Lesbian group's new fight over trans call
Back in 2023, the Lesbian Action Group sought an five-year exemption of the Sexual Discrimination Act to hold regular 'lesbians born female only' social events.
'This exemption is absolutely necessary to enable lesbians to once again advertise our events in order to once again meet publicly without fear of litigation or discrimination,' the group said.
But the Human Rights Commission rejected their permit, finding while it would be lawful for them to ban men and heterosexual women from events, they could not discriminate against transgender lesbian women.
'The Commission is not persuaded it is appropriate and reasonable to make distinctions between women based on their biological sex at birth or transgender experience, and to exclude transgender lesbians, from a community event of this kind,' the Commission said.
The Lesbian Action Group appealed, and lost, at the Administrative Appeals Tribunal and has now challenged that decision in the Federal Court of Australia.
The case was called on for a case management hearing on Friday morning as the group's barrister, Leigh Howard, applied for the case to be heard by a full bench of the court rather than a single judge.
The court was told the Lesbian Action Group wanted the case decided by the 'same bench' set to hear an appeal against the landmark Roxanne Tickle v Giggle for Girls ruling in August.
Mr Howard said having the same judges hear their appeal would save the court's time as they would have a deep understanding of the relevant law.
'It's going to help dispose the appeal in a timely manner,' he said.
'Otherwise it will take a lot longer to run the case.'
Last year, Roxanne Tickle successfully sued the Giggle for Girls online application, arguing it had discriminated against her based on her identity as a transgender woman.
The Giggle App is marketed as a 'digital women-only safe space' and Ms Tickle was blocked from using the app in late 2021.
Justice Robert Bromwich found Giggle had indirectly discriminated against Ms Tickle because the company's chief executive Sall Grover believed she appeared to be a man.
Justice Mark Moshinsky told the court a decision on whether the case could be assigned to the same bench was a matter for the Chief Justice, but a decision would likely be made in the coming days.
Mr Howard said the Lesbian Action Group had considered seeking to join the Giggle v Tickle proceedings due to 'common ambition' but decided that case was complicated enough.
He told the court Justice Bromwich's 'construction of sex' and meaning of gender identity had impacted the adverse findings against the Lesbian Action Group in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.
'Taking into account all the issues we can't see how the Administrative Appeals Tribunal came to the decision it made,' he said.
'If we're not give this opportunity we again lose our opportunity to run our construction of the (Sexual Discrimination) Act.'
The case was adjourned to a date yet to be fixed.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBS News
a day ago
- CBS News
Wisconsin elections officials find clerk broke laws over uncounted ballots
Wisconsin elections officials declared Thursday that the former clerk of the state's capital city broke several laws related to not counting nearly 200 absentee ballots in the November presidential election, but they stopped short of recommending criminal charges be brought. The bipartisan Wisconsin Elections Commission voted 5-1 to accept a report finding that the former Madison clerk broke five election laws. The commission delayed a vote on ordering the city of Madison to take additional steps to improve election security. No outcome of any race was affected by the missing ballots. Maribeth Witzel-Behl resigned as Madison city clerk in April amid investigations into the missing ballots. The investigation was not a criminal probe and the elections commission does not have the power to bring charges. The report does not recommend that prosecutors do so. There is no intention to refer the case to prosecutors for possible charges, commission chair Ann Jacobs said after the meeting. The goal of the probe was to find out what happened and stop it from happening again, she added. Charges could be brought by the Dane County attorney's office or the state Department of Justice. Dane County District Attorney Ismael Ozanne said his office would review the case if it received a referral. DOJ spokesperson Riley Vetterkind did not immediately respond to an email seeking comment. Commissioners said they were shocked at how the Madison clerk handled the missing ballots. The investigation determined that two bags of uncounted absentee ballots likely never made it to the poll sites where they should have been counted. The clerk's office did not notify the elections commission of the oversight until Dec. 18, almost a month and a half after the election and well after results were certified on Nov. 29. Jacobs, a Democrat, called the incident a "rather shocking dereliction of just ordinary responsibility." Republican Commissioner Bob Spindell, who cast the lone vote against accepting the report, said he blamed the problem on an extremely complicated system in the clerk's office and poor management. "It's not something I think the clerk should be crucified for," he said. The elections commission report concluded that the former clerk broke state law for failing to properly supervise an election; not providing the most recent current registration information for pollbooks in two wards; improperly handing the return of absentee ballots; not properly canvassing the returns as it pertained to the 193 uncounted ballots; and failing