NFL Referees Association calls "conspiracy theories" both "insulting" and "preposterous"
On Monday, Commissioner Roger Goodell pushed back on the suggestion that game officials favor the Chiefs. On Tuesday, the union representing game officials issued a statement expressing appreciation for the Commissioner's remarks.
'Commissioner Goodell's comments that it is 'ridiculous' to presume that NFL Officials are not doing everything possible to make the right call on every play is spot on,' NFL Referees Association executive director Scott Green said. 'Officiating crews do not work the same team more than twice each regular season. It is insulting and preposterous to hear conspiracy theories that somehow 17 officiating crews consisting of 138 officials are colluding to assist one team.'
That's a bit strong. And it teeters on the possibility of protesting too much. The fans who believe that the Chiefs are receiving assistance from the officials believe that the league has made it clear to the officials that they should assist the Chiefs. A conspiracy among the 138 officials isn't needed, if they're taking their directions from 345 Park Avenue.
'There are many things that fans can worry about over a 17-game season, such as coaching decisions, player injuries, the weather and, yes, even close calls on incredible plays made by incredible athletes,' Green said. 'But you can rest assured that on every single down, NFL officials, both on the field and in the replay booth, are doing everything humanly possible to officiate every play correctly.'
That still doesn't prevent subconscious motivations from creeping into the brain of the officials. As we've said in the past, the elimination of the wall between football business and football integrity could easily prompt officials to become keenly aware that money comes from ratings, ratings come from having star quarterbacks available to play, and officials have a role in keeping star quarterbacks healthy.
It's not about the Chiefs. It's about the star quarterbacks. Beyond Mahomes being the biggest star quarterback — and arguably the player most valuable to the entire league — he's consistently playing in the most important games. So if the officials have a subconscious bias to protect star quarterbacks, Mahomes will be the one who benefits from it the most.
It's not a conspiracy. It's a manifestation of the league's belief that, without star quarterbacks available to play, the product will suffer, the ratings will drop, the revenue decline, and there will be less money available to pay everyone — including the officials.
With the Super Bowl approaching, the immediate question is whether the subconscious bias to protect players like Mahomes will, given the talk of the officials favorng the Chiefs, result in a correction that will benefit the Eagles.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Times
29 minutes ago
- New York Times
Patrick Mahomes' future blindside protector? Chiefs have high expectations for rookie Josh Simmons
KANSAS CITY, Mo. — Andy Reid likes to point out that his star quarterback doesn't merely pay attention to the NFL Draft each spring but studies it intently, scouring the class of college prospects so he can identity a handful of players whom he believes might one day help the Kansas City Chiefs win another world championship. Advertisement Mahomes, his coach believes, pores through enough film to put his own draft board together. So when the Chiefs traded back one spot at the end of the first round in April, then took Ohio State left tackle Josh Simmons with the 32nd pick, Reid had a sense of what his quarterback's response was going to be. 'He knew about this kid,' Reid said. Mahomes wasted little time, posting an emoji on X that shared his sentiment. 😎 — Patrick Mahomes II (@PatrickMahomes) April 25, 2025 In other words, the QB approved. The Chiefs might've found the blindside protector for the second half of Mahomes' career. Truth told, it was an easy call for Kansas City, now four months removed from a 40-22 shellacking in Super Bowl LIX. The Eagles didn't just rout them that night in New Orleans, they forced the Chiefs — the league's gold standard for years — to confront some hard truths about the state of their roster and what the next few years for Mahomes could look like if the issues exposed weren't addressed, and addressed promptly. Same as the franchise's Super Bowl LV loss to the Bucs four years prior, this humbling served as a referendum for a leaky offensive line. Mahomes spent three hours running for his life (he was sacked six times and hit 11) and played his worst game as a pro. To get back on track — and have a shot at a fourth Super Bowl triumph in the Mahomes era — it starts in the trenches. 