Google, Justice Department face off in climactic showdown in search monopoly case
Google lawyers are expected to assert only minor concessions are needed, especially as the upheaval triggered by advances in artificial intelligence already are reshaping the search landscape, as alternative, conversational search options are rolling out from AI startups that are hoping to use the Department of Justice's four-and-half-year-old case to gain the upper hand in the next technological frontier.
Get Starting Point
A guide through the most important stories of the morning, delivered Monday through Friday.
Enter Email
Sign Up
'Over weeks of testimony, we heard from a series of well-funded companies eager to gain access to Google's technology so they don't have to innovate themselves,' Lee-Anne Mulholland, Google's vice president of regulatory affairs, wrote in a blog post earlier this month. 'What we didn't hear was how DOJ's extreme proposals would benefit consumers.'
After the day-long closing arguments, Mehta will spend much of the summer mulling a decision that he plans to issue before Labor Day. Google has already vowed to appeal the ruling that branded its search engine as a monopoly, a step it can't take until the judge orders a remedy.
Advertisement
While both sides of this showdown agree that AI is an inflection point for the industry's future, they have disparate views on how the shift will affect Google.
The Justice Department contends that AI technology by itself won't rein in Google's power, arguing additional legal restraints must be slapped on a search engine that's the main reason its parent company, Alphabet Inc., is valued at $2 trillion.
Google has already been deploying AI to transform its search engine i nto an answer engine, an effort that has so far helped maintain its perch as the internet's main gateway despite inroads being made by alternatives from the likes of OpenAI and Perplexity.
The Justice Department contends a divestiture of the Chrome browser that Google CEO Sundar Pichai helped build nearly 20 years ago would be among the most effective countermeasures against Google continuing to amass massive volumes of browser traffic and personal data that could be leveraged to retain its dominance in the AI era. Executives from both OpenAi and Perplexity testified last month that they would be eager bidders for the Chrome browser if Mehta orders its sale.
The debate over Google's fate also has pulled in opinions from Apple, mobile app developers, legal scholars and startups.
Apple, which collects more than $20 billion annually to make Google the default search engine on the iPhone and its other devices, filed briefs arguing against the Justice Department's proposed 10-year ban on such lucrative lock-in agreements. Apple told the judge that prohibiting the contracts would deprive the company of money that it funnels into its own research, and that the ban might even make Google even more powerful because the company would be able to hold onto its money while consumers would end up choosing its search engine anyway. The Cupertino, California, company also told the judge a ban wouldn't compel it to build its own search engine to compete against Google.
Advertisement
In other filings, a group of legal scholars said the Justice Department's proposed divestiture of Chrome would be an improper penalty that would inject unwarranted government interference in a company's business. Meanwhile, former Federal Trade Commission officials James Cooper and Andrew Stivers warned that another proposal that would require Google to share its data with rival search engines 'does not account for the expectations users have developed over time regarding the privacy, security, and stewardship' of their personal information.
The App Association, a group that represents mostly small software developers, also advised Mehta not to adopt the Justice Department's proposed changes because of the ripple effects they would have across the tech industry.
Hobbling Google in the way the Justice Department envisions would make it more difficult for startups to realize their goal of being acquired, the App Association wrote. 'Developers will be overcome by uncertainty' if Google is torn apart, the group argues.
Buy Y Combinator, an incubator that has helped create hundreds of startups collectively worth about $800 billion filed documents pushing for the dramatic overhaul of Google, whose immense power has discouraged venture capitalists from investing in areas that are considered to be part of the company's 'kill zone.'
