US President Donald Trump fires labour statistics official over jobs numbers
Photo:
AFP / MICHAEL M. SANTIAGO
By
Kit Maher
,
Matt Egan
and
Alicia Wallace
, CNN
President Donald Trump has fired Dr Erika McEntarfer, the commissioner of the Bureau of Labor Statistics, whom he accused, without evidence, of manipulating the monthly jobs reports for "political purposes".
The BLS' monthly labour report Friday (US time) showed that the US economy added only 73,000 jobs in July, far below expectations. It also sharply revised down the employment growth that had been previously reported in May and June - by a combined 258,000 jobs.
After the revisions, the jobs report showed the weakest pace of hiring for any three-month period since the pandemic recession in 2020.
"In my opinion, today's Jobs Numbers were RIGGED in order to make the Republicans, and ME, look bad," Trump said in a Truth Social post.
Although the May and June jobs numbers were worse than initially believed, revisions are normal in this process. The BLS' initial monthly jobs estimates are often based on incomplete data, so they are revised twice after the initial report - followed by an annual revision every February.
Additionally, BLS economists use a formula to smooth out jobs numbers for seasonal variations and that can exacerbate revisions, when they fall outside economists' expectations.
On Friday, Trump incorrectly called the revisions a "mistake".
"McEntarfer said there were only 73,000 Jobs added (a shock!) but, more importantly, that a major mistake was made by them, 258,000 Jobs downward, in the prior two months," Trump said on Truth Social.
"Similar things happened in the first part of the year, always to the negative. The Economy is BOOMING under 'TRUMP'."
Trump said McEntarfer "faked" the jobs numbers before the election to try to boost former Vice President Kamala Harris' chances in the 2024 presidential election.
"We're doing so well. I believe the numbers were phony, just like they were before the election, and there were other times. So, you know what I did? I fired her, and you know what? I did the right thing," Trump told reporters Friday on the South Lawn.
Trump has also threatened the firing of Federal Reserve Chaie Jerome Powell.
Photo:
AFP
McEntarfer was confirmed by the Senate 86-8 in January 2024 for a term of four years.
CNN has reached out to McEntarfer for comment.
Until Trump replaces McEntarfer, Deputy Commissioner William Wiatrowski will serve as Acting Commissioner, the administration said.
Trump has previously criticised the BLS for its jobs data and revisions, and he told reporters Friday evening he's "always had a problem with these numbers".
In 2016, during his first presidential campaign, Trump claimed that the unemployment rate was significantly higher than the BLS let on. In 2024, he accused former President Joe Biden's administration of orchestrating a cover-up, after the BLS reported that it had overcounted jobs by 818,000 over the previous 12 months.
"I was thinking about it this morning, before the numbers that came out. I said, 'Who is the person that does these numbers?' And then they gave me stats about before the election," Trump said.
"We need people that we can trust," he added.
Trump and his administration have also praised the BLS data when it has been favourable to them. During Trump's first term, former White House Press Secretary Sean Spicer said, in March 2017, that the jobs data was no longer "phony", after the BLS issued a strong jobs report.
A month ago, current White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt posted on social media that the economy had beaten expectations for jobs in four straight BLS labour reports.
The BLS is nonpartisan, and businesses and government officials rely on the accuracy of its data to make determinations about investment, hiring, spending and all sorts of key decisions.
"It's outrageous for anyone in government to question the integrity of the BLS," said Jason Furman, a Harvard professor and former Obama economic adviser.
"Accurate statistics are essential to the economy."
Furman doubted that replacing McEntarfer would compromise the BLS, but he said even the possibility or appearance of that notion "would be bad".
"Countries that have tried to fake those statistics have often ended up with economic crises as a result," Furman said.
Mark Zandi, chief economist at Moody's Analytics, said the BLS data is at the "highest standard", and "as accurate as it can be".
"Anything that undermines that or even the perception of that high standard is deeply worrisome," Zandi said. "I've never seen anything even close to this."
At Moody's, Zandi said he has hired a number of former BLS economists, whom he called "fantastic".
