
Fascinating look inside US mega factory making artificial food dyes as it races to ditch chemicals
In a sprawling Milwaukee lab facility, lab workers are mixing beet root and carrot juice to obtain the right shades of blues and oranges to replace the technicolor artificial dyes in Americans' favorite snack foods.
People in head-to-toe suiting at Sensient Technologies Corp., one of the world's largest dye-makers, create powdered and liquid dyes out of natural ingredients and store them in a giant warehouse to be shipped out to businesses they contract with.
Dave Gebhardt, Sensient's senior technical director, said: 'Most of our customers [including companies that make candies, sodas, and frozen treats] have decided that this is finally the time when they're going to make that switch to a natural color.'
However, Sensient also fears that it, along with the broader food dye manufacturing industry, will struggle to meet the demand for natural dyes that HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and the wider Trump Administration are compelling food companies to use exclusively by 2026.
It takes up to two years to grow the plants used to make natural colors, including black carrot extract, beet juice, and red cabbage. Synthetic dyes like the controversial Red 40, meanwhile, are relatively easy to make in large quantities.
According to Sensient, there is no guarantee that a robust enough supply of carrots, cabbage, beets, and algae will be available to produce the bright hues of red, orange, blue, and green that Americans have become accustomed to eating.
James Herrmann, marketing director of food colors at Sensient Technologies, said: 'If everybody switches at once, there is simply not enough material around the world available to meet the demand.'
Major manufacturers, such as Sensient, will also need to alter their processing practices to scale up the development of natural products, a costly undertaking that may take longer than the timeline ordered by RFK Jr.
Abby Tampow, a researcher in the lab, is working over petri dishes of red dyes spanning different ruby hues, trying to match the synthetic shade used for years in raspberry vinaigrette dressing.
'With this red, it needs a little more orange,' she told the Associated Press, mixing in purplish black carrot juice and an orange-red tint made from algae.
Sensient is investing in the cultivation of new plant-based ingredients for dyes and broadening its sourcing network for crops from around the world, to maintain a stable supply regardless of climate issues or geopolitical disruptions.
However, adhering to the Trump Administration's new initiative will necessitate a significant scale-up in growing and producing the natural sources of the dyes, which Sensient leadership does not believe is currently feasible.
Paul Manning, the company's chief executive, said: 'It's not like there's 150 million pounds of beet juice sitting around waiting on the off chance the whole market may convert.
'Tens of millions of pounds of these products need to be grown, pulled out of the ground, extracted.'
Furthermore, small bugs called cochineal, which can create the bright Barbie pink used in candies, come from only a few sources, such as prickly pear cacti in Peru. Approximately 70,000 insects are required to produce just 2.2 pounds of dye.
Sensient sources raw materials from global farmers and producers. The ingredients typically arrive in bulk concentrates, which Sensient workers refine into liquids, granules, or powders.
Then, they are supplied to food manufacturers to be used in finished products.
Natural dyes are significantly more challenging to produce, store, and transport than their synthetic counterparts.
It can take around 10 times as much material to make natural colors to mimic just a small amount of artificial dye, which will likely drive up costs for producers.
Light and heat can cause colors to fade or change, or even separate. They are also likely to become chemically unstable with slight changes in acidity.
There are also specific colors, namely blue, that are particularly difficult to maintain during processing.
Manning said: 'How do you get that same vividness, that same performance, that same level of safety in that product as you would in a synthetic product?
'There's a lot of complexity associated with that.'
RFK Jr., flanked by FDA Commissioner Marty Makary, announced last week that the agency will phase out the use of eight petroleum-based artificial food dyes – Red No. 3, Red No. 40, Yellow No. 5, Yellow No. 6, Blue No. 1, Blue No. 2, Citrus Red No. 2, and Orange B.
The new timeline follows a recent meeting in which he urged food industry executives to eliminate artificial dyes from products before the end of his term in 2028.
The FDA has not reached a formal agreement with the food industry to implement these goals, although it appears to have an understanding, and the agency has not presented a detailed plan for achieving them.
RFK Jr suggested more additives could be next, telling the crowd: 'We're going to get rid of the dyes and we're going to get rid of every ingredient and additive in food that we can legally address.
'And for those ingredients we can't ban legally, we're going to start informing Americans about what they're eating.'
