Why an Aussie mine worker was PAID $20,000 after he was accused of speeding in a company car
Irfan Shaik was fired on Christmas Eve over the claim he had misused the company car while travelling between North and South Kestrel Mine in Emerald, Queensland, in 2024.
Mr Shaik had been earning $146,000 for his job as an IT contractor with Field Solutions Group (FSG) at the mine.
However, he contested the firing and took the matter to the Fair Work Commission for a verdict, reported The Courier Mail.
The commission sided with Mr Shaik after noting there was no credible evidence provided that he had ever unlawfully used his company car.
Fair Work Commission deputy president Nicholas Lake awarded Mr Shaik $22,461 - or two months worth of his pay - as the decision was handed down on Tuesday.
Mr Shaik was also told he had the option to seek reinstatement but he chose not to.
Mr Lake said there was no credible reason for the company to have dismissed its employee, based on the commission's findings.
No representation from FSG was available to appear at the May 8 hearing because the company went into receivership in February.
Mr Shaik represented himself.
FSG had previously insisted Mr Shaik was fired over 'serious misconduct' allegations and claimed he had even admitted to these breaches during a recorded interview.
This recording was not supplied to the Fair Work Commission and Mr Shaik 'vehemently' denied ever having admitted to doing so.
He learned of his dismissal via a letter which was delivered to him on December 24.
The letter included Mr Shaik's alleged history of warnings in a timeline which his employer said was a justification for his dismissal.
FSG claimed it had its operations manager discuss alleged unlawful use of the company car in July 2023.
Mr Shaik was stood down on 'gardening leave' after receiving a complaint in October before he was fired just over a month later.
Mr Shaik repeatedly denied FSG's claims and insisted they were 'completely unfounded'.
In a written response to the tribunal he claimed to have only been 'advised' to slow down on highways in August 2023.
The tribunal eventually sided with the sacked worker and he was awarded two months pay plus superannuation to be paid within 21 days of the judgement.
Mr Shaik had previously been earning $12,135 per month for 164 ordinary hours.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
18 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Learned Behaviours by Zeynab Gamieldien review – murder mystery probes privilege and class politics
Interrogating your privilege can be a divisive, somewhat uncomfortable endeavour – but the way it underpins everyday lives makes for great fiction. It's a topic that has been explored via familial relationships in Brit Bennett's The Vanishing Half, through the employer-employee dynamic in Kiley Reid's Such a Fun Age, and in a schoolgirl narrative in Alice Pung's teen novel Laurinda. Australian author Zeynab Gamieldien's second book, Learned Behaviours, also tackles the issue, via a murder mystery: a searing look at how the intersections of race, class and gender can affect the trajectory of a person's life, even when they no longer seem consequential. It follows Zaid, a prospective barrister who has made considerable efforts to shed his past in a diverse outer part of Sydney known to locals as The Area, which he describes as a 'broad collection of western Sydney suburbs with Canterbury-Bankstown at its heart'. He has travelled overseas, lived in London, drives a Mercedes, and works a job that sees him socialise with the wealthier and whiter north shore and eastern suburbs types on weekends. There he 'assume[s] the role of informant' on the quirks of his past life; it's a currency he trades off in his new world. Sign up for the fun stuff with our rundown of must-reads, pop culture and tips for the weekend, every Saturday morning That past comes back to him in the form of Amira, the sister of his high school best friend, Hass, who killed himself after being arrested for the murder of a female friend in their final year of school. Amira has found Hass's diary and asks Zaid to read it, convinced her brother might have been innocent. Her request draws Zaid back in time to confront painful memories, make rattling revelations and square up to his own role in his friend's death. Told between his high-school past and the present, Learned Behaviours isn't a typical murder mystery. Fans of true crime and meticulously plotted crime fiction might find the ending lacks the kind of detail that provides closure; they might even scoff at the possibility that the police bungled the investigation so spectacularly. But this book is not about a clean finish or plausibility (I could never imagine the boys I know from The Area keeping a diary, for example). In it, the intricacies of the murder investigation