Monkey and dog 'demonisation' blamed on habitat loss, not viciousness, says lawyer
Lawyer and animal rights advocate Rajesh Nagarajan criticised recent media and public narratives that blame monkeys and stray dogs for posing a threat to urban communities. The residents have taken various preventive measures, including installing fences and traps as well as clearing the bushes, but these efforts have yet to yield results. - File photo for illustration purpose only
He described these claims as deeply irresponsible and a gross oversimplification.
'It is deeply irresponsible to blame monkeys and dogs as the root of danger; this narrative is a grotesque oversimplification.
'Monkeys and stray dogs are not inherently vicious, but their behaviour is directly shaped by human actions. Rather than dealing with the real issue, the narrative scapegoats displaced animals," he told Sinar Daily.
Rajesh argued that long-tailed macaques, now listed as endangered by the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN), are being pushed into human spaces due to habitat destruction, not malicious intent.
'They are not invaders, they are victims of habitat destruction. Their raids into homes, bins or rooftops are desperate attempts to find food and shelter that was once theirs.
'Meanwhile, stray dogs in cities are typically abandoned, unvaccinated and unsterilised due to systemic neglect not because they are biologically predisposed to chase children or bark incessantly.
"The problem lies with poor waste management, failed spay/neuter programmes and inadequate public infrastructure, not in natural aggression,' he added.
Rajesh warned that knee-jerk responses like culling not only fail to solve the issue but often escalate fear and reinforce public hostility.
He stated that authorities often resort to culling or harsh control instead of humane deterrence or coexistence.
'These animals simply adapt, reinforcing fear rather than solving the root causes.
'In Penang, a compassionate method of shaking fruit trees to encourage monkeys to depart safely has worked without harm. Similar methods can work elsewhere," he said.
He also cautioned against misplaced fear, pointing out that the real danger is from humans.
He acknowledged that there have been monkey incidents in places like Kuala Krai, with some causing injuries, but these numbers pale in comparison to human-caused tragedies.
Malaysia has logged over 66,800 human–wildlife conflict reports from 2020–2024 alone, showing that the real loss is habitat.
Rajesh also issued a powerful call for accountability and systemic reform.
'Everytime we depict monkeys and dogs as uncontrollable threats, we seriously deflect responsibility for deforestation, urban sprawl, unregulated feeding, improper waste disposal and lack of humane control policy.
'These animals are acting out of a survival instinct. We forced them into these roles. Monkeys and stray dogs are not terrorists in our neighbourhoods; they are displaced survivors.
"If residents truly felt endangered, the solution wouldn't be demonising these creatures. It would be ending the displacement that created the issue in the first place," he said.
Rajesh's statements come amid increasing reports of human–animal encounters in neighbourhoods bordering green zones.
In Bukit Wawasan, Puchong, residents have grown fearful due to frequent intrusions by wild macaques from the nearby forest reserve.
A local Joint Management Body (JMB) staff member who wished to be known as Adila, said the monkeys appear every afternoon, climb fences onto rooftops, and even open windows.
'If the kitchen window is open, they ransack the food. No wonder, the residents are constantly fearful and anxious about their families' safety,' she said.
"Children have reportedly been chased and homes damaged by monkeys prying open roof tiles. Adila said the JMB has lodged several complaints with the Subang Jaya City Council (MBSJ) but was told such issues fall under the jurisdiction of the Department of Wildlife and National Parks (Perhilitan).
Meanwhile, stray dogs have raised safety concerns in areas like USJ11, Bandar Puteri Puchong and Seri Putra in Kajang.
Residents report dogs chasing children, barking incessantly, and even causing injuries.
Indian food vendor Nanthasundari Kuppan from Puchong described her daily anxiety.
'Sometimes the dogs seem calm, but once they start chasing people, there is no time to react. What frightens us is the fear of a rabies outbreak.
'I run my stall under a tent in an open area, even customers get worried and hesitate to come to my stall," she said.
Despite this, Nanthasundari rejected extreme measures.
She urged authorities to catch the animals properly and send them to people who genuinely want to care for them. She added that people are willing to adopt the animals.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
2 hours ago
- The Star
Nacsa investigates alleged data breach of 11 government portals
PETALING JAYA: The National Cyber Security Agency (Nacsa) is investigating a post made by a threat actor on a hacker forum that is allegedly offering live access to Malaysian government gateways and data for sale. A Nacsa spokesperson told LifestyleTech that the agency is aware of the situation and is currently looking into the matter. 'We are still investigating. We can't verify it yet. All claims by the actor have been escalated to relevant agencies to verify the authenticity. Some claims show inaccurate information. 'Some threat actors have a history of publishing recycled data and have claimed they are new ones. So their credibility is in question,' the spokesperson said. The post on the data leak first appeared on Saturday (Aug 2). The hacker claimed to have breached at least 11 government portals, including those belonging to the Defence Ministry, Health Ministry, Higher Education Ministry, and the National Registration Department (JPN), among others. Based on the sample data and screenshots shared in the post, the alleged leak includes 'display names', user IDs, passwords and IP addresses, along with screenshots that appear to show backend management dashboards. The post also lists live access and data for sale at US$19,999 (RM84,645) in cryptocurrency.
