Businessmen demand EFS restoration in original form
Karachi Chamber of Commerce and Industry (KCCI) President Jawed Bilwani, while highlighting the crucial role played by the Export Finance Scheme (EFS) in sustaining Pakistan's exports, emphasised that the scheme must continue in its original status and position, which was before the presentation of federal budget for fiscal year 2024-25.
In a statement, he called for allowing local purchases under Section 880 (1)(b) of SRO 957(I)/2021 (local input goods liable to sales tax to be supplied against zero-rated invoices) to ensure liquidity, competitiveness and formalisation across the entire value chain, as recommended by the Inter-Ministerial Committee.
"The EFS is critical to ensuring continued export-led growth and trade balance improvement," he said. "Despite facing the highest regional costs of electricity, gas, water and interest rates, Pakistan's exports have shown remarkable resilience, a feat largely attributable to the support provided by the EFS. Preserving and expanding this scheme is essential for maintaining export competitiveness."
Bilwani highlighted that the EFS was strategically developed by consolidating all previous schemes under one umbrella, which minimised documentation requirements and facilitated ease of doing business through a fully automated system integrated with Web-based One Customs (WeBOC) and the Pakistan Single Window (PSW).
"Much of the quality yarn and fabric used by Pakistan's apparel exporters is not produced domestically and the local alternatives, where available, are often of lower quality and higher cost," he pointed out. "The imported yarn used by garment manufacturers is of superior quality, giving exporters a competitive edge in global markets." The value-added apparel sector makes up to 70% value addition to export goods and requires uninterrupted access to high-quality raw material.
"Countries like Bangladesh and Vietnam are completely reliant on imported raw material for their export-oriented textile sectors and their success is a proof of effectiveness of such models when supported by robust facilitation mechanisms," he said. Bilwani warned that policy changes announced in the last federal budget, particularly the removal of zero-rating for local supplies, disrupted the balance between imported and local raw material.
"Currently, while the imported raw material is exempt from taxes, local inputs are subject to 18% sales tax with delayed and costly refunds," he said. "This creates a structural imbalance, discouraging local sourcing and impacting SMEs across the value chain."
In view of the IMF's reservations about fully restoring the zero-rating facility, he proposed a pragmatic middle path such as adopting a negative list to restrict high-risk imports under the EFS while preserving the broader scheme's facilitative framework.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
4 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Over 350,000 registered businesses in Karachi: creation of district chambers emphasised
KARACHI: The National Assembly's Standing Committee on Commerce was informed on Monday that there were more than 350,000 registered businesses in Karachi and creation of district chambers in the metropolitan city would help improve business facilitation and expand the tax base. The committee convened at the Parliament House, Islamabad, under the chairmanship of Muhammad Jawed Hanif Khan, MNA. 'It was highlighted that with more than 350,000 registered businesses in Karachi, the creation of district chambers would decentralise services, improve business facilitation, and expand the tax base,' the NA Secretariat said in a statement. 'Members across party lines expressed support for granting districts the right to establish chambers, while also agreeing that KCCI [Karachi Chamber of Commerce & Industry] should be given an opportunity to present its position.' Finance Division, not FBR, will present next year's budget The committee reviewed the legal framework governing the formation of chambers of commerce, noting the introduction of women's chambers through amendments in 2006 and 2009 and the requirements under the Companies Act, 2013. The members observed that centralisation of representation with the KCCI 'has created difficulties for the business community, with many entrepreneurs compelled to travel long distances to access services'. The committee chairman directed the Director General of Trade Organisations (DGTO) to invite KCCI representatives to the next session and emphasised that the committee was, in principle, supportive of district chambers, with a final decision to be taken after hearing KCCI's stance. 'Representatives of various chambers that have applied for licenses also attended the meeting and were given the opportunity to present their concerns,' the NA statement read. 'Motor vehicle import: opening up commercial imports could place pressure on FX reserves' Meanwhile, the committee also heard from representatives of the motor vehicle import sector. 'Concerns were raised that the Engineering Development Board (EDB), whose primary mandate relates to manufacturing, should not be tasked with licensing commercial imports, and members recommended that this responsibility lie with the Ministry of Commerce.' While stressing the need to ensure fair competition between new and used cars in line with international practice, the members also cautioned that opening up commercial imports could place pressure on foreign exchange reserves and adversely affect local industry. Business community 'disappointed' at status quo in policy rate The Secretary, Ministry of Commerce, briefed the committee on proposed policy features, including restrictions on the age of imported vehicles, tariff structures, environmental compliance requirements, and the consolidation of existing import schemes. 'After deliberations, the committee decided to refer the matter to the Ministry of Industries for detailed policy input, particularly on the impact of electric vehicle imports, and directed the ministry to brief the committee in its forthcoming meeting.'
Business Recorder
5 days ago
- Business Recorder
KCCI support hailed: Sindh CM says commited to improve business environment
KARACHI: Sindh Chief Minister Syed Murad Ali Shah, while commending the Karachi Chamber for its steadfast support to the province's development agenda, reaffirmed the Sindh government's commitment to improving the quality of life and business environment in Karachi. Speaking at the Flag Hoisting and Independence Day Ceremony at the Karachi Chamber of Commerce and Industry (KCCI) on Wednesday, the Chief Minister announced that the newly constructed 100 MGD Hub Canal, along with the rehabilitation of the existing canal, was inaugurated by Chairman PPP Bilawal Bhutto Zardari today, significantly boosting Karachi's water supply. Furthermore, development work on K-IV water supply scheme will also be completed soon whereas Sindh government is also in the process of effluent water treatment plants so that the water being dumped into the ocean can be utilized by Karachiites to overcome their water needs, he added. The event was attended by Sindh Minister for Industries Jam Ikramullah Khan Dharejo, Mayor Karachi Barrister Murtaza Wahab, Chairman BMG Zubair Motiwala, President KCCI Muhammad Jawed Bilwani, Senior Vice President Zia ul Arfeen, Vice President Faisal Khalil Ahmed, members of the Managing Committee, and former Presidents of KCCI. CM Sindh praised KCCI for embracing this year's Independence Day theme, 'Marka-e-Haq,' calling it a reflection of the nation's quest for dignity and justice. He also lauded the restoration of KCCI's historic building, describing it as a landmark of Karachi's economic heritage, and congratulated Chairman Zubair Motiwala and his team for reviving its grandeur. The Chief Minister assured that surrounding streets will be rehabilitated by Mayor Karachi and reaffirmed the Sindh Government's commitment to resolving Karachi's civic and business challenges in close partnership with KCCI. While addressing the gathering, CM Shah reflected on the unity displayed by Pakistanis in the face of recent hostilities by India. He recalled that when India cast an aggressive eye towards Pakistan, the nation stood shoulder to shoulder with the Armed Forces, compelling the adversary to declare a ceasefire within hours. He stressed that Pakistan remains a peace-loving nation but will always respond with strength to safeguard its sovereignty. He further remarked that Pakistan is no longer in isolation, as countries around the world are seeking stronger ties with it. Chairman Businessmen Group, Zubair Motiwala, in his remarks, said that August 14 is a remarkable day that set Pakistan free from colonial rule and must be celebrated with full zeal while remembering the two million people who sacrificed their lives for independence. He paid glowing tribute to Quaid-e-Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah for creating Pakistan and lauded the Armed Forces for their exemplary response to Indian aggression, leaving no choice but for the adversary to raise the white flag. He also expressed his firm belief that Kashmir will one day become part of Pakistan, reaffirming it as a national pledge. President KCCI, Muhammad Jawed Bilwani, extended heartfelt congratulations to the nation on Pakistan's 78th Independence Day and paid homage to the sacrifices of those who made freedom possible. He praised the Sindh Government's 'Marka-e-Haq' theme as resonating with the spirit of the independence struggle. Highlighting the historic significance of KCCI's building, he noted that it had undergone its second major renovation after a gap of 16 years with the aim of preserving its original grandeur. He expressed deep appreciation for the leadership of the Businessmen Group, particularly Chairman Zubair Motiwala, for keeping KCCI strong, united, and proactive in safeguarding the interests of the business community. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
6 days ago
- Business Recorder
Public choice at work? The end of EFS?