Red 40 is among a group of dyes that contain benzidine, a known carcinogen for both humans and animals. While regulators permit trace amounts deemed 'safe,' concerns remain.
In 1985, the FDA estimated that exposure to free benzidine from these dyes could increase cancer risk to nearly 1 in 1 million people, just below the official threshold for concern.
Sensient's CEO Paul Manning emphasized the challenges of scaling natural dye production, noting that the industry can't rely on existing surplus crops like beet juice. Transitioning the market would require cultivating and processing tens of millions of pounds of raw materials
Studies have also linked Red 40 and similar dyes to hyperactivity in children, including those without ADHD. Research suggests that these additives may exacerbate symptoms or induce behavioral changes.
Additionally, Canadian scientists have found that Red 40 (also known as Allura Red) can disrupt gut function, impairing nutrient absorption and increasing the risk of inflammatory bowel diseases (IBD), such as Crohn's disease and ulcerative colitis.
They warn that prolonged exposure may weaken the body's defenses.
Blue 1, another common dye found in candies like gummy bears, has also been tied to hyperactivity and attention issues in kids.
Unlike the U.S., where the FDA often reacts to safety concerns after products hit the market, European regulators ban or require warning labels on many of these dyes, taking a more preventive approach to food safety.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


NBC News
7 hours ago
- NBC News
Walmart is using its own fintech firm to provide credit cards after dumping Capital One
Walmart 's majority-owned fintech startup OnePay said Monday it was launching a pair of credit cards with a bank partner for customers of the world's biggest retailer. OnePay is partnering with Synchrony, a major behind-the-scenes player in retail cards, which will issue the cards and handle underwriting decisions starting in the fall, the companies said. OnePay, which was created by Walmart in 2021 with venture firm Ribbit Capital, will handle the customer experience for the card program through its mobile app. Walmart had leaned on Capital One as the exclusive provider of its credit cards since 2018, but sued the bank in 2023 so that it could exit the relationship years ahead of schedule. At the time, Capital One accused Walmart of seeking to end its partnership so that it could move transactions to OnePay. The Walmart card program had 10 million customers and roughly $8.5 billion in loans outstanding last year, when the partnership with Capital One ended, according to Fitch Ratings. For Walmart and its fintech firm, the arrangement shows that, in seeking to quickly scale up in financial services, OnePay is opting to partner with established players rather than going it alone. In March, OnePay announced that it was tapping Swedish fintech firm Klarna to handle buy now, pay later loans at the retailer, even after testing its own installment loan program. One-stop shop In its quest to become a one-stop shop for Americans underserved by traditional banks, OnePay has methodically built out its offerings, which now include debit cards, high-yield savings accounts and a digital wallet with peer-to-peer payments. OnePay is rolling out two options: a general purpose credit card that can be used anywhere Mastercard is accepted and a store card that will only allow Walmart purchases. Customers whose credit profiles don't allow them to qualify for the general purpose card will be offered the store card, according to a person with knowledge of the program. OnePay hasn't yet disclosed the rewards expected for making purchases with the cards. The Synchrony partnership was reported earlier by Bloomberg. 'Our goal with this credit card program is to deliver an experience for consumers that's transparent, rewarding, and easy to use,' OnePay CEO Omer Ismail said in the Monday release. 'We're excited to be partnering with Synchrony to launch a program at Walmart that checks each of those boxes and will help serve millions of people,' Ismail said.


