Nearly half of Gen Z and millennials say college was a waste of money—AI has already made degrees obsolete
College is often advertised as the best four years of one's life, but many Americans now have regrets.
More than a third of all graduates now say their degree was a 'waste of money,' according to a new survey by Indeed. This frustration is especially pronounced among Gen Z, with 51% expressing remorse—compared to 41% of millennials and just 20% of baby boomers.
Overall, a growing share of college-educated workers are questioning the return on investment (ROI) of their degree, Kyle M.K., a career trend expert at Indeed, told Fortune. It's something that's not all too surprising considering that the average cost of a bachelor's degree has doubled in the last two decades to over $38,000, and total student loan debt has ballooned to nearly $2 trillion.
'Another 38% feel student loans have limited their career growth more than their diploma has accelerated it,' M.K. said. 'Together, these realities are nudging universities and employers to shift focus from pedigree to practical skill. In fact, 52% of U.S. job postings on Indeed don't list any formal education requirement.'
However, for many young people, this realization is coming too late. Already, some 4.3 million Gen Z have been left behind as 'NEETs'—not in education, employment, or training—with no clear direction on how to restart their early careers.
For young people in particular, who are navigating a less than ideal job market, it can be difficult to see the long-term ROI of college. This is especially true when, for some subjects, like psychology, philosophy, or English, it can take over 20 years in the workforce for the degree to pay for itself, according to the Education Data Initiative.
However, Christine Cruzvergara, chief education strategy officer at Handshake, warns against valuing a degree from a purely quantitative standpoint.
'It's shortsighted to focus only on immediate employment, as that makes the assumption that the value of higher education is only to get your first job,' Cruzvergara told Fortune. 'When in reality, higher education contributes to career advancement opportunities, exposure to a variety of fields, aids in self-discovery, and develops management and leadership skills.'
While nearly 70% of young graduates believe they could do their job without a degree, they may have not been exposed to their network without it. Cruzvergara says that universities are failing to promote that they're more than just a piece of paper that'll open doors after graduation day, but a hotbed for learning and meeting like-minded people while on campus.
For example, Mark Zuckerberg dropped out of Harvard during his sophomore year to focus on building Facebook into the social media empire it is today. But he couldn't have done it without the four cofounders he met at university.
'Gen Z faces a particularly uncertain job market, and there's a need for a better connection between education investment and outcomes,' she adds.
The spread of artificial intelligence into all parts of education and the workplace has made college graduates question their degree even more, with some 30% feeling AI has outright made their degree irrelevant—a number that jumps to 45% among Gen Zers.
This is despite efforts from thought leaders in the space to calm fears about AI replacing workers. 'AI is not going to take your job,' Netflix's co-CEO Ted Sarandos said last year. 'The person who uses AI well might take your job.'
While M.K. admits that skill areas like routine programming, basic data analysis, and templated content creation have become highly exposed to AI, fields like nursing, advanced project management, and creative strategy are relatively insulated.
'AI is more of an amplifier than a pink slip,' M.K. said, adding that above all else, those who prioritize lifelong learning and have open conversations with their employer about AI will be able to soar in the wake of technological advancements.
'AI won't invalidate a solid education, but it will reward those who keep upgrading their toolkit.'
This story was originally featured on Fortune.com
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Los Angeles Times
7 minutes ago
- Los Angeles Times
Huntington Beach pegs Jason Schmitt as new city treasurer
Huntington Beach has appointed just its third city treasurer in nearly 30 years. Jason Schmitt, a former Fortune 500 executive and CEO, was unanimously approved for the position by the City Council on Tuesday night. Schmitt, 48, was sworn in by Orange County Supervisor Janet Nguyen. 'I believe that everyone deserves a shot at their American Dream,' Schmitt said in a speech following his appointment. 'I will bring that exact same spirit to the treasurer's office, as America is just too big for small dreams. Our office's priorities will always be transparency in the collecting of our taxes, and prudence in investing those funds to stretch Huntington Beach's dollars further. My duty is to safeguard taxpayer dollars with integrity, and earn this community's trust with every decision my office makes.' Schmitt succeeds Alisa Backstrom, who had been Surf City's treasurer since 2011. Backstrom, who was reelected in 2024, announced in May that she would be stepping down, effective July 1. The position was also previously held by Shari Freidenrich, the current Orange County treasurer-tax collector who served Huntington Beach from 1996 to 2010. Schmitt, who has a law degree from Harvard University and a master's degree in business administration from Pacific College, said he moved to Orange County about a year ago from Tennessee with his husband, Michael. From 2019-2023, he was chief executive officer for Old Time Pottery, a private equity sponsored home decor retailer in Tennessee. His time as a Fortune 500 executive included stints with businesses like Walmart, Amazon, Gap and Mattel. Huntington Beach has projected budget deficits in future years, though the city was able to draw from reserves to adopt a structurally balanced budget for 2025-26. 