Missing EU climate targets could leave Ireland facing a €26 billion bill
This stark warning about the cost of missing its goals comes via a joint report from the Irish Fiscal Advisory Council (IFAC) and Climate Change Advisory Council (CCAC).
It says the country's government needs to 'act now' or it could be in line to pay significant compliance costs further down the line. Plans to cut emissions that have yet to be enacted could reduce the potential costs by between €3 billion to €12 billion.
Why does Ireland have to pay for missing emissions targets?
The EU's Effort Sharing Regulation sets binding national targets for reducing greenhouse gas emissions.
Member states have to meet climate targets for five key sectors: road transport, buildings, small industry, waste, and agriculture. Each goal is adjusted based on a country's GDP, with wealthier nations having stricter requirements.
Countries that underperform will have to buy 'emissions allocations' – essentially carbon credits – from those that are overperforming in order to bridge the gap.
But the price of these allocations depends on the extent to which other EU member states achieve or overachieve on their targets. A report from Transport & Environment (T&E) last year warned that, with so many countries set to miss their goals, the scarcity of allocations could lead to a bidding war in 2030.
This makes the price of each credit challenging to predict, leading to the massive variation in the predicted cost.
'Ireland can take actions now to offset potential costs down the line,' explains Seamus Coffey, chair of the IFAC, adding that it can do so in a way that 'doesn't threaten the wider sustainability of public finances'.
In the past four years, the report also notes that Ireland has missed out on around €500 million in revenue from carbon credits it is entitled to sell. Two other pieces of national legislation on land use and forestry and the share of energy from renewable sources could also pose smaller yet significant costs.
How far is Ireland from meeting its emissions targets?
The latest data from the country's Environmental Protection Agency projects that Ireland will reduce its greenhouse gas emissions by 29 per cent by 2030. That is a long way off of its agreed target to cut emissions by 51 per cent by 2030.
While we have made some progress in reducing emissions, our pace of change is not enough to meet our national and EU climate targets.
Marie Donnelly
Chair of the Climate Change Advisory Council
It isn't alone, however, with just Luxembourg, Greece, Portugal, Spain and Slovenia overachieving on emissions cuts. Though many other EU member states are also on track to miss targets agreed under the Effort Sharing Regulation, Ireland is among the worst.
The country had the highest emissions gap per capita of any EU state at 8.7 tonnes of CO2 per person. This leaves it as one of the least likely to meet its 2030 emissions reduction target under current climate policies.
'While we have made some progress in reducing emissions, our pace of change is not enough to meet our national and EU climate targets,' says Marie Donnelly, chair of the CCAC.
Can Ireland cut its greenhouse gas emissions in time?
If Ireland's government implements its 'more ambitious' Climate Action Plan by 2030, this course of action could reduce costs by between €3 billion and €12 billion. But, the report warns, this plan is not being delivered at the 'scale of the speed required' and urges officials to 'act now or risk substantial costs later'.
Around a tenth of the country's planned capital spending to 2030 could be enough, it says. This would cover the cost of upgrading Ireland's electricity grid, reducing the cost of 700,000 new electric vehicles to less than €15,000, improving EV charging infrastructure, and supporting forestry initiatives and the rewetting of the country's wetlands.
Not doing so would be a massive missed opportunity to cut emissions, the report's authors say.
'The government must take clear and decisive action now to transition to a climate neutral economy,' Donnelly explains.
'It is better to make the investments into Irish households, communities and businesses now, rather than paying significant compliance costs in the years ahead.'
Taoiseach, Micheál Martin, has defended the government's emissions progress to the Irish press, saying the country has made 'very significant progress' over the last four years, adding that emissions have come down in the last 12 months.
