Retiring in a big city? You may need $1.6M to live comfortably
For retirees in big cities, however, Social Security dollars may not even go that far.
In large U.S. cities and their suburbs, Social Security income covers only around 30% of what the average retiree spends in a year, according to a new analysis from the personal finance site LendingTree.
Across the 100 largest metropolitan areas, Social Security covers anywhere from 24% of annual retirement spending (in San Francisco) to 35% of yearly spending (in McAllen, Texas), LendingTree found in the July 15 report.
To retire comfortably in big cities, you need big savings
To live a comfortable retirement in any of those cities, the report says, you'll need lots of savings: $1.6 million in Los Angeles or San Francisco, $1.3 million in Philadelphia or Chicago, $1.1 million in Memphis, Tennessee.
'Life is expensive in bigger cities in America today,' said Matt Schulz, chief consumer finance analyst at LendingTree. 'Not breaking news, but unfortunately, this is not something that's going to get better anytime soon. And it makes for a scary situation.'
The analysis used data from the Labor Department, Social Security Administration and U.S. Census to estimate annual retiree spending and average Social Security benefits in each large metropolitan area. Among the findings:
The most affordable cities for retirees don't share much in common, except that they don't rank among the very largest metros, and they aren't in California. Relatively affordable cities include Pittsburgh; Tucson, Arizona; and Rochester, N.Y.
'These are very different cities, in all sorts of ways,' Schulz said. 'One thing this does show is that the biggest of the big cities are going to be a challenge, in no uncertain terms.'
How far does Social Security go in your city?
Here's how far Social Security goes in some of America's largest metropolitan areas. We'll list the most affordable metros first.
Pittsburgh: Social Security retirement income averages $21,978 per year, and retirement spending averages $55,882 per year. Social Security covers 32.2% of the pre-tax dollars you'd need to cover that spending, which total $68,176.
(For the remaining cities on this list, we will skip the wonky 'pre-tax' figure. You get the idea.)
Rochester, N.Y.: Rochester has an average Social Security retirement income of $22,581 per year. Retirees spend an average of $57,835 annually. Social Security covers 32% of annual retirement spending.
Oklahoma City, Oklahoma: Social Security income averages $20,860, and retirement spending averages $53,869. Social Security covers 31.7% of that spending.
Milwaukee: Average Social Security income is $21,784 a year. Average retirement spending is $56,533. Social Security covers 31.6% of that spending.
Indianapolis: Retirees spend an average of $56,000 a year in Indianapolis. Average Social Security income is $21,491. Social Security covers 31.5% of retirement spending.
Las Vegas: Social Security income averages $22,105 a year. Retirees spend $57,658 per year. Social Security covers 31.4% of that spending.
Detroit: Retirees spend $58,013 a year, on average. Social Security income averages $22,117. Social Security covers 31.3% of retirement spending.
Des Moines, Iowa: Retirees spend an average of $54,876 per year. Social Security retirement income averages $20,817. Social Security covers 31.1% of retirement spending.
Louisville, Kentucky: Social Security income averages $20,948. Retirement spending averages $55,645. Social Security covers 30.9% of that spending.
Cleveland: Social Security income averages $20,665, and retirement spending averages $55,053 per year. Social Security covers 30.8% of that spending.
Cincinnati: Social Security income averages $20,665 a year. Retirement spending averages $55,704. Social Security covers 30.4% of that spending.
Austin, Texas: Social Security income averages $21,398, and retirement spending averages $57,776 per year. Social Security covers 30.4% of that spending.
Jacksonville, Florida: Social Security income averages $21,740. Annual retirement spending averages $58,723. Social Security covers 30.4% of that spending.
Columbus, Ohio: Social Security income averages $20,665, and retirement spending averages $55,941 a year. Social Security covers 30.3% of that spending.
Nashville, Tennessee: Social Security income averages $21,157. Retirement spending averages $57,568. Social Security covers 30.1% of that spending.
Chicago: Social Security income averages $21,922. Annual retirement spending averages $60,736. Social Security covers 29.6% of that spending.
Houston: Social Security income averages $21,398 a year. Retirement spending averages $59,315. Social Security covers 29.6% of that spending.
Philadelphia: Social Security income averages $21,978 a year. Retirement spending averages $61,269. Social Security covers 29.4% of that spending.
Atlanta: Social Security income averages $21,317 a year. Retirement spending averages $59,730. Social Security covers 29.3% of that spending.
Phoenix: Average Social Security income is $21,989 a year. Retirement spending averages $62,453. Social Security covers 28.9% of that spending.
Dallas: Average Social Security income is $21,398 a year. Retirement spending averages $61,150. Social Security covers 28.7% of that spending.
Boston: Social Security income averages $22,397 a year. Retirees spend $66,064, on average. Social Security covers 27.8% of that spending.
New York: Average Social Security income is $22,581 a year. Retirement spending averages $66,597. Social Security covers 27.8% of that spending.
Miami: Social Security income averages $21,740. Retirees spend $66,182 per year, on average. Social Security covers 26.9% of that spending.
