Multiple heritage sites in Bengal, Sikkim starved of funds for two-years
The RTI response, accessed by the Sabar Institute, highlights prolonged gaps in conservation funding in the post-pandemic period, even as public interest and footfall at major sites began to recover.
Opinion: A thumbs down for the 'Adopt a Heritage' scheme
According to data shared by the ASI in response to the RTI, monuments in the districts including Cooch Behar, Dakshin Dinajpur, Darjeeling, Malda, Murshidabad, and Purba Medinipur saw no expenditure on upkeep over the two-year span. The lack of maintenance has also been felt in neighbouring Sikkim, where prominent sites like Rabdentse and Dubdi Monastery also received no funding during the same two years.
Increase in visitors
However, the number of visitors has risen post-pandemic, especially to popular sites such as Metcalfe Hall, Hazarduari Palace, Cooch Behar Palace, and the Bishnupur temples. Revenue from entry tickets and filming licences — especially at temples in Bankura and Purba Bardhaman — has also gone up.
'Kolkata has received maximum maintenance expenditure in the post-pandemic era. Many of the major heritage sites received no maintenance after the pandemic,' Annay De, Research Associate, Sabar Institute, one of the people behind the RTI queries, told The Hindu. He also stressed that some of the most significant and culturally rich locations are being affected due to this lack of maintenance and need immediate attention from stakeholders.
Decline in allocation
Yet the overall maintenance allocations have seen a steep decline. ASI sites in West Bengal received ₹4.73 crore in 2019–20 and ₹4.78 crore in 2020–21. This figure dropped significantly in the immediate aftermath of the pandemic and only marginally improved to ₹3.78 crore in 2022–23 — well below pre-COVID levels.
Mr. De added that credit is due to the ASI to a certain extent because they have also managed to raise maintenance expenditure after the sharp decline during the pandemic era.
Experts warn that such prolonged neglect could lead to irreversible damage to monuments and historical structures. 'This isn't just about stone and mortar,' said a researcher at the Sabar Institute. 'It's about memory, identity, and continuity. The cost of forgetting is far greater than the cost of preservation.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
7 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Shortage of teachers hits NEP in colleges
MUMBAI: Government and government-aided colleges across Maharashtra are reeling under a 38% shortfall in teachers, leaving them struggling to implement the requirements of the National Education Policy (NEP). Shortage of teachers hits NEP in colleges According to data obtained through the Right to Information (RTI) Act, 11,918 posts of lecturers and assistant professors in 2,000 government-aided colleges were vacant as of December 31, 2024. The situation is particularly dire in aided colleges affiliated to the University of Mumbai, where there are 2,127 vacancies – a staggering 41%. Colleges say the lack of permanent teachers makes it very difficult to meet the bar set by the NEP. 'We need permanent staff to teach the various courses we need to offer under the NEP,' said the principal of a South Mumbai aided college. 'We are currently hiring teachers on a clock-hour basis, but most of them don't continue beyond six months owing to low remuneration at government-approved rates.' Another college principal in Mumbai, said, 'We started implementing the NEP in our college three years ago, but offering students open electives in the spirit of providing a truly multidisciplinary education is impossible with the current staff strength. Without adequate faculty, the very purpose of the NEP is defeated. We are operating with contractual staff.' According to information sourced from the higher education department by RTI activist Abhay Kolhatkar, the state had sanctioned 31,185 teaching posts in over 2,000 aided colleges across the state, of which 11,918 remain vacant. The shortage of teachers began during the Covid pandemic, which began to unfold in early 2020, when the government ordered a recruitment freeze. Although 3,580 posts for assistant professors had been approved in 2018, only 1,492 were filled before the pause in May 2020. In 2021, another 2,088 posts were sanctioned but recruitment remained sluggish. The challenge has grown since the NEP was rolled out in autonomous colleges in 2023-24, and extended to affiliated colleges in 2024-25. The new policy introduced skill-based and practical subjects, requiring a greater number of teaching hours and specialised instructors. The University Grants Commission (UGC) has directed all states to fill at least 80% of sanctioned posts to maintain their accreditation grades under the National Academic Accreditation Council (NAAC). In July, the state government approved recruitment for over 7,900 teaching posts and more than 2,200 non-teaching posts across universities and government aided colleges. Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis cleared the long-pending drive, which was last attempted in 2022 but had stalled. However, no advertisements have been published so far. Professor Kushal Mude, national convenor of the All India NET and SET Teachers' Organisation, said, 'If a healthy teacher-student ratio is not maintained, the standards set by the central government for NEP cannot be achieved. Nearly 40% of sanctioned posts in aided colleges are vacant, and many private colleges have no full-time teachers. The government must recruit assistant professors in mission mode.'