"They do great work," Zandi said. "They are critical to a well-functioning economy."
Democratic Virginia Senator Mark Warner accused Trump of working the referees.
"Firing the ump doesn't change the score," Warner said in a statement. "Americans deserve to know the truth about the state of the Trump economy."
Labor Secretary Lori Chavez-DeRemer said she supported replacing McEntarfer.
"A recent string of major revisions have come to light and raised concerns about decisions being made by the Biden-appointed Labor Commissioner," Chavez-DeRemer said on X. "I support the President's decision to replace Biden's Commissioner, and ensure the American People can trust the important and influential data coming from BLS."
The BLS jobs survey is widely considered by economists to be robust. It samples more than 100,000 businesses and government agencies each month, representing roughly 629,000 individual worksites.
As part of larger cost-cutting taking place around practically every part of Trump's government, the BLS is laying off staff and, as a result, reducing the scope of its work.
For example, the BLS posted a notice in June stating it stopped collecting data for its Consumer Price Index in three cities - Lincoln, Nebraska; Buffalo, New York; and Provo, Utah - and increased "imputations" for certain items - a statistical technique that, when boiled down to very rough terms, essentially means more educated guesses.
That worried Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell. In testimony before Congress in June, Powell said he believed the BLS data to be accurate, but he was upset about what could become a trend.
"I wouldn't say that I'm concerned about the data today, although there has been a very mild degradation of the scope of the surveys," Powell said at the time, in response to a question about survey data quality. "I would say the direction of travel is something I'm concerned about."
-
CNN
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Higher US tariffs kick in for dozens of trading partners
By Beiyi Seow Donald Trump holds a signed executive order after delivering remarks on reciprocal tariffs during an event in the Rose Garden entitled "Make America Wealthy Again" at the White House in Washington, DC, on 2 April, 2025. Photo: AFP The United States has begun charging higher tariffs on goods from dozens of trading partners, in a major escalation of President Donald Trump's drive to reshape global commerce in America's favour. Shortly before the new levies kicked in, Washington separately announced it would double Indian tariffs to 50 percent and hit many semiconductor imports from around the world with a 100-percent levy. As an executive order signed last week by Trump took effect, US import duties rose from 10 percent to levels between 15 percent and 41 percent for a list of trading partners. Many imports from economies including the European Union, Japan and South Korea now face a 15-percent tariff, even with deals struck with Washington to avert steeper threatened levies. But others like India face a 25 percent duty - to be doubled in three weeks to 50 percent - while Syria, Myanmar and Laos face staggering levels at either 40 percent or 41 percent. Switzerland's government, which failed to convince Trump not to impose a stinging 39 percent tariff, was set to hold an extraordinary meeting later on Thursday (local time). Taking to his Truth Social platform just after midnight, Trump posted: "IT'S MIDNIGHT!!! BILLIONS OF DOLLARS IN TARIFFS ARE NOW FLOWING INTO THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA!" The latest wave of "reciprocal" duties, aimed at addressing trade practices Washington deems unfair, broadens the measures Trump has imposed since returning to the presidency. On the eve of his latest salvo, he doubled planned duties on Indian goods to 50 percent, citing New Delhi's continued purchase of Russian oil. The new levy - up from 25 percent now - would take effect in three weeks. The Federation of Indian Export Organisations called the move a "severe setback for Indian exports, with nearly 55 percent of our shipments to the US market directly affected." For New Delhi, one of the main sticking points has been Washington's demand to access India's vast agricultural and dairy market. "We will not compromise with the interests of our farmers, our dairy sector, our fishermen," Prime Minister Narendra Modi said on Thursday. Trump's order also threatened penalties on other countries that "directly or indirectly" import Russian oil, a key revenue source for Moscow's war in Ukraine. Washington has already separately stuck tariffs on sector-specific imports such as steel, autos and pharmaceuticals. Trump said Wednesday he also planned an "approximately 100 percent tariff" on semiconductor imports, but with "no charge" for companies investing in the United States or committed to do so. Shares in Taiwanese chip-making giant TSMC surged as Taipei said it