Advertisement
Startups 'also need to be able to get their products into the hands of users, free from restrictive dealing and self-preferencing that locks up important distribution channels. As things stand, Google has locked up the most critical distribution channels, freezing the general search and search text advertising markets into static competition for more than a decade,' Y Combinator told Mehta.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Tom's Guide
11 minutes ago
- Tom's Guide
5 tips to be more productive in Google Keep
Google Keep is a surprisingly useful app anyone can use to be more productive on the web, and since it has free Android and iOS apps I've found it super-useful for staying on top of everything on the go. I've been using Google Keep casually for years, but after I recently switched from an iPhone to an Android device, I've started to become something of a Keep power user. After all, as useful as the Google Keep web interface has been, now that I can easily access Keep from the external screen of my new Motorola Razr (2025) I'm unlocking new levels of productivity — and finally appreciating why Keep is one of the best note-taking apps around. To show you what I mean, I thought I'd share the most useful Google Keep tips and tricks I've discovered over the last month of making it a core part of my daily workflow. Let's dive in! Like many note-taking apps, Google Keep lets you set reminders for individual notes. Unlike much of the competition, Keep doesn't stop at time and date. Not only can you remind yourself about a specific note at a later time, you can remind yourself about a note about a specific place. This is obviously most useful if you use the Keep app through Android or iOS, but it also works with your browser, so you can use it on your laptop to remind yourself about specific things when you get to certain places. Get instant access to breaking news, the hottest reviews, great deals and helpful tips. For example, you might use it to remind yourself to ship a specific product or check in about a specific receipt when you get to the office. Or you can remind yourself about a grocery list when you get to the supermarket. To access these features, just click or tap on the little Reminder icon (it's shaped like a bell) on an individual note and select "Pick place" or "Pick date & time" to get started. To check what reminders you've already set, click the three-dot icon in the upper-right corner of the Keep app and select "Reminders" to get a rundown. One of my favorite ways to use Google Keep is as a sort of backup memory, a place where I can stash things I know I need to remember and then look them up later and categorize them when I have time. Easily my favorite way to do this is to simply photograph anything I want to remember, stash it in Google Keep and catalog it later. And with Keep's OCR (Optical Character Recognition) tech you can generally count on it to parse text in images pretty effectively. So I end up using Keep all the time to do things like photograph invitations, flyers and business cards, then use the "Get image text" function in the web version of Keep — just click the three-dot icon and select "Get image text" — to parse the text and store it for later. Plenty of reminder apps let you color-code your notes, but so far Keep is the only one I've tried that lets you assign custom backgrounds. I like to use these backgrounds to categorize my Keep files so I can quickly find things like shopping lists and recipes at a glance. They're a little difficult to see on images in Keep so I prefer to use single colors to categorize those, but for text? Custom backgrounds are a great way to stay organized. To access them, simply click on the little paint palette icon in the lower-left corner of any file in Google Keep. From there you'll get a drop-down menu of 12 colors and 10 patterned backgrounds to choose from, with themes ranging from music to recipes to travel. I'm a little embarrassed it took me a while to realize this, but you can embed Google Keep notes directly into your Google Docs and vice versa. I've found this incredibly useful for working as a journalist, because I often start stories from notes I take in Google Keep but I hate writing more than a few sentences in the Keep app. I used to start new stories from scratch in Google Docs, but now I know you can just click the three-dot icon in the lower-right corner of any Google Keep note and select "Copy to Google Docs" to import it directly into a new Google Doc. Likewise, you can quickly access your Google Keep notes within Google Docs by clicking the yellow Google Keep icon on the righthand side. The No. 1 thing that's helped me get more done in less time with Google Keep is to learn the keyboard shortcuts for some of my most commonly-executed tasks. I chiefly use them when working with the web version of Keep, where I have my keyboard close to hand. While there are also shortcuts you can use on the iOS and Android versions of Keep, I find I rarely need them when using my smartphone. But when I'm on my PC, being able to rapidly jump between notes or format a to-do list quickly makes all the difference in my day-to-day productivity. To show you what I mean, I've compiled my most-used keyboard shortcuts in the tablet below. Keyboard shortcut Command Create new note C Create new list L Search notes / Archive note E Trash note D Jump to next/previous note J/K Jump to next/previous list item Shift + J/K Toggle between list and grid view Ctrl + G Reference keyboard shortcuts Shift + / Try them for yourself in the web version of Google Keep and see if you don't feel faster and more productive in minutes! Follow Tom's Guide on Google News to get our up-to-date news, how-tos, and reviews in your feeds. Make sure to click the Follow button.