'It's on me to fix it, to get it where it should be,' Reid told The Athletic's Mike Silver last week. Kansas City had camouflaged the problem for months late in the season, shuffling the lineup and chasing some semblance of consistency. At the same time, Reid, Mahomes and Steve Spagnuolo's defense carried the team to a third consecutive Super Bowl berth. But internally, Reid knew. They were living from week to week, and it wasn't sustainable. Eventually, it grew so dire that he had to shift All-Pro guard Joe Thuney out to left tackle, his fourth different starter at that spot since the season opener. Advertisement Patchworking the position that safeguards Mahomes' blindside wasn't going to cut it. It was enough of a worry, Reid later admitted, that 'we thought we'd spend a first-round pick on it.' Enter Simmons. The Chiefs were originally picking 31st in April, but when Eagles general manager Howie Roseman called while Kansas City was on the clock, wanting to trade up a spot, Chiefs general manager Brett Veach's response was succinct: 'You don't have to tell me the player. Just tell me offense or defense.' 'Defense,' Roseman told him. Veach gave the go-ahead on the trade, which netted him an additional fifth-rounder. He knew Roseman would keep his word, and that Simmons would be available. The 6-foot-5, 317-pound Ohio State product initially hit the team's radar early last fall, before a torn patella tendon in his right knee ended his 2024 season. 'Hopefully we're not in a position to take him,' Veach remembers telling himself during the scouting process, 'because he's going to go pretty high.' Both Veach and Reid believed that without the injury, Simmons would've gone inside the top 10. The Chiefs haven't drafted inside the top 10 since trading up for Mahomes in 2017. 'We felt like he was a true left tackle,' Reid said, noting that a big part of Simmons' tool kit that sold them was his ability to anchor in the passing game. The Chiefs' offense, once the most electric unit in the league, has stalled considerably the last two seasons; somehow, Kansas City was 27th in passing plays of 20 yards or more in 2024. The downfield threat has all but disappeared. Part of that was a rash of injuries to the wide receiver room. Another reason was a line that couldn't give Mahomes enough time. The Eagles just happened to expose it stunningly in front of 127.7 million viewers. 'He's the best player in the game,' Veach said of the two-time MVP. 'When Pat is upright, we have some pretty talented weapons (around him).' Advertisement Simmons, Veach said, looks like 'a future starter and difference-maker at left tackle.' What has encouraged the team thus far is his swift recovery from surgery: Simmons is on schedule to be ready for training camp and was participating in 11-on-11 work during Tuesday's first mandatory minicamp practice. 'I wanna be available,' Simmons said after Tuesday's practice. One veteran the Chiefs were thrilled to welcome back was guard Trey Smith, who was on the field Tuesday for the first time this spring. Smith, who was franchise-tagged in March, skipped all of OTAs and is seeking a new deal. 'It's good Trey didn't take my approach,' said teammate Chris Jones, the All-Pro defensive end who held out two years ago all the way into the regular season before signing a five-year, $158 million contract. 'Trey's doing the right thing, man. I think the future plans of the Chiefs is to have Trey around.' Smith is expected to report to training camp in July, and the Chiefs have said they want to get a deal done. Simmons' arrival offers the Chiefs valuable depth at a position of glaring need: The team signed former 49ers reserve Jaylon Moore in the offseason to a two-year, $30 million deal. At this point, Moore is the projected starter at left tackle, which will allow Simmons time to acclimate to the pro game while he continues to strengthen his knee. Simmons said every stage of his rehab has gone to plan, and that he felt 'good straight off the (operating) table' because he had the operation done by Dr. Neal ElAttrache, one of the leading surgeons in the field. For their sake, the Chiefs examined Simmons' knee closely during the draft process and felt confident there would be no lingering effects. So far, so good. On the field, Simmons said the learning curve hasn't been as severe as he'd imagined, something he credits his time at Ohio State for. 'I know what to anticipate,' he said. Another layer to his education is the persistent presence of Mitchell Schwartz, the Chiefs' former right tackle who retired after the 2020 season and remains a sounding board for the team's linemen. Schwartz was on hand Tuesday, watching intently from the sideline. 'He'll give me tips and tricks that'll help me on this play, or what Pat might do on this play that can set me up for a different angle,' Simmons said. Advertisement All that's left are the final stages of Simmons' war with patience — 'I want to be able to throw the pads on ASAP,' he said Tuesday. That won't come until training camp, and the Chiefs have said they won't rush him. Reid has gone out of his way to counsel the rookie, Simmons said, after most practices, stressing the long game. The Chiefs and Mahomes don't need Simmons just yet. In time, they will. (Top photo of Josh Simmons: Charlie Riedel / Associated Press)