would be exempt, but some other Asian manufacturers took a beating. Companies and industry groups warn the new levies will severely hurt smaller American businesses, while economists caution that they could fuel inflation and hit growth. With the dust settling on countries' tariff levels, at least for now, Georgetown University professor Marc Busch expects US businesses to pass along more of the bill to consumers. An earlier 90-day pause in these higher "reciprocal" tariffs gave importers time to stock up, he said. But although the wait-and-see strategy led businesses to absorb more of the tariff burden initially, inventories are depleting and it is unlikely they will do this indefinitely, he told AFP. "With back-to-school shopping just weeks away, this will matter politically," said Busch, an international trade policy expert. The tariffs leave lingering questions for partners that have negotiated deals with Trump recently. Tokyo and Washington, for example, appear at odds over key details of their pact, in particular on when lower levies on Japanese cars will take place. Generally, US auto imports now face a 25-percent duty under a sector-specific order. Toyota has cut its full-year profit forecast by 14 percent because of the tariffs. Japan and the United States also appear to differ on whether the "reciprocal" tolls of 15 percent on other Japanese goods would be on top of existing levies or - like the EU - be capped at that level. China and the United States, meanwhile, currently have a shaky truce in their stand-off but that is due to expire on 12 August. Chinese exports to the United States tumbled 21.7 percent last month, official data showed, while those to the European Union jumped 9.2 percent and to Southeast Asia by 16.6 percent. The EU is seeking a carveout from tariffs for its key wine industry. In a recent industry letter addressed to Trump, the US Wine Trade Alliance and others urged the sector's exclusion from tolls, saying: "Wine sales account for up to 60 percent of gross margins of full-service restaurants." Trump has separately targeted Brazil over the trial of his right-wing ally, former president Jair Bolsonaro , who is accused of planning a coup. US tariffs on various Brazilian goods surged from 10 percent to 50 percent Wednesday, but broad exemptions including for orange juice and civil aircraft are seen as softening the blow. Still, key products like Brazilian coffee, beef and sugar are hit. - AFP
RNZ News
2 hours ago
- RNZ News
Trump-Putin meeting due in 'coming days', Kremlin says
The Kremlin says Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin could meet for a summit as soon as next week. Photo: AFP US President Donald Trump and Russian counterpart Vladimir Putin could meet for a summit as early as next week, the Kremlin says. The meeting would be the first between a sitting US and Russian president since Joe Biden met Putin in Geneva in June 2021, and comes as Trump seeks to broker an end to Russia's military assault on Ukraine. "At the suggestion of the American side, an agreement has been reached in principle to hold a bilateral summit in the coming days," Kremlin aide Yuri Ushakov was quoted as saying by Russian state news agencies. "We are now starting to work out the details together with our American colleagues," Ushakov added. "Next week has been set as a target date." Ushakov also said that the venue for the meeting "has been agreed upon in principle" but did not elaborate on where it would be held. The announcement comes a day after US envoy Steve Witkoff met Putin in Moscow. Witkoff proposed a trilateral meeting with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, but Russia did not respond to that proposal, Ushakov said. "The Russian side left this option completely without comment," he added. - AFP
1News
3 hours ago
- 1News
Trump's tariffs go into effect — just as economic pain is surfacing
President Donald Trump has officially begun levying higher import taxes on dozens of countries — just as the economic fallout of his months-long tariff threats has begun to create visible damage for the US economy. The White House said that starting just after midnight (4pm NZ Time) that goods from more than 60 countries and the European Union now faced tariff rates of 10% or higher. Products from the European Union, Japan, South Korea and New Zealand are taxed at 15%, while imports from Taiwan, Vietnam and Bangladesh are taxed at 20%. For places such as the EU, Japan and South Korea, Trump also expects them to invest hundreds of billions of dollars in the US. 