi and her husband, Mewalal 'Mewa' Ramgobin with a group of Buddhist Monks standing on the platform of what was her grandfather, Mahatma Gandhi's home in the Phoenix Settlement in 1998. Image: Supplied Gandhi said she attended Durban Girls' Indian High School from Standard 7 until matric, which she completed in 1957. 'However, when I look back, I realise my grounding at home taught me critical thinking, self-confidence and values, which are qualities that get entrenched in children from 0 to 10 years.' Gandhi (standing - second from right), in a needlework class at the Inanda State-Aided Indian School in the early 1950s. Image: Supplied Gandhi(front), with her grandfather, Mahatma Gandhi, during a visit to India. Image: Supplied Early years in activism Gandhi said from a young age, she became aware of the challenges faced by people in communities. 'While I was in primary school, some of my teachers were involved in welfare programmes such as making food hampers for families in need in Inanda. When I was 12, I joined them as a volunteer and collected things such as food. I became conscious of the welfare movement at that time, which I believe sparked my interest in getting involved with social work later on in my life.' Gandhi said she and her siblings joined their parents during the Defiance Campaign in the early 1950s. The campaign was a major act of civil disobedience against apartheid in South Africa, launched by the ANC and the South African Indian Congress in 1952. 'I was quite young, then but was part of the thousands of people who gathered at Red Square in central Durban. During this meeting, about 20 people volunteered to defy one of the laws, such as entering through the whites-only entrance at the post office or going into the whites-only library. We were outside supporting them.' Further studies Gandhi pursued a BA degree with law subjects at the then Natal University. 'I initially wanted to become a lawyer. My majors were English and political science, with law subjects, Roman Dutch Law, Roman Law and Native Administration. But those plans later changed.' Family Gandhi said in 1961, while at university, she married her childhood sweetheart, Mewalal 'Mewa' Ramgobin, an anti-apartheid activist and politician. He died at the age of 83 in 2016. 'We grew up together and were studying at the university. He was active in the Struggle and he got banned. He was unable to attend university, so it was difficult for me as well. However, we continued with our studies part-time and eventually graduated.' Career Gandhi said she worked at the Durban Indian Child and Family Welfare Society in the early 1960s. 'I worked there on and off for a few years as I became a mother during those years. But while working, I continued with my studies and graduated with a BA degree in social science through Unisa. I later joined the Verulam Child and Family Welfare Society where I remained for about 15 years. During this time, I also graduated with an Honours degree in social science from Unisa,' she said. Children Gandhi had five children – Kidar Ramgobin, 62; Kush Ramgobin, 29, who was killed in 1993; Asha Ramgobin, 58; and twin daughters, Arti and Ashish, 55. She also has two grandchildren. Natal Indian Congress Gandhi said in the late 1960s, her husband decided to start a clemency committee after travelling to Cape Town for a family holiday. 'It was during this time that Nelson Mandela was imprisoned on Robben Island. During this time, we met some academics and other activists. After speaking to them, he said to me: 'Don't you think we should ask for the release of all the prisoners?' 'When we returned to Durban, he formed a clemency committee. However, we first met with the community to get a mandate, and there was a lot of enthusiasm. But they also found there was a need for political direction. So, we thought 'let us use this opportunity to revive the Natal Indian Congress (NIC)',' she said. The NIC, a political organisation, was established in 1894 by Mahatma Gandhi to fight discrimination against Indians in the then Natal colony. Gandhi said she became one of the vice presidents after her husband was banned and placed under house arrest. 'I was initially in the background but came to the forefront when my husband was banned. We held demonstrations against the Tricameral System. However, in the early 1970s I was banned for eight years and placed under house arrest for five years. It was a terrible period, but as a social worker, I still had access to the community and worked underground. As soon as my ban was over, I joined the NIC again.' Parliament Gandhi said after leaving child welfare, she worked at the Diakonia Centre, which was known as the home for agencies committed to justice, peace and development. 'I worked in the career information centre, helping young people. While I was there, I was asked to be part of the Convention for a Democratic South Africa (Codesa). I was on the negotiation committee ahead of the 1994 elections. After the elections, I joined Parliament from 1994 to 2003. I resigned before my term ended in 2004.' While in Parliament, she focused on welfare programmes and motherhood support. In 2007, Gandhi was also appointed the chancellor at the Durban University of Technology and held the position until 2012. 