Letters: Rights group should stick to defending anglos instead of wooing francophones
With the CAQ government targeting the anglo community in the courts and elsewhere, it seems like the wrong time to blue-wash the QCGN 'to reach out to francophone Quebecers.'
I doubt Quebec nationalist politicians will care. Some years ago the EMSB adopted the slogan 'Être bilingue, c'est gagnant!' The CAQ government still wants to abolish English school boards.
Perhaps the QCGN should spend less time trying to engage Quebec nationalists and more time defending the community it's supposed to represent. Its budget should be focused on the court battles forced on the anglophone community and forging connections with federal politicians instead of paying consultants for a rebrand.
The time for TALQ is over.
Pietro Bucci, Rivière-des-Prairies
Ramp failure not just an oversight
The ramp in Place des Montréalaises designed for cyclists and wheelchairs 'doesn't have a barrier preventing people from falling off and poses a danger,' The Gazette reports.
That sounds like not just an oversight, but more like incompetence or workers not doing their job(s).
Further, the square will be 'impossible for wheelchairs to use during the repair process.'
Mayor Valérie Plante says the work will be completed during the summer. Great, maybe in time for people in wheelchairs to use it in snow and ice?
Looks to me like another example of Plante's failures.
Bob Vanier, N.D.G.
GP blunders are indefensible
Mayor Valérie Plante addressed the lack of organization during last year's Grand Prix weekend, saying the city has learned from its errors and will do better this year. What an inadequate and laughable response.
Any learning curve had long since passed by the time the police closed access points to Île Notre-Dame, and the fire department forced several restaurants on Peel St. to shut their terrasses.
What happened was inexcusable in my view and yet another example of the way Projet Montréal has managed our city.
Ian Copnick, Côte-St-Luc
Lack of parking hurts merchants
Re: ' Hydro work hurts T.M.R. businesses ' (The Gazette, June 2)
Retail businesses all over Montreal have been hurt for far too long by never-ending construction projects.
What if a mayoral candidate in November's election had the vision and courage to announce a plan to enable better parking options for shoppers patronizing those suffering businesses?
Empathetic and business-friendly leadership — what a concept!
Barry Beloff, Montreal
Students' needs must come first
Re: ' Dear Miss Teacher, Why can't I fail too? ' (Opinion, May 31)
A thank you to Maïka Forget for bravely sharing her experience with our education system. My two young adults can certainly validate her story.
After serving for more than 10 years on my kids' school boards, I could see things had vastly changed since I was in school. Everything was now focused on grades, rankings and competition, which leached the fun of learning out of them.
As long as their grades were good and they were impressing teachers, no one seemed to care about the anxiety that was slowly consuming them.
We need to invest sufficiently in our education system to serve students, not bureaucrats. Students are not a product; they are people.
Karen Bleakley, Dorval
Submitting a letter to the editor
Letters should be sent by email to letters@montrealgazette.com
We prioritize letters that respond to, or are inspired by, articles published by The Gazette.
If you are responding to a specific article, let us know which one.
Letters should be sent uniquely to us. The shorter they are — ideally, fewer than 200 words — the greater the chance of publication.
Timing, clarity, factual accuracy and tone are all important, as is whether the writer has something new to add to the conversation.
We reserve the right to edit and condense all letters. Care is taken to preserve the core of the writer's argument.
Our policy is not to publish anonymous letters, those with pseudonyms or 'open letters' addressed to third parties.
Letters are published with the author's full name and city or neighbourhood/borough of residence. Include a phone number and address to help verify identity; these will not be published.
We will not indicate to you whether your letter will be published. If it has not been published within 10 days or so, it is not likely to be.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Montreal Gazette
an hour ago
- Montreal Gazette
Opinion: Why is the PQ resonating with so many Quebecers right now?