take a back seat to the bigger themes of belonging, upward social mobility and wrangling a past that weighs heavy on your present – not just in Zaid's case, but in that of his father, Tapey, who is constantly dwelling on the injustices he experienced in District 6 in apartheid South Africa. Gamieldien has done an excellent job of interrogating privilege without being sententious or didactic. It's in the cost of Zaid's barrister training, which he feels more than his moneyed colleagues; it's in the bills piling up in his father's home, and Tapey's reticence to seek compensation for the wrongs done against him; it's in his sister Iman's struggle to leave an abusive relationship in London and return home with a young child in tow. Despite appearances, Zaid knows he has not really 'made it'; he's perpetually on the outer edge of his colleagues' orbit, lacking the fancy school connections that are traded for favours in the workplace, and the weekends away at coastal second homes. Like Gamieldien's debut, The Scope of Permissibility – which explored the push-pull of faith and desire – Learned Behaviours explores social codes and what happens when they are broken. Zaid's inability to swim is a motif, representing how the stark disparity between social classes is experienced on even the most mundane levels. Zaid does his best to rectify it, and the novel is littered with scenes where he plunges himself into bodies of water, hoping for a shift. Sign up to Saved for Later Catch up on the fun stuff with Guardian Australia's culture and lifestyle rundown of pop culture, trends and tips after newsletter promotion Early on in the story, Zaid realises that ''making it' is not synonymous with movement', and that social climbing does not ensure success or belonging. As he ventures back to The Area more frequently – to continue visiting his father, yes, but also to spend more time with Amira – Zaid begins to recognise that getting out of The Area doesn't mean escaping it. Learned Behaviours is a pacy, compelling and immersive narrative that deftly tackles a weighty topic. It's understated but sophisticated, with more than one tragedy at its heart: a murder, yes, but also a necessary reminder that some people can 'afford missteps … requiring only a single step to get back on course', while others need to tread more carefully, or risk being derailed for ever. Learned Behaviours by Zeynab Gamieldien is out through Ultimo Press, $34.99
The Guardian
18 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Pari just wants to get a good night's sleep – but each morning he's woken by NSW police, telling him to move on
Pari Nikau was woken by being hit in the face with a shovel. He'd been sleeping in a shed on a rooftop near Sydney's CBD and he thought he was safe. He remembers playing dead, then blackness. Hours later, he woke at St Vincent's hospital, where his head was being stapled. Two weeks after the 16 June assault, Nikau was told he was being discharged. 'I said 'I don't have money, I'm homeless',' says Nikau, who doesn't qualify for housing assistance from the government as he is from New Zealand and is not an Australian citizen. 'The hospital shouldn't have let me out unless they knew I'd be cared for.' Sign up: AU Breaking News email Nikau briefly moved to a centre that provides accommodation and healthcare to homeless people, before losing that spot. Now Nikau is among a group of rough sleepers at Sydney's Central Station struggling with changing rules. Earlier this month, after a string of increasingly restrictive rules, they were told to move from a sheltered area between 6am until midnight. 'I was in pain, I moved [to Central Station] because I need to sleep,' Nikau says. 'And every time I do, they come over and yell at me to move on. I'm over having to repack. I can't start again.' Since the latest change, Nikau and his friends have moved from the light rail stop to a partially covered area out of the way of passengers. They're still woken at 6am, but they can return once the morning peak hour is over. But there's nowhere to sit, forcing them to huddle on the floor, exposed to the elements. Nikau still has his arm in a cast and is still recovering from multiple wounds. Amanda, who did not want her surname publish, also doesn't qualify for housing assistance as she's American, has been sleeping at the station for two-and-a-half years. She says Transport for NSW told her the rules had changed due to the 'flow of commuters' and 'inconveniencing passengers'. 'We said 'we commuters as well, I take the train multiple times a day',' says Amanda. 'This train station is publicly funded, so why aren't we allowed to stay here?' Amanda still stays on the benches near the light rail stop – she has back problems and needs seating. She keeps her belongings tidy: a few suitcases, some backpacks covered in plastic sheeting. So far, she hasn't been reprimanded, but she says the police treat them 'like we're children'. 