NBC News
a day ago
- NBC News
Sen. Cory Booker says he won't accept campaign donations from Elon Musk
Sen. Cory Booker on Sunday said that he would not accept campaign donations from tech mogul Elon Musk but urged the former Trump advisor to "get involved right now in a more substantive way" in Democrats' push against the sweeping GOP-backed spending bill. "This bill is disastrous for our long-term economy," Booker told NBC News' "Meet the Press." "This is an American issue, and I welcome Elon Musk not to my campaign. I welcome him right now, not to sit back and just fire off tweets, get involved right now in a more substantive way, in putting pressure on Congress people and senators to not do this." Asked directly whether he would ever accept campaign funding from Musk, Booker said, "I would not accept money from Elon Musk for my campaign, but I would be supportive of anybody, including Elon Musk, putting resources forward right now to let more Americans know," about the bill. Booker's remarks come as other Democrats, like California Rep. Ro Khanna, have floated welcoming Musk into the Democratic party after a feud between President Donald Trump and the Tesla and SpaceX CEO exploded into public view last week. "We should ultimately be trying to convince him that the Democratic Party has more of the values that he agrees with,' Khanna told Politico last week after Musk and Trump fired off a series of social media posts online criticizing each other. The falling out started after Musk called the budget bill a "disgusting abomniation" in a post on X. In subsequent posts on Truth Social, the president accused Musk of "wearing thin" and said "he just went crazy." Musk later accused Trump of " ingratitude" in another post on X after he spent $250 million boosting Trump's campaign in 2024 and accused Trump of links to deceased sex offender Jeff Epstein in a now-deleted post. On Saturday, in a phone call with NBC News, Trump said he has no desire to repair his relationship with Musk after their public spat. The president also responded to a direct question about what might happen if Musk decided to financially support Democrats in the 2026 midterm elections, days after Musk wrote in a post on X,"In November next year, we fire all politicians who betrayed the American people," appearing to refer to Republicans who voted for the GOP-backed spending bill in the House. 'If he does, he'll have to pay the consequences for that,' Trump told NBC News, adding that there could be "serious consequences." In May, House Republicans passed a sweeping domestic policy bill called the "One Big Beautiful Bill Act" that extends tax cuts passed in the first Trump administration, increases funding for border security and eliminates federal taxes on tips and overtime pay. The bill has also drawn scrutiny from Democrats for slashing funding for Medicaid and some food stamps while implementing work requirements for Medicaid, which provides healthcare for low income Americans. Musk and some Senate Republicans have blasted the bill for estimated effects it could have on the federal debt and deficit, though Trump and House Republicans have downplayed those concerns. "More Americans have to understand that if this bill passes, average Americans are going to see their costs skyrocket as this president again pushes legislation that is indicative of his chaos, corruption and cruelty towards Americans," Booker said on Sunday.


The Independent
2 days ago
- The Independent
Katie Miller, Stephen Miller's wife, in a ‘tricky situation' after Musk and Trump's falling out
Katie Miller, the wife of White House Deputy Chief of Staff Stephen Miller, recently departed from the Trump administration to work for Elon Musk, days before the spectacular falling out between President Donald Trump and the billionaire. The 33-year-old Miller was one of Musk's first hires as he established the Department of Government Efficiency and began reducing the federal workforce. She left the administration alongside him last week. Like Musk, she was designated as a 'special government employee' during her time in government, which allowed her to work for Musk and Trump, as well as in the private sector, simultaneously. Miller even helped to set up the departing press conference in the Oval Office featuring Musk and Trump, according to The Wall Street Journal. Musk and Trump's relationship fell apart in public on Thursday, with Musk unfollowing Stephen Miller on X. Friends of Miller told the paper that she was in a difficult position between Trump and Musk. 'Katie Miller was a critical reason DOGE was able to get off the ground and deliver massive cuts to waste, fraud, and abuse for the American people,' White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt told the outlet. This isn't the first time that Miller has been caught in the crossfire of a Trump feud. Miller also worked for then-Vice President Mike Pence when Trump began attacking him for not aiding him in his attempt to overturn the 2020 election towards the end of his first term. However, at the time of the January 6, 2021, Capitol riot, she was on maternity leave. In December last year, Miller became one of the first DOGE staffers announced by the then-president-elect. However, her work at DOGE soon became the catalyst for disagreements with the White House, where top Trump aides argued that she hadn't sufficiently convinced Musk to work alongside the administration. Top administration officials told The Journal that she often spoke on behalf of Musk, issued orders about what agencies should do, and how the government's work should be communicated. Officials were concerned about her continuing work for P2. However, she left the firm after The Journal published an article about her work there. She then also departed the White House to work for Musk, just before the blowup between the billionaire and the president. Miller has been described as having endless energy and as being fiercely protective of her husband. Current and previous co-workers told The Journal that she could go from charming to abrasive. Those who know her told the paper that she has a 'YOLO' tattoo on the inside of her lip. Miller has at times worked for clients while lobbying the government, simultaneously addressing government issues. She quickly rose through the ranks after being hired in 2015 by Republican U.S. Sen. Steve Daines of Montana. Former Daines aide Jason Thielman told The Journal that 'Everything was always at full speed, full throttle.' 'Sometimes, she just exhausted people, and they gave her what she wanted,