'It was a great responsibility, but it was wonderful as I graduated many of the students. Since then, I have immersed myself in satyagraha work.' Satyagraha is a philosophy of non-violent resistance developed by Mahatma Gandhi. Inspired by her grandfather's philosophy, in 2000 Gandhi started a monthly newspaper called Satyagraha – In Pursuit of Truth. The newspaper focused on education and fostering interracial and intercultural understanding. She is also the chairperson of the Gandhi Development Trust, and an executive member of the Mahatma Gandhi Salt March Committee. Gandhi added that one of her highlights was being able to get the international community to accept the peace agenda and being able to promote respect for all. 'I serve on a number of international committees, including as a co-president of Religions for Peace (RFP), which is the world's largest and most representative multi-religious coalition, working to advance common action for peace. 'One of my goals through my peace activism is to change the mentality of people, to make them realise you can't just do something bad to another human. The golden rule in every religion is that: 'In everything, do to others as you would have them do to you'.' Gandhi said she was also involved in the anti-nuclear movement, which called for nuclear weapons to be abolished. 'While in Parliament, I joined the Parliamentarians for Nuclear Non-proliferation and Disarmament. I attended many international conferences and worked on campaigns for nuclear disarmament through RFP and the hibakusha, the survivors of the atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. 'We have done a lot of research that shows the amount of money that goes into the production of nuclear bombs or anything that is destructive. I believe if you put that same money into education or health care, you will achieve far more,' she said. Accolades Gandhi has received numerous recognitions, including the Community of Christ International Peace Award in 2002, the Padma Bhushan award from the Government of India in 2007, and the Pravasi Bharatiya Samman, which is the highest honour conferred on overseas Indians by the Government of India's Ministry of External Affairs in 2014. She has also received honorary doctorates from the Durban University of Technology, the University of KwaZulu-Natal, Sidharth University in India, and Lincoln University in the UK. National Dialogue President Cyril Ramaphosa recently announced that Gandhi was chosen as a member of the eminent persons group to guide and champion the national dialogue later this year. Gandhi said she was humbled and honoured for the opportunity. 'However, I will not be a rose in a vase at that table. I am hoping to provide significant input on how we can address critical issues in our country, especially for the future generation. I will be speaking to people about what they believe needs to be done.' THE POST
The Citizen
10 hours ago
- The Citizen
Proposal to change name of South Africa to Republic of Azania
The ATM, which hopes to table the proposal in parliament, argues that South Africa is a colonial label imposed by the British and the Boers. The Republic of Azania is what South Africa could be called, following a proposal by a political party to change the country's name. The African Transformation Movement (ATM) and other political parties have opened a debate about changing South Africa's name to the Republic of Azania. Azania The ATM, which hopes to table the proposal in parliament, argues that South Africa is a colonial label imposed by the British and the Boers. ATM leader Vuyo Zungula said the name change is about reclaiming identity and restoring heritage. 'South Africa is still a colonised name because before 1652, we were not South Africans. The name South Africa came as a result of the British and the Boers coming to club together and forming what is called the Union of South Africa. 'They are working together for the oppression of the indigenous people… We must not be conditioned to subscribe to a colonial identity given to us by colonisers and oppressors,' Zungula said. ALSO READ: EFF wants SA renamed Azania, says Shivambu 'Renaming SA necessary' Zungula believes that renaming the country is a necessary step toward reclaiming national pride and restoring cultural heritage. 'Other countries have done it. Take South West Africa, for example. It is now Namibia. We should not have to cling to a name given to us by colonisers.' 'No success' North West University professor and political analyst Andre Duvenhage said the name change has no prospects of success. 'It's definitely not going to be accepted easily. You will need a two-thirds majority, maybe six of the nine provinces as well, and it will come with a huge cost on all levels. 'Think about it, we need to change all the ID documents, all the driver's licenses, all the passports, just to mention literally the tip of the iceberg, so I think it is controversial, each chance of success? Not very strong,' Duvenhage said. ALSO READ: WATCH: Joburg mayor gives update on Sandton Drive rename Why Azania? Duvenhage said the concept of Azania is associated with East Africa, specifically the dry, arid lands of countries like Somalia and parts of Kenya. 