Once A Strength, Cleveland Guardians Now Lack Middle Infield Depth
It wasn't long ago, when the Cleveland Guardians organization had a wealth of well regarded middle infield prospects.
The quality depth of highly ranked middle infielders in the Guardians development program has dwindled.
The Guardians were always careful to give their prospects enough development time to best prepare for the major leagues. Be that with Cleveland, or with another club.
This old scout has always stated that the talent gap between Triple-A and the big leagues is as wide as the grand canyon.
That is particularly true for prospect pitchers.
And because MLB pitchers are so advanced in their pitching skills, many prospects falter when given a chance with the parent club.
Consider the number of Cleveland Indians/Cleveland Guardians prospects that are now playing elsewhere in Major League Baseball, or are out of professional baseball altogether.
Each of the middle infielders noted below was part of the Indians/Guardians MLB.com Top 30 prospects, from 2020 until today.
In those a short years, the following young prospects are gone from the Cleveland organization:
MIAMI, FLORIDA - JUNE 04: Tyler Freeman #2 of the Colorado Rockies celebrates with teammates after ... More scoring a run against the Miami Marlins in the fifth inning of the game at loanDepot park on June 04, 2025 in Miami, Florida. (Photo by)
Tyler Freeman-drafted by the Indians, and traded to the Colorado Rockies in 2025
Jose Tena-signed as an international free agent by the Indians in 2017, and traded to the Washington Nationals in 2024.
Ernie Clement-drafted by the Indians in 2017, selected off waivers by the Athletics in 2022, and signed by the Toronto Blue Jays in 2023
Carson Tucker-out of baseball (a 2020 Cleveland Indians 1st round draft pick)
Owen Miller-drafted by the San Diego Padres, traded to Cleveland, and then traded by Cleveland to the Milwaukee Brewers. Now in the Rockies organization.
Richie Palacios-drafted by the Indians in 2018, and traded to the St. Louis Cardinals. Traded to the Tampa Bay Rays in 2024.
The list does not include Amed Rosario, and Andres Gimenez, both traded to Cleveland from the New York Mets in 2021. Both are gone from the organization.
Rosario was traded by Cleveland to the Los Angeles Dodgers in 2023. After being granted free agency, Rosario signed with the Tampa Bay Rays in 2024. He was traded to the Los Angeles Dodgers in 2024, granted free agency, and then signed with the Washington Nationals in 2025.
Gimenez was traded to the Toronto Blue Jays in December 2024.
EASTLAKE, OHIO - JULY 31, 2024: Travis Bazzana #37 of the Lake County Captains celebrates hitting a ... More grand slam home run during the fifth inning against the Beloit Sky Carp at Classic Auto Group Park on July 31, 2024 in Eastlake, Ohio. This is the continuation of the July 30 game which was suspended due to inclement weather. (Photo by Nick Cammett/Diamond Images via Getty Images)
The Guardians have young middle infielders in development, but many are still a year, or more away from graduation to the big leagues. Those players include:
-Travis Bazzana-2024 1st overall draft pick, now dealing with an oblique injury
-Angel Genao-a terrific defensive player, Genao in still at Double-A Akron
-Welbyn Francisca-a good hitter, with little power, Francisca is still in Class-A
-Juan Brito-a solid hitter with some power, Brito is currently injured at Triple-A Columbus
-Gabriel Rodriguez-a young prospect in Rookie Ball.
Bryan Rocchio began this season as the Guardians starting shortstop. He didn't hit well, had some defensive hiccups at shortstop, and was optioned to Triple-A Columbus. Rocchio likely remains a candidate to return to the parent club at some point this season.
GOODYEAR, AZ - FEBRUARY 22: Juan Brito #74 of the Cleveland Guardians poses for a photo during the ... More Cleveland Guardians Photo Day at Goodyear Ballpark on Thursday, February 22, 2024 in Goodyear, Arizona. (Photo by Chris Coduto/MLB Photos via Getty Images)
There is little question Cleveland misses the defense of Andres Gimenez, who is now playing solid second base, but not hitting well at Toronto.
It seems likely Bazzana is the second baseman of the future. If he hits. If he plays solid defense.
A superb defender, Gabriel Arias has claimed the shortstop role, supplanting Rocchio. For now. How much will Arias hit? Can the Guardians continue to handle his inconsistency on offense?
Brito may win a role with the Guardians in the future. But with Bazzana likely at second, where does Brito play?
Genao might be as good, or better than Arias at shortstop. Will he hit?
Lots of Cleveland middle infielders have walked out the door.
Now, the team has to determine which players in their organization fit in their immediate, and long-range future.
Middle infielders, once a deep strength of the Guardians, have now been reduced in number.
