The issue facing SNP and Labour when dealing with Donald Trump
"It's an unprecedented situation because Donald Trump is confusing his personal business interests and his political interests,' Cogliano said. 'In the past, poor Jimmy Carter put his peanut farm in a blind trust so there would be no appearance of impropriety. Donald Trump doesn't operate like that.'
Referencing reports that the UK Government had lobbied for The Open, golf's oldest major tournament, to be held at the Trump Turnberry course, Cogliano went on: 'One can imagine the UK Government wanting to use whatever soft power it has to try and influence Trump.
READ MORE: Donald Trump bid to have Open at Turnberry 'could breach US constitution'
'On the other hand, this is a blurring of a business interest in politics, which is not what we do here in the UK as a rule. Historically we haven't really done it in the United States since the 19th century, which was quite corrupt, but Trump, Trump is old fashioned in this regard.'
The University of Edinburgh professor added: 'The UK Government is kind of stuck in a bind – and I imagine that governments around the world where Trump has business interests are facing this – because on one hand this gives them leverage. On the other hand, it's complicated.
'Let's suppose John Swinney took a principled stand and said, 'The Open should not be a Turnberry because this is corruption'.
'Well then you don't want him slapping a 100% tariff on whisky, which is the kind of thing he might do.'
US president Donald Trump is half-Scottish on his mother's sideMuch has been made of the US president's close familial ties to Scotland – his mother was born and raised in Lewis before emigrating – but Cogliano cautioned against thinking this would bind Trump in any way.
'His relationship with Scotland is very strange and interesting because he makes relatively little of it considering his mother is from Scotland,' he said.
'[Trump's] got a direct link, but he doesn't make that much of that except I suppose when trying to promote his business interests here.
'I remember before his inauguration talking to some people in the government and some people in business, and the business folks were fairly optimistic, saying, 'well, he's Scottish, he likes us, we don't have to worry that much about tariffs'. I thought, 'Oh, I don't know about that'.
READ MORE: Petition to stop Donald Trump addressing UK Parliament hits milestone
'He's a very transactional guy, he's a very vindictive guy. His history is littered with people who he allegedly liked who he betrayed.
'He'll run roughshod over everybody – and I don't think the Scottish connection will necessarily protect Scotland.'
Attempts to appease Trump present a second challenge for UK politicians, who must court him without angering their own voters – with whom he is overwhelmingly unpopular. YouGov polling has found just 16% of UK adults have a positive view of the US president.
'[It's] like juggling,' Cogliano said, 'trying to keep Trump happy with trying to keep the vast, vast majority of your own voters that don't like him happy.'
In February, Prime Minister Keir Starmer delivered a letter from the King inviting Trump for a second state visit – a move widely seen as an attempt to appease the US president.
Prime Minister Keir Starmer presents Donald Trump with a letter from the King (Image: PA) YouGov polling showed the public was almost evenly split on whether the visit should go ahead (43% in favour, 42% opposed). However, Labour voters opposed it by 49% to 37%, while Tory and Reform voters – the latter overwhelmingly supportive of Trump (72% to 19%) – tipped the balance.
Trump's polling troubles are much worse in the US, Cogliano said.
'He's got the worst 100-day polling results since they started polling. This is unprecedented,' the University of Edinburgh expert said.
'Obama's approval rating was around 63% at this point back in 2009, for example. Biden was in positive territory at this point back four years ago.
'The only person who's in the same neighbourhood is Trump during his first administration. This is historically bad.'
Cogliano added: 'So he's unpopular, a lot of his policies are unpopular, a lot of the things he's doing are unpopular, but he's also unconstrained. It's very strange.'
READ MORE: Major blow to Labour as Donald Trump 'downgrades UK trade deal talks'
Could today's situation mirror Trump's experience in Scotland 15 years ago, when the SNP government allowed him to develop golf courses in Aberdeenshire despite opposition from locals and environmental groups?
In both Scotland and the US, Trump made grand promises – of a £1 billion investment and 6000 jobs in Aberdeenshire, or a 'golden age' for American citizens – that have failed to materialise.
Cogliano said the US president's actions in Scotland and the Oval Office were a 'good comparison'.
