
Tiffany's $52,000 Patek watch strategy backfires among elite clients
'Everyone wanted that piece,' said luxury watch consultant Oliver R. Müller. 'With rich people, if you tell them they can't have something, they want it. It's the psychology of billionaires.'
The release of the Blue Dial came during the pandemic-era luxury boom. For Tiffany, the timing was ideal. The brand had just entered a new chapter under LVMH Moët Hennessy Louis Vuitton SE, which acquired it for $16 billion in 2021. The acquisition was the largest in luxury history and aimed to reinvigorate Tiffany, whose sales had stagnated before the deal.
But what began as a masterstroke of exclusivity has become a cautionary tale—how mishandled scarcity can tarnish brand prestige.
Since the Blue Dial's launch, Patek Philippe has closed three of its four boutiques inside Tiffany locations. Former staff say the fractured relationship with the Swiss watchmaker continues to weigh on store revenue and staff morale.
Tiffany's press office declined to comment. Executives Kilaniotis and Anthony Ledru were unavailable for comment. However, LVMH maintains that Tiffany's strategic shift—including upscale store renovations and a focus on high-end Icons collections—is paying off.
'We are seeing continued very good progress on Tiffany's transformation plan,' said LVMH Chief Financial Officer Cécile Cabanis in April.
Tiffany remains the biggest contributor to LVMH's watches and jewelry division, which also includes Bulgari and Tag Heuer. Despite that, Bloomberg forecasts the division will post a 1% revenue decline when LVMH reports earnings on July 24.
Patek Philippe declined to comment on its Tiffany relationship or the Blue Dial's distribution.
In a 2021 interview, Patek President Thierry Stern hinted at potential trouble: 'Tiffany executives may not realize how difficult it's going to be to choose the clients.'
The financial logic for Tiffany was clear: If even two-thirds of the watches unlocked $2.5 million each in jewelry sales, the company stood to gain nearly $300 million. Sales staff could reportedly earn six-figure commissions on such deals.
But the execution left many clients bitter. Sources claim staff were warned not to put any bundling expectations in writing. Everything was discretionary—and often inconsistent.
Some loyal clients spent millions and received nothing in return. Others who did receive the watch grew frustrated when they appeared on the secondary market, often depreciating in value.
One client sued Tiffany over a $4 million jewelry purchase tied to a delayed custom necklace, ultimately settling out of court. Sources confirm that the client had purchased the jewelry to access the Blue Dial.
Another client, who was asked to spend $5 million, walked away and sold off his existing Patek watches from Tiffany in protest. 'I don't shop there anymore,' he said.
One entrepreneur from the Tri-State area spent over $2 million, believing the purchase would secure him the watch. Tiffany staff reportedly asked him to keep the amount confidential, since they quoted different spending thresholds to different clients.
Eventually, the backlash led Tiffany to make exceptions—allowing some clients to return items valued at over $75,000, which broke company policy, according to sources.
While Patek officially framed its boutique closures as part of a 'global consolidation,' insiders claim the Blue Dial controversy played a significant role.
Meanwhile, some luxury clients shifted loyalty to rivals like Cartier. According to Euromonitor International, Tiffany's global jewelry market share has dropped by one percentage point since 2022, while Cartier's has increased.
In contrast to LVMH's flat watch and jewelry sales, Richemont—owner of Cartier and Van Cleef & Arpels—reported 14% growth through March 2024.
Symbolically, the Blue Dial was meant to close a chapter. The final release of the 5711 model. The beginning of the LVMH era. 'It was my little gift to say congratulations on buying Tiffany,' Stern said in 2021.
Tiffany had long served as one of Patek's key U.S. partners. Its dual-stamped dials are highly prized. As hype grew, clients were placed on 'wish lists'—a term deliberately used to avoid saying 'waitlist,' which implied delay and disappointment.
When photos of celebrities like Jay-Z, LeBron James, and Leonardo DiCaprio wearing the Blue Dial surfaced in early 2022, frustration deepened among regular clients who had spent millions and still had nothing to show for it.
The bundling tactic—requiring jewelry purchases to access the watch—though common in the industry, remains controversial. Watchmakers discourage the practice, and retailers rarely speak of it openly.
'Watchmakers give stores impossible tasks,' said Eric Wind, of Wind Vintage. 'You get three watches a year with hundreds on a list. So it becomes: Who's spending more?'
In 2023, a California man sued a jeweler for allegedly pressuring him to purchase $221,000 worth of watches and jewelry to access a specific Patek model, which he never received.
In 2024, Hermès faced similar litigation over alleged bundling practices with its Birkin bags—an accusation the brand denies.
In April 2022, Tiffany invited top spenders to an exclusive Miami jewelry gala, where staff told guests that spending $2 million or more might secure them a Blue Dial.
Clients stayed in five-star accommodations, attended lavish dinners, and bought pieces worth millions. Sales exceeded expectations.
However, after the event, some clients who had made large purchases were never offered the watch. Others waited months. Frustration spread.
Auction prices for the Blue Dial have since dropped—from $6.2 million in December 2021 to around $1.2 million in 2024, according to WatchCharts.
Patek, known for its craftsmanship, discourages the reselling of its watches. Still, Tiffany reportedly failed to vet some buyers. Watching the resale values tumble became the final disappointment for many.
Yet the bundling continues. In December 2024, Charlie Ho, a Boston anesthesiologist, was told by Tiffany staff that buying jewelry might help him obtain a gold Patek 5396R.
Ho declined. 'I've played that game,' he said. Years earlier, Ferrari told him to buy several cars to earn access to a limited-edition model. He bought five—and never got it.
'I don't want to play the game anymore.'

