For Argentine farmers, Milei's free-market reforms fall short
Tractors come and go groaning under the weight of sweet navel oranges plucked from the tree tops by laborers perched on ladders.
Like many farmers, Artigues embraced Milei's election in December 2023 as a win for free enterprise after two decades of mainly protectionist centre-left policies.
But he feels that the gains for farmers so far have been timid, and that producers "are growing weary."
Agricultural products represented 58 percent of Argentina's exports in 2024, making it a key driver of economic growth and a major source of foreign currency.
Farmers' frustrations are chiefly directed at the multiple taxes imposed at the national, provincial and municipal levels, which they say harm their competitiveness.
While campaigning in 2023, Milei promised to cut punishing taxes on beef and cereal exports -- a longstanding source of government revenue which he called "robbery," and eventually scrap them altogether.
But the cuts were slow in coming and fell short of industry expectations when he finally announced them last month.
Export taxes on poultry and beef fell from 6.75 percent to five percent, on corn from 12 percent to 9.5 percent, and soybeans -- one of Argentina's biggest farm exports -- from 33 to 26 percent.
There was also some relief for sorghum, sunflower seeds and byproducts and soybean byproducts.
From 'hell' to 'purgatory'
"We were in hell and now we've ascended to purgatory," Raul Vítores, president of the Rural Society of San Pedro, commented on the cuts.
Artigues, who lost 30 percent of his orange and peach harvest this year due to a record cold spell in July, called the changes "insufficient."
As he supervised the sorting of oranges being packed for export to Europe, he acknowledged that the "situation is difficult" for maverick economist Milei, given the poor public finances he inherited.
"Shipping a box of oranges from an Argentine port costs us 40 percent more than our competitors in Chile, Uruguay, or South Africa," he argued.
His orange trees are also a magnet for thieves who raid the orchards at night.
"Producers are growing weary, many are abandoning (fruit) and renting their fields to soybean producers," said Artigues, who employs about 120 people, noting that soybean production, being less labor-intensive than fruit, creates far less employment.
Bumpy route to market
Milei was elected on a promise to cut spending, tame inflation and erase a steep budget deficit.
He has delivered on those promises through a program of biting austerity, which has seen tens of thousands of public sector workers laid off and left many others on the breadline.
But he still had to go back to the International Monetary Fund, to which Argentina already owes $44 billion, to secure another $20 billion loan.
At the annual "Expo Rural" farm fair in Buenos Aires in July, Milei cast doubt on his plan to eradicate export duties altogether, saying he would not do so if it threatened his hard-won fiscal surplus.
But it hasn't been all doom and gloom for farmers.
Food producers have cheered his partial elimination of exchange controls and success in fighting inflation, which had been driving up the cost of their inputs.
They also largely support his austerity measures -- except when it impacts their bottom line.
One of Milei's first acts as president was to freeze public works, including maintenance of more than 40,000 kilometers (25,000 miles) of highways used to transport 90 percent of Argentina's freight.
Nicolas Pino, president of the Argentine Rural Society which represents large landowners, warned the increasingly ruinous state of roads was affecting business.
"It is not viable to increase production if there are no roads, railroads, or waterways to transport it," he told the farm fair.
© 2025 AFP
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
France 24
6 days ago
- France 24
France strikes down return of banned bee-killing pesticide
The so-called "Duplomb law" sparked public anger for permitting a return of acetamiprid -- a chemical known to be toxic to bees and other creatures but relied on by some European farmers. A student-led petition against the bill garnered more than two million signatures after lawmakers adopted it on July 8, with critics saying it was rushed through a divided lower house of parliament without a proper debate. The Constitutional Council said in its ruling that a provision in the bill allowing exemptions to the ban of products containing neonicotinoid chemicals such as acetamiprid would violate France's environmental charter, which has constitutional status. In 2020, the council had granted a temporary exemption to the ban, limited to the beet sector and seed coating. But the ruling said this measure did not give enough detail about how long the pesticides could be used, how they would be applied, or which crops they would affect. The legislature undermined "the right to live in a balanced and healthy environment" enshrined in the charter, the council said. "Neonicotinoids have an impact on biodiversity, in particular on pollinating insects and birds, as well as consequences for water and soil quality, and pose risks to human health," the council said. The Constitutional Council approved two other measures in the law: one allowing for the construction of water storage for agricultural purposes, and another raising thresholds at which pig and poultry farms require prior authorisation. French President Emmanuel Macron took "note" of the ruling, his office said on Thursday. The president will enact the law as soon as possible in a form that takes the ruling into account, the Elysee said. -'Bee-killer'- Banned in France since 2018, acetamiprid remains legal in the European Union, and proponents said that some French farmers needed it to help them compete economically. The insecticide is particularly sought after by beet and hazelnut growers, who say that they have no alternative against pests and face unfair competition. But a petition on France's lower-house National Assembly's website, which garnered more than 2.1 million signatures, called the measure a "frontal attack on public health". Beekeepers have described the chemical as "a bee killer", and its possible effects on humans are also a source of concern, though its risk remains unclear in the absence of large-scale studies. For some opponents, frustration stretched beyond environmental and health concerns to exasperation over the country's political deadlock. One supporter of the petition called it "democratic revenge" after Macron forced a controversial pension reform through parliament in 2023 and dissolved the lower chamber last year, sparking political turmoil that resulted in a hung parliament. In late June, before the law's passage, several thousand demonstrators — including farmers, environmental organisations and scientists -- rallied across France calling for the bill to be withdrawn.