to provide sufficient information for the municipal board of canvassers to do its work. The report blamed a "confluence of errors" and said that Madison did not have procedures in place to track the number of absentee ballots going to a polling place. It also said there was a "complete lack of leadership" in the clerk's office. "These are mistakes that could have been avoided," said Republican commissioner Don Millis. Madison city attorney and interim clerk Michael Haas said the city did not contest the findings of the report. "The most important asset we have is the trust of the voters and that requires complete transparency and open coordination with partners when mistakes happen," Haas said in testimony submitted to the commission. "That did not happen in this case." Madison has already implemented numerous safeguards and procedures that were in place for elections earlier this year to ensure that all eligible absentee ballots are accounted for, Haas said. The recommendations in the report for further actions exceed what is required under state law and are not within the authority of the commission to order, Hass testified. He urged the commission to delay a vote. The commission voted unanimously to give Madison until Aug. 7 to respond before voting a week later on whether to order additional steps to be taken. Four voters whose ballots weren't counted have filed claims for $175,000 each, the first step toward a class-action lawsuit. Their attorney attended Thursday's hearing but did not testify.
Washington Post
a day ago
- Washington Post
Wisconsin elections officials find clerk broke laws over uncounted ballots
MADISON, Wis . — Wisconsin elections officials declared Thursday that the former clerk of the state's capital city broke several laws related to not counting nearly 200 absentee ballots in the November presidential election, but they stopped short of recommending criminal charges be brought. The bipartisan Wisconsin Elections Commission voted 5-1 to accept a report finding that the former Madison clerk broke five election laws. The commission delayed a vote on ordering the city of Madison to take additional steps to improve election security. No outcome of any race was affected by the missing ballots. Maribeth Witzel-Behl resigned as Madison city clerk in April amid investigations into the missing ballots. The investigation was not a criminal probe and the elections commission does not have the power to bring charges. The report does not recommend that prosecutors do so. There is no intention to refer the case to prosecutors for possible charges, commission chair Ann Jacobs said after the meeting. The goal of the probe was to find out what happened and stop it from happening again, she added. Charges could be brought by the Dane County attorney's office or the state Department of Justice. Dane County District Attorney Ismael Ozanne said his office would review the case if it received a referral. DOJ spokesperson Riley Vetterkind did not immediately respond to an email seeking comment. Commissioners said they were shocked at how the Madison clerk handled the missing ballots. The investigation determined that two bags of uncounted absentee ballots likely never made it to the poll sites where they should have been counted. The clerk's office did not notify the elections commission of the oversight until Dec. 18, almost a month and a half after the election and well after results were certified on Nov. 29. Jacobs, a Democrat, called the incident a 'rather shocking dereliction of just ordinary responsibility.' Republican Commissioner Bob Spindell, who cast the lone vote against accepting the report, said he blamed the problem on an extremely complicated system in the clerk's office and poor management. 'It's not something I think the clerk should be crucified for,' he said. The elections commission report concluded that the former clerk broke state law for failing to properly supervise an election; not providing the most recent current registration information for pollbooks in two wards; improperly handing the return of absentee ballots; not properly canvassing the returns as it pertained to the 193 uncounted ballots; and failing to provide sufficient information for the municipal board of canvassers to do its work. The report blamed a 'confluence of errors' and said that Madison did not have procedures in place to track the number of absentee ballots going to a polling place. It also said there was a 'complete lack of leadership' in the clerk's office. 'These are mistakes that could have been avoided,' said Republican commissioner Don Millis. Madison city attorney and interim clerk Michael Haas said the city did not contest the findings of the report. 'The most important asset we have is the trust of the voters and that requires complete transparency and open coordination with partners when mistakes happen,' Haas said in testimony submitted to the commission. 'That did not happen in this case.' Madison has already implemented numerous safeguards and procedures that were in place for elections earlier this year to ensure that all eligible absentee ballots are accounted for, Haas said. The recommendations in the report for further actions exceed what is required under state law and are not within the authority of the commission to order, Hass testified. He urged the commission to delay a vote. The commission voted unanimously to give Madison until Aug. 7 to respond before voting a week later on whether to order additional steps to be taken. Four voters whose ballots weren't counted have filed claims for $175,000 each, the first step toward a class-action lawsuit. Their attorney attended Thursday's hearing but did not testify.