'I think the growth is going to be unprecedented,' Trump said Wednesday afternoon (local time). He added that the US was 'taking in hundreds of billions of dollars in tariffs,' but he couldn't provide a specific figure for revenues because 'we don't even know what the final number is' regarding tariff rates. Despite the uncertainty, the Trump White House is confident that the onset of his broad tariffs will provide clarity about the path of the world's largest economy. Now that companies understand the direction the US is headed, the administration believes they can ramp up new investments and jump-start hiring in ways that can rebalance the US economy as a manufacturing power. But so far, there are signs of self-inflicted wounds to America as companies and consumers alike brace for the impact of new taxes. What the data has shown is a US economy that changed in April with Trump's initial rollout of tariffs, an event that led to market drama, a negotiating period and Trump's ultimate decision to start his universal tariffs on Thursday. ADVERTISEMENT A truck carries a cargo container away from a ship unloading at the Port of Oakland, Wednesday, Aug. 6, 2025, in Oakland, Calif. (Source: Associated Press) After April, economic reports show that hiring began to stall, inflationary pressures crept upward and home values in key markets started to decline, said John Silvia, CEO of Dynamic Economic Strategy. 'A less productive economy requires fewer workers,' Silvia said in an analysis note. 'But there is more, the higher tariff prices lower workers' real wages. The economy has become less productive, and firms cannot pay the same real wages as before. Actions have consequences.' Even then, the ultimate transformations of the tariffs are unknown and could play out over months, if not years. Many economists say the risk is that the American economy is steadily eroded rather than collapsing instantly. 'We all want it to be made for television where it's this explosion — it's not like that,' said Brad Jensen, a professor at Georgetown University. 'It's going to be fine sand in the gears and slow things down.' Trump has promoted the tariffs as a way to reduce the persistent trade deficit. But importers sought to avoid the taxes by importing more goods before the taxes went into effect. As a result, the $582.7 billion trade imbalance for the first half of the year was 38% higher than in 2024. Total construction spending has dropped 2.9% over the past year, and the factory jobs promised by Trump have so far resulted in job losses. The lead-up to Thursday fit the slapdash nature of Trump's tariffs, which have been variously rolled out, walked back, delayed, increased, imposed by letter and frantically renegotiated. ADVERTISEMENT The process has been so muddled that officials for key trade partners were unclear at the start of the week whether the tariffs would begin Thursday or Friday (local time). The language of the July 31 order to delay the start of tariffs from August 1 said the higher tax rates would start in seven days. On Wednesday morning (local time), Kevin Hassett, director of the White House National Economic Council, was asked if the new tariffs began at midnight Thursday, and he said reporters should check with the US Trade Representative's Office. A student of Gurukul school of Art completes artwork of US President Donald Trump and Prime Minister of India Narendra Modi, in Mumbai, India, Friday, August 1, 2025. (Source: Associated Press) Trump today announced additional 25% tariffs to be imposed on India for its buying of Russian oil, bringing their total import taxes to 50%. He has said that import taxes are still coming on pharmaceutical drugs and announced 100% tariffs on computer chips, meaning the US economy could remain in a place of suspended animation as it awaits the impact. The president's use of a 1977 law to declare an economic emergency to impose the tariffs is also under challenge. The impending ruling from last week's hearing before a US appeals court could cause Trump to find other legal justifications if judges say he exceeded his authority. Even people who worked with Trump during his first term are skeptical that things will go smoothly for the economy, such as Paul Ryan, the former Republican House speaker, who has emerged as a Trump critic. 'There's no sort of rationale for this other than the president wanting to raise tariffs based upon his whims, his opinions,' Ryan told CNBC today. 'I think choppy waters are ahead because I think they're going to have some legal challenges.' ADVERTISEMENT Still, the stock market has been solid during the recent tariff drama, with the S&P 500 index climbing more than 25% from its April low. The market's rebound and the income tax cuts in Trump's tax and spending measures signed into law on July 4 have given the White House confidence that economic growth is bound to accelerate in the coming months. As of now, Trump still foresees an economic boom while the rest of the world and American voters wait nervously. 'There's one person who can afford to be cavalier about the uncertainty that he's creating, and that's Donald Trump,' said Rachel West, a senior fellow at The Century Foundation who worked in the Biden White House on labor policy. 'The rest of Americans are already paying the price for that uncertainty.'
