No-show Setka too sick to deal with lawyers over push to oust AFL umpiring boss
Setka, or lawyers on his behalf, have now failed to show up for two preliminary Federal Court hearings to respond to accusations from the Fair Work Ombudsman, instead providing a medical certificate that he is too unwell to attend meetings.
The court heard that while the certificate provided few details of the nature of the union hardman's ailment, it also indicated he had a WorkCover claim in progress.
The ombudsman alleges the disgraced former CFMEU boss breached workplace laws by trying to pressure the AFL into dumping its umpiring chief, Steve McBurney, due to his previous job at the Australian Building and Construction Commission (ABCC).
A case management hearing on Friday was unable to proceed after Setka's second no-show in a month, leaving Justice John Snaden and lawyers representing the ombudsman to discuss options to go forward with the matter.
Loading
Representing the ombudsman, lawyer Marc Felman, KC, said he had received correspondence including a medical certificate that stated that Setka was not currently in a state of mind to attend meetings, make decisions or instruct legal representation, though there was no indication of how long it would take him to recover.
Felman said the letter indicated Setka would be receiving treatment for several months and had a WorkCover claim that was being assessed, but the nature of his illness was not disclosed because Setka was concerned about releasing personal and private information to government organisations.
He told the court Setka needed to file a defence or a report from a qualified specialist medical practitioner.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
3 hours ago
- News.com.au
Woman loses bid to challenge damages awarded after husband nearly died following ‘Covid cruise'
A woman whose husband nearly died following a major Covid outbreak on a cruise that led to 28 deaths has lost her challenge to the damages she was awarded. Nearly 700 passengers contracted Covid-19 on the 13-day Ruby Princess cruise from Sydney on March 8, 2020. The Federal Court in 2023 found the cruise line, Carnival Australia, was negligent in allowing the ship to set sail following a class-action lawsuit launched by Shine Lawyers. Justice Angus Stewart also found the cruise line misled passengers by making representations that the cruise was reasonably safe to embark on and the company would take reasonable care for the safety of passengers and increase monitoring, screening and sanitation protocols. The class action's lead applicant, Susan Karpik, most likely contracted Covid on-board the ship along with her husband, Henry Karpik, Justice Stewart found. Her husband became so sick from the virus that he was given only a few days to live at one stage, spending nearly two months in hospital during which time he was intubated, ventilated and placed into an induced coma. Mr Karpik survived the ordeal. Mrs Karpik experienced minor symptoms of the virus; however, she was unable to be with her husband, as she was in isolation and feared he might die. Justice Stewart found that she'd suffered psychiatric illness as a result but did not uphold her claims that she suffered long Covid. Mrs Karpik lodged an appeal against her personal injury, disappointment and distress damages; she'd sought more than $300,000 but was only awarded about $4000 as a refund for her ticket. Carnival Australia also lodged a cross-appeal against Justice Stewart's findings of negligence and misleading representations. Justice Sarah Derrington dismissed both appeals in the Federal Court on Tuesday morning, ordering each party to pay for each other's costs. 'Each of the appeal and the cross-appeal have failed in their entirety,' Justice Derrington said. She upheld the findings of Justice Stewart that Carnival Australia breached consumer guarantees and its duty of care to passengers by not cancelling the cruise, nor warning Mrs Karpik of the heightened risk of the virus on the cruise. Justice Derrington also found the primary judge was correct in concluding Mrs Karpik's damages didn't exceed the cost of the ticket refund she was given, and she wasn't entitled to personal injury damages, as it fell below the severity required. Justice Derrington described how Mr Karpik was 'gravely ill and nearly died' in her reasons for judgment, with Mrs Karpik unable to be by her husband's side, as she was told he only had about a 10 per cent shot at survival while she was still self-isolating. Mr Karpik's condition improved over the following days and he survived despite a 'long and difficult recovery'. Shine Lawyers joint head of class action Vicky Antzoulatos said she was pleased with the Federal Court's upholding of negligence findings in a statement outside of court. 'The Full Court has upheld the comprehensive findings of Justice Stewart, the trial judge, that Carnival Cruises was negligent and breached the Australian Consumer Law in its conduct of the voyage of the Ruby Princess in March 2020,' Ms Antzoulatos said. 'The Full Court has also upheld the trial findings in relation to Mrs Karpik's damages. 'The case is now in its fifth year, and sadly, several of the passengers on this ill-fated cruise have now passed away.' Ms Antzoulatos said passengers can have their claims assessed. 'We hope this result will lead to a meaningful resolution of their claims so that they can finally put this sorry episode of their lives behind them,' she said.