France 24
6 days ago
- France 24
France to rule on controversial bee-killing pesticide bill
The so-called "Duplomb law" has sparked public anger for permitting a return of acetamiprid -- a chemical known to be toxic to pollinators, such as bees, and to the environment. A student-led petition against the bill garnered more than two million signatures after lawmakers adopted its reintroduction on July 8, when it was rushed through a deeply-divided lower house of parliament without a proper debate. President Emmanuel Macron has said he is waiting to hear the verdict of the Constitutional Council, which is expected to deliver its ruling on the constitutionality of the law at 6:00 pm (1600 GMT). If the law is upheld, Macron will have two weeks to enact it or request a second vote in parliament. Banned in France since 2018, acetamiprid remains legal in the European Union, and proponents say that some French farmers need it to help them compete economically. The insecticide is particularly sought after by beet and hazelnut growers, who say that they have no alternative against pests and face unfair competition. But the petition on France's lower-house National Assembly's website, which has garnered more than 2.1 million signatures, calls the measure a "frontal attack on public health". Beekeepers have described the chemical as "a bee killer", and its effects on humans are also a source of concern, though its risk remains unclear in the absence of large-scale studies. Left-wing lawmakers, who referred the bill for constitutional review, said it violates France's environmental charter which guarantees the "right to live in a balanced and healthy environment". For some opponents, frustration stretches beyond environmental and health concerns to exasperation over the country's political deadlock. One supporter of the petition called it "democratic revenge" after Macron forced a controversial pension reform through parliament in 2023 and dissolved the lower chamber last year, sparking political turmoil that resulted in a hung parliament. According to a poll published in La Tribune Dimanche in late July, 64 percent of people surveyed hope that Macron will not sign the bill into law but will instead submit it to a new debate in parliament. In late June, before the law's passage, several thousand demonstrators — including farmers, environmental organisations and scientists -- rallied across France calling for the bill to be withdrawn.
France 24
7 days ago
- France 24
For Argentine farmers, Milei's free-market reforms fall short
That includes Ruben Artigues and his orchards in La Buena Moza region, two hours northwest of Buenos Aires, where the orange harvest is in full swing. Tractors come and go groaning under the weight of sweet navel oranges plucked from the tree tops by laborers perched on ladders. Like many farmers, Artigues embraced Milei's election in December 2023 as a win for free enterprise after two decades of mainly protectionist centre-left policies. But he feels that the gains for farmers so far have been timid, and that producers "are growing weary." Agricultural products represented 58 percent of Argentina's exports in 2024, making it a key driver of economic growth and a major source of foreign currency. Farmers' frustrations are chiefly directed at the multiple taxes imposed at the national, provincial and municipal levels, which they say harm their competitiveness. While campaigning in 2023, Milei promised to cut punishing taxes on beef and cereal exports -- a longstanding source of government revenue which he called "robbery," and eventually scrap them altogether. But the cuts were slow in coming and fell short of industry expectations when he finally announced them last month. Export taxes on poultry and beef fell from 6.75 percent to five percent, on corn from 12 percent to 9.5 percent, and soybeans -- one of Argentina's biggest farm exports -- from 33 to 26 percent. There was also some relief for sorghum, sunflower seeds and byproducts and soybean byproducts. From 'hell' to 'purgatory' "We were in hell and now we've ascended to purgatory," Raul Vítores, president of the Rural Society of San Pedro, commented on the cuts. Artigues, who lost 30 percent of his orange and peach harvest this year due to a record cold spell in July, called the changes "insufficient." As he supervised the sorting of oranges being packed for export to Europe, he acknowledged that the "situation is difficult" for maverick economist Milei, given the poor public finances he inherited. "Shipping a box of oranges from an Argentine port costs us 40 percent more than our competitors in Chile, Uruguay, or South Africa," he argued. His orange trees are also a magnet for thieves who raid the orchards at night. "Producers are growing weary, many are abandoning (fruit) and renting their fields to soybean producers," said Artigues, who employs about 120 people, noting that soybean production, being less labor-intensive than fruit, creates far less employment. Bumpy route to market Milei was elected on a promise to cut spending, tame inflation and erase a steep budget deficit. He has delivered on those promises through a program of biting austerity, which has seen tens of thousands of public sector workers laid off and left many others on the breadline. But he still had to go back to the International Monetary Fund, to which Argentina already owes $44 billion, to secure another $20 billion loan. At the annual "Expo Rural" farm fair in Buenos Aires in July, Milei cast doubt on his plan to eradicate export duties altogether, saying he would not do so if it threatened his hard-won fiscal surplus. But it hasn't been all doom and gloom for farmers. Food producers have cheered his partial elimination of exchange controls and success in fighting inflation, which had been driving up the cost of their inputs. They also largely support his austerity measures -- except when it impacts their bottom line. One of Milei's first acts as president was to freeze public works, including maintenance of more than 40,000 kilometers (25,000 miles) of highways used to transport 90 percent of Argentina's freight. Nicolas Pino, president of the Argentine Rural Society which represents large landowners, warned the increasingly ruinous state of roads was affecting business. "It is not viable to increase production if there are no roads, railroads, or waterways to transport it," he told the farm fair. © 2025 AFP
