APRA's refusal to revise the 3 per cent stress test keeps Aussies locked in mortgage prison
ANALYSIS
If you're in mortgage prison, you just had a parole hearing. And the result? Parole denied.
That was the outcome when the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA) announced recently that it would be keeping the 3 per cent mortgage repayment 'stress test' buffer in place.
That's right, we're not being prudent enough! And we must be regulated.
The buffer dictates that anyone applying for a home loan is 'stress tested' at a loan repayment rate 3 per cent higher than what they will actually be paying if successful in their loan application.
MORE: Shock RBA twist as home prices surge
So, if you want to borrow money at 6 per cent, the bank will check your income and financial habits to make sure you could make repayments at 9 per cent interest. You know, just in case there is a series of rate rises. They don't want you to default and lose that dream home.
Only problem is, for a lot of people, the rule is stopping them getting a home at all.
Let's be real here. Interest rates are coming down. They are not going to go up 3 per cent in the near term.
The stress buffer started out at 2 per cent in 2014. It went to 2.5 per cent in 2019 on the back of a growth cycle that left many borrowers overexposed to the risk of a market correction.
It was rightly increased to 3 per cent in October 2021 when the official cash rate was at 0.1 per cent and there were variable rate home loans with interest rates below 2 per cent. The only way was up at that time.
Mortgage prison is not where you want to be.
Now is a completely different story. We have seen a cost of living crisis, stagnant wages, and rising house prices, yet someone who has somehow managed to scrape a deposit together needs to be able to show they can make repayments at a level not seen from variable interest rates since before the 2008 GFC.
MORE: 34-year-old goes from broke to $100m
This is especially difficult for young people, as noted by my colleague Jonathan Chancellor in his Sydney Weekend column, who quoted Michael Sukkar, the Coalition's shadow housing minster during the 2025 election campaign, criticising APRA's 'one size fits all' rule as preventing nearly 40 per cent of first home buyers from getting a loan. That type of outcome is disastrous for future generations.
But possibly the most absurd thing is that some people already with a mortgage who are struggling to make repayments might see a loan out there with a lower interest rate, but they won't be able to refinance to it because they don't pass the stress test. They might be paying 6 per cent currently, but if they wanted to pay 5.5 per cent, they'd have to prove they can pay 8.5 per cent.
The mortgage stress test can cause plenty of stress for would-be borrowers.
MORE:Aus bank slashes rates to lowest level in two years
Just that 0.5 per cent difference would save you more than $300 a month on a $1 million mortgage and $114,000 over 30 years.
Granted, there is a workaround for some lenders, who are able to use discretion to assess some borrowers at 1 or 2 per cent buffers, but for those who don't qualify?
They are stuck in mortgage prison. And it's looking like APRA hasn't just left the keys in its 'other pants', but has thrown them away altogether. The 3 per cent buffer stayed in place even when the cash rate was at 4.35 per cent and there were borrowers being assessed at 10 per cent in order to get a 7 per cent home loan.