Perth Now
4 hours ago
- Perth Now
Update after 28 die on ‘Covid cruise'
A woman whose husband was told he had just days to live following a major Covid outbreak on a cruise that led to 28 deaths has lost her challenge to the damages she was awarded. Nearly 700 passengers contracted Covid-19 on the 13-day Ruby Princess cruise from Sydney on March 8, 2020. The Federal Court in 2023 found the cruise line, Carnival Australia, was negligent in allowing the ship to set sail following a class-action lawsuit launched by Shine Lawyers. Justice Angus Stewart also found the cruise line misled passengers by making representations that the cruise was reasonably safe to embark on and the company would take reasonable care for the safety of passengers and increase monitoring, screening and sanitation protocols. The class action's lead applicant, Susan Karpik, most likely contracted Covid on-board the ship along with her husband, Henry Karpik, Justice Stewart found. Her husband became so sick from the virus that he was given only a few days to live at one stage, spending nearly two months in hospital during which time he was intubated, ventilated and placed into an induced coma. Mr Karpik survived the ordeal. Susan Karpik was the lead applicant in the class action launched by Shine Lawyers. NewsWire / Dylan Coker Credit: News Corp Australia Mrs Karpik experienced minor symptoms of the virus; however, she was unable to be with her husband, as she was in isolation and feared he might die. Justice Stewart found that she'd suffered psychiatric illness as a result but did not uphold her claims that she suffered long Covid. Mrs Karpik lodged an appeal against her damages; she'd sought more than $360,000 but was only awarded $4423 plus interest for out-of-pocket medical expenses. Mrs Karpik's husband was at one stage given only days to live. NewsWire / Dylan Coker Credit: News Corp Australia Carnival Australia also lodged a cross-appeal against Justice Stewart's findings. Justice Sarah Derrington dismissed both appeals in the Federal Court on Tuesday morning. Her reasons are expected to be published on Tuesday. More to come …
News.com.au
a day ago
- News.com.au
AFL and Carlton player Zac Williams signs up to become a registered organ donor after finding out his wife already was
Zac Williams has kicked plenty of goals in his career as an AFL star. But a recent shift off the field has lead him to quite a different goal in his personal life. After a converstaion with wife Rachel Lucas, the Carlton Football player has signed up as a registered organ donor with DonateLife. 'I'm probably one of those people that have been oblivious for so long about organ donation,' Williams told Lucas, a former Ballerina, was already a registered organ donor and helped encourage the former GWS Giant to do the same, along with other family and close friends. 'It was actually a very passionate conversation that we had about it,' Williams said. 'Hearing stories from people that have received organ donations and how it saved their lives, was really inspirational. 'I was pretty easily convinced that if you become an organ donor how much you can help others.' The pair, who married in 2024 share two children, son Beckham and daughter Ayla. Williams' decision to register as a donor comes as the median time people currently on the kidney transplant wait list has risen to 2.6 years. The waiting period is dependant on individual's blood type and location, but is significantly higher than the average wait time for a liver transplant which is eight to 12 months. More than 200 Australians have died in the past five years waiting for a transplant, but there are concerns the figure may actually be higher as patients are removed from waitlists as they're conditions worsen. Williams is speaking ahead of DonateLife Week which aims to raise national awareness about organ and tissue donation between July 27 and August 3. Williams even let his good friend and rival AFL player from Port Adelaide Jeremy Finlayson know he'd made the move. Finlayson's wife Kellie was diagnosed with Stage four bowel cancel at 25 years old in 2021, after giving birth to their daughter Sophia just three months prior. Not long later in 2022 after experiencing shortness of breath, it was confirmed the disease had spread to her colon. Kellie has been receiving blood from donors helping save her life following surgeries and ongoing treatment. Williams meanwhile is facing a tough uphill battle with a struggling Carlton side that have slumped to 12th in this season's standings. The 2013 AFL rising star has seen a positional shift at times and has been a consistent member of the squad.