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

LeMonde
9 hours ago
- LeMonde
Cognac drags down LVMH's spirits division
The engine driving cognac sales has yet to regain full speed. LVMH acknowledged it in its half-year results, published Thursday, July 24. Moët Hennessy, its wine and spirits division – of which British company Diageo owns 34% – reported an 8% drop in revenue to €2.58 billion. This marks a further slide after an 11% decline over 2024, to €5.9 billion. The blow was even harsher for recurring operating profit, which fell by one-third to €524 million in the first six months of 2025. The group, led by Bernard Arnault, explained the disappointing performance due to "weak demand for cognac" and "the impact on customers of trade tensions weighing on key markets in the US and China." The US and China accounted for 80% of sales of the prized Charente region spirit, whose leading brand is Hennessy. Across the Atlantic, LVMH – and major competitors such as Pernod Ricard, owner of Martell, or Rémy Cointreau, known for its Rémy Martin brand – were caught off guard. After the post-Covid-19 boom, the wave of inflation disrupted consumer behavior. They suddenly became more cautious about spending just as spirits groups continued to raise their prices. The drop-off was abrupt. Chinese customers also adopted a wait-and-see attitude, troubled by their country's economic slowdown. After trade battles On top of this new consumer mindset, fierce trade battles compounded the problem. Since early 2024, cognac has been ensnared in a conflict between Europe and China. The sector breathed a sigh of relief in early July. Although Beijing decided to impose 32% tariffs on European wine-based spirits, most companies that agreed to set a minimum price – in effect, a price increase ranging from 12% to 16% – were granted exemptions. LVMH benefited from this agreement. Likewise, Rémy Cointreau revised down the impact of Chinese tariffs on Friday, July 25, from €40 million to €10 million. Conversely, the impact in the US would rise from €25 million to €35 million.


Fashion Network
13 hours ago
- Fashion Network
LVMH shares rise after mixed bag results with 'glimmers of hope'
Shares in French luxury group LVMH rose on Friday after the group reported quarterly results, with analysts pointing to hopes on the horizon as the group said it saw some signs of recovery in the key Chinese market. LVMH's quarterly sales for products like Louis Vuitton handbags, Dior dresses and Moet & Chandon champagne came in slightly below expectations, at 19.5 billion euros (22.88 billion dollars), down 4% year-on-year, with a 9% sales drop at the group's core leather and fashion division. After an initial dip at market open as investors grappled to get a reading of what Citi analysts called a "mixed bag" of results, LVMH shares steadily reversed course, trading 3.5% up midday and lifting sector peers Kering and Hermes. HSBC analysts said in a note that higher-than-expected profit margins were a sign the group has become more pragmatic and efficient under the leadership of CFO Cecile Cabanis, who was appointed at the end of 2024. Deutsche Bank analyst Adam Cochrane said that while the second-quarter results were not "stellar", there were some "glimmers of hope". "Investors have been waiting for an opportunity to revisit this stock and the conference call highlighted a number of factors which may encourage a tangible recovery in China, market share gains in key brands and potential for structural efficiencies as well as ongoing tight cost management", he wrote in a note. LVMH's finance chief on Thursday said the company saw some "tangible improvement" In China, where a real estate crisis has dampened appetite for luxury goods. French luxury heavyweights have been facing a prolonged downturn as brands also face the threat of U.S. import tariffs.


Fashion Network
13 hours ago
- Fashion Network
LVMH shares rise after mixed bag results with 'glimmers of hope'
Shares in French luxury group LVMH rose on Friday after the group reported quarterly results, with analysts pointing to hopes on the horizon as the group said it saw some signs of recovery in the key Chinese market. LVMH's quarterly sales for products like Louis Vuitton handbags, Dior dresses and Moet & Chandon champagne came in slightly below expectations, at 19.5 billion euros (22.88 billion dollars), down 4% year-on-year, with a 9% sales drop at the group's core leather and fashion division. After an initial dip at market open as investors grappled to get a reading of what Citi analysts called a "mixed bag" of results, LVMH shares steadily reversed course, trading 3.5% up midday and lifting sector peers Kering and Hermes. HSBC analysts said in a note that higher-than-expected profit margins were a sign the group has become more pragmatic and efficient under the leadership of CFO Cecile Cabanis, who was appointed at the end of 2024. Deutsche Bank analyst Adam Cochrane said that while the second-quarter results were not "stellar", there were some "glimmers of hope". "Investors have been waiting for an opportunity to revisit this stock and the conference call highlighted a number of factors which may encourage a tangible recovery in China, market share gains in key brands and potential for structural efficiencies as well as ongoing tight cost management", he wrote in a note. LVMH's finance chief on Thursday said the company saw some "tangible improvement" In China, where a real estate crisis has dampened appetite for luxury goods. French luxury heavyweights have been facing a prolonged downturn as brands also face the threat of U.S. import tariffs.