Time will tell how the Guardians manage their infield in the coming months and years.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
a minute ago
- New York Post
Tyrone Taylor's Mets playing time won't completely disappear despite Cedric Mullins addition
Access the Mets beat like never before Join Post Sports+ for exciting subscriber-only features, including real-time texting with Mike Puma about the inside buzz on the Mets. Try it free After getting little out of center field for most of the season — especially after Jose Siri was lost to a broken leg — the Mets' expectations at the spot have shifted with the arrival of Cedric Mullins from Baltimore. Mullins arrived late Friday afternoon following his trade from the Orioles and wasn't in the starting lineup against the Giants at Citi Field, but Carlos Mendoza said the 30-year-old would 'get a lot of playing time there.' But the manager also added that Tyrone Taylor, in center again Friday, would continue to get time at the position, as would Jeff McNeil. Still, the Mets got enough of a look at the Taylor/McNeil pairing in center that they decided to go ahead with the Mullins trade. 'I watched this guy play [for] a lot of years,' Mendoza said of Mullins. 'Defensively, offensively, whether it's hitting for power, running the bases … going first to third, getting a bunt down, cutting a ball [off] in the outfield. There's a lot behind the numbers he does well. He's a really good player.' 5 New York Mets center fielder Cedric Mullins (28) on the field before a game against the San Francisco Giants at Citi Field. Brad Penner-Imagn Images To make room for Mullins on the roster, Luisangel Acuña was optioned to Triple-A Syracuse. Acuña had appeared in just six games — with three plate appearances — since July 21. McNeil was back at second base for the first time in two weeks Friday, with Mark Vientos at third base and Brett Baty on the bench. Mendoza said he hoped the playing time situation would create 'healthy competition' among the young infielders. CHECK OUT THE LATEST MLB STANDINGS AND METS STATS 'It's been that way a long time,'' the manager said. 'There's a reason why they're here. We believe in them and they'll continue to help us win baseball games. … We're counting on all of them.' 5 Mark Vientos throws on the field during batting practice before the start of his teams game against the San Francisco Giants at Citi Field in Queens, New York, USA, Friday, August 01, 2025. JASON SZENES/ NY POST And Taylor will stick around, as well, at least for now. Mendoza said Taylor would continue to get playing time — although it would decrease — but the Mets still value his defense. Taylor has provided excellent defense, but had an OPS of just .278 over his previous 29 games. Mullins has been up and down with the Orioles this season and the lefty hitter has hit left-handed pitching better than usual. 5 Tyrone Taylor (15) makes a catch in the 9th inning. The New York Mets win against the Cincinnati Reds 3-2 at Citi Field, Sunday, July 20, 2025. Corey Sipkin for the NY POST But his defensive metrics are lacking, with Fangraphs rating him the worst among center fielders with enough playing time, with -14 Defensive Runs Saved, but Mullins was in the middle of the pack, according to Baseball Savant. Mendoza praised Mullins' 'jumps, routes [and] speed.' But he acknowledged the shaky defensive numbers. 'There are years where it feels like, 'Man, that's weird he graded so low defensively,' ' Mendoza said. 'I've watched this kid play … and he's a pretty elite defender out there. He's a natural there. I'm not worried about numbers because I've seen this guy play and he's pretty good out there.' 5 Mets outfielder Cedric Mullins (28) before the game when the New York Mets played the San Francisco Giants Friday, August 1, 2025 at Citi Field in Queens, NY. Robert Sabo for NY Post 5 Mets manager Carlos Mendoza (64) on the dugout fence in the fifth inning against the Cincinnati Reds at Citi Field, Sunday, July 20, 2025, in Queens, NY. Corey Sipkin for the NY POST Mullins said being moved prior to Thursday's trade deadline was 'somewhat to be expected,' since the Orioles are in last place in the AL East and he's a free agent following this season. 'I didn't know where it might be,' Mullins said of how he viewed a trade prior to the deadline. 'New York is a great place to land. It's a good fit.' And he noted the feelings with the Mets are similar to the ones that were with the Orioles the past few years —including entering what became a wildly disappointing 2025 at Camden Yards. He said his goal in Queens is 'bringing a ring back to the city. That's what it's all about.'