Now that the cash rate and variable rates are both on the way down, adjusting the buffer is becoming less urgent, so expect more borrowers to miss out as APRA stays firm.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
3 hours ago
- News.com.au
Money guru's $612k offer for Aussie homebuyers
It's mixed news for homeowners and house hunters after the RBA's 2025 rate cut hat-trick. Interest rates have fallen significantly for Aussies this year on the back of Tuesday's third interest rate cut for this year. But finance guru Mark Bouris believes that is the end of good news for mortgage holders in the foreseeable future. However truggling Aussie home buyers are being given the chance to save hundreds of thousands of dollars and get into a home much sooner via a new lending option offering up to 105 per cent finance. The finance offering backed by Bouris is aimed at helping Aussie home buyers, including those looking for their first property, a way around many of the onerous hurdles to real estate ownership. Despite recent falls in interest rates, the chance at owning a new home is increasingly beyond the reach of the average Aussie due to continued unaffordability, relentless upward pressure on prices due to a lack of stock and high immigration levels and punishing taxes. 'With every year that passes, there's a new crop of borrowers potentially being locked out of the market. This new generation needs these kinds of lending products to help them climb the property ladder', said Bouris, Executive Chairman of Yellow Brick Road. 'Governments keep introducing demand-side incentives that don't address the root problem. 'Deductible interest, CGT and transfer duty relief all just pour fuel on the fire of demand. We have moved to remove the deposit barrier, focus on new builds, and make the loan affordable. 'That's how we tackle both cost of living and property supply shortages.' Yellow Brick Road has partnered with Empower Money to help buyers overcome many of the difficulties in buying a new home. Non-bank lender Empower Money is offering approved clients up to 105 per cent finance, that will cover the purchase price of approved home and the associated risk fees, eliminating the need for a housing deposit. 'This means that if you're a first homebuyer in a location where transfer duty is covered by the First Home Buyers Grant, you can get a loan approved with no money down and only a minimal contribution of borrower funds,' said Peter Khoury, Chairman of Empower Money. 'Buyers only need to cover application, legal, and settlement adjustment fees. Even if you're not eligible for the First Home Buyers Grant, transfer duty is only a fraction of the deposit cost, which represents a much better borrowing position than having to pay both from the borrower's personal funds.' Empower Money says that in order to 'ensure responsible lending' the product is restricted to vetted new dwellings, including apartments and house and land packages from a national stock list. The new lending product offers a 6.95 per cent interest rate as opposed to most 90 per cent LVR loans that require a 10 per cent deposit. Yellow Brick Road and Empower Money estimates the average Aussie homebuyer can save $612,000 when the time taken to raise money for a home deposit, rental costs and rising property values are taken into consideration. Given it takes around 10 years for potential buyers to save for a 20 per cent deposit. After Tuesday's rate cash which took the cash rate down to 3.85 per cent – the third rate cut this year from the RBA, Bouris said homeowners would be wrong to expect any more cuts in 2025. 'The first thing I would expect is for that rate cut to be passed on across the country by all lenders,' he said. However Bouris believes remaining uncertainty over inflation and unemployment will mean RBA boss Michelle Bullock won't drop rates again this year. 'There is a lot of talk in the media that there will be two more rate cuts this year but I don't think we are guaranteed any more reductions,' he said. 'The language in the RBA notes is pretty clear. Don't listen to what you hear in the press. To me the cash rate it settled at the moment. I just don't see another cut happening. This will be the last rate reduction we will see for 2025.'
7NEWS
15 hours ago
- 7NEWS
RBA cuts rates - But is AI the real threat to Australia's economy?
Flint Group After three interest rate cuts in just six months, the Reserve Bank has sent a clear signal: inflation is under control, and the easing cycle is here. In my previous role as an economist at the Federal Treasury, I saw firsthand how productivity has been at the centre of Australia's economic agenda for decades, yet the ambitious targets have rarely been met. This week, the one key theme I am sharing with home buyers, sellers, and investors with Flint Group, one of Australia's fastest growing mortgage brokerages, is that the RBA's latest move is not just about lower repayments. It has also begun a bigger national conversation about productivity, living standards, and whether now is the moment for reform. Productivity takes centre stage Yesterday's 0.25 per cent cut took the cash rate down by 0.75 per cent since February. That was expected by markets, but what was not expected was the RBA's downgrade to its productivity growth assumptions for the next two years. In plain English, productivity is how much more we can produce without adding extra labour or capital. Higher productivity means higher real wages and better living standards without fuelling inflation. Lower productivity means the opposite, slower growth and tighter household budgets. Governor Michele Bullock made it clear this is not a permanent downgrade, but it is an important reality check. The RBA had been hitting its inflation and jobs targets but consistently overestimating GDP and consumption. The culprit was an overly optimistic productivity assumption. A reform