FYJC admissions: HC halts effect of Maharashtra decision to apply SC/ST/OBC reservation to minority institutions
The court granted the interim relief to colleges run by minority trusts and their association after finding substance in their submissions.
'Accordingly, as far as admission to Class 11 is concerned, the mandate of social reservation shall not be made applicable to any minority educational institutions,' the court held and directed the state government to take steps in that regard. The state will have to update the online admission portal in accordance with court order.
This came after the government lawyer informed the court that she had no instructions from the officials to withdraw the relevant clause in the government resolution issued by the school education department.
On Wednesday, the court asked the government to consider withdrawing the relevant portion of the government resolution. The court also reminded the government that it had withdrawn a similar government resolution in 2019.
A bench of Justices Makarand S Karnik and Nitin R Borkar passed an interim order on a batch of petitions by the Maharashtra Association of Minority Educational Institutions, two minority colleges in Solapur and those from South Mumbai, including Jai Hind, KC, HR and St Xavier's colleges, challenging the government resolution.
Senior advocate Milind Sathe and advocate S C Naidu, appearing for petitioners, argued that the decision was 'arbitrary' and 'imposed without any authority of law' and without hearing or consulting them.
They claimed that minority institutions were excluded from applying social reservations under Article 15(5) of the Constitution and that they can establish and administer educational institutions, as per Article 30 (1).
Government Pleader Neha Bhide, however, defended the decision stating that minority educational institutions' rights were not fettered by the government resolution, as per which she said social reservation was applicable only to the surrendered seats from the minority quota and would not therefore affect such institutions.
As per the established practice followed until the previous academic year, 45 per cent of the total intake in minority institutions was kept open to all students, regardless of category, after allocating 50 per cent for the respective minority community and 5 per cent for the management quota. However, this year, after the impugned government resolution, the FYJC admission portal showed that SC/ST/OBC reservation is being applied to those 45 per cent seats, which led to confusion and controversy in FYJC admissions for 2025-26.
Clause 11 in the May 6 government resolution stated, 'If admissions are lower than the intake capacity in minority quota, admissions can be given as per interchanging between linguistic and religious minority groups. Even after that, if seats remain vacant, those surrendered vacant seats will be filled based on the centralised admission process where all social and parallel reservations are applicable.'
While colleges claimed that the government resolution pertained to leftover seats in the minority quota, government officials had said it implied that social reservation would be applicable to all open (non-minority) seats in minority-trust-run colleges.
Thereafter, the state government issued a corrective resolution on June 2, which implied social reservation to all open seats in minority colleges.
The Association, through its writ plea for setting aside the relevant portion of the government resolution, also sought the court's directive to authorities to take immediate steps to correct/update the online admission portal for Class 11 admissions for the member institutions.
On June 10, the government issued a new corrective government resolution, which brought back the same sentence along with additional inputs from the May 6 government resolution.
The court has asked the state government to file its reply to the pleas within four weeks and posted further hearing to August 6.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News18
7 minutes ago
- News18
IAS Officers Slam Personal Attacks On CEC Gyanesh Kumar's Family After Spat With Rahul Gandhi
Curated By : Last Updated: August 19, 2025, 23:42 IST Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar and Congress leader Rahul Gandhi. (PTI) The IAS fraternity has strongly condemned abuse and personal remarks against Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar and his family, following a tense confrontation between the Election Commission and Congress leader Rahul Gandhi, who has accused the poll body of stealing votes to benefit the BJP. 'We strongly condemn unwarranted abuse and personal attacks against Hon'ble Chief Election Commissioner Shri Gyanesh Kumar and his family. We urge everyone to maintain respect and decorum, acknowledging his dedicated service and significant contributions towards the nation," read a post by IAS Fraternity on X. We strongly condemns unwarranted abuse and personal attacks against Hon'ble Chief Election Commissioner Shri Gyanesh Kumar and his family. We urge everyone to maintain respect and decorum, acknowledging his dedicated service and significant contributions towards the nation. IAS Fraternity 🇮🇳 (@IASfraternity) August 19, 2025 The confrontation between two Constitutional position holders—the CEC and the LoP – began after Rahul Gandhi alleged 'vote theft" and irregularities in the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of voter rolls in the state. The Election Commission has repeatedly denied these 'baseless" accusations and called on Gandhi to sign an affidavit or apologise. ALSO READ: Can India's Chief Election Commissioner Be Impeached? The Law, Politics And Current Row In a departure from norms, the Chief Election Commissioner held a press conference to address Gandhi's 'Voter Adhikar Yatra', where he stressed that the Bihar SIR is aimed at removing all shortcomings in voter lists, while slamming political parties for spreading misinformation. In a tersely-worded speech, Kumar rejected as 'baseless" the allegations of double voting and 'vote theft", saying it was an insult to the Constitution. He also called on Rahul Gandhi to either sign an affidavit or apologise to the country for his claims of vote theft. Swipe Left For Next Video View all Meanwhile, the opposition parties, led by the Congress, said the Election Commission is not acting like an unbiased entity and is in the hands of officers who are taking sides. The parties also accused CEC Gyanesh Kumar of acting like a BJP spokesperson, saying he failed to answer their questions on the SIR exercise. On Sunday, Rahul Gandhi accused the ECI of 'stealing" elections in collusion with the BJP, claiming that attempts were underway to manipulate the Bihar Assembly polls through voter additions and deletions through the SIR exercise. Aveek Banerjee Aveek Banerjee is a Senior Sub Editor at News18. Based in Noida with a Master's in Global Studies, Aveek has more than three years of experience in digital media and news curation, specialising in international... Read More Aveek Banerjee is a Senior Sub Editor at News18. Based in Noida with a Master's in Global Studies, Aveek has more than three years of experience in digital media and news curation, specialising in international... Read More News india IAS Officers Slam Personal Attacks On CEC Gyanesh Kumar's Family After Spat With Rahul Gandhi Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Read More
United News of India
17 minutes ago
- United News of India
Telangana CM appeals for united support to Justice Sudarshan Reddy's Vice-Presidential candidature
Hyderabad, Aug 19 (UNI) Telangana Chief Minister A Revanth Reddy today appealed to all political parties across the Telugu states to rise above politics and support Justice Sudarshan Reddy, who has been declared as the Vice-Presidential candidate by the INDIA bloc. Addressing a press conference at his residence in Jubilee Hills, the Chief Minister said the announcement has brought immense pride to the Telugu people, particularly Telangana. 'After PV Narasimha Rao, it is a matter of honour that a Telugu son from an agricultural family is being fielded for such a high constitutional post,' he said. Reddy contrasted the INDIA alliance's decision with that of the NDA, which he accused of 'vote theft and mocking democracy.' He stressed that the INDIA alliance is fighting to uphold the Constitution with the spirit of Mahatma Gandhi. Calling Justice Sudarshan Reddy a non-political legal expert of high repute, the Chief Minister said, 'He does not belong to any political party. He is a constitutional expert and Chairman of the Independent Expert Committee. This candidature is beyond politics, and it is the responsibility of every Telugu to ensure his victory.' Revanth recalled the political maturity shown in 1991 when TDP founder N T Rama Rao extended support to P V Narasimha Rao, who contested from Nandyal. 'Today, the same wisdom is needed,' he remarked. The Chief Minister appealed to leaders, including Andhra Pradesh Chief Minister N Chandrababu Naidu, former Telangana Chief Minister K Chandrasekhar Rao (KCR), Andhra Pradesh Deputy Chief Minister Pawan Kalyan, the Left parties, and even BJP MPs from Andhra Pradesh and Telangana to support Justice Sudarshan Reddy. 'This is a historic moment to unite beyond politics and protect democracy,' he asserted. Deputy Chief Minister Bhatti Vikaramarka Mallu and other cabinet ministers were present at the press conference. UNI VV SSP
Hindustan Times
37 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Rahul Gandhi claims EC, BJP will steal voter cards, then ration cards and land in Bihar
Congress leader Rahul Gandhi on Tuesday alleged that a "partnership" has been going on between the Election Commission and the BJP to "steal votes" and cautioned people in Bihar that once their right to vote is snatched away, their ration cards and lands will also be taken away. Leader of Opposition in Lok Sabha and Congress leader Rahul Gandhi holding Tiranga during Voter Adhikar Yatra at Nawada, Bihar, India, Tuesday,19, 2025. (Hindustan Times) Gandhi also claimed that the last Bihar Assembly polls were also "stolen" and this truth would come out one day. "When this truth comes out, the Election Commission people should not forget that our government is going to take action against them," the leader of opposition in the Lok Sabha said while addressing a gathering in Nalanda on the third day of his Voter Adhikar Yatra in Bihar. He also asserted that the youth of Bihar will not allow votes to be "stolen". "They will not let it happen because vote is our right and the poor in today's India have only their right to vote left, and if your right to vote is taken away, then your ration card, your land and everything will be taken away," Gandhi said. Alleging that the EC is getting "vote chori" done, Gandhi said that after an analysis the Congress found over one lakh fake voters voted in one assembly segment of the Bangalore Central Lok Sabha seat but the poll body refused to answer and asked him to give an affidavit instead. "EC did not give an answer when we asked for a machine-readable voters' list and videography as it is getting 'vote chori' done," the former Congress chief said. "Don't ask for an affidavit from me, it is your (EC's) of Bihar will come to ask you to give an affidavit, people of Bihar will not let vote chori happen," he said. Gandhi said 65 lakh voters have been deleted in the Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls in Bihar and urged people to not allow this. "We have started this yatra against 'vote chori' that will travel through Bihar," Gandhi said with the crowd responding with the slogan 'vote chor, gaddi chhor'. He also asserted that there is an urgent need to combat unemployment. "We have to finish 'Made in China' and bring in 'Made in India' and 'Made in Bihar'. We have to end unemployment," Gandhi said. Earlier, addressing a gathering at Bhagat Singh Chowk in Nawada, Gandhi said the right to vote has been given to the people by the Constitution and alleged that Prime Minister Narendra Modi, Home Minister Amit Shah and the election commissioners are "snatching" it away from them. "This is your right that has been given to you by the Constitution that you have fought for and Modi, Shah and election commissioners are snatching away from you. (RJD's) Tejashwi (Yadav), me and the other (Mahagathbandhan) leaders standing here want to tell them that we will not let you steal even one vote in (Bihar)," Gandhi said. He alleged that the EC-BJP have "stolen" the elections in Haryana, Maharashtra, and Madhya Pradesh. In Maharashtra, about one crore voters were added through magic between the Lok Sabha and assembly polls, Gandhi said. "Now in Bihar they are carrying out 'vote chori' in a new manner. They are doing this chori before your eyes but we will not let them do vote chori," he said. Cautioning the people, he said, "First your voter card will go, then your ration card will go and then your land would be handed over to Adani and Ambani." This country belongs to farmers, labourers, small traders and the youth, and not to a few billionaires like Adani and Ambani, he said. Gandhi said all the wrong laws, GST, demonetisation are aimed at benefiting a few billionaires. "You give money and resources and the country cannot give you employment, this has to change and that is why we have started this Voter Adhikar Yatra," he said in his address to the people standing atop his vehicle flanked by RJD's Tejashwi Yadav and CPI(ML) Liberation's Dipankar Bhattacharya. At the start of the address, Gandhi asked a person whose name had been deleted from the voters' list to address the people. The person said he had been a polling agent in the Lok Sabha polls but his name had been removed from the SIR of electoral rolls. "There are lakhs of such people in Bihar who voted but their names have been removed from the voters' list," Gandhi said. "There is a partnership going on between the BJP and the Election Commission, they are together colluding to indulge in vote chori," he charged. Rashtriya Janata Dal leader Tejaswi Yadav, while addressing the gathering in Nawada, said that whenever the Lok Sabha elections are held in future, "we will make Rahul Gandhi the prime minister." The leader of opposition in Bihar Assembly targeted the EC on the issue of SIR and said that "vote theft" will not be allowed in Bihar. He also claimed that after "vote theft", people's ration cards and pensions will be snatched away. On Tuesday, the third day of the yatra started from Wazirganj in Gaya and entered Nawada. After this, the yatra reached Nalanda via Sheikhpura. Wednesday is a break day in the yatra and it will again start from Nalanda on Thursday. Gandhi also paid homage to the statue of Bihar's first chief minister Krishna Singh in Sheikhpura. The yatra is being undertaken in a hybrid mode, on foot and by vehicle, as was Gandhi's Manipur to Mumbai Bharat Jodo Nyay Yatra ahead of the Lok Sabha polls. It will also pass through Lakhisarai, Munger, Bhagalpur, Katihar, Purnea, Araria, Supaul, Madhubani, Darbhanga, Sitamarhi, East Champaran, West Champaran, Gopalganj, Siwan, Chhapra and Ara.