'They wake us up like it's a school day,' she says. 'How are we inconveniencing people when we're not in the way of traffic? It's ridiculous.' A NSW police spokesperson says officers can issue move on directions if a person is causing, or is likely to cause, inconvenience to other people on railway premises. 'Failure to comply with a move on direction can result in a fine or removal from the premises. 'Being homeless is not an offence, and NSW Police will continue to work with the community and help homeless people make contact with appropriate services if needed.' Kylie Emery, who has been sleeping at Central Station while grappling with complex trauma and PTSD, has been looking out for Nikau. She's been recovering from the 'worst flu of [her] life'. 'We can't use the benches because they say we're disrupting commuters, so I've been sleeping in wet clothes in the pouring rain,' she says. Transport for NSW has recently begun confiscating or disposing of belongings left unattended. Last month, an unattributed poster warned homeless people at Central Station to remove their belongings or they would be 'disposed of', which a spokesperson for Transport for NSW says was a directive from NSW police. 'People looking for their items are referred to the station office where they are assisted,' they say. 'If unattended belongings are moved, they are able to be collected. Sydney Trains will hold belongings for at least 24 hours.' Stephen Devine, who has been staying near the light rail stop for the past few weeks, has been helping to guard his friends' belongings. He says one elderly woman went to get hand surgery last Friday, and stayed in hospital overnight. The next morning, all her things were taken. Although she was able to recover her things, he worried that if she had come back a day later, her belongings would have been binned – something he says he has seen happen to other people. Sign up to Breaking News Australia Get the most important news as it breaks after newsletter promotion Nikau also found his items had been taken when he returned from the smoking area. After asking a number of people, he found his belongings next to some rubbish bins. Kira Levin, a solicitor at the Justice and Equity Centre says police can only move people on in public areas in accordance with the Law Enforcement (Powers and Responsibilities) Act, which covers instances where people are obstructing persons or traffic. She says authorised officers can also remove property if it's unattended, but there's also a specific protocol for homeless people in public spaces – which requires that notice be given. She says the poster was 'not appropriate and not clear' as it didn't specify who was giving the order. 'Creating this confusion is really not helpful.' Levin says instead of police instructing the homeless people to move on, they should talk to them and find out 'why there are a growing number of people sleeping there'. 'Where are people supposed to go is my question,' she says. 'There's a limited number of places in Sydney where there's shelter and CCTV.' According to a state government count, the number of rough sleepers has grown by nearly 70% in five years, from 1,314 in 2020 to 2,192 in 2025. Levin says many have difficulty finding temporary accommodation or social housing, as they can lack identification, be unable to pay or may not be a permanent resident. 'You need to engage with people in a way that's trauma informed, explaining what's happening, and giving options about where they're supposed to go,' she says. The NSW minister for homelessness, Rose Jackson, says she is 'absolutely concerned about the situation at Central Station'. 'No one should be forced to live rough. It's not safe, it's not dignified, and we have a responsibility to do better,' she says. 'We've already surged services in the area to connect people with support, accommodation and long-term housing pathways.' Jackson says the state government has provided the largest investment in homelessness services in NSW history, including a $6.6bn Building Homes for NSW program, focused on social housing and homelessness support. 'We know the system hasn't worked. But we are rebuilding it,' she says. 'People experiencing homelessness are not problems to be managed.' For Nikau, all he wants is a place to rest and recuperate. 'I'm constantly scared to sleep,' he says. 'Where is the compassion? I don't get the support a lot of other people do, but I always want to help others. I'll give someone my spare shoes. But people just ignore us.' With additional reporting by Luca Ittimani
The Guardian
18 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Sydney and Toronto had equivalent home prices, then Canada's crashed. Could Australia see a similar slump?
