Don't trust the ‘influencers' — Trump's base isn't breaking over Israel
The base will not stand for it! they shouted, calling the very idea a betrayal — and the liberal media accepted their framing. 'MAGA is split over Iran,' the headlines screamed.
They were soon proved wrong. Republican voters overwhelmingly supported ridding the planet of the threat of a nuclear Iran, to the tune of 80%.
Advertisement
The same thing played out over the administration's awkward handling of the Jeffery Epstein files.
This time he's really done it! brayed the influencers — Trump's supporters would not tolerate burying the Epstein list, they declared. 'The Epstein case is tearing MAGA apart,' the media parroted.
Once again, the commentariat was wrong; polling showed how little GOP voters cared about the topic, and how little they blamed Trump for his aides' stumbles.
The lesson should be clear: Doubt the president's understanding of his base at your peril.
Advertisement
Yet today these same characters, following the social-media engagement algorithms, declare that Israel's war with Hamas is losing the right.
Attention-seeking lawmakers are claiming a 'genocide' in Gaza, as influencers predict an imminent GOP rupture.
And again, it's just not true.
Advertisement
For starters, polling still shows vast support for Israel among Republicans —including for the current war against Hamas.
Last week 71% of Republican voters told Gallup that despite all the headlines claiming famine in Gaza, they are on Israel's side in this war — compared to just 25% of independents and a shocking 8% of Democrats.
Meanwhile, 81% of Republicans approve of Trump's handling of the situation, including his clear and proud Israel backing.
Every morning, the NY POSTcast offers a deep dive into the headlines with the Post's signature mix of politics, business, pop culture, true crime and everything in between. Subscribe here!
Advertisement
True, younger Republicans express less support for Israel — their approval of the Jewish state is at 50%, polls show.
But the reason for that isn't anti-Israel sentiment. It's populism.
Young Republicans, like young Americans across the board, have less appetite for war — especially when they are being asked to fund it.
A survey of attendees at the recent Turning Point USA Student Action Summit, which gathered over 5,000 young conservatives, found that 73% called themselves pro-Israel — even as the event's prominent speakers were expounding on Epstein's alleged ties to Mossad.
The vast majority of the young activists in attendance agreed that Israel has a right to defend itself.
But they also said they were sick of being asked to pay for wars they don't see as benefiting them — unlike the strike on Iran, which 86% supported.
A few days ago Turning Point USA founder Charlie Kirk convened a focus group on Israel with conservative Gen Z students.
Advertisement
'What's the first word that comes to mind when you hear 'Israel'?' Kirk asked them.
Some responded with terms including 'Judaism,' 'conflict' and 'sacred' — but by far, the word that came up most often was 'aid.'
'Our house is burning down and so is our neighbor's, and we're trying to put their fire out before we put ours out,' one student explained.
Israel absolutely has a right to exist and a right to defend itself, these young Americans said, but we have a right to want our taxpayer dollars spent at home.
Advertisement
It's the exact same logic heard from many MAGA partisans when they explain their fatigue with paying for the war in Ukraine, or for USAID grants: They can't afford to buy a home, yet their tax dollars are going elsewhere.
Meanwhile, when pro-Israel partisans paint these young Trump supporters as antisemitic for opposing aid to Israel, they feel alienated, complaining that a woke speech code has infected the discourse.
'It's very similar to our support for Ukraine,' one of the students explained to Kirk.
Advertisement
'We're sending a lot of money over there, not really getting in my opinion a huge return on investment . . . When people talk about their distrust or dis-support for Israel, that's the first thing that usually comes up, is all the money that we're sending them.'
'I think we have a lot bigger issues at home,' another said. 'I think we should be spending most of our tax dollars on securing our border, keeping our home people safe . . . we have a much bigger problem on the home front, rather than sending money to foreign countries.'
Crucially, they don't see this stance as being anti-Israel — but as being pro-American.
'I think it's critical that we remain friends with them, they remain our ally,' another focus group participant succinctly put it. 'I just don't think we should be subsidizing them as much as we are.'
Advertisement
So ignore the newly anti-Israel right-wing podcasting class. Gen Z Republicans aren't turning on Israel.
They're just insisting that their own right to the American Dream must come first — as they should.
Batya Ungar-Sargon is the author of 'Second Class: How the Elites Betrayed America's Working Men and Women.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
USA Today
11 minutes ago
- USA Today
'South Park' trolls DHS for using screengrab to recruit ICE agents: 'So we ARE relevant?'