Malaysiakini
2 hours ago
- Malaysiakini
Punch up, not down: The cruelty behind 'content culture'
LETTER | In a country where kindness is often celebrated as a national virtue, it's difficult to watch three Malaysian content creators proudly film themselves handing a homeless man a parcel of rice with nothing but leftover chicken bones. The video, posted on Instagram, begins with the trio happily enjoying a KFC meal. Then, in what they claim was a joke or 'social experiment,' they wrap up the scraps of picked-clean chicken bones and hand them to a sleeping homeless man. When he wakes and discovers the contents, his face falls. They film it all. The internet, understandably, erupts in disgust. Later, one of the creators claimed the man had been given a proper meal beforehand and agreed to act in the video. But that does little to change the moral calculus. Even if the man was paid, even if he agreed, the core message of the video remains the same: that a person's vulnerability can be turned into spectacle. That those who have little can be mocked in exchange for clicks. This is not a prank. This is punching down. And there should be a moral red line when it comes to creating content online. In a digital era where anyone with a camera phone can become a 'key opinion leader', going viral has become a drug. Social media rewards attention and not ethics, empathy, or decency. And when creators lack real talent or ideas, some turn to outrage bait and cruelty disguised as comedy. This isn't new, but it's getting worse. To be clear: I do not believe in state censorship as the first resort. Government over-regulation of content carries real risks to speech, creativity, and political dissent. We must always be cautious when addressing online harm, ensuring that any efforts to regulate content do not come at the expense of free expression or public trust. But we cannot stand by and pretend there is no problem either. What we need is not a clampdown, but a cultural shift. One that demands moral standards from creators, platforms, and viewers alike. We need to ask: Why do we reward content that humiliates others? Why do we give likes, shares, and algorithmic fuel to people who exploit the marginalised for laughs? And why are so many creators seemingly unaware, or worse, uncaring, about the power they wield? The creators in question claimed their video was meant to raise awareness. But here's the truth: awareness doesn't require cruelty. If your method of advocacy involves mocking, tricking, or emotionally wounding someone in need, then you're not raising awareness. You're just being cruel. The line between satire and sadism matters. Satire, at its best, punches up by challenging the powerful, critiquing injustice, and shaking the status quo. What these young men did was the opposite. They found someone at the bottom of society's ladder and used his circumstances as a prop. That's not bravery. That's cowardice. Social media platforms must take responsibility, too. Algorithms must stop promoting content based solely on engagement, without factoring in context or ethics. Social media platforms and agencies like the MCMC must help by supporting digital literacy campaigns and ethical content guidelines. They should not just ban content after it goes viral, but do more to cultivate a healthier online culture in the first place. Ultimately, the burden lies with us, viewers, creators, and citizens. We must set the tone. We must remind ourselves, and each other, that content is not exempt from conscience. That virality without values is hollow. And that the measure of a society is how we treat those who have the least. So to any aspiring content creator out there: punch up, not down. Use your platform to challenge injustice, uplift voices, and speak truth to power. But never, ever trade someone's dignity for your one minute of fame. That's not content. That's cruelty. The views expressed here are those of the author/contributor and do not necessarily represent the views of Malaysiakini.