While Martin admitted to not having read the report in its entirety, he pointed to a 'big wave' of upcoming spending on the electricity grid and an upcoming push for offshore wind. He also added that the government was 'determined' to continue progressing on climate.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Euronews
12 hours ago
- Euronews
Europe's power grids under pressure amid record-breaking heatwaves
ADVERTISEMENT This summer, Europe has again been gripped by a series of intense and widespread heatwaves. This week alone, temperature records have been broken across south-west France, Croatia and Hungary, with some regions enduring highs of over 40°C. As climate change makes heatwaves more frequent and more intense, demand for energy is soaring as people attempt to keep cool. At the same time, high temperatures are undermining electricity supplies, particularly from thermal plants - a type of power station in which heat energy is converted into electricity - that rely on river water for cooling. Experts warn that heatwaves are putting the continent's power grid under severe stress. They say energy systems urgently need to adapt, increasing flexibility and transitioning to renewable energy to avoid planet-warming fossil fuels. Governments also face the challenge of coping with heatwaves without blackouts or increasing planet-warming emissions. Energy consumption increases as people try to keep cool Recent heatwaves are a 'stark reminder' that Europe's power system needs to be prepared for increasingly extreme temperatures, according to energy think tank Ember's Europe policy director, Pawel Czyak. 'Europe's power systems are once again being tested by record-breaking temperatures.' Czyak adds that the think tank's analysis of the July heatwave showed how soaring demand from cooling pushed electricity demand to summer peaks. In Spain, electricity use jumped by around 14 per cent. Germany and France saw demand spike during peak hours, putting power operators on high alert. High summer temperatures are rapidly becoming the norm, and as they do, air conditioning systems are becoming an increasingly common sight. The number of room air conditioners in the EU is predicted to rise from less than 7 million in 1990 to more than 100 million in 2030. Despite this dramatic increase, air conditioning still only makes up around 0.6 per cent of household energy use in Europe Data shows that Italy is by far the EU's biggest user of air conditioning. It accounts for one-third of all electricity consumed by air conditioning across the 27 member states, despite having some of the highest electricity prices in Europe. In second place is Greece, followed by France, Spain and Germany. Pressure on power plants as temperatures rise Heatwaves don't just increase demand for electricity; they can also reduce power production from some forms of energy. Several European countries have had to repeatedly reduce electricity production or shut down nuclear reactors due to extreme heat this summer. During the heatwave between 28 June and 2 July, 17 out of France's 18 nuclear power plants in the country faced capacity reductions, with some shut down completely. The latest heatwave saw multiple warnings of power reductions, particularly on the Rhône river in the east and on the Garonne in the west of the country. Around three-quarters of the country's mainland faced heat alerts on Wednesday, and temperature records were broken in the southwest. So why is extreme heat a problem for nuclear power stations? To cool down reactors, water is pumped in from local rivers or the sea. It is then released back out at a higher temperature. But heatwaves mean the water being pumped in is already hot to begin with. It impacts the plant's ability to use it to cool down, and if the water that's released is too hot, it can threaten local biodiversity. Built for milder, more predictable climates, Europe's grid itself also struggles in extreme heat. In early July, blackouts hit parts of Rome, Florence, Bergamo and Milan as Italy's ageing infrastructure was pushed to its limits by the weather. The strain to balance the system due to a surge in electricity demand from cooling systems was partly to blame. But energy provider Enel said that underground cables had also expanded and overheated. In high temperatures, the underground cables struggle to dissipate heat. Without efforts to upgrade the grid and make it more resilient to extreme weather, the direct stress test of increasing heatwaves could lead to more blackouts like those seen in Italy. Can renewables help electricity grids adapt? While sunny conditions bring heat, they can also bring more electricity generation. June 2025 saw the highest monthly EU solar electricity production on record, amounting to more than 40 per cent of generation in the Netherlands and 35 per cent in Greece. The solar boost kept the electricity grid well supplied during daylight hours. It was most abundant at midday when there was the greatest demand from air conditioning, helping to ease the strain on the grid and prevent blackouts. 'Thermal plants saw outages, driven by cooling challenges in nuclear facilities, whereas strong solar performance helped stabilise strained grids,' says Czyzak. 'Investing in flexible, renewable-powered grids will help the power system be resilient and keep costs low.' Elsewhere, July heatwaves caused wind power outputs to crash. During an unprecedented spate of high temperatures, Finland saw wind power production plummet, with generation among the weakest on record. The country turned to hydropower, but this alone was not enough to cover the production gap. Wind turbines almost ground to a halt in the UK this week as the heatwave brought calm conditions. Wind accounted for only 5 per cent of the energy mix on Wednesday, with gas jumping to more than a third, according to data from the National Energy System Operator. These extremes underline solar's growing role in heatwave resilience, but they also show that renewables alone are no silver bullet unless supported by storage and smarter grids.
Euronews
a day ago
- Euronews
European leaders to support trilateral meeting following Alaska summit
European leaders have said they are "ready to work with US President Trump and Ukrainian President Zelenskyy towards a trilateral summit with European support," in a statement issued by the European Commission on Saturday. "It will be up to Ukraine to make decisions on its territory. International borders must not be changed by force," the statement read, which was released a few hours after the conclusion of a meeting between Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin. The statement was signed by European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, French President Emmanuel Macron, Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, German Chancellor Friedrich Merz, British Prime Minister Keir Starmer, Finnish President Alexander Stubb, Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk and European Council President António Costa. They said they "welcomed President Trump's efforts to stop the killing in Ukraine, end Russia's war of aggression, and achieve just and lasting peace," following the US President's meeting with his Russian counterpart Vladimir Putin in Alaska. The leaders insisted on "ironclad security guarantees" for Ukraine, with "no limitations" on Ukraine's armed forces. "Russia cannot have a veto against Ukraine's pathway to EU and NATO." The statement also reiterated a pledge to continue to impose sanctions on Russia "as long as the killing in Ukraine continues". Zelenskyy calls for 'real peace' Zelenskyy echoed the European statement in a post on X, calling for "real peace" and "not just another pause between Russian invasions." He added that he told Trump "sanctions should be strengthened if there is no trilateral meeting or if Russia tries to evade an honest end to the war." He also reiterated the importance of involving European leaders, who also were not present at the summit. Other European leaders responded more fiercely to the outcome of Friday's summit in Alaska. Norwegian Foreign Minister Espend Barth Eide told reporters in Oslo Putin's talking points were "code for the Russian justification for the illegal invasion of Ukraine." Czech Prime Minister Petr Fiala said in a statement that "Putin is still only interested in the greatest possible territorial gains and the restoration of the Soviet empire." EU foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas said 'the harsh reality is that Russia has no intention of ending this war anytime soon,' noting that Moscow's forces launched new attacks on Ukraine even as the delegations met. 'Putin continues to drag out negotiations and hopes he gets away with it. He left Anchorage without making any commitments to end the killing,' she said.
Euronews
3 days ago
- Euronews
Plastic pollution treaty talks end without an agreement
Negotiators working on a treaty to address the global crisis of plastic pollution won't reach an agreement in Geneva on Friday. They were meeting for the 11th day at the United Nations office in Geneva to try to complete a landmark treaty to end the plastic pollution crisis but remained deadlocked over whether the treaty should reduce the exponential growth of plastic production and put global, legally binding controls on toxic chemicals used to make plastics. This round of negotiations was meant to be the last, producing the first legally binding treaty on plastic pollution. But now delegates are leaving without a treaty after talks collapsed, just like they did at the meeting in South Korea last year. Nations deeply disappointed to leave Geneva without a treaty Representatives of Norway, Australia, Tuvalu and other nations said they were deeply disappointed to be leaving Geneva without a treaty. "We came to Geneva to secure a global plastics treaty because we know the stakes could not be higher," European Commissioner for Environment, Water Resilience and Competitive Circular Economy, Jessika Roswall said in a post on social media. "While the latest text on the table does not yet meet all our ambitions, it is a step forward—and the perfect must not be the enemy of the good." Roswall added that the EU will continue to push for a stronger, binding agreement. Saudi Arabia said both drafts lacked balance, and Saudi and Kuwaiti negotiators said the latest proposal takes other states' views more into account and addresses plastic production, which they consider outside the scope of the treaty. No further action on the latest draft text Luis Vayas Valdivieso, the chair of the negotiating committee, wrote and presented two drafts of treaty text in Geneva based on the views expressed by nations at the talks. That draft, released early Friday, did not include a limit on plastic production but recognised that current levels of production and consumption are 'unsustainable' and global action is needed. New language had been added to say these levels exceed current waste management capacities and are projected to increase further, 'thereby necessitating a coordinated global response to halt and reverse such trends.' The representatives from 184 countries did not agree to use either one as the basis for their negotiations. Valdivieso said Friday morning, as the delegates reconvened in the assembly hall, that no further action is being proposed at this stage on the latest draft. Talks in Geneva have been an "abject failure", David Azoulay, health programme director and head of the delegation for the Center for International Environmental Law, said in a statement. "In the final days of the negotiations, we have clearly seen what many of us have known for some time - some countries did not come here to finalise a text, they came here to do the opposite: block any attempt at advancing a viable treaty. "It's impossible to find a common ground between those who are interested in protecting the status quo and the majority who are looking for a functional treaty that can be strengthened over time." What happens now? Delegates are still meeting and have not decided on the next steps yet. Azoulay said that, while negotiations will continue, they will fail again if solutions aren't identified and the process doesn't change. "We need a restart, not a repeat performance. Countries that want a treaty must now leave this process and form a treaty of the willing. And that process must include options for voting that deny the tyranny of consensus we have watched play out here."