New York Times
2 minutes ago
- New York Times
Carlos Correa returns to the Astros, where the dynamic ‘is completely different'
BOSTON — Knox Bregman turned 3 years old Friday, but his parents threw a birthday party when most of their family and friends could celebrate. The Houston Astros and Boston Red Sox shared a mutual off day Thursday, bringing Bregman's past and present together on a thunderstorm-soaked afternoon in Massachusetts. Advertisement Anything with the Bregmans must involve some baseball, so when the clouds cleared, two sets of fathers started throwing batting practice to their 3-year-old sons. Knox's left-handed swing is 'better than mine,' his father acknowledged. Lucas Hader can hold his own against his dad, but had one round of swings Thursday halted by an important announcement from his mother. 'Maria comes out and says 'We got Carlos,'' Josh Hader said with a smile. Hader met Maria while he played alongside Carlos Correa at Houston's Double-A affiliate in Corpus Christi during the 2015 season. 'We had a squad, man,' Hader often says of a roster that also included Teoscar Hernandez, Joe Musgrove and Lance McCullers Jr. All but McCullers and Correa were traded away with thoughts they'd never return. Hader did so on the largest free-agent contract of Jim Crane's ownership tenure. Thursday, Correa came back in the sort of trade Crane has become conditioned to constructing. 'I never thought this would happen or there was a chance for this to happen,' Correa said before hitting cleanup Friday evening at Fenway Park. Correa's presence in the visiting clubhouse completed one of the wildest 48 hours in the history of this franchise. Longtime friend Jose Altuve had to text Correa after reports emerged of an agreed-upon trade. Once Correa confirmed it, 'I was real excited,' Altuve said. 'I don't have Twitter, so I was refreshing Instagram to see who we got and who we gave up. I stopped looking as soon as we got Correa,' utilityman Mauricio Dubón said. Blockbusters can bring anything to a halt, be it batting practice at a birthday party or another dad's desire to finish 'The Bad Guys 2.' Joe Espada enjoyed the bit he saw, but soon felt the phone ringing in his pocket. General manager Dana Brown promised to keep Espada, his second-year manager, abreast of the Astros' actions during a trade deadline that always included this possibility. Brown and his baseball operations team first called the Minnesota Twins to inquire about Correa on Wednesday. Advertisement Before it, the baseball world did not even know Correa would be available at all. His contract contained a full no-trade clause. Friday, Correa acknowledged other players had reached out about waiving it 'to different teams.' 'I told them I was not going to waive it to those teams,' Correa said, 'And then when the Astros thing happened, obviously that was the only one place that I would have waived my no-trade clause.' Discussions with Twins officials revealed a franchise headed in a direction Correa did not like. The team, which is still up for sale and in a two-year state of underachievement, traded 10 players off its 26-man roster Thursday. None carried more shock than Correa, who will change positions, play third base and, according to Altuve, 'be our leader.' We have made several roster moves today after yesterday's trade deadline: — Houston Astros (@astros) August 1, 2025 'The dynamic in there is completely different right now,' Espada said, nodding over his shoulder toward the visiting clubhouse. 'He was so fired up. Happy to come home. He immediately started talking about winning. He immediately started talking about working at third base. He wants to know about some of the players, what they're like. He doesn't want to talk about himself. He wants to know who we have in our clubhouse, and how can he help win games. That's just who he is.' Before boarding a Boston-bound airplane Wednesday afternoon, Espada hoped traveling with his two daughters, Eliana and Viviana, would calm his nerves on the busiest day of the baseball calendar. Bringing them to see an animated movie Thursday became another distraction tactic. Doing so two hours before the trade deadline seemed like suspect scheduling, but the family persisted. Correa and Miami Marlins outfielder Jesús Sanchez both became Astros in the middle of 'The Bad Guys 2.' Espada never saw the ending. Advertisement 'I did not mind missing the movie,' Espada said. Espada's injury-ravaged team treaded water in July and required reinforcements to complete its remarkable season. Brown and owner Jim Crane took notice, a fact Espada emphasized during a brief team meeting before Friday's game. 'It shows that they're willing to do whatever it takes to win a championship again. As a player, that's what you want,' Hader said. 'Just like us going out here and doing the right s— and doing things the right way, they see the effort and vice versa. We see their effort. We hope that we can put a good push and make it to the World Series, but nothing is guaranteed. That's the fun thing about this game.' Blockbusters have become habitual for Hader. He's been a part of two himself. The first sent him out of Houston's organization. The second sent him to the San Diego Padres, perhaps the only franchise more aggressive than the Astros at each July's trade deadline. They built a behemoth in 2022 by acquiring Juan Soto for the stretch run. That San Diego team did not win a World Series, something that still sticks in Hader's mind. Getting a second chance — after another seismic trade — is a gift. 'It's go time,' Dubón said. 'Who we have in this clubhouse is who we're going to go with into October, possibly the World Series. It's uplifting having new faces and everything. It's going to recharge everybody and try to go out there and win every year.'
Washington Post
2 minutes ago
- Washington Post
Phillies slugger Bryce Harper ejected following outburst over called third strike
PHILADELPHIA — Phillies slugger Bryce Harper was ejected in the seventh inning of Friday's game against Detroit for arguing a called third strike on a check swing. The Phillies scored three runs in the seventh to tie the game 3-all and had two runners on base with two outs when Harper faced Tigers reliever Will Vest. Harper tried to check his swing on a full-count changeup from Vest, but third base umpire Vic Carapazza rang up the Harper, who ripped his helmet off his head in a outburst and shouted as he waved his arms at Carapazza. Harper was promptly tossed and kept his helmet with him as he walked into the dugout. ___ AP MLB:
