logo
Opinion: Spain's Huge Power Blackout Is A Wake-Up Call For India

Opinion: Spain's Huge Power Blackout Is A Wake-Up Call For India

NDTV05-05-2025

For Spain and Portugal, last week's nationwide blackout may have felt unprecedented. But in India, we have lived through these already. In July 2012, a grid collapse caused 400 million Indians to lose access to power, many of them for days. Most assume that, as the country grows richer and energy becomes more abundant, such problems won't recur.
But, as Europe has learned, preventing grid collapse is a constant endeavor, not a battle that you only fight once. India's government has prioritized energy access, vastly expanding availability to households and building more generation capacity. It is now time for it to work on grid stability as well.
As your energy choices change, your grid and how you manage it must too. We don't yet know what caused the initial disruption to Spain's grid that made it to lose its connection to France's more stable electricity network, but the additional variability introduced to its system by renewables - particularly on a sunny day - probably did not help. That should worry India's regulators.
This is not an argument against renewable energy, especially not in India. Politicians in New Delhi have correctly noted that solar and wind power meet three requirements they view as crucial. First, they might end our crippling dependence on imported fossil fuels; second, grid-scale solar energy is now quite cheap; and third, off-grid renewables can sometimes reach where the regular grid does not.
As a consequence, they have prioritized building out renewable energy capacity. Of the 34 gigawatts of generation added last year, 85% was renewables, with 24 gigawatts from solar power alone. Another 300 gigawatts is planned by the end of the decade.
Much of this is driven by private capital and entrepreneurial energy at every level. At one end of the scale, street markets in the poorest states are full of cheap rooftop solar sets. And at the other, highly valued companies like ReNew Power Pvt. and Tata Power Co. have soaked up investor dollars, promising to benefit from the nation's vast solar ambitions. This week, the United Arab Emirates-led green private capital fund ALTERRA and Brookfield Asset Management Ltd. announced plans to invest $100 million in the solar project developer Evren.
All of this sounds great. India does best on those tragically few occasions when its consumers and companies are left to make the right choices, and are given access to capital and supportive regulations. That is how the country became an IT superpower that now has the cheapest high-speed data in the world.
Yet the government has responsibilities, too. It has to ensure the grid can manage the additional requirements - both new consumers and new sources. This will cost money, but not even the government knows how much. Predictions vary from $107 billion to $500 billion, and even the lower end seems unaffordable at the moment. New Delhi hates spending money, but it is going to have to construct a workable plan for investment into the grid, and soon.
The government's tasks don't stop there. It must also try and figure out what's actually getting installed in terms of solar power, and who is doing the building.
Self-consumption electricity systems of various kinds - whether off grid, or the sort that can provide power to the grid as well as taking it out - come with very special issues that must be addressed. As BNEF Research has pointed out, one of the problems that Spain faces is that authorities there don't know enough about solar power generation in the country; it may have 10.5 gigawatts more photovoltaic modules installed than official data suggest.
Grid management becomes very complex under such circumstances. Ideally, you should be able to forecast electricity demand, when it will peak and who will put how much into the network under various circumstances. But a lack of clarity about self-consumption means predictions lose accuracy, and the grid turns vulnerable.
It has also become clear that all is not well even among India's large corporate champions of renewable power. One such, Gensol Engineering Ltd., has just run into trouble after the misbehavior of its founders came to light. Government raids on Genpact offices and various other problems have eroded 70% of its value in two months, and sent shock-waves through the solar sector. Clearly, it can't stay the Wild West forever. Regulators have realized that it is now systemically important, and corporate governance standards need to reflect that.
India's per-capita consumption of energy is still very low by global standards - 1,331 kilowatt-hours in 2022-23, compared to 6,257 kilowatt-hours a year in China. The government, responding to the demands of its voters, is determined to narrow that gap. We may not know how much and when, but there it is absolutely certain that more new generation capacity will be installed in India than anywhere else in the world in the next few decades. And the majority of that will come from renewables.
For a build-out without blackouts, regulators and the government will also need to work on better data, a more robust grid, and better-run companies. As Europe's grid collapse showed, some problems aren't magically solved when you get rich.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

New AC Temperature Rules: What It Means For Indian Homes And How It Compares Globally
New AC Temperature Rules: What It Means For Indian Homes And How It Compares Globally

News18

time10 minutes ago

  • News18

New AC Temperature Rules: What It Means For Indian Homes And How It Compares Globally

Last Updated: Union Minister Manohar Lal Khattar has announced new provisions that will soon make it mandatory for air conditioners across India to operate only within a set temperature range A Big Shift In How Indians Will Use Air Conditioners In a major move to promote energy efficiency and reduce electricity consumption, Union Minister Manohar Lal Khattar has announced new provisions that will soon make it mandatory for air conditioners across India to operate only within a set temperature range — between 20°C and 28°C. This step is aimed at regulating energy use across households and commercial spaces, especially at a time when India is grappling with rising electricity demand and increasingly severe heatwaves. Manohar Lal Khattar said, 'A new provision is being implemented soon regarding air conditioning standards. The temperature standardisation for ACs will be set between 20°C to 28°C, which means we will not be able to cool below 20°C or heat above 28°C." The minister described the move as a 'bold step" to address inefficient cooling practices and reduce excessive energy usage caused by setting air conditioners at extremely low temperatures. What Do The New Rules Say? The new directive from the Centre will cap the operational temperature range of all air conditioners, whether in homes or commercial settings. In practical terms, this means users will not be able to set their ACs below 20°C or above 28°C. Currently, many air conditioners available in the market allow temperatures as low as 16°C or 18°C, and heating settings going up to 30°C. Under the revised standards, manufacturers will need to reprogramme devices or issue software updates to ensure compliance with the new 20°C–28°C range. The government has indicated that implementation will be monitored, though specific enforcement measures, particularly across sectors, are yet to be detailed. Why Has The Government Taken This Step? The rationale behind the move lies in a broader national policy push for sustainable energy usage. With the urban middle class expanding rapidly and air conditioner penetration increasing each year, India is witnessing a sharp surge in electricity consumption during peak summer months. Air conditioners, particularly when operated at very low temperatures, put an enormous load on the power grid. According to the Bureau of Energy Efficiency (BEE), most Indians set their ACs at around 20–21°C, far lower than what is necessary for thermal comfort. These practices not only spike electricity bills but also lead to higher emissions from coal-fired power plants that supply the bulk of India's electricity. By setting a minimum cooling threshold at 20°C and a maximum heating cap at 28°C, the government aims to improve energy efficiency, reduce strain on the national electricity grid, lower greenhouse gas emissions, and bring about a behavioural shift in how people use cooling systems. The goal is not just compliance through technology, but a mindset change around responsible energy use. How Much Electricity Can You Save? The Bureau of Energy Efficiency has long advocated for responsible air conditioning practices. Its data shows that increasing your AC temperature by just one degree can reduce electricity usage by roughly 6 per cent. To put this in perspective, simply raising the temperature from 20°C to 24°C could lead to savings of up to 24 per cent. Over an entire summer season, this could translate into significantly lower electricity bills for households and reduced load on the national grid. What many people do not realise is that cooling a room to 16°C in a country as warm and humid as India is neither necessary nor healthy. Experts note that the optimal comfort zone for indoor spaces lies between 24°C and 26°C, especially when taking into account humidity, ventilation, and regular clothing. The new guidelines therefore align closely with actual comfort levels rather than imposing undue discomfort on users. How Does India Compare To Global Standards? India's new AC temperature norms echo a growing global trend of regulating indoor cooling to conserve energy and reduce emissions. Several countries have already implemented similar rules, some as government mandates, others as strong public guidelines, particularly targeting public and commercial buildings where energy use is concentrated. In Japan, the Ministry of Environment recommends that air conditioners be set at 28°C during summer months, especially in offices. The policy is backed by public awareness campaigns and corporate compliance, though it remains advisory in nature. Spain took a stricter route in 2022, passing legislation that mandates public buildings, offices, and commercial establishments maintain cooling temperatures no lower than 27°C. The rule is part of the country's energy-saving plan amid rising electricity costs and climate concerns. In the United States, while not a legal requirement, the Energy Star programme recommends households set air conditioners to 25.5°C (78°F) when occupied, supported by incentives and utility-driven awareness efforts. China enforces a minimum cooling temperature of 26°C in government buildings, especially during peak summer months. The rule is mandatory and includes penalties for non-compliance in public sector buildings. Australia regulates the energy efficiency of air conditioners, rather than how cold they can be set. Through Minimum Energy Performance Standards (MEPS), only air conditioners that meet specific efficiency benchmarks are allowed to be sold in the country. However, there is no national mandate on thermostat settings. While individual state agencies and workplace guidelines often recommend comfort temperatures of around 22°C to 24°C, especially in offices, these are advisory, not enforceable rules. Italy mandates that public buildings, including schools and post offices, must not set cooling below 25°C. This measure was introduced to cut energy costs and curb emissions as part of the EU's climate targets. Belgium, like Spain and Italy, has set specific indoor climate rules for public buildings — cooling must not go below 27°C, while heating is capped at 19°C in winter. These are legally enforced and part of a broader effort to promote energy responsibility in public infrastructure. India's proposed range of 20°C to 28°C offers more operational flexibility than most of these examples. While countries like Spain and China impose limits only on public institutions, India is expected to apply the rule across residential, commercial, and industrial settings, making it broader in scope. By doing so, India is not just aligning with global best practices but potentially going a step further in creating a uniform, enforceable standard aimed at widespread behavioural change. Is This Mandatory Or Voluntary? Unlike earlier advisories by the Bureau of Energy Efficiency (such as the 2018 suggestion to set AC defaults at 24°C), the latest announcement by Manohar Lal Khattar indicates that the upcoming rules will be mandatory. While the exact implementation roadmap has not yet been publicly detailed, the minister confirmed that a new provision 'is being implemented soon", signalling a shift from recommendation to regulation. Further clarity on enforcement, scope, and compliance is expected in the official guidelines. Why A Simple Temperature Rule Could Deliver Big Energy Gains At first glance, capping air conditioner temperatures may seem like a minor administrative change. But it carries far-reaching consequences for energy security, climate goals, and consumer savings. top videos View all In a country like India, where scorching summers drive massive demand for artificial cooling, rationalising AC usage is both practical and strategic. By aligning temperature limits with realistic comfort needs and global best practices, this initiative can significantly cut emissions, reduce energy waste, and lower electricity bills for millions. As India continues to urbanise and confront climate extremes, such scalable interventions will be essential in building a future that is both energy-efficient and equitable. About the Author Karishma Jain Karishma Jain, Chief Sub Editor at writes and edits opinion pieces on a variety of subjects, including Indian politics and policy, culture and the arts, technology and social change. Follow her @ More Get Latest Updates on Movies, Breaking News On India, World, Live Cricket Scores, And Stock Market Updates. Also Download the News18 App to stay updated! tags : air conditioner manohar lal khattar Location : New Delhi, India, India First Published: June 11, 2025, 09:35 IST News explainers New AC Temperature Rules: What It Means For Indian Homes And How It Compares Globally

'Full-blown assault on peace': Donald Trump pledges to 'liberate' Los Angeles; says military needed to protect federal property
'Full-blown assault on peace': Donald Trump pledges to 'liberate' Los Angeles; says military needed to protect federal property

Time of India

time13 minutes ago

  • Time of India

'Full-blown assault on peace': Donald Trump pledges to 'liberate' Los Angeles; says military needed to protect federal property

Donald Trump US President Donald Trump delivered a fiery speech on Tuesday, marking the 250th anniversary of the US Army, in which he pledged to "liberate Los Angeles." This statement follows the MAGA chief's decision to deploy thousands of troops in response to protests over immigration raids. The riots included burning cars, vandalising stores, assaulting officers, and raising slogans against deportation by the US administration. Speaking at Fort Bragg, North Carolina, Trump used the commemorative event to defend his move to send 700 Marines and over 4,000 National Guard members to Los Angeles. The deployment followed days of protests sparked by aggressive federal immigration raids in the city. 'Generations of Army heroes did not shed their blood on distant shores only to watch our country be destroyed by invasion and third-world lawlessness,' Trump told the gathered troops. 'What you're witnessing in California is a full-blown assault on peace, on public order and on national sovereignty, carried out by rioters bearing foreign flags," he added. He insisted the military presence was needed to protect federal property and staff amid what he described as escalating unrest. 'My administration will liberate Los Angeles,' he said, framing the protests as a threat to national unity. Street demonstrations in Los Angeles began last Friday after federal agents were seen detaining immigrants in unmarked vans. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Вот что поза во сне говорит о вашем характере! Удивительные Новости Undo Local officials have said that most protests have remained peaceful, limited to parts of downtown, though some clashes with sheriff's deputies have occurred. California's Democratic-led government has responded sharply, filing a lawsuit to block Trump's deployment order. State leaders have described the president's actions as an abuse of power and a political provocation. Earlier in the day, Trump reiterated his hardline stance from the Oval Office, warning that any demonstrations during Saturday's parade in Washington would be met with 'very big force.' He did not distinguish between peaceful and violent demonstrators. However, both the FBI and the Metropolitan Police Department have stated there are no credible threats to the upcoming event. The Fort Bragg event also featured defence secretary Pete Hegseth and included military demonstrations such as a special forces assault and a long-range missile launch.

Chandigarh: NDA govt has done unprecedented work for welfare of poor: Anurag Thakur
Chandigarh: NDA govt has done unprecedented work for welfare of poor: Anurag Thakur

Hindustan Times

time20 minutes ago

  • Hindustan Times

Chandigarh: NDA govt has done unprecedented work for welfare of poor: Anurag Thakur

Hamirpur MP and former Union minister Anurag Thakur on Tuesday hailed BJP-led NDA government's achievements as it completed 11 years in power, while opposition parties lambasted the BJP for what they called 'failed promises' and 'misrule'. Addressing a press conference here, Thakur, accompanied by Chandigarh BJP president Jatinder Pal Malhotra, mayor Harpreet Kaur Babla, and state vice president Kailash Chand Jain, credited Prime Minister Narendra Modi for India's historic progress. Thakur said, 'Our borders are secure, and India has emerged as a rising global power. The mantra of 'Sabka Saath, Sabka Vikas, Sabka Vishwas, Sabka Prayas' has brought the country into the mainstream of development.' He highlighted that under Operation Sindoor, the Indian Army destroyed 9 terrorist camps and 11 airbases on Pakistani soil, showcasing India's strength to the world. 'In the past 11 years, the NDA government has done unprecedented work for the welfare of the poor and the common people. Schemes like PM Ujjwala Yojana, Jan Dhan, and Ayushman Bharat have transformed lives across the country,' Thakur said. 'Today marks the beginning of a people's movement connecting 140 crore Indians with the vision of a developed India by 2047,' he added. Chandigarh BJP president Jatinder Pal Malhotra outlined plans for door-to-door campaigns to mobilise public participation in this mission. Opposition slams BJP for 'misrule' Chandigarh Congress president HS Lucky termed the 11 years as a 'decade of betrayal' and said that the dreams sold in 2014 have turned into daily struggles for ordinary Indians. 'People trusted the promise of 'Achhe Din'. But instead of jobs, growth, and unity, the nation has endured record unemployment, rising prices, social unrest, and broken institutions. The government failed on every front, including jobs and economy, inflation, farmer crisis, institutional erosion, foreign failures and many more. Most of his promises remained unfulfilled including ₹15 lakh in every account, 2 crore jobs per year, smart cities, and the bullet train,' he said. Chandigarh Aam Aadmi Party president Vijaypal Singh said, 'The BJP's attempt to celebrate its 11-year rule as 'service, good governance, and welfare of the poor' is a grand scam based purely on false statistics, hollow slogans, and media propaganda. If there had been real development in the country, the BJP wouldn't need to beat the drum of its achievements so loudly. This is like a hollow house.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store