San Diego: Social Security income averages $20,726. Retirement spending averages $66,005. Social Security covers 25.7% of that spending.
Washington, D.C.: Social Security income averages $19,540. Retirement spending averages $64,288. Social Security covers 24.9% of that spending.
Los Angeles: Social Security income averages $20,726. Retirement spending averages $68,372. Social Security covers 24.9% of that spending.
San Francisco: Social Security income averages $20,726. Retirement spending averages $69,971. Social Security covers 24.3% of that spending.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Newsweek
26 minutes ago
- Newsweek
Nurse Gets $6,000 Refunded Instead of $60, Shock Over What Happens Next
The unexpected windfall came at a time when the couple was living with the poster's parents and saving to buy a home—an increasingly difficult goal for many Americans. According to a 2024 report from the Joint Center for Housing Studies at Harvard University, the U.S. housing market is in the grips of an affordability crisis. Elevated interest rates and surging home prices have "priced out" millions of potential buyers, the report found. In 97 of the top 100 housing markets, home prices rose sharply, especially in the northeast and Midwest of the country. The report also found that nearly 20 million homeowners were considered cost-burdened as of 2022—spending more than 30 percent of their income on housing and utilities. Nine million of those households were "severely burdened," devoting more than half their income to housing-related expenses. Several Reddit users were shocked that the couple were able to bypass any scrutiny from mortgage providers about the source of the $6,000 extra income they had. In a follow-up comment, the Reddit user explained that the mortgage lender's financial review never questioned the deposit because it fell outside the time window the bank scrutinized. "The bank did say we would have to explain any charges I think over 1k [$1,000] & I didn't know how I was going to explain it," they said. "But the time frame they ended up looking at was less than the time when it happened (over a year later) so it was never pressed further." Though the poster acknowledged the $6,000 was "literally the only money in my bank," the couple was able to complete the home purchase by borrowing the rest of the deposit from her husband's 401(k) earnings. The confession prompted mixed but mostly supportive reactions on Reddit. "I'd say you lucked out!" wrote user u/Alarmed-Rope-9062. "I don't blame you one bit. Charge it to the game. We do what we must to survive out here," commented u/Coola**mom. Others pointed to the realities of corporate accounting and customer service errors. "Honestly, after 7 years you're probably fine," wrote u/Careless-Fox-5018. "Companies write off way worse losses than 6k daily." U/jadedflames added: "Honestly, you probably saved someone's job. For a big company, $6,000 was likely a rounding error. But for the minimum wage worker who forgot to put the decimal point in $60.00, that was more than his job was probably worth. Everybody wins." Newsweek has contacted the original poster for comment via the Reddit messaging system. A stock image of a woman smiling while holding a payment card in one hand and looking at a mobile phone. A stock image of a woman smiling while holding a payment card in one hand and looking at a mobile phone. Getty Do you have a similar story to share? Let us know via life@ and your story could be featured on Newsweek.
an hour ago
US applications for jobless benefits up modestly but remain at a healthy level
WASHINGTON -- The number of Americans filing for jobless benefits rose modestly last week, a sign that employers still retaining workers despite economic uncertainty related to U.S. trade policy. Jobless claims for the week ending Aug. 2 rose by 7,000 to 226,000, the Labor Department reported Thursday, slightly more than the 219,000 new applications that economists had forecast. The report is the first government labor market data release since Friday's grim July jobs report sent financial markets spiraling downward, spurring President Donald Trump to fire the head of the agency that tallies the monthly jobs numbers. Weekly applications for jobless benefits are seen as a proxy for U.S. layoffs and have mostly settled in a historically healthy range between 200,000 and 250,000 since COVID-19 throttled the economy in the spring of 2020. It was just the second time in eight weeks that jobless benefit applications rose. While layoffs remain low by historical standards, there has been noticeable deterioration in the labor market this year. Last week, the government reported that U.S. employers added just 73,000 jobs in July, well short of the 115,000 expected. Worse, revisions to the May and June jobs figures shaved a stunning 258,000 jobs off previous estimates and the unemployment rate ticked up to 4.2% from 4.1%. 'The 'no hire/no fire' theme in the labor market remains firmly intact,' analysts for Jeffries wrote in a note to clients. Many economists contend that Trump's erratic tariff rollout in April created uncertainty for employers, who have grown reluctant to expand their payrolls. Friday's grim jobs report raised the ire of Trump, who alleged that the data was manipulated for political reasons and ordered the firing of Erika McEntarfer, the head of the Bureau of Labor Statistics, which produces the monthly jobs figures. The firing was roundly criticized by economists, who, along with Wall Street investors, have long considered the job figures reliable. Stock and bond markets often react sharply when they are released. U.S. markets recoiled at last week's jobs report, with the Dow Jones Industrial Average tumbling more than 600 points on Friday. The BLS does not contribute to the weekly unemployment benefits report except to calculate the annual seasonal adjustments that account for changes in weather, holidays, and school schedules. The Department of Labor's Employment and Training Administration collects the weekly unemployment insurance claims reported by each state. There was another indicator that the