IHC questions 'look-after' charge
The Islamabad High Court (IHC) has admitted a petition, challenging the alleged illegal "look-after" charge of the all-important position of the chief economist of Pakistan given to the vice chancellor of a public sector university by the Planning Commission.
Acting IHC Chief Justice Justice Sarfraz Dogar has asked the government to submit replies by March 26. The court has instructed that it should be provided the legal basis for giving the look-after charge of the chief economist position to the vice chancellor of Pakistan Institute of Development Economics (PIDE).
However, Planning Minister Ahsan Iqbal has defended the decision, saying Dr Nadeem Javaid has been appointed temporarily and there is also legal merit in the appointment.
He said that Nadeem Javaid was also Member Research of the Planning Commission and thus there was modus operandi for giving him the look-after charge. The charge has been given until the regular appointment process is completed, the minister added.
Soon after appointing Dr Nadeem Javaid as PIDE Vice Chancellor, the government on February 18 gave him the look-after charge of the vacant post of chief economist in clear violation of the Establishment Division's instructions of April 2021.
The court admitted the petition and served notices on the day a high-powered board promoted Dr Imtiaz Ahmad, belonging to the economist group, to the highest Pay Scale-22. This makes Imtiaz Ahmad eligible for the post of chief economist or secretary in any division.
The Planning Commission is entrusted with the responsibility of making Pakistan's long-term economic plans and ensuring their implementation.
The petitioner, the senior most officer of Grade-21 in the economist group, challenged the look-after charge given to PIDE vice chancellor and also challenged the continued placement of his services at the disposal of the Establishment Division since December 2021.
The petitioner prayed the court that it may declare that the look-after charge for the vice chancellor of a university was unlawful and devoid of legal basis.
According to the Establishment Division's instructions, "there is no provision of look after charge in Civil Servants Act, 1973 and Rules made thereunder, rather an officer can be deputed temporarily as an internal arrangement to look after the work of another post for disposal of day to day work of urgent and routine nature in the Ministry, Division, Organization concerned".
Going by these instructions, either one of the senior most officers should have been appointed the chief economist or the look-after charge should have been given to any of the senior most officers.
The Establishment Division's instructions further read that as a matter of principle, the senior most officer is normally asked by the head of a division or department to look after the work of a post when its incumbent is temporarily away.
However, the instructions further clarified "there may be certain issues which are of quasi-judicial nature and decision cannot be taken by an officer not formally designated to exercise those powers".
However, Nadeem Javaid is taking all the decisions which in the routine business fall within the domain of the chief economist.
The Establishment Division further stated that certain financial and administrative powers can only be exercised by an officer to whom the additional or current charge of the post is entrusted in the prescribed manner.
An officer looking after the work cannot exercise such powers as he has not been delegated such powers by the competent authority, according to the Establishment Division.
The petitioner prayed the court that the vice chancellor was an external element in the established hierarchy but he still was granted the look-after charge of chief economist, despite it being a promotional post.
He made the Establishment Division secretary, planning secretary and Nadeem Javaid parties in the case.
The petitioner asserted that the planning ministry "improperly assigned the look-after charge of the vacant position of chief economist". He contended that the assignment was unlawful as the chief economist was a promotional post.
The petitioner said that the term "look-after charge" lacked statutory basis within the Civil Servants Act and constituted an attempt to circumvent the petitioner's legal right to be considered for promotion.
He disclosed that he had earlier filed a writ petition before the IHC but the petition was subsequently withdrawn on September 16, 2024, premised upon assurances extended to the petitioner by senior officials that their candidacy for promotion would be duly considered.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
4 days ago
- Express Tribune
Buoyed projections?
Listen to article The government's projection of an exalted growth rate of 4.2% for the next fiscal year has made jaws drop. On what premise it is so confident is hard to guess, but the ground realities suggest a dismal picture. The beleaguered dispensation is pinning its hopes on tight monetary control and effective management of the economy – but that is no small task. All the projected targets for the ongoing fiscal year were missed as the economy achieved 2.68% growth as against the projected 3.6%. The agrarian sector merely posted 0.56% growth and the country is now on the verge of importing grains. So are the pathetic statistics with industry and other plum portfolios. The euphoria seems based on the sole achievement that the economy has swelled to $411 billion with a per capita income rise to $1,824. Likewise, the services, transport, storage, construction, information and communication sectors have managed moderate upward trends. All this seems to have encouraged the government to propose new growth targets of 4.4% in commodity-producing sectors; 4.5% in agriculture sector, 3.5% in LSM and 3% in mining. Inflation is being seen at 7.5%. But there is a surprising squeeze too that the government is eyeing: the construction sector which grew by 6.6% this year is targeted at only 3.8%. So is the case with electricity, gas and water supply sectors that are nourished by 29% this year, but are projected to grow by only 3.5% next year. This is untenable and what crosscurrents they will leave behind is another enigma of sorts. On the international front, there is a tight-walking for the government as the IMF is too inquisitive, having almost torpedoed the plans on crypto, and insisting on tax collection to be raised to Rs16 trillion. On the other hand, the Planning Commission says it has only left with Rs880 billion and only high-priority developmental projects will see the light of the day. The rare hope-line is the largesse of the ABD which has doled out $800 million to strengthen fiscal sustainability and improve public financial management programmes.