Just when some fans thought the feud between "South Park" and the White House reached an impasse. The raunchy comedy showed no signs of easing up this week, with more jabs at President Donald Trump as a 20-second teaser for its Aug. 6 episode featured an image of Trump sitting at a dinner table with Satan. The moment depicts Trump rubbing Satan's leg under the table before Satan tells him to stop. Despite the ongoing satirical jabs, Homeland Security's official X account shared a screengrab from that trailer to encourage people to apply for jobs at Immigration and Customs Enforcement. The still depicts multiple masked and armed ICE agents storming a road in the same direction, with a link to the agency's careers page. "Wait, so we ARE relevant?" the "South Park" X account replied to the Aug. 5 post before telling the agency to "eat a bag of [expletive]." The show's Season 27 premiere last month made a not-so-subtle dig at Trump, who was depicted cuddling in bed with Satan, his lover, using actual photos of the president crudely placed on an animated body. White House spokesperson Taylor Rogers later dismissed the episode, calling the Comedy Central staple a "fourth-rate show" that "hasn't been relevant for over 20 years and is hanging on by a thread with uninspired ideas in a desperate attempt for attention." The controversial episode, titled "Sermon on the Mount," proved to be a ratings juggernaut, marking the show's most-watched season premiere since 1999, with viewership up 68% from last season's premiere, according to Paramount Global. The Aug. 5 post from Homeland Security comes amid a massive recruitment campaign to hire more than 14,000 immigration agents, attorneys, and other workers. Through his federal spending plan, Trump aims to have enough ICE agents to execute his border crackdown and the goal of deporting 1 million people a year. What time does the next 'South Park' episode drop? The newest episode of "South Park" Season 27 is set to drop Wednesday, Aug. 6, at 10 p.m. ET/PT on Comedy Central. The episode will be available to stream on Paramount+ the following day, Aug. 7, at 6 am ET/3 a.m. PT, according to the streaming platform. Contributing: Brendan Morrow, Trevor Hughes, Sara Chernikoff, and Fernando Cervantes Jr., USA TODAY
New York Post
11 minutes ago
- New York Post
Michael Goodwin: Sen. Warren backing Mamdani is the latest example of Dems floundering — and their zany agenda
More than six months into Donald Trump's highly consequential second term, Democrats are still looking for their sputtering resistance movement to deliver some big victories. Instead, they've suffered repeated failures and are responding with an increasingly angry radicalism that has zero appeal to the hearts and minds of most voters. A recent Wall Street Journal poll found that a mere 33% of national respondents hold a favorable view of Dems, which the Journal called the party's lowest point in its polls over three decades. Advertisement It also found that a stunning 63% of voters hold an unfavorable view of the party. Those dismal results are the fruit of a run of bad candidates —think Kamala Harris and Tim Walz — and a scatter-shot strategy that consistently defies common sense and traditional American middle-class values. The impression is that party leaders and high-profile advocates are lurching from one temper tantrum about Trump to another, each delivered with the desperation of a Hail Mary pass. Advertisement They seem more concerned about the welfare of illegal immigrants, including gang-bangers, than about the physical safety and financial security of innocent, tax-paying Americans. Comes now the latest example of their zany agenda, this one courtesy of Massachusetts Sen. Elizabeth Warren. In a few brief remarks Monday, she managed to prove that the passing years have not dimmed her gift for poor judgment and terrible ideas. Major party headache Her new brainstorm threatens to become another major headache for her party. Advertisement Appearing in Gotham with socialist mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani, Warren declared that 'New York City is the place to start the conversation for Democrats on how affordability is the central issue, the central reason to be a Democrat, and that delivering on it in meaningful, tangible ways that will touch working families is why we're here.' It's a pretty strange thing to say given that it was almost exclusively Democratic mayors, governors and lawmakers that created the affordability crisis she now bemoans. She went on to claim that Mamdani, the 33–year-old nepo-baby radical who won the Dems' mayoral primary, should be the party's national face. 'Bring it on!' Republicans say, convinced that he would be a major drag for Dems in the 2026 elections. Advertisement The GOP would be delighted to run against a party that features a radical leftist who never held a real job in his life. It's worth noting that four years ago, then-Mayor-elect Eric Adams declared himself 'the new face of the Democratic Party.' The idea never gained much traction, with his tenure soon swamped by the tide of illegal border crossers waved in by Joe Biden, as hundreds of thousands made their way to New York for free housing, food and medical care. Adams never quite recovered, and that was even before he faced federal corruption charges brought under Biden that the Trump Justice Department dropped. Nonetheless, the turmoil and critical coverage were such a burden that Adams passed up his party's primary and is seeking re-election in November as an independent. Although he and the NYPD deserve great credit for driving shootings to historic lows, recent polls show the mayor's support is stuck in single digits and sometimes falls below the slice of voters who say they are undecided. NY Dems shun him As for Warren's idea about making Mamdani the national model for the party, she is so deep in fantasy land that she's even out of step with leading New York Dems. They are avoiding the far-leftist candidate like the plague, which is what he could be politically in areas that are more balanced than the People's Republic of New York, where there is just one registered Republican for every six registered Dems. Advertisement And so