CNN
12 minutes ago
- CNN
The ‘godfather of AI' reveals the only way humanity can survive superintelligent AI
Geoffrey Hinton, known as the 'godfather of AI,' fears the technology he helped build could wipe out humanity — and 'tech bros' are taking the wrong approach to stop it. Hinton, a Nobel Prize-winning computer scientist and a former Google executive, has warned in the past that there is a 10% to 20% chance that AI wipes out humans. On Tuesday, he expressed doubts about how tech companies are trying to ensure humans remain 'dominant' over 'submissive' AI systems. 'That's not going to work. They're going to be much smarter than us. They're going to have all sorts of ways to get around that,' Hinton said at Ai4, an industry conference in Las Vegas. In the future, Hinton warned, AI systems might be able to control humans just as easily as an adult can bribe 3-year-old with candy. This year has already seen examples of AI systems willing to deceive, cheat and steal to achieve their goals. For example, to avoid being replaced, one AI model tried to blackmail an engineer about an affair it learned about in an email. Instead of forcing AI to submit to humans, Hinton presented an intriguing solution: building 'maternal instincts' into AI models, so 'they really care about people' even once the technology becomes more powerful and smarter than humans. AI systems 'will very quickly develop two subgoals, if they're smart: One is to stay alive… (and) the other subgoal is to get more control,' Hinton said. 'There is good reason to believe that any kind of agentic AI will try to stay alive.' That's why it is important to foster a sense of compassion for people, Hinton argued. At the conference, he noted that mothers have instincts and social pressure to care for their babies. 'The right model is the only model we have of a more intelligent thing being controlled by a less intelligent thing, which is a mother being controlled by her baby,' Hinton said. Hinton said it's not clear to him exactly how that can be done technically but stressed it's critical researchers work on it. 'That's the only good outcome. If it's not going to parent me, it's going to replace me,' he said. 'These super-intelligent caring AI mothers, most of them won't want to get rid of the maternal instinct because they don't want us to die.' Hinton is known for his pioneering work on neural networks, which helped pave the way to today's AI boom. In 2023, he stepped down from Google and started speaking out about the dangers of AI. Emmett Shear, who briefly served as interim CEO of ChatGPT owner OpenAI, said he's not surprised that some AI systems have tried to blackmail humans or bypass shutdown orders. 'This keeps happening. This is not going to stop happening,' Shear, the CEO of AI alignment startup Softmax, said at the Ai4 conference. 'AIs today are relatively weak, but they're getting stronger really fast.' Shear said that rather than trying to instill human values into AI systems, a smarter approach would be to forge collaborative relationships between humans and AI. Many experts believe AIs will achieve superintelligence, also known as artificial general intelligence, or AGI, in the coming years. Hinton said he used to think it could take 30 years to 50 years to achieve AGI but now sees this moment coming sooner. 'A reasonable bet is sometime between five and 20 years,' he said. While Hinton remains concerns about what could go wrong with AI, he is hopeful the technology will pave the way to medical breakthroughs. 'We're going to see radical new drugs. We are going to get much better cancer treatment than the present,' he said. For instance, he said AI will help doctors comb through and correlate the vast amounts of data produced by MRI and CT scans. However, Hinton does not believe AI will help humans achieve immortality. 'I don't believe we'll live forever,' Hinton said. 'I think living forever would be a big mistake. Do you want the world run by 200-year-old white men?' Asked if there's anything he would have done differently in his career if he knew how fast AI would accelerate, Hinton said he regrets solely focusing on getting AI to work. 'I wish I'd thought about safety issues, too,' he said.
Tom's Guide
40 minutes ago
- Tom's Guide
If you're moving from Apple to Garmin, you'll want to install this watch face
There's a lot to consider when moving from Apple Watch to Garmin — sure, you'll get a better battery life and more health tracking features, but one thing you might miss, as well as answering calls and texts from your wrist, is closing your rings. The good news is, you can still close your rings using this Garmin watch face. I review the best Garmin watches for a living, and while this is the watch face I always download, the Goals screen is super popular, and mimics Apple's rings. The best part is, unlike Apple, you can completely customize what your rings measure. Like all custom Garmin watch faces, you can download the watch face, named Goals, from the Connect IQ app. You can download a free trial of the watch face first, and then it will cost $1.99/£1.99. Once you've downloaded the face, you'll be able to move it from watch to watch, if you ever choose to upgrade your Garmin. Here's why I recommend it. I've been reviewing the best fitness trackers for the past decade, and I'm the first to admit, the Apple Watch rings are extremely motivating. Far more motivating than my watch randomly buzzing throughout the day, telling me to move. I've been known to go for a walk at 10 pm just to close my move ring, and the same applies with the Garmin goals, which I love seeing my move throughout the day. One big step up from the move, exercise, and stand rings you'll find on the Apple Watch is the ability to customize your goals to ones that are important to you. The goals watch face lets you pick from a huge list of stats, including all of the obvious options like steps, movement, and calories, but also more unique goals, such as floors climbed, monthly walking minutes, and time to recover in hours. As a marathon runner, it's always helpful to see my active calories — a stat you can't see on most of Garmin's built-in watch faces. This helps me ensure I'm eating enough when my training plan involves high mileage runs. If you're looking to lose weight, it's also a helpful metric to keep an eye on, as you want to ensure you're in a calorie defict, burning more calories than you consume. Get instant access to breaking news, the hottest reviews, great deals and helpful tips. I've installed the Goals watch face on my Garmin Forerunner 570, Garmin Forerunner 970, and Garmin Epix Pro, and have not experienced any difference in battery life while using it. It looks fantastic on the bright, AMOLED screen, and I appreciate the option to customize the colors of the bars to suit my style. Follow Tom's Guide on Google News to get our up-to-date news, how-tos, and reviews in your feeds. Make sure to click the Follow button.