labor market is softening in a government report last week that revealed employers posted 7.4 million job vacancies in June, down from 7.7 million in May. The number of people quitting their jobs — a sign of confidence in finding a better job — fell in June to the lowest level since December. Hiring also fell from May. Yet major companies have announced job cuts this year, including Procter & Gamble, Dow, CNN, Starbucks, Southwest Airlines, Microsoft, Google and Facebook parent company Meta. Most recently, Intel and The Walt Disney Co. announced staff reductions. The deadline on most of Trump's stiff proposed taxes on imports kicked in on Thursday, though some deals have been made and other deadlines to negotiate have been extended. Unless Trump reaches deals with countries to lower the tariffs, economists fear they could act as a drag on the economy and spark another rise in inflation. Thursday's report also showed that the four-week average of claims, which smooths out some of the week-to-week volatility, fell by 500 to 220,750. The total number of Americans collecting unemployment benefits for the previous week of July 26 jumped by 38,000 to 1.97 million, the highest level since November of 2021.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
10 Midwest Cities Where You Should Retire — It Costs $3,000 or Less Per Month
There's good news if you're anticipating being on a budget during your retirement years. An in-house study from GOBankingRates has identified 25 Midwest cities as the most affordable for retiring on $3,000 or less monthly. From this list, we pulled the 10 cheapest Midwestern cities for retirement where the average monthly cost of living is under $2,650 — and that's before Social Security benefits kick in. Check Out: Explore Next: From most to least expensive, see which 10 Midwestern cities you can retire in and spend $3,000 or less each month. Lansing, Michigan Livability score: 79 Average monthly mortgage: $879 Average monthly cost of living (not including housing): $1,769 Average monthly cost of living for homeowner before Social Security: $2,649 Learn More: Find Out: Cherokee, Iowa Livability score: 79 Average monthly mortgage: $835 Average monthly cost of living (not including housing): $1,810 Average monthly cost of living for homeowner before Social Security: $2,645 For You: Hillsboro, Kansas Livability score: 79 Average monthly mortgage: $871 Average monthly cost of living (not including housing): $1,767 Average monthly cost of living for homeowner before Social Security: $2,637 Britt, Iowa Livability score: 79 Average monthly mortgage: $907 Average monthly cost of living (not including housing): $1,729 Average monthly cost of living for homeowner before Social Security: $2,636 Sac City, Iowa Livability score: 79 Average monthly mortgage: $783 Average monthly cost of living (not including housing): $1,835 Average monthly cost of living for homeowner before Social Security: $2,618 Be Aware: Creighton, Nebraska Livability score: 79 Average monthly mortgage: $593 Average monthly cost of living (not including housing): $2,019 Average monthly cost of living for homeowner before Social Security: $2,612 Lemmon, South Dakota Livability score: 79 Average monthly mortgage: $612 Average monthly cost of living (not including housing): $1,943 Average monthly cost of living for homeowner before Social Security: $2,555 Audubon, Iowa Livability score: 79 Average monthly mortgage: $624 Average monthly cost of living (not including housing): $1,880 Average monthly cost of living for homeowner before Social Security: $2,503 Trending Now: North Baltimore, Ohio Livability score: 79 Average monthly mortgage: $742 Average monthly cost of living (not including housing): $1,733 Average monthly cost of living for homeowner before Social Security: $2,475 Phillipsburg, Kansas Livability score: 79 Average monthly mortgage: $565 Average monthly cost of living (not including housing): $1,768 Average monthly cost of living for homeowner before Social Security: $2,333 Find more original studies and surveys in the GOBankingRates original research center. Photo disclaimer: Photos are for illustrative purposes only. In many cases, the closest major city outside of the city/county mentioned in the article was used. Methodology: For this study, GOBankingRates analyzed cities across the United States to find the best places to retire for under $3,000 a month. First GOBankingRates used the U.S. Census American Community Survey to find cities and basic information including total population, households, household median income and population ages 65-plus. The cost-of-living indexes were sourced from Sperling's BestPlaces and include the grocery, healthcare, housing, utilities, transportation and miscellaneous cost of living. Using the cost-of-living indexes and the national average expenditure costs, as sourced from the Bureau of Labor Statistics Consumer Expenditure Survey, the average expenditure cost for each location was calculated. The average single-family home value and the average rental cost was sourced from Zillow Home Value Index and Zillow Observed Value Index for December 2024. Using the average home value, assuming a 10% down payment, and using the most recent national average 30-year fixed mortgage rate, as sourced from the Federal Reserve Economic Data, the average mortgage was calculated. Using the average mortgage, rental costs and expenditure costs, the average cost of living for homeowners and renters was calculated. Livability indexes were sourced from AreaVibes and included to determine the quality of life for each location. The average Social Security benefits were sourced from the Social Security Administration and used to calculate the cost of living for homeowners and renters after Social Security. The cities were sorted to show the highest livability locations first. All data was collected on and is up to date as of Jan. 30, 2025. More From GOBankingRates 8 Common Mistakes Retirees Make With Their Social Security Checks This article originally appeared on 10 Midwest Cities Where You Should Retire — It Costs $3,000 or Less Per Month Solve the daily Crossword