moment? Next week's national Economic Roundtable brings together policymakers, economists, and business leaders to focus on exactly this issue. With inflation easing, rates falling, and the spotlight firmly on productivity, the big question is: can this moment kickstart the reform agenda our country desperately needs to lift living standards? There is also a wild card in the mix, the rise of artificial intelligence. Some believe AI could spark a step change in productivity, transforming industries and boosting output dramatically. Others are sceptical, warning the benefits will take time and may not reach all sectors equally. The RBA is not betting on an AI boom just yet, but it is a key uncertainty that could reshape our economic future. What this means for buyers and sellers Mortgage holders: Another cut means slightly lower repayments, and the RBA is signalling the possibility of more easing ahead. This can free up household cash flow and improve borrowing capacity. Property market: The RBA acknowledged housing is a key channel through which monetary policy works. Lower rates boost buyer confidence, spur activity, and support construction. So far, the rebound has been measured, but momentum could build quickly. Investors: Easing rates lift serviceability, reduce financing costs, and often drive early capital growth as sentiment improves. My message right now This is the time to revisit your borrowing power. Conditions are shifting quickly, and many Australians who felt constrained earlier this year may now be in a much stronger position than they realise. The property market tends to move ahead of official rate cuts, and confidence is already returning. If you wait until the reform debate is settled or AI delivers its promised gains, you may miss the early mover advantage. Whether you are buying, selling, or investing, act strategically but do not stand still. The landscape is changing, and right now, opportunities are emerging. ------------------------------------------------------------
Sky News AU
18 hours ago
- Sky News AU
‘Prioritising dog groomers': Anthony Albanese panned for expanding immigration system, and increasing spending to boost economic growth
Nationals leader David Littleproud has lashed the Albanese government for prioritising wild jobs in the skilled migration program including 'dog groomers' and 'skilled martial arts instructors' to boost economic growth. As the government prepares to address productivity head-on through its economic roundtable, its migration program has again come under fire. Labor is facing accusations of papering over Australia's flagging economy with rapidly boosting the net-migration rate. Net permanent and long-term immigration arrivals reached record levels in the year ending in April 2024, with the net intake in April 2025 also coming in at the highest ever on record at 24,660. This represents a 24 per cent year-on year increase despite the government vowing to substantially reduce permanent migration numbers prior to the May 3 election. In addition, the government's skilled migration cohort prioritises positions such as yoga instructors and martial artists at a similar level of importance as bricklayers, carpenters and plumbers. Tradies had previously been placed behind professions like dog handlers and jewellery designers on the draft "core skills" occupations list. Yoga instructors and martial arts teachers will remain on the list of about 450 professions. Nationals' leader David Littleproud savaged the government's strategy and said that raising immigration and government spending would not solve the nations historic productivity slump. 'The workforce which the government is putting in is competing with private sector employment, and the only way the governments has tried to fix is that is by pouring more people into this country," Mr Littleproud told Sky News. '(The government) is prioritising dog groomers and martial arts instructors rather than those that would add to productivity and grow the pie. 'We have a housing crisis that state and local governments need to lean into and this where some hard decisions need to be made." In a major blow to the government's economic agenda the RBA on Tuesday downgraded its medium-term productivity assumption to just 0.7 per cent year-on-year down from its previous assumption of one per cent. It also warned Australia's economy was incapable of growing faster than two per cent over its forecasts. Despite Prime Minister Anthony Albanese pledging to take steps to reduce both permanent and net overseas migration, it was revealed in early August that the government would move to increase the number of international student placements by 25,000 to 295,000 for 2026. Public sector employment under the Albanese government has also reached record highs, with new figures released by the Australian Bureau of Statistics in June showing the nation now had a million a bureaucrats. The federal bureaucracy alone has ballooned to a record-breaking 213,000 staff, up from a 14-year low of 144,704 workers at the end of 2019. The government also faced intense scrutiny after quietly lowering the English language threshold for visa applicants, with the pass mark for the Pearson Test of English (PTE) being dropped from 30 out of 90 to 24. Mr Littleproud said the government needed to 'be honest about spending' and that bipartisan conversations needed to be had about reigning in federal expenditure. 'There are some bipartisan things we need to look at, the NDIS, we are going to need to have some honest conversations about getting back to first principals on what it was originated for, those that are most in need,' he said. 'We are also going to need to have those conversations about taxation and increasing tax, we need to have a broader conversation about what our tax takes should be. However, he did not explicitly state which taxes the government should look at amending.