'For me, I'm going to start this job like I would any other job, whether we have the biggest budget surplus or biggest budget deficit in the world,' Schmitt said in an interview with the Daily Pilot. 'I'm going to listen, I'm going to ask my team lots of questions, I'm going to gather a lot of information. I'm going to be talking to my team, other leadership in Huntington Beach, having conversations with the residents of Huntington Beach. I'm trying to gather as much information as possible so we have a data-driven perspective, as much information as we can to make good decisions that impact the financial health of our city.' Schmitt was recommended for the position by an ad hoc committee consisting of Mayor Pat Burns and Councilmembers Gracey Van Der Mark and Butch Twining. During public comments Tuesday night, it was brought up that Schmitt had donated $249 each to the city council campaigns of Twining, Don Kennedy and Chad Williams last year. All three council members were elected. 'I've given tens of thousands of dollars to Republicans and Democrats over the last 30 years, across the spectrum,' Schmitt said after the meeting when asked about the contributions. 'I donated to council members in probably six or seven different municipalities in 2024 because I wanted good government. These guys happened to be the folks that we supported in Huntington Beach.' He added that he had no way of knowing that Backstrom would resign just months after being elected. 'It's just a fortuitous accident that those two things happened to occur,' he said. Twining and Kennedy said during the meeting that they did not know of Schmitt until he applied for the position. 'If somebody can think like a CEO and act like a CFO, that is someone that is highly qualified,' Kennedy said. Schmitt, during his speech after he was sworn in, made reference to a 1984 political advertisement by President Ronald Reagan when he said that 'We believe it is always morning in America.' He added that he and his husband have an 85-pound English cream golden retriever named Reagan. 'All great change in America begins at the kitchen table,' Schmitt added, referencing Reagan's farewell address before switching it up a bit. 'Or sometimes, at the dog beach.'
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Saks Fifth Avenue's Latest AI Venture: A Virtual Voice Assistant Called Sophie
Saks Fifth Avenue is getting deeper into AI. The luxury retailer has partnered with two tech companies, NLX and Amazon Web Services (AWS), to provide an AI-powered virtual voice assistant for conversations with customers. More from WWD Monique Billings Talks WNBA Off-court Style, Love for Tyra Banks and More Amazon and Saks Take Their Relationship to the Hamptons Lectra's Maximilien Abadie on Reshaping Fashion's Future With AI and a Consumer-first Mindset Shoppers can call Saks and ask 'Sophie,' the virtual assistant, questions about the status of orders and returns, details on their gift cards, store assistance, price match policy and other subjects. There is also an optional texting component, so if Sophie requests your order number or zip code, you can submit a text with the information, or continue to speak to the virtual assistant. With some tasks, such as changing a password or an address, it's not necessarily practical over a voice-only interface, particularly if a customer does not speak clearly enough. NLX has patented its dual virtual voice and text exchange capability. Saks Fifth Avenue customers also still have the option to request a human assistant. Such virtual voice technologies are widely used by banks, tech firms, health care organizations and 411 directory assistance, but not so much by retailers, with a few exceptions such as Amazon and Walmart. Saks Fifth Avenue implemented the NLX technology in April but just decided to publicize it after piloting it on a limited basis to remove any kinks before fully rolling it out. With the NLX proprietary no-code platform and with the help of Amazon Web Services, Saks built, tested and analyzed voice-first, generative AI-powered conversations in a matter of weeks without needing to tap IT resources. In the future, Saks could enable its virtual voice assistant to respond to a wider set of questions including inquiries on private label credit cards, or to help customers asking for suggestions when they are searching for merchandise. Other possibilities are extending the technology so customers can converse in languages other than English, and extending the technology to Neiman Marcus, Bergdorf Goodman and Saks Off 5th, which along with Saks Fifth Avenue, are part of Saks Global. 'In a nutshell, NLX enables anyone from individuals to very large organizations to build and deploy these conversational applications,' said Andrei Papancea, chief executive officer of NLX, which specializes in conversational AI with a platform for building and managing chat, voice and multimodal applications at scale. 'So if you're a brand like Saks, or United or Toyota which are also our customers, and you want to provide your end customers with the ability to talk to your brand in this free-form natural way, the NLX platform allows you to build such applications.' Comcast and United Airlines are also NLX clients. Amazon also provides the critical infrastructure for operating this technology through its cloud services business unit, Papancea said. NLX stands for natural language experiences, which in technology refers to interactions between humans and computers involving everyday language, not technical inputs. 