Barnama
2 hours ago
- Barnama
Shielding Children From Online Exploitation
T he rapid advancement of the telecommunications industry, proliferation of smart and mobile devices and expansion of Internet access have made social connectivity possible anytime and anywhere. Technology and social media platforms have become inseparable companions in modern life – so integral that many feel their day is incomplete without going online. Having transformed lifestyles across all age groups, the borderless digital world raises concerns such as digital addiction and exposure to cyber threats. Children are especially vulnerable, often unknowingly falling prey to predators, scammers and bullies in cyberspace. According to UNICEF's 'Our Lives Online' report in 2020, 91 percent of Malaysian children aged 13 to 17 accessed the Internet daily, with 70 percent exposed to disturbing content and more than 40 percent unwilling to seek help. In 2021, a study by UNICEF Malaysia found that four percent of children aged 12 to 17 who used the Internet had experienced threats of sexual exploitation and abuse. The Malaysian Communications and Multimedia Commission (MCMC), in its 2020 Internet Users Survey, also revealed that 56.3 percent of children surfed the Internet alone using digital devices. CAMPAIGN In response to these concerns, the nationwide Safe Internet Campaign, launched recently by the Ministry of Communications in collaboration with MCMC, serves as a timely initiative to promote cyber safety and teach the public, especially primary schoolchildren, to become responsible Internet users. As Communications Minister Datuk Fahmi Fadzil rightly points out in a brief video message, produced by National Film Development Corporation Malaysia (FINAS) and MCMC and aired on TV in conjunction with the launch of the Safe Internet Campaign, children today are exposed to a borderless world filled with threats and deception. In Sabah, nearly 1,300 schools are involved in the campaign, including Sung Siew National Primary School in Sandakan, about 324 kilometres from here. 'We cannot afford to be complacent. Make sure our children are protected from cyber dangers that are ever present. Monitor all their online activities. 'The digital world must be a safe space – not a trap that destroys our children's future,' he said. The module for the Safe Internet Campaign focuses on four key areas: cyberbullying; online scams and gambling; child sexual exploitation; and data protection and digital literacy. The organisers hope to conduct the campaign in more than 10,000 educational institutions by the end of this year. Sekolah Rendah Kebangsaan (SRK) Sung Siew in Sandakan was among the schools in Sabah where the campaign was carried out. Its headmistress Liew Choi Yen described the initiative as the right step towards guiding schoolchildren to use the Internet safely. A total of 120 Year Four to Year Six pupils from her school took part in the campaign in June, with each activity conducted by trained facilitators from MCMC. Liew said the rapid growth of technology, including the emergence of artificial intelligence, calls for the implementation of campaigns such as this to enhance digital literacy and serve as a safeguard to protect young children from negative influences and cyber threats. 'The activities held as part of this campaign were very interesting and creative. With this initiative, students will learn to distinguish online content that is appropriate for their age and be able to navigate the Internet safely. We hope this campaign will be expanded further because it is highly beneficial,' she told Bernama. She said the Safe Internet Campaign should also involve pupils from Year One to Year Three to ensure they are not left behind in learning about the ethical use of digital devices and the Internet. Liew added that parental involvement is equally important, especially in monitoring children's online activities as they spend more time at home than in school. Chong Yee Kei, a guidance and counselling teacher at SRK Sung Siew, said close cooperation between parents and teachers is essential in supervising students' online behaviour and encouraging them to adopt a healthy lifestyle and avoid overdependence on smart devices. PREVENTION She also believed the Safe Internet Campaign can help students understand how to use technology more responsibly and protect themselves from cyber exploitation. This is particularly important now, she said, as digital learning has become widespread among students, which indirectly exposes them to online risks when left unsupervised. Deputy Minister of Communications Teo Nie Ching (second, left) explains how to use the internet safely to several school students in conjunction with the Safe Internet Campaign at Sung Siew National Primary School. Chong, who is also her school's Kapten K-Dat (Safe Internet Campaign icon), noted: 'Digital learning platforms are generally safe as they don't involve social media. However, there is concern when students use the Internet for study, but also browse other sites at the same time. 'This becomes a risk when there is no parental or teacher supervision. Students may be exposed to various threats, including scammers. They are underage and often unaware that sharing personal information is unsafe. Through this campaign, students are learning to use digital platforms more wisely,' she explained. She also recommended that the campaign continue in the future so that more students become aware of online risks and the consequences of improper Internet use. Sharifah Alya Adriana Habib Alibi, 12, a Year Six pupil at SRK Sung Siew, said after participating in the campaign, she now understands the importance of using the Internet safely due to the large amount of content that is inappropriate for children her age. 'This campaign teaches students to use social media properly, safely and under parental supervision,' said Sharifah Alya, who spends between one and four hours a day online, mostly for learning and playing games. BE MORE FIRM Sharing his experience, 12-year-old Brandon Jeffrin said he is happy he took part in the campaign as the information provided at each activity station was easy to understand. Mohd Daniel Quesairy Abdul Lamit, also 12, said the campaign not only taught participants proper Internet etiquette but also raised awareness about the risks of spending too much time on smart devices as it can have a negative impact on health. Teo Nie Ching (centre) participated in a netball game with school students in conjunction with the Safe Internet Campaign at Sung Siew National Primary School recently. Parents interviewed by Bernama also supported the campaign and hoped it would be implemented more widely, given the growing use of smart devices and the Internet among children today. Norayuni Jaafar, 38, said parenting apps can help parents monitor their children's use of smart devices and the Internet, including ensuring the content they access is not harmful. 'We need to keep up with the times because schoolwork is now often done via mobile phones. That's why controlling children's Internet use is important to prevent them from accessing unsafe apps or content,' she said. Another parent Herman Yussof, 47, takes a firmer approach by setting screen time limits to ensure his children use their devices and the Internet mainly for studying and completing their homework. 'I allow them to use the Internet (as a leisure activity) only on Saturdays and Sundays. Usage is limited to between 8 am and noon. From Monday to Friday, it's strictly for learning and completing schoolwork… but not till late at night as they have to go to school the next day,' he said.