Opinion The results of the Arthabaska byelection confirm what polls have been saying for months: a vast majority of Quebecers want the Legault government out. On Monday, only 7.2 per cent of voters gave their support to the Coalition Avenir Québec candidate. Even Premier François Legault conceded that this poor outcome is an indication of Quebecers' discontent. The next general election will be held a little over a year from now — Oct. 5, 2026 — and it is easy to predict what the main theme will be: change. Quebecers will wonder which party best represents this ever-important political value. In Arthabaska, as in the two previous byelections won by the Parti Québécois, voters concluded that the separatist party is the most credible alternative to the CAQ. Why? One reason is that, considering his relative youth (he is 48) and the fact that he has never been in government, PQ Leader Paul St-Pierre Plamondon personifies change. His style of direct, sincere, thoughtful politics also differs from the stuff of many career politicians. Veteran pollster Jean-Marc Léger noted on Tuesday that 30 per cent of Parti Québécois voters are federalists. Instead of voting Liberal as would be expected, those Quebecers choose to support the PQ because Plamondon's party is perceived as the one with the best chance of winning and therefore, of sending the CAQ government packing. In Monday's byelection, the Quebec Liberal Party had a strong local candidate. They also, finally, have a new, well-known leader. Despite those assets, Chantale Marchand received only 9.3 per cent of the byelection votes. Clearly, voters in Arthabaska did not consider the QLP as the party through which one could express their longing for a fresh start. This is a weakness that leader Pablo Rodriguez will have to address quickly if he wants his party to be competitive come October 2026. Another reason for the PQ's success is the rapid decline of Québec solidaire. No one expected QS to win in Arthabaska, a traditionally conservative riding. Still, in the 2022 general election, they had obtained 9.2 per cent of Arthabaska votes ; on Monday, their score fell to an anemic 1.5 per cent. Voters, specifically young voters, who were attracted to the societal changes proposed by the leftist party may have switched their vote to the PQ, notwithstanding some major differences between the positions of the 'péquistes' and that of the 'solidaires' on immigration, for example. After the 2022 election, some commentators predicted the death of the party founded by René Lévesque. To Plamondon's credit, he succeeded in bringing the PQ back from the brink. His commitment to hold a third referendum on sovereignty was thought to be an obstacle to growing the party's base. That has not happened yet, and it remains to be seen whether things will change when Quebecers are called upon to choose the province's next government instead of simply voting for their local MNA. In his victory speech Monday night, Plamondon emphasized concrete issues that concern Quebecers — ineffective public services, the increase in the cost of living, the worrisome state of the province's finances, uncontrolled immigration — rather than separation. Is this the beginning of a strategic turn where, even if still committed to hold a third referendum on independence, the PQ will first and foremost promise a competent government ('un bon government'), as they have often done in the past? Of course, a lot can happen in the next year. However, for now, Plamondon and his party are clearly being perceived by many Quebecers as the most credible alternative to the Legault government. Strategically, that is a very enviable position to hold. This story was originally published
Montreal Gazette
3 hours ago
- Montreal Gazette
After crushing byelection loss, Legault says his government must listen, show humility
Quebec Politics By QUEBEC — Premier François Legault says it's time to listen to what Quebecers have to say about what his government is doing wrong and to make the necessary corrections. 'Obviously, I am very disappointed in the results of Monday,' Legault said while arriving for an unusual August meeting of his cabinet Wednesday. 'I think i's time for me to show humility and to listen to citizens. 'Today I will listen to my ministers. Tomorrow I will listen to MNAS. I am lucky to have 86 MNAs who listened to citizens all summer. I want to hear from them on everything, including the negative comments they got this summer. I am really at the stage of humility and listening.' They were Legault's latest comments since his party, the Coalition Avenir Québec, suffered a devastating electoral loss to the Parti Québécois in the central Quebec riding of Arthabaska. The CAQ's share of the vote plunged from the 52 per cent it got in the 2022 general election to 7.2 per cent as the PQ continues to surf on a wave of public support and anger over the CAQ government's work. This week, Legault launched a kind of soul-searching operation to figure what his government has to do to rebuild support. Part of the exercise involved him meeting, away from media scrutiny, with voters. On Monday, he glad-handed with voters in a restaurant in Beauport in suburban Quebec City and later visited a mall. At the same time, Legault is meeting privately with his cabinet ministers as he gradually prepares for a cabinet shuffle that he hopes will breathe new life into the government's actions. Back in June, he announced the shuffle was coming, a move which immediately put his ministers on edge wondering whether they would get chopped. It is expected to take place some time around Labour Day. 'I started a month ago to meet, one at a time, the ministers to see what interests them,' Legault said, adding some of his other MNAs also have ideas on what changes are needed to shore up support. 'I will take the weeks ahead to digest this,' Legault said. 'We also have big projects already underway on the economy and what is happening with (U.S. President) Donald Trump.' Talks with the province's powerful doctor's lobby have also bogged down talks to achieve a new contract, he added. 'I will take the time to adjust our plan, our priorities based on the changes which are proposed,' he said. He repeated, as he has many times, that he intends to stay on as premier and CAQ leader. 'It's already decided that I am staying,' Legault said. 'I will be there for the elections of October 2026.' On their way in to the cabinet meeting, ministers who stopped insisted they are not nervous about the future. Asked if has confidence voters are with the CAQ, Education Minister Bernard Drainville answered: 'You betcha.' 'We await the decision of the premier,' he added when asked if he will stay on in education. 'I always said I loved the challenge of this ministry,' said Health Minister Christian Dubé. 'I love this. It will be the choice of the premier. We'll see.' 'It is the prerogative of the premier,' Justice Minister Simon Jolin-Barrette said when asked if wanted to change jobs. 'I am in politics to serve my fellow citizens and will fulfill any mandates the premier gives me.' 'The pace is pretty intense, energy and the economy, the metropolis,' said Economy and Energy Minister Christine Fréchette. 'I'm very happy. If I can stay there I will be happy. If I can serve elsewhere, I will be happy.'