'Saks Fifth Avenue understands that its customers expect excellence in everything, and their post-purchase service experiences are no exception,' Papancea said. 'At its core, luxury is personal. By thoughtfully integrating advanced technology like NLX, we are not replacing the human touch, we are enhancing it,' said Jessica Bengtzen, vice president of service centers for Saks Global, who listed several advantages to using the NLX technology. She said it 'deflects high-volume inquiries and provide immediate support with no wait times, and improves the customer experience with intuitive, conversational self-service. These time savings scale to measurable gains in workforce efficiency, service speed and bottom-line performance, all while increasing customer satisfaction and driving loyalty.' Bengtzen also indicated that by redeploying some of the workforce, service improves 'across all facets of the customer journey.' Basically, it reduces agent call volume for routine inquiries, enabling them to focus on complex customer needs and prioritize more meaningful customer interactions. So far, the voice technology has decreased agent call volume by about 20 percent, Saks said. 'We are pleased with the early results and positive customer adoption,' said Bengtzen. 'If this momentum continues, we anticipate deploying more broadly across our Saks Global brands.' AI technology can also lead to a reduction in headcount and costs. Asked if the implementation of the virtual voice system has led to, or could lead to some headcount reduction, Bengtzen replied, 'With this technology, our intention is to enhance our teams' capabilities, enabling them to work smarter. By automating routine tasks, we're empowering our teams to focus on higher-value interactions that require human judgment, creativity and care.' As previously reported, Saks Global is seeking to reduce annual expenses by approximately $600 million through consolidations and cutbacks. Saks is navigating a tough business climate marked by a global slowdown in consumer luxury spending which is complicated by Saks' efforts to repair relations with vendors and catch up on hundreds of millions of dollars in unpaid bills. Some vendors have recently been made whole, others not as of yet. Saks Global, considered the largest multibrand luxury retailer in the world, operates 70 full-line luxury store locations, additional off-price locations and five e-commerce websites. Aside from its latest tech innovation with NLX, the group also uses AI for personalizing marketing communications to customers through its websites and mobile apps involving suggesting products they might be interested based on past preferences on styles and brands, and other purposes. Saks has a history working with Salesforce, which uses AI for predictive analytics, personalization and customer relationship management, as well as Amazon, which uses AI for Alexa. In April, Saks Fifth Avenue launched on Amazon's Luxury Stores platform with a storefront. Both Amazon and Salesforce provided financial support for Saks Global's $2.7 billion acquisition of the Neiman Marcus Group in December 2024. Two apparel industry giants also invested in Saks Global's purchase of NMG, the Authentic Brands Group and G-III. Saks' technology initiatives are integral to the agenda at the Saks Global to 'reset' the luxury customer experience, as the company's chief executive officer Marc Metrick has said. The agenda centers around intensifying personalization and bolstering customer service, and involve several operational aspects and integrations, such as inventory sharing between Saks and Neiman's which is currently being tested in one market, enriched data, deeper customer insights and smoother interactions with consumers, and utilizing AI to a greater degree. Thinking of AI innovations for the future, Papancea said: 'Saks Fifth Avenue could roll out, if they were interested, an 'AI personal shopper.' You go and be like, Hey, I'm going to a gala at the Met in two weeks. Here's the theme. What should I wear? And then it won't just come back to you with like textual descriptions. It will give you product recommendations, add them to your cart if you accept, and be able to even check out and pay in that conversational experience. That would also be leveraging unique capabilities from NLX.' Asked if some customers believe they are conversing with a real human versus a virtual voice, Papanceo replied, 'What we recommend to customers is they don't misrepresent that they're talking to a real person like they should say, Hey, I'm the Saks AI assistant. My name is Sophie. I'm here to assist you or to take you to a customer support agent. That's our recommendation to brands.'Best of WWD Macy's Is Closing 66 Stores in 2025 — Here's the List, Live Updates Inside the Demise of Lord & Taylor COVID-19 Spikes Elevate Retail Concerns
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Should step siblings get some of your inheritance? Dave Ramsey gave him some blunt advice