'There don't seem to be consequences for him not living up to his promises,' he added. 'The question here is when or if he will face any.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Reuters
a few seconds ago
- Reuters
India's Gland Pharma posts quarterly profit rise on Cenexi recovery, Europe sales growth
Aug 5 (Reuters) - India's Gland Pharma ( opens new tab reported a nearly 50% jump in first-quarter profit on Tuesday, driven by better margins and a recovery at its European unit Cenexi. The company reported a consolidated net profit of 2.15 billion rupees ($24.50 million) for the quarter ended June 30, from 1.44 billion rupees in the year-ago quarter. Revenue from operations rose 7.4% to 15.06 billion rupees. While sales from its U.S. business, which accounts for nearly half of the total, fell 2%, its Europe business posted a 29% rise. For further results highlights, click KEY CONTEXT Gland and several Indian pharma companies that make generic drugs derive a significant share of revenue from the United States and has continued to face pricing pressure in that market following U.S. President Donald Trump's imposition of hefty tariffs on goods imported from India. Rivals Sun Pharma ( opens new tab and Cipla ( opens new tab and Dr Reddy's ( opens new tab reported subdued U.S. sales in the quarter. However, Gland Pharma said improved margins and Cenexi's earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortisation (EBITDA) break-even supported quarterly performance, marking a turnaround after production setbacks at its Paris and Belgium units weighed on earnings over the past year. The company's EBITDA margin rose to 35% in the June quarter from 29% a year earlier. PEER COMPARISON * Mean of analysts' ratings standardised to a scale of Strong Buy, Buy, Hold, Sell, and Strong Sell ** Ratio of the stock's last close to analysts' mean price target; a ratio above 1 means the stock is trading above the PT APRIL TO JUNE STOCK PERFORMANCE -- All data from LSEG -- $1 = 87.7570 Indian rupeesthe
North Wales Live
a minute ago
- North Wales Live
Calls to cut country road speed limits to 30mph backed by North Wales mayor
Wrexham's mayor has thrown her weight behind moves to lower speed limits on all rural roads and lanes. A petition has been launched calling on the UK Government to cut the default speed limit on single-carriageway rural roads from 60mph to 30mph. The proposal is in line with the approach adopted by roads charity Brake. It notes that, per mile travelled, rural roads are more dangerous that motorways and urban roads. The Welsh Government is responsible for setting speed limits in Wales, meaning any change to the rules here would be determined in Cardiff as opposed to Westminster. As Wrexham's current mayor, Cllr Tina Mannering, who represents the Gwersyllt East ward, is urging constituents to sign the Westminster petition, saying it was 'important'. She's long campaigned for safer limits on a country road with a 60mph limit that runs right through Alyn Waters Country Park between Llay and Bradley. The narrow, twisty lane, is often used by walkers, cyclists and horse riders. Despite cutting through Wrexham 's largest country park, the road lacks pavements or walkways for its entire length, leaving little room for pedestrians to escape speeding vehicles. Cllr Mannering described it as a 'race track'. The petition, launched by Rhiannon Vivian, runs until November 13 and has so far collected 1,079 signatures. This includes 190 from Wales, a country criss-crossed with country roads that's already taken controversial steps to cuts speeds in built-up areas. Moves to halve default speeds on rural roads are likely to split opinion. In an online debate centred on the Ceiriog Valley near Chirk, one driver refused to sign the petition on the basis it was an 'absolutely asinine piece of nanny state crap'. He added: 'Why should the whole population be penalised for the actions of few idiots?' When it comes to country roads, many people say they use common sense and drive to the conditions. One man noted that 'no one in their right mind' would try to drive at 60mph along these roads. Join the North Wales Live Whatsapp community now Although local authorities can set lower speed limits, 60mph limits remain commonplace on rural roads. The petition points to a study which estimated a 10% increase in average speeds on these roads results in a 30% increase in fatal and serious crashes. UK Government figures show that rural roads – which include most B roads – carry 44% of all traffic but are responsible for 33% of all casualties and 60% of all fatalities. Rhiannon wrote: 'I think the fact that drivers can legally do 60mph is absolute negligence and shows a disregard for human life. Cyclists, motorcyclists and car drivers are more than three times as likely to be killed per mile travelled on a rural road than an urban road.' On social media, Wrexham councillor Trevor Bates also questioned the default limit. He wrote: 'It does seem silly having national speed limits on some of our narrowest bendiest steepest and potholiest lanes.' Earlier this year the Ceiriog Valley was turned into a pothole 'theme park' in a tongue-in-cheek dig to highlight the area's rutted and pitted country roads. Although some routes were eventually fixed by Wrexham Council (WCBC), one local resident suspects the lack of maintenance is deliberate. 'It is impossible to drive at more than 10mph or 20mph on some lanes, and even 5mph on the worst stretches,' she said. 'I'm sure WCBC will consider potholes a much cheaper method of slowing down traffic, saving them the expense of putting up loads more signs!' Refusing to sign the petition is a man who said there were 'enough bloody rules in this country already'. Likewise, a woman doubted 30mph could be enforced and doubted it would stop the 'idiots'. Threatening to prejudice the debate is Wales' 20mph policy in built-up areas. In 2024, more than 85,000 motorists were caught breaking the limit and the measure continues to divide opinion. Commenting on the rural speed limit debate, one man sighed: 'I may as well buy a horse and cart.' Subsequent revisions to the 20mph rule are fanning the flames, with motorists complaining of regular speed changes – particularly when crossing county boundaries. Wrexham Council alone has agreed to rescind 20mph limits on 52 sections of highway in a move that will cost hundreds of thousands of pounds. Some people believe that focusing on new footpaths and cycle lanes on country roads would make more sense than cutting the speed limit. But others fully support the idea, with a Denbighshire man describing 60mph rural limits as 'madness'. Already there's been a minor surge of support for the idea following Cllr Mannering's intervention, with 28 Wrexham residents signing the petition, along with nine from Clwyd East. Enthusiasm is less pronounced in other parts of North Wales, with eight signatures in Dwyfor Meirionnydd, five in Alyn and Deeside and four each in Anglesey and Bangor Aberconwy. Backing the idea was a Llanarmon DC resident who noted that rules are 'what makes civilised societies'. He added: 'Frankly, it's incredibly disappointing that those who shout and rant against a rule that would make everyone safer, seem to win the day."