Montreal Gazette
9 hours ago
- Montreal Gazette
Premier François Legault launches soul-searching operation
Quebec Politics By QUEBEC — The soul-searching operation is underway. One day after his Coalition Avenir Québec party suffered a crushing defeat by the Parti Québécois in a byelection in Arthabaska riding, Premier François Legault is stepping up efforts to jump-start his sagging government. And before he meets his cabinet and caucus in unusual summer meetings this week, Legault Tuesday took some time to step out of his office in Quebec City to go and meet ordinary citizens for some heart-to-heart talks. 'He's going to listen, that's the deal,' a senior government source said Tuesday. The encounters were not included on the premier's official agenda and the media was not invited. The plan was for Legault to meet and talk informally with people on the street, in the shops, or at the mall. Legault set the stage for the shifts he is planning by making a mea culpa in his concession speech Monday night. He said he 'got the message' that people are unhappy with his government's actions on a number of fronts. That includes losses on the Northvolt project, the SAAQclic fiasco and the government's inability to improve services. 'We must not put our heads in the sand,' Legault told CAQ supporters gathered in a Victoriaville bar. 'The people of Arthabaska were the spokespeople for all Quebecers. 'They sent us a very clear message, very direct. They are disappointed. Over the coming weeks we're going to look at ourselves in the mirror and we will bear all the responsibility of Quebecers' disappointments. We will make changes.' The numbers were devastating. The CAQ's share of the vote in Arthabaska Monday dropped from the 52 per cent the party got in 2022 to 7.2 per cent. The CAQ has held the riding, in central Quebec, since 2012. The PQ's score went from 10.02 per cent in 2022 to 46.37 per cent. Also telling was the turnout level: 60 per cent. That is rare in a regular byelection and even more surprising in a vote held in the middle of summer. 'I think it sends a very, very strong message to the government,' PQ winner, former radio host Alex Boissonneault said in an interview with Radio-Canada Tuesday. 'People did their duty. They had a message to send and I think they expressed their desire for change in no uncertain terms.' He conceded the PQ's independence agenda was not really an issue in the byelection. Voters were more interested in finding a good MNA than worrying about that part of the PQ's profile. It was a third byelection win for the PQ, which continues to position itself as the vehicle for voter discontent. The other two wins were in Jean-Talon in 2023 and Terrebonne in March 2025, both former CAQ ridings. The result was a major disappointment to Éric Duhaime, leader of the Quebec Conservative Party. After failing to win a seat in the legislature in the 2022 general election, Duhaime believed a break through was possible in Arthabaska, a riding in central Quebec that includes Victoriaville. 'Despite the wounds of defeat, my soul is at peace,' Duhaime said Tuesday in a social media post. 'Our support continues to grow. Last night we improved our score of 2022 by 10 per cent, moving from less than 25 per cent (support) to about 35 per cent.' Duhaime added what gives him hope for the future are the numbers of youth that voted for his party. 'We are the party of the future,' he said. Over at the CAQ, the focus is on what can be done to save themselves before the 2026 general election. Some pollsters have already predicted that at this rate the CAQ could wind up winning zero seats in the next general election. What offensive measures does the party have left? One biggie is the cabinet shuffle Legault has been working on over the summer after announcing it is coming last June. Sources said it will take place some time around Labour Day, which will leave ministers about two weeks to get up to speed on their files before the legislature resumes sitting Sept. 16. Legault is no fan of such shuffles, referring to the few changes he has made to cabinet since the CAQ's first election in 2018 as 'adjustments.' Some of his ministers have thus been in the same job for more than seven years. By definition, shuffles are risky exercises. Once you start moving around the pieces on the chess board it's not always clear how it will end. The last thing Legault wants to do is anger a minister who could respond by quitting. That explains the Wednesday cabinet meeting and the meeting Thursday with the 85 members of the CAQ caucus. Legault wants to hear from all the members of his team before proceeding with his operational re-set. Talk of the shuffle has sparked a series of rumours of who might be in and who might be out of cabinet. Asked about the looming shuffle over the last few days, ministers remained evasive, insisting they will serve in whatever role Legault offers. 'I am happy in education because when I get up in morning I am working for the children,' Education Minister Bernard Drainville said last week. 'This has meaning. When you do politics it has to have meaning. Otherwise it's not worth it. 'Will it be the decision of premier to leave me there? I don't know. If he leaves me there I will do my last year to the election. I will give my all. If the premier decides to send me elsewhere, I will do my best wherever that is.' 'Regardless of the challenge I am offered, I put all my heart and energy into it because I am working for the interests of the taxpayers,' said Transport Minister Geneviève Guilbault.