SRO 1395(I)2025 is not the end of the EFS. It is certainly the end of the beginning of the end of the EFS. SRO 1395(I)25, July 29, 2025, excludes 'Raw cotton, yarns, and fabrics' from the purview of the EFS. Imported cottons, yarns, and fabrics will now be at par with local produce and attract a 'refundable' 18 percent GST. The Public Choice Theory provides a framework about how private, material, bureaucratic and even ideological interests, of bureaucrats, politicians etc., work their way into full-blown public policies resulting in stunting and killing public goods and policies-like the inevitable demise of the EFS. EFS, July 2021 was launched, recognizing that the domestic fiscal constraints must not burden exporters as they compete internationally with competitors with no such baggage. The EFS intended to immunize exporters from the chronically 'kadak', cash-deficient FBR's penchant for meeting its revenue requirements by illegally denying refunds to EFS registered exporters. EFS meant no pay-ins, no refunds. Exporters and few in Islamabad were happy. However, many in Islamabad had different thoughts. FBR, like all, would like to retain control over the refund pipeline. EFS had blown that 'Nordstream 2' of coveted refunds which FBR would tap during lean days when these funds could buy the Republic a day or more. Via denial and delay of refunds, FBR perhaps got away, when needed, by passing off the cash thus withheld as 'revenues' to the 'gullible' multilateral overlords who often took it with a soup ladle. The good FBR was thus doing a sacred work. There is, however, reportedly another cohort who had seen slammed shut doors and tunnels to the cavernous corrupt bowels of the 'refund industry', i.e., the bad FBR. Oddly such officers doing a sacred work saving the Republic are no different from accountants in 'kadak' corporates who routinely stretch payables to meet 'priority' financial commitments. There is, perhaps, no daylight between 'kadak' cadres in public and private worlds. Kudos, however, and now commiserations, to the Ministry of Commerce and the few good men at FBR who had enacted the EFS SRO in 2021whose unravelling is an education in itself. How do you dismantle a scheme which is wildly popular with exporters and the Ministry of Commerce? Public Choice offers a possible explanation. A few quarters after EFS' enactment, the press had suddenly started carrying stories of EFS frauds. Must not FBR be apprehending the fraudsters? Many exporters' associations approached FBR to work with them to make EFS more robust, but to no avail. The 'good' and the 'bad' FBRs were at least indifferent or positively upset with EFS. Here is one way this fraud might have happened. Those who imported 60s yarn under EFS, made a killing by illegally selling it locally, pocketing the unpaid GST and then exporting some 20s yarn-based product claiming it was a twisted/tripled 3×60s! Local 20s was purchased GST free, under EFS! Fraudsters made a killing. Industry wanted to plug the leakage, FBR instead blew the pipeline. It was in this backdrop, last year and literally out of the left field, FBR rendered local yarn purchases ineligible for EFS. If an EFS registered exporter wanted to purchase local cotton yarn, it had to pay GST while it could import the same product GST free! EFS fraud tales-many, even most could be true-set the stage with a sinister hum of expectations. A few rent-an-associations also played their quisling parts. Local yarn manufacturers cried at this obvious miscarriage of justice. Exclusion of local yarns from EFS created a genuinely aggrieved party who just wanted re-inclusion into EFS. They were dragged, stomped on, slapped around until the aggrieved confederates sued for peace and on July 29 were served the textile equivalent of the Treaty of Versailles. Now, many are happy at their own defeat. Imposition of GST on cotton yarns is not a victory for spinners and not for the value-added champions. All exporters are losers. All manufacturers are losers. It is like on account of few purse snatching incidents, the city police banned pillion riding. Spinners and a few more, in their desperation — they were hurting bad — were offered Hobson's choice. They had to take it. Today it is yarns and fabrics tomorrow it will be something else. The real losers, however, mostly textiles exporters, continue to congregate in a motley crew of cults and associations whose chaotic best has never been good enough. The unravelling of EFS is the latest epiphany of the 'Entrepreneurs as Chor' creed which the tax collectors, ageing accountants and highly paid bankers who enjoy a revolving door access to the top echelons continue to believe and mean. Still, EFS, has perhaps been the most notable success that the Ministry of Commerce had notched in its long history of lost battles with the FBR. In Islamabad, tomorrow always trumps the future. EFS is not the first pro-exports government initiative to go down. It is high time that FBR evolved into a learning organization, learning by doing, driven by data, in perpetual consultation with entrepreneurs whose competitiveness depends on lifesavers like EFS. FBR can then use data to 'Rank and Yank' exporter population. For now, it is curtains for EFS. Textile exports of USD 1.5b per month or so is our fate. On a good day, that is. This tactical victory for some in the textile value chain is a strategic rout for the entire textile value chain. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