'It was also picked up in the literature of the Roman Empire, as well as the Arab literature. I think in Jewish it has a link to the land of God, but it was picked up in the South African context within the black consciousness context. 'It is seen as a land of the Black people. And taking this as your point of departure, it's basically an attempt to get rid of the colonial heritage. It's part of the process that is well known in South Africa, that of name changes, you raising the colonial history, and so it's coming from a radical background,' Duvenhage said. PAC Duvenhage said the proposal to rename South Africa to the Republic of Azania also stems from the Pan Africanist Congress (PAC) that South Africa should be renamed 'Azania'. 'It was also named by the PAC, so it is an established name in the South African context, but without any doubt it is very exclusive and it's excluding colonial, slash, in this case white people, and I cannot see this as an attempt to bring together South Africans'. Political climate Duvenhage said the ATM's proposal is also part of the current political climate in the country. 'I think it is also part of the climate we are in at the moment, a climate where we know that we need change. Changes are on the cards, we saw the polarisation within the government of national unity, the so-called national dialogue that needs to kick off, so it seems as if the political process is opening, 'But I'm also picking up that politicians are putting up a flyer, to test the political winds of change and see how people will react to this,' Duvenhage said. While the name South Africa is descriptive of a geographic location, the name gives a strong cultural, political, and historical connection that reminds citizens of different epochs in the country's history and how it interacted with other countries. NOW READ: Former SA deputy president David Mabuza has died
The Citizen
11 hours ago
- The Citizen
A VIEW OF THE WEEK: Spare the rod, save the inmate
While corporal punishment for adults may seem like a good idea, the last thing an already violent country needs is another way to beat out its anger. In his 1961 book on corporal punishment, British Parliamentarian Leslie Hale asked, 'Has an innocent man ever been hanged?' South Africa may have abolished the death penalty in 1995, but the debate over it rages on 30 years later. At the heart of the call for its reinstatement is the country's crime crisis. Frustrated at peaceful interventions that go nowhere, repeat offenders, and a slow justice system, police and residents often take matters into their own hands. When officers are gunning down suspects in a shootout or residents are overturning a car to try to reach alleged criminals, they are fighting violence with violence and adding to an already violent society. They are creating an unofficial death penalty that is fueled by vengeance and retaliation, not deterrence. Return to the good old days? Correctional Services Minister Pieter Groenewald this week suggested the formal return of another channel of violence: corporal punishment. Corporal punishment in prisons has been illegal since 1996, but the minister believes its return may alleviate overcrowding. His suggestion comes from a frustration that so many suspects are awaiting trial and, because thousands of them can't even afford the cheapest of bail, are clogging up prisons and resources. Alleged criminals are flooding into prisons, but courts can't deal with the number, so it causes a bottleneck that needs to be addressed, or it risks further destabilising the system. While deporting foreign suspects is one option, the diplomatic, legal, and administrative headache it would bring will add to an already unbearable migraine for the justice system. This and corporal punishment are both compelling arguments, but are populist and shallow when more balanced and thoughtful solutions to the issue are needed. Expanding public works and basic maintenance projects, labour or production camps, and increasing prison farms would all serve awaiting-trial inmates and the country better. ALSO READ: A VIEW OF THE WEEK: We need a ceasefire in the war on children Blood and violence everywhere Dealing out violence is not a workable solution. Countries that have taken such an approach have not seen a marked improvement, but rather a spiralling of the problem into further lawlessness. South Africa's Apartheid past is soaked in blood from all sides, justified through suppression, resistance, and tribalism. Events like the Marikana Massacre post-1994 have shown we have not outgrown the scourge. The prevalence of domestic violence and violent crimes on a daily basis points to a population psychologically damaged, and who have been taught the only way to express their point or solve disputes is with a weapon. For centuries, innocent men and women were hanged, and many more were beaten. Returning to corporal punishment will add to those assaulted wrongly and, even if dealt to those guilty, keep us trapped in the never-ending cycle of violence. NOW READ: A VIEW OF THE WEEK: Trump should have learnt from SA 'white genocide' moemish before bombing Iran