At the start of 2022, the typical house in Australia and Canada was worth about $840,000 in each country's local currency. Australian city prices have climbed by about A$85,000 over the subsequent three years, while Canadian prices have crashed by C$150,000, leaving the median Canadian home nearly 20% cheaper. The Canadian correction has raised questions over whether properties in Australia, economically comparable to its Commonwealth comrade, could face a similar selldown. Borrowers in both countries enjoyed low interest rates in 2020 and 2021, driving up prices. Australia's most expensive city, Sydney, saw median values surge A$250,000 from 2020 to early 2022, reaching nearly A$1.2m. Overheated demand drove prices far higher in Toronto, Canada's biggest city, up by A$400,000 to a peak of C$1.3m over the same period, according to the Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA). Canada's central bank responded by ratcheting up interest rates while the government banned foreign buyers and curbed immigration, sending prices into freefall. Toronto's median price fell below C$1.1m and is yet to recover. Toronto's pandemic buying boom saw home sales surge in 2021 then halve by 2023 as high numbers of homes arrived on the market simultaneously, further dragging down prices. Demand slumped further as locals fled Toronto for more affordable towns with the advent of remote work. Sign up: AU Breaking News email Tyson Erlick's landlord clients at Property Management Toronto had been excited by surging home prices back in 2021. One investor paid C$1m for a sub-50 square metre flat in downtown Toronto's Yorkville neighbourhood that's now worth about C$700,000. 'We're seeing a lot of landlords panic,' Erlick said. 'You're now looking at a mega loss.' Sydney endured a brief slump but resumed its upward climb by early 2023, with rents and home prices rising as a growing population grappled with a shortage of homes. Rents in Toronto, already constrained by local government rent caps, have fallen on average since 2023. Homebuyers are taking out smaller mortgages on houses and apartments, or condominiums, as they're called in Canada. Greater Toronto resident Dave, who lives 70km from the city centre, bought a condo for a $100,000 discount in July 2024 after the previous owners struggled to sell. 'There are so many condominiums that they can't sell,' said Dave, who asked for his surname not to be shared. 'We were lucky.' The improved affordability in Canada has raised the prospect a similar slump could happen in Australia. Both countries saw a rare nationwide price drop when interest rate hikes in 2022 limited borrowing power, though Australians faced slower and smaller rate increases. Along with surging migration and strong job creation, smaller rate hikes kept Australian prices from falling more than 10%, according to Eliza Owen, head of research at property data firm Cotality. 'As long as Australians can keep paying their mortgage and they don't have to sell, that will always restrict supply [and] limit the amount that property values can fall,' she said. Australian home values have kept rising through 2025, up 3.7% in the year to July according to Cotality, and Commonwealth Bank analysts predict that pace will reach 6% by December. Sign up to Breaking News Australia Get the most important news as it breaks after newsletter promotion An economic shock and blowout in the unemployment rate would be a direct but damaging way for that momentum to reverse, Owen said. 'That technically would make housing cheaper, but it doesn't necessarily make housing more affordable if a crash is coming alongside severe economic downturn [and] people really can't afford to buy,' she said. Donald Trump's tariff threats, for example, have prolonged Canada's crash by pushing more Canadians out of work, leaving buyers without incomes and unable to pay off their mortgages. Data released at the end of July showed Canada's economic activity had fallen for two consecutive months as it grappled with US trade chaos. The same day, Trump lifted tariff rates on Canadian goods from 25% to 35%. The number of unemployed Canadians reached 1.6 million and the national unemployment rate climbed to 7% in May, from 5% in early 2023. The share of Canadians more than 90 days behind on mortgage repayments remains small but has doubled since 2022, much faster than in Australia. Tariffs have had a muted impact on the Australian economy, where the jobs market remains robust, unemployment has only risen to 4.3% and mortgage arrears remain at modest levels. While Sydney's unemployment rate remains low, at 4.5%, Toronto's is nearly than double that, approaching 9%, leaving fewer locals with the incomes to take advantage of a slight improvement on the city's still-unaffordable homes, according to the renters advocate Bruno Dobrusin. 'The vast majority are still struggling with increasing rents, without the capacity to benefit from the slowdown of home prices,' said Dobrusin, organiser at the York South-Weston neighbourhood's tenant union. Housing in both countries is already too far out of reach for price corrections to help affordability, according to Carolyn Whitzman, a housing researcher and adjunct professor at the University of Toronto. 'It is nice to see a little bit of a correction in what has been such a steady and frightening upward climb,' said Whitzman, who has lived in Toronto and Melbourne. '[But] if a house is 300% too expensive, and goes down by 20%, it still isn't going to help you.' Economists do not expect a near-term slump in Australian house prices, which are accelerating amid rate cuts and supply shortages. While Canada's temporary price correction will not solve its affordability, it should remind Australians real estate is not immune to a drop, Whitzman said. 'Both Australia and Canada started to believe that it was impossible that house prices ever fall [but] at some point house prices have to fall,' Whitzman said.
