'Misogyny and against transformation': Nkabane after budget rejection
The budget vote was rejected by political parties including the DA and EFF, with some MPs accusing her of failing to lead the department.
Nkabane said the rejection would affect the transformation of the post-school education and training sector.
'It's a pity and unfortunate that we are witnessing some MPs not accepting and adopting the budget,' she said.
'Those who reject the budget are rejecting the transformation of the post-school education and training sector. They are not rejecting the budget of Nobuhle Nkabane. This is not the budget of Nobuhle Nkabane. This is the budget of the people of South Africa.
'When you are against transformation it irritates a lot when you see such a young woman leading such a huge ministry in your presence. It's misogyny. I understand it, I know where it's coming from, and worse when it's a black woman.'
Nkabane has been embroiled in controversy over the appointment of Sector Education and Training Authority (Seta) board chairpersons. The DA laid criminal charges against her for allegedly 'lying' to parliament about the appointment process. Some MPs and the South African Students Congress have called for her immediate removal.
The EFF's Laetitia Arries said Nkabane failed to account for the appointments and address issues faced by students in universities.
'You have failed to lead the nation to the realisation of adequate higher education,' Arries said.
'You have failed to account for appointments that are glaring examples of political patronage, where state institutions intended to empower youth and workers are turning into ANC deployment zones for cadres and family members of the ruling elite.'
Despite the criticism, Nkabane emphasised her department's commitment to rooting out corruption, highlighting plans to terminate contracts with four fintech companies and end a lease agreement in the Western Cape, which would save R2.5m.
She said the EFF should have supported the budget to help address issues faced by the department.
'The sad part of it is that now they are not supporting the budget. My question, I am asking myself, is how we are going to address those issues that have been raised?'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Eyewitness News
35 minutes ago
- Eyewitness News
Simelane accuses DA of shielding man suspected of murdering her sister
CAPE TOWN - As the Democratic Alliance (DA) on Wednesday insinuated that Minister Thembi Simelane is unfit to manage a more than R30 billion Human Settlements budget, she hit back at the party, accusing it of shielding a man suspected of murdering her sister in an apartheid-era crime more than 40 years ago. Simelane said the DA's criminal complaint against her had not resulted in any charges, and the call for her to be fired is part of attempts to detract from the good work she's doing. ALSO READ: Simelane lashes out at detractors, says she's been tried in court of public opinion The former justice minister found herself in the DA's crosshairs in 2024, following investigative media revelations that linked her to the siphoning of funds from the now-defunct VBS bank. At a media briefing ahead of delivering the budget for the Department of Human Settlements, Simelane said that to reject the budget would be to delay even further the provision of decent homes for the millions of people living in the country's 475 informal settlements. In response to corruption allegations against her, Simelane said she won't shirk accountability, but the DA is jumping the gun. 'Now, if an investigation is being done, and you reported the case, but you can't wait for the investigation to be concluded, you now want other things before the investigation. I fear I'm going to disappear, honestly.' Simelane alleged that a former DA representative was involved in her sister's disappearance and death in the 1980s. 'In 2016, when I managed to file charges against him, it was only then that the DA suspended him. Even on my calls to the DA to get a statement of murder against my sister, they didn't. In 2019, three years later, he died.' Simelane also slammed the DA's governance in the Western Cape, saying it had returned R200 million in unspent funds meant for housing.
eNCA
9 hours ago
- eNCA
Minister Creecy tables budget before parliament
CAPE TOWN - It was a day for budget votes. Some were more controversial than others after the DA said it would boycott the budgets of at least two departments presided over by compromised minister. It's the final leg of the national budget process because the Appropriation Bill can only be passed if all departmental votes have been agreed to. One of the less controversial budget vote was for transport – although opposition parties criticised none the less.
TimesLIVE
10 hours ago
- TimesLIVE
DA rejects Simelane, Nkabane departmental budgets
The DA has followed through on its threat to vote against departmental budget votes of ministers who are facing allegations of wrongdoing. This after the party this week voted against budgets of the departments of human settlements and higher education led by Thembi Simelane-Nkadimeng and Nobuhle Nkabane respectively. This decision was taken as a direct response to President Cyril Ramaphosa axing trade and industry deputy minister Andrew Whitfield, of the DA, last week for defying his order that none of the members of his executive were allowed to go to the US at the height of the diplomatic tensions between the two countries. The DA in response argued that Ramaphosa had been harsh on Whitfield and that it was not acceptable that he fired him for such a minor transgression while he still kept Simelane and Nkabane in his cabinet. Unlike Whitfield, the DA argued, Simelane was accused of corruption and Nkabane stood accused of lying to parliament. Instead of dealing with the two ministers who were facing serious allegations, Ramaphosa decided to axe Whitfield for going on a trip without getting permission, the DA argued. DA MP Luyolo Mphithi on Wednesday said his party was voting against Simelane's budget vote because of the corruption allegations she was facing. Mphithi said the DA was concerned that instead of firing Simelane, Ramaphosa had moved her from the department of justice to human settlements. 'You'd think that the response to this that the president would have shown minister Simelane the door, he did not. He asked for the report that he stayed with for three months,' said Mphithi. 'And even though the DA sustained pressure asking the president to act, he lacked courage to act and instead decided to dump minister Simelane at human settlements, one of the most important departments for South Africans.' 'It seems that this president does not take an issue with the fact that a person accused of corruption sits in his cabinet and will have to look after a budget of R30bn that is set aside for South Africans,' he said. Ideally, Mphithi said, the DA would not have a problem with voting for the department of human settlements' budget as it relates to people's housing and security but they could not do it because of the allegations faced by Simelane. 'The DA will always support the granting of funds to house the vulnerable at the same time fast-tracking jobs and growth to give many more South Africans the dignity of being able to buy and own their own houses,' he said. 'And though this budget and the department have many challenges under normal circumstances it would be supported. However, we sit with a minister who faces corruption allegations who has not been accountable to the South African public. And it is because of this we struggle support this particular budget.' Mphithi and the MK Party's Thulani Gumede raised several issues with the human settlements budget presented by Simelane, saying it was not dealing with some of the key issues faced by South Africans in the sector. 'A critical examination reveals a fundamental flaw, an overall real decline in the department's budget. None of its five main programmes demonstrates above-inflation increases,' said Gumede. 'This systemic underfunding of human settlements initiatives will inevitably worsen existing backlogs and impair the progressive realisation of adequate housing.' He said his party could not vote for as it would mean they accepted the decrease in allocation. 'I asserted during the committee meeting last week and I reiterate now that this draft budget must be rejected. It's real term decline across key programmes particularly in integrated human settlements and informal settlements upgrading directly contradicts the constitutional obligation to provide adequate housing and the strategic goals of the national development plans,' he said. 'Accepting this budget will constitute a retreat from addressing deeply entrenched structural inequalities and the pressing needs of the vulnerable communities for basic services and dignified living conditions.'