Gov. Hochul, Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer and House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries all have declined to endorse Mamdani, which is an exceptional rebuke to him and his platform. Normally, they would reflexively back the winner of the party's mayoral primary, but they look ahead and see his major positions — defund the police, hike taxes, boycott Israel and support the anti-Jewish mobs disrupting cities and college campuses — as a toxic brew that even if it prevails in the city, won't fly around the rest of the state or across the nation. They see him as a major burden next year, when Hochul will be seeking re-election and Schumer and Jeffries will be trying to guide Dems to victory in their respective chambers. Of the group, Hochul has been the most outspoken and explicit in shunning him. Advertisement Mamdani's plan to tax high-income New Yorkers would require legislative approval and her signature, and the governor made it clear that's not going to happen. Days before the late June primary, Hochul threw cold water on the tax proposals he aims to use to fund his long list of free things, including buses and child care. 'I'm not raising taxes at a time where affordability is the big issue,' she said in a TV interview. 'I don't want to lose any more people to Palm Beach. We've lost enough . . . so let's be smart about this.' Advertisement Hochul's answer was surprising in that she's usually an automatic yes vote for new taxes, congestion pricing being a recent example. But her answer was also clever in that she adopted Mamdani's theme of an 'affordability crisis' and turned it on its head to use it as a reason not to support him. She's right in the sense that when it comes to affordability, New York governments' addiction to high spending and taxing already are major causes. Trickle-down pain City and state regulations also amount to a mountain of expensive red tape that discourage construction as well as business and job creation. Advertisement Her congestion tax is a good example of the trickle-down impact. The price of every loaf of bread, bottle of beer and bag of potato chips sold in Midtown now includes a portion of the added tax she slapped on delivery trucks. Meanwhile, the state's enormous budget reflects the way the government mafia grabs a piece of every action. Albany is now spending $254 billion this year, more than $100 billion more than it spent a decade ago. Florida has millions of more people than New York, but somehow manages to make do with spending $117 billion. That's almost identical to the city's budget alone, which is $116 billion this year, up from $75 billion over the last decade. These exploding expense budgets do not include the numerous 'off-the-books' entities such as the MTA, public colleges and universities, the Dormitory Authority and scores of other lesser-known units that spend multiple billions of dollars they collect from the public. Just remember: As bad as things are, they can always get worse. And if Mamdani is elected, everything definitely would get worse.
New York Post
11 minutes ago
- New York Post
DHS Secretary Kristi Noem unveils plans for new migrant detention space in Indiana: ‘The Speedway Slammer'
The Trump administration is collaborating with Indiana to expand capacity at a state correctional facility in order to hold illegal migrants, Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem announced Tuesday – dubbing the new wing of the prison, 'The Speedway Slammer.' 'Today, we're announcing a new partnership with the state of Indiana to expand detention bed space by 1,000 beds,' Noem wrote on X. 'Thanks to [Indiana Gov. Mike Braun] for his partnership to help remove the worst of the worst out of our country.' 'If you are in America illegally, you could find yourself in Indiana's Speedway Slammer.' Advertisement 3 Noem indicated that Indiana's 'Speedway Slammer' would be opening 'soon.' AP The name is a nod to Indiana's auto racing culture, particularly the famous Indianapolis Motor Speedway, which is located about 75 miles south of the new detention space at the Miami Correctional Facility. Braun, a former Republican US senator, announced on Aug.1 that Indiana would 'fully partner with federal immigration authorities' to assist President Trump carry out mass deportations. Advertisement As part of the partnership, the Indiana Department of Correction would work with Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) to make available up to 1,000 beds at Miami Correctional Facility, near Bunker Hill, Ind., and the Grissom Joint Air Reserve Base, to house migrants slated for deportation, Braun said. Camp Atterbury – operated by the Indiana National Guard – will also be made available for temporary use by DHS to house illegal migrants subject to deportation, according to the governor. 'We are proud to work with President Trump and Secretary Noem as they remove the worst of the worst with this innovative partnership,' Braun said in a statement. 'Indiana is taking a comprehensive and collaborative approach to combating illegal immigration and will continue to lead the way among states,' he added. Advertisement 3 Braun said the facility would house 'the worst of the worst' migrants. Getty Images 3 The state-run Miami Correctional Facility will add 1,000 beds to house detained illegal migrants. Miami Correctional DHS noted the agreement was 'fully funded' by the One Big Beautiful Bill Act Trump signed into law on July 4, which authorized spending for 80,000 new beds for ICE to utilize when detaining and deporting migrants. Indiana's 'Speedway Slammer' follows the opening of Florida's 'Alligator Alcatraz' earlier this summer to assist the Trump administration's deportation efforts. Advertisement Republican Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis opened the swampland facility, located deep in the Everglades and on the site of an old airport, on July 3. The property, outfitted with tent structures to house the illegal migrants, has the capacity for 2,000 detainees but will eventually hold 4,000. The Trump administration began deporting migrants directly from the Alligator Alcatraz airport, which is able to accept commercial-sized aircraft and conduct both day and nighttime operations, on July 25.