Time of India
a day ago
- Time of India
TN's Keeladi dig shows us the perils of politicising the past
Archaeology, a science that requires slow, contemplative work to understand the human past through material remains, often makes headlines prematurely in today's India. Digging up the past takes time, and findings are revealed to the public only after thorough scrutiny by the archaeological community. In recent years, however, the rules of engagement have changed. Artefacts go straight from soil to social media, get discussed on popular podcasts, and are speedily co-opted by political narratives. The clues of the ancient past trapped inside a tiny potsherd or bead are overlooked in exchange for instant political gratification. Material evidence is retrofitted to modern concepts of nation-states to help validate ancient literary and religious texts. The Keeladi archaeological excavations sit squarely within this context. Discovered in Tamil Nadu in 2014 by the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI), roughly 12 km from the ancient city of Madurai, Keeladi offered clues of an urban settlement with insights into brick structures, water management, early writing systems, trade, and commerce. The brick structures were a 'rare phenomenon' in the Early Historic phase of Tamil Nadu, dated 300 BCE to 300 CE, making the excavations highly significant. Besides providing insights into the second urbanisation phase in India, the finds allowed for a deeper scrutiny into whether South India urbanised at the same time as the Gangetic plains. Keeladi has captured the public's imagination in Tamil Nadu at scale. The rest of India is only noticing it now, owing to a spat between the archaeologist who discovered the site, K Amarnath Ramakrishna, and his employer, the ASI. Ramakrishna dated the site to the 8th century BCE and the ASI asked for 'concrete justification' for the dating. Ramakrishna, trained by the same agency that was now challenging his findings, refused to change his report. In an interview with this paper, he termed any changes 'criminal'. Keeladi was mired in controversy even in its early days, with Ramakrishna hastily transferred to Assam after two seasons of excavations. The move was seen as a brazen attempt by the Centre to sideline an archaeologist who was in the process of unearthing a unique Tamil civilisation linked to Sangam texts, a rich collection of indigenous literature roughly dated to between 300 BCE and 300 CE. The Keeladi finds were viewed as evidence of these texts. Keeladi also showed that the South was not a passive inheritor of technological advancements from the North in ancient times. It spurred other digs in Tamil Nadu, leading to the revelation that iron may have been smelted in a place called Sivagalai in southern Tamil Nadu as early as 3345 BCE (5,300 years ago) — potentially earlier than anywhere else in the world. But neither Keeladi nor the 'oldest Iron Age site' in Sivagalai has got its share of national spotlight. Contrast this with the Sinauli excavations — discovered roughly around the same time as Keeladi — where the ASI found the remains of a 4,000-year-old horse-drawn carriage and linked it to the Vedic period. Sinauli found a mention in Prime Minister Modi's speech at the World Heritage Committee meeting last year. The chariots now have pride of place in the National Museum and were earlier showcased for visiting G20 dignitaries. The Discovery Channel even commissioned a web series on it, calling it the discovery of the century. Claims of bias in how South Indian excavations are treated and funded are not entirely without basis. In the last five years, the ASI has allocated nearly 25% of its total excavation expenditure to Gujarat, with 94% of that sum allocated to Vadnagar, Modi's hometown, according to parliamentary data analysed by The Print. However, it's worth noting that the ASI has never refused a license to the TN govt, which took over the excavations, to dig at Keeladi or elsewhere. The Keeladi excavations, in its eleventh phase this year, continues to offer an understanding of the unique dialogues that went on in ancient Tamil Nadu. It would be worthwhile for the state, which relies heavily on scientific dating of finds, to release a comprehensive report on it. Not just Keeladi, every excavation in India enriches our understanding of our past. It allows us a peek into a time when the entire subcontinent was culturally integrated beyond the modern states that define our identities today. That glimpse of an interconnected past is perhaps what politicians don't want us to see. So, the real question is: are we investigating the past because of a genuine curiosity about how our ancestors lived and what we can learn from them? Or is it a way to ratchet up tales of glory to distract from today's issues? It might be time to pay attention to what the past is really telling us and let go of convenient conjectures. Facebook Twitter Linkedin Email Disclaimer Views expressed above are the author's own.
The Hindu
a day ago
- The Hindu
After two decades, ASI resumes underwater archaeological studies off Mahabalipuram
The Underwater Archaeology Wing (UAW) of the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) has resumed underwater archaeological studies on submerged remains off the Mahabalipuram coast. The exercise is in continuation of the earlier studies done about two decades ago. The UAW had undertaken archaeological studies at the Mahabalipuram coast in 2001 and subsequently, systematic excavations were carried out in 2004-05, which involved diving operations and surveys. The investigations had provided evidence of submerged structures. Mahabalipuram, a UNESCO World Heritage Site, is known for its rock-cut monuments, temples, and sculptures of the Pallava period (7th-8th century CE). Beyond its monumental architecture on land, the site has long been associated with historical accounts and legends of submerged structures lying beneath the sea. The UAW has launched a new phase of fieldwork at Mahabalipuram, building on the earlier discoveries. The team is equipped with a newly acquired Remotely Operated Vehicle (ROV) which can capture high-resolution imagery and video documentation of submerged remains without causing physical disturbance. The use of ROV not only enables exploration of deeper and more challenging marine environments but also enhances safety and precision in underwater research. The exercise began a few days ago and the ASI team comprised, Alok Tripathi, Additional Director General, Aprajita Sharma, Head of Underwater Archaeology Wing, Assistant Epigraphist, Sanjay Kumar Sharma, Senior Photographer, and assisted by archaeologists of ASI's Chennai Circle. In a post on X, the ASI said that the UAW is 'exploring the submerged remains off Mahabalipuram coast to solve the riddle of the ancient past built during the 7-8th century Pallava dynasty which served as a landmark to the sailors for hundreds of years.' Union Minister of Culture and Tourism, Gajendra Singh Shekhawat, in a post on X, said that the team was being guided by a woman diver-archaeologist. 'Proud of the UAW, out in the waters off Mahabalipuram bringing to light its hidden stories... Thanks to their dedication, the treasures beneath the waves will be cared for, just like the monuments that rise on the shore – for generations to discover and cherish,' he said. The first underwater exploration at Mahabalipuram in 2001 was carried out around the area to the east of the shore temple. Further investigation was conducted in 2004-05 to the north of Shore temple. Systematic study to the north of Mahisasura rock brought to light submerged remains of 'archaeological interest' including three walls and a number of carved architectural members belonging to ancient temples, ASI officials said.