USA Today
31 minutes ago
- USA Today
Cowboys former first-round pick has to improve to avoid dreaded bust label
Cowboys former first-round pick has to improve to avoid dreaded bust label The 2024 first-round pick was benched last season, but Dallas is giving him a second shot to protect Dak Prescott's blindside. Tyler Guyton didn't sugarcoat his rookie season performance. He didn't blame injuries... he didn't hide behind coaching turnover... he owned it. That level of mindset is a positive one to hear, especially for a first-round pick who's already facing questions about whether he can live up to his draft status. Bleacher Report's Matt Holder recently included Guyton on his list of 2024 First-Round Picks Who Must Bounce Back in 2025 to Avoid Bust Label, a nod to just how steep the expectations remain in Dallas. "I didn't do too good last season, I want to do better, I want to be the guy that can be depended on," Guyton told reporters. "I'm not gonna make any excuses, I just didn't play as good as I needed to last year. I'm coming with a different attitude this year to become a better player." Guyton, selected 29th overall out of Oklahoma, struggled in both pass protection and the run game. He gave up six sacks, drew 18 flags, and posted a sub-50 overall grade from Pro Football Focus. By the end of the year, the Cowboys benched him in favor of veteran Chuma Edoga. The team made it clear during this offseason's activities they're giving the second-year tackle another chance. Despite a shaky debut, Dallas didn't bring in a veteran to challenge him, instead opting to develop from within. That includes 2023 fifth-rounder Asim Richards, who saw limited action last season, and rookie Ajani Cornelius, who may need time to adjust to the pro level. The trust in Guyton is there, but so is the pressure to step up at a spot still looking to replace future Hall of Famer Tyron Smith. Dallas is still chasing a championship in what feels like the twilight of their current Super Bowl window. With a core that has multiple spots up for grabs, and a quarterback in Dak Prescott who will be 32 and coming off a season-ending hamstring injury, the margin for error is razor thin. And on a line that lost stalwart Zack Martin, who retired this offseason, Guyton stepping up is essential to a young line on a young team looking to return to postseason form. The Cowboys are betting that mindset shift, and another offseason under his belt, will be enough to solidify him as their left tackle of the future. If not, head coach Brian Schottenheimer and his staff could be forced at trying any of the other options waiting in the wings. But make no mistake, the job is still Guyton's to lose. Follow Cowboys Wire on Facebook to join in on the conversation with fellow fans!
USA Today
34 minutes ago
- USA Today
Arizona Cardinals Year 2 player outlook: TE Tip Reiman
Arizona Cardinals Year 2 player outlook: TE Tip Reiman A look 2024 at third-round pick Tip Reiman and his second-year outlook in 2025. The Arizona Cardinals drafted 12 players in 2024. Some of them had contributions as rookies. Some will have greater roles in 2025. Others will have to battle for the roster. They selected tight end Tip Reiman in the third round with the 82nd overall pick. Entering Year 2 in the NFL, let's have a look at his 2025 outlook. TE Tip Reiman's 2024 season Reiman was a quiet consistent contributor on offense as a rookie. He was listed as the No. 3 tight end on the roster behind Trey McBride and Elijah Higgins but he started nine games and logged 450 offensive snaps, playing more than Higgins' 411 snaps. Now, while Higgins had 20 receptions, Reiman was the Cardinals' blocking tight end. He had six catches for 37 yards. He also logged 189 special teams snaps. Tip Reiman's Year 2 outlook for 2025 Reiman in Year 2 probably will have the exact same role as he did as a rookie. The Cardinals like that he has potential upside as a pass catcher, but he is a mauler in the run game. Since Higgins is a better natural pass catcher (he played receiver in college), the way the Cardinals deployed their tight ends probably won't change much. Reiman will have a quiet, critical role on offense and probably will have limited offensive production. Get more Cardinals and NFL coverage from Cards Wire's Jess Root and others by listening to the latest on the Rise Up, See Red podcast. Subscribe on Spotify, YouTube or Apple podcasts.