Moneywise and Yahoo Finance LLC may earn commission or revenue through links in the content below. Dividing an inheritance is rarely straightforward, but in blended families, the stakes and emotions can be particularly high. On a recent episode of The Ramsey Show, Jared from Phoenix, Arizona called in to discuss whether he should give some of the $3 million inheritance he received from his late father to his stepsister, since she wasn't happy about being left out of the will. He has already built a nest egg of roughly $750,000 for himself, so he felt guilty for denying her money that could potentially help her later in life. Don't miss Thanks to Jeff Bezos, you can now become a landlord for as little as $100 — and no, you don't have to deal with tenants or fix freezers. Here's how I'm 49 years old and have nothing saved for retirement — what should I do? Don't panic. Here are 6 of the easiest ways you can catch up (and fast) Want an extra $1,300,000 when you retire? Dave Ramsey says this 7-step plan 'works every single time' to kill debt, get rich in America — and that 'anyone' can do it 'She got upset because of the numbers involved,' recounting his stepsister saying: ''I don't understand why we can't all just share?'' Ramsey had a blunt response: 'Because we're not communists.' The situation highlights how difficult it can be to manage the expectations of your loved ones even if you have a simple estate plan in place. Simple plan, complicated emotions Jared described his father's estate plan as relatively simple on paper: both he and his brother received $3 million to $4 million each. However, the fact that his step-siblings have been left out of the will has ignited strong emotions and family drama. This isn't unusual — but at least the direction was clear. Tensions can be amplified if there's no plan at all. According to a 2023 survey by LegalShield, nearly 60% of Americans don't have an estate plan and 58% of people have experienced family disputes due to a lack of a plan. Families can have disputes even when there is an end-of-life plan in place. Of those that had wills, 36% of respondents said their will had surprises for their beneficiaries. Assuming some of these are unpleasant surprises, the potential for family drama is high. Seeking out the help of a professional wills and estates lawyer to proactively prepare a robust estate plan can mitigate some of these issues – though a study by found that 13% of Americans believe that it's too expensive to make a will, while 12% find the process to be cumbersome. But securing your family's future doesn't need to cost an arm and a leg. With Ethos Will & Trust, you can create a will for as little as $149. In as little as 20 minutes, you can create a custom will online. For eligible policies, you can make edits to your will in the future with no additional costs. Plus, you can get a will for free from Ethos Will & Trust with your purchase of a life insurance policy. You can get term life insurance in 5 minutes, with no medical exams or blood tests. You can get a policy with up to $2 million in coverage, starting at just $2/day. Ethos' application process ensures you get flexible coverage options quickly and transparently, allowing you to focus on what matters most. Read more: Do you own rental properties in the US? Avoiding family drama To avoid creating tension within the family over your estate, it makes sense to not only have a plan, but also to talk about it with all your loved ones. By taking the time to inform your family about your plan and all the reasons and motivations behind your decisions, you can eliminate any room for ambiguity. Conflicts can be further reduced if you discuss your will not just with your beneficiaries but also with any other family members who may have been excluded. If you're unsure of the best approach for you, it might be worth speaking with a financial advisor who can help craft a strategy that fits your goals — and gives you peace of mind. can help you find someone that's right for you. This online platform connects you with vetted financial advisors in minutes. How it works is easy: Just answer a few quick questions about yourself and your finances, and the platform will match you with a financial advisor best suited to helping you make your money last in retirement. From here, you can view their profile, read past client reviews and schedule an initial consultation for free with no obligation to hire. Also, having your will vetted by an experienced lawyer can help you ensure your wishes are upheld, even if disputes arise. Wills created through Ethos Will & Trust are vetted by attorneys with decades of experience under their belt. This may make it easier for your beneficiaries in the event your will is contested in probate court. Unfortunately, 35% of Americans don't plan on discussing their inheritance plans with their family, according to a 2024 survey by Edward Jones in partnership with NEXT360 Partners and Morning Consult. Jared's father presumably did not explain to his stepchildren why he was leaving them out of the will. Without this conversation, the family must now follow what's outlined on paper, according to Ramsey. 'Dad already clearly said what he wanted to have happen,' he told Jared. Cohost John Delony agreed: 'Yes, behavior's a language and he was loud and clear.' With this in mind, both hosts encouraged Jared to turn down his stepsister's request. What to read next Robert Kiyosaki warns of a 'Greater Depression' coming to the US — with millions of Americans going poor. But he says these 2 'easy-money' assets will bring in 'great wealth'. How to get in now The biggest myth in real estate investing? That you need big money. Here are 5 ways to grow your wealth — starting with just $10 This tiny hot Costco item has skyrocketed 74% in price in under 2 years — but now the retail giant is restricting purchase. Here's how to buy the coveted asset in bulk Dave Ramsey warns nearly 50% of Americans are making 1 big Social Security mistake — here's what it is and 3 simple steps to fix it ASAP Stay in the know. Join 200,000+ readers and get the best of Moneywise sent straight to your inbox every week for free. This article provides information only and should not be construed as advice. It is provided without warranty of any kind.