Associated Press
a day ago
- Associated Press
Wisconsin elections officials find clerk broke laws over uncounted ballots
MADISON, Wis . (AP) — Wisconsin elections officials declared Thursday that the former clerk of the state's capital city broke several laws related to not counting nearly 200 absentee ballots in the November presidential election, but they stopped short of recommending that criminal charges be brought. The bipartisan Wisconsin Elections Commission voted 5-1 to accept a report finding that the former Madison clerk broke five election laws. But the investigation was not a criminal probe and the commission does not have the power to bring charges. The report does not recommend that prosecutors do so. Charges could be brought by the Dane County attorney's office or the state Department of Justice. Dane County District Attorney Ismael Ozanne said his office had not received a referral, but if it did it would review it. DOJ spokesperson Riley Vetterkind did not immediately respond to an email seeking comment on whether it would be bringing charges. No outcome of any race was affected by the missing ballots. Maribeth Witzel-Behl resigned as Madison city clerk in April amid investigations into the missing ballots. Wisconsin Elections Commission Chair Ann Jacobs, a Democrat, called the incident a 'rather shocking dereliction of just ordinary responsibility.' Republican Commissioner Bob Spindell, who cast the lone vote against accepting the report, said he blamed the problem on an extremely complicated system in the clerk's office and poor management. 'It's not something I think the clerk should be crucified for,' he said. The investigation determined that two bags of uncounted absentee ballots likely never made it to the poll sites where they should have been counted. 'There was just no tracking of these absentee ballots,' Jacobs said. The clerk's office did not notify the Wisconsin Elections Commission of the oversight until Dec. 18, almost a month and a half after the election and well after results were certified on Nov. 29. The elections commission report concluded that the former clerk broke state law for failing to properly supervise an election; not providing the most recent current registration information for pollbooks in two wards; improperly handing the return of absentee ballots; not properly canvassing the returns as it pertained to the 193 uncounted ballots; and failing to provide sufficient information for the municipal board of canvassers to do its work. The report blamed a 'confluence of errors' and said that Madison did not have procedures in place to track the number of absentee ballots going to a polling place. It also said there was a 'complete lack of leadership' in the clerk's office. 'These are mistakes that could have been avoided,' said Republican commissioner Don Millis. Madison city attorney and interim clerk Michael Haas said the city did not contest the findings of the report. 'The most important asset we have is the trust of the voters and that requires complete transparency and open coordination with partners when mistakes happen,' Haas said in testimony submitted to the commission. 'That did not happen in this case.' Madison has already implemented numerous safeguards and procedures that were in place for elections earlier this year to ensure that all eligible absentee ballots are accounted for, Haas said. The recommendations in the report for further actions exceed what is required under state law and are not within the authority of the commission to order, Hass testified. He urged the commission to delay a vote. The commission voted unanimously to give Madison until Aug. 7 to respond before voting a week later on whether to order additional steps to be taken. Four voters whose ballots weren't counted have filed claims for $175,000 each, the first step toward a class-action lawsuit. Their attorney attended Thursday's hearing but did not testify.