Business Recorder
29-05-2025
- Business Recorder
FBR suspends senior tax auditor
ISLAMABAD: On complaints of harassment, the Federal Board of Revenue has suspended a Senior Auditor (BS-17) who was posted under Section 40B of the Sales Tax Act 1990 at the premises of a feed mill to monitor the supply of taxable goods. As per the FBR notification issued under Rule 5(1) of the Civil Servants (Efficiency and Discipline) Rules, 2020, the Senior Auditor of the Regional Tax Office, Multan, has been suspended for a period of 120 days or until further orders, whichever is earlier. When contacted for comments, Shahid Jami, tax advisor of the feed manufacturers, lauded the prompt action by the chairman FBR, who has assured the industry representative that no instance of any harassment reported to the FBR will be tolerated in the future. FBR begins action against companies However, Jami urged the FBR that staff posted at the factories be provided logistic support and the requisite facilities so that posting there for 30 days or more is not burdensome for the compliant taxpayers. He further urged that where monitoring of taxable supplies matches with the declared version and there is a progressive trend of voluntary compliance, such measures be avoided in future for at least two years or until there is some definite information about underreporting, he added. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
28-05-2025
- Business Recorder
Infrastructure must also safeguard health of people: Ahsan
ISLAMABAD: Federal Minister for Planning, Development and Special Initiatives Professor Ahsan Iqbal addressed a high-level event jointly organised by the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank (AIIB) and the Pakistan Institute of Development Economics (PIDE), marking the launch of AIIB's flagship report, Asian Infrastructure Finance 2025: Infrastructure for Planetary Health, said a press release. The minister stated that the launch of this report is both timely and deeply relevant to Pakistan's national and global development goals. Speaking to a distinguished audience comprising experts from PIDE, representatives of AIIB, development partners, and leaders from across sectors, the minister emphasised that Pakistan is standing at a critical moment, a point where infrastructure must not only support economic growth but also safeguard the health of its people and the health of the planet. Iqbal underlined that infrastructure today encompasses much more than roads, buildings, or power plants. It is equally about the air quality, the water nation drinks, and the healthcare systems that protect its people. He said this broader definition of infrastructure touches the idea of planetary health, where human health is intrinsically linked to the health of nature and the planet. Iqbal made clear that the Government of Pakistan is not allowing any infrastructure project to move forward unless it takes into account climate resilience, public health, and environmental protection. He affirmed that working in silos has ended, as every sector and system, be it hospitals, schools, transport systems, sewage networks, or electricity grids, must be integrated and climate-ready to remain functional and safe during natural disasters. The minister added that the government recognises the need to reduce dependence on fossil fuels and is actively investing in solar, wind, and green hydrogen technologies as part of its transition to cleaner energy. He stated that Pakistan is embracing nature-based solutions, highlighting ongoing initiatives such as planting mangroves along the country's coastal areas and developing green parks in cities, calling these smart, cost-effective, and equitable methods to enhance resilience. Iqbal pointed out that the data in the AIIB report echoes Pakistan's lived reality, diseases are rising due to floods and substandard water systems, food insecurity is worsening due to changing rainfall patterns, erratic rains are contributing to higher infant mortality, and lead pollution from industries and batteries is damaging children's health and brain development. He stressed that these phenomena are not abstract projections but are unfolding across Pakistan in real time. From floods and heatwaves to smog and water shortages, the impacts of climate inaction have become embedded in daily life. Iqbal assured that Pakistan is not beginning from scratch. The government has already started aligning national plans with the concept of planetary health. He specifically cited the 'Uraan Pakistan' initiative and the government's Five Es Framework as part of a comprehensive national agenda to promote climate-smart, health-responsive, and inclusive infrastructure. Under Uraan Pakistan, the government has begun transitioning to zero-emission electric buses in public transport, restoring riverbanks and wetlands to reduce flooding risks and promote green tourism, and upgrading healthcare centres to make them energy-efficient and resilient in the face of disasters. He highlighted that these efforts are well-aligned with the principles highlighted in AIIB's report, which promotes a transformative model of infrastructure that links sustainability with biodiversity conservation, public health outcomes, and climate resilience. Citing findings from the Global Commission on Adaptation, Prof Iqbal noted that every dollar invested in climate-resilient infrastructure can generate a fourfold return by avoiding future losses. He said Pakistan is incorporating urban green infrastructure solutions, including green belts, permeable surfaces, and climate-sensitive zoning regulations, which are proven to reduce urban temperatures by up to 4°C and mitigate extreme heat, particularly in cities like Jacobabad and Lahore. He added that the restoration of mangroves in coastal areas, already underway in Pakistan, is reducing storm damage by up to 30 to 50 percent while simultaneously improving fish livelihoods. Concluding his address, Prof Iqbal stated that historically, infrastructure planning in Pakistan has prioritized quantity over quality and expansion over resilience. He affirmed that the government is turning this page decisively and is committed to a new era of planning grounded in the principles of climate-smart, health-protective, inclusive, and sustainable infrastructure development. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