Leader Live
a minute ago
- Leader Live
Russia says it will no longer abide by self-imposed missile moratorium
It is a warning that potentially sets the stage for a new arms race as tensions between Moscow and Washington rise again over Ukraine. In a statement on Monday, the Russian Foreign Ministry linked the decision to efforts by the US and its allies to develop intermediate-range weapons and preparations for their deployment in Europe and other parts of the world. It specifically cited US plans to deploy Typhoon and Dark Eagle missiles in Germany starting next year. The ministry noted that such actions by the US and its allies create 'destabilising missile potentials' near Russia, creating a 'direct threat to the security of our country' and carry 'significant harmful consequences for regional and global stability, including a dangerous escalation of tensions between nuclear powers'. It did not say what specific moves the Kremlin might take, but President Vladimir Putin has previously announced that Moscow was planning to deploy its new Oreshnik missiles on the territory of its neighbour and ally Belarus later this year. 'Decisions on specific parameters of response measures will be made by the leadership of the Russian Federation based on an interdepartmental analysis of the scale of deployment of American and other Western land-based intermediate-range missiles, as well as the development of the overall situation in the area of international security and strategic stability,' the Foreign Ministry said. The Russian statement follows US President Donald Trump's announcement on Friday that he is ordering the repositioning of two US nuclear submarines 'based on the highly provocative statements' of Dmitry Medvedev, who was president in 2008-12 to allow Mr Putin, bound by term limits, to later return to the office. Mr Trump's statement came as his deadline for the Kremlin to reach a peace deal in Ukraine approaches later this week. Mr Trump said he was alarmed by Mr Medvedev's attitude. Mr Medvedev, who serves as deputy chairman of Russia's Security Council chaired by Mr Putin, has apparently sought to curry favour with his mentor by making provocative statements and frequently lobbing nuclear threats. Last week he responded to Mr Trump's deadline for Russia to accept a peace deal in Ukraine or face sanctions by warning him against 'playing the ultimatum game with Russia' and declaring that 'each new ultimatum is a threat and a step toward war'. Mr Medvedev also commented on the Foreign Ministry's statement, describing Moscow's withdrawal from the moratorium as 'the result of Nato countries' anti-Russian policy'. 'This is a new reality all our opponents will have to reckon with,' he wrote on X. 'Expect further steps.' Intermediate-range missiles can fly between 500 to 5,500 kilometres (310 to 3,400 miles). Such land-based weapons were banned under the 1987 Intermediate-range Nuclear Forces (INF) Treaty. Washington and Moscow abandoned the pact in 2019, accusing each other of violations, but Moscow declared its self-imposed moratorium on their deployment until the US makes such a move. The collapse of the INF Treaty has stoked fears of a replay of a Cold War-era European missile crisis, when the US and the Soviet Union both deployed intermediate-range missiles on the continent in the 1980s. Such weapons are seen as particularly destabilising because they take less time to reach targets, compared with intercontinental ballistic missiles, leaving no time for decision-makers and raising the likelihood of a global nuclear conflict over a false launch warning. Russia's missile forces chief has declared that the new Oreshnik intermediate-range missile, which Russia first used against Ukraine in November, has a range to reach all of Europe. Oreshnik can carry conventional or nuclear warheads. Mr Putin has praised the Oreshnik's capabilities, saying its multiple warheads that plunge to a target at speeds up to Mach 10 are immune to being intercepted and are so powerful that the use of several of them in one conventional strike could be as devastating as a nuclear attack. Mr Putin has warned the West that Moscow could use it against Ukraine's Nato allies who allowed Kyiv to use their longer-range missiles to strike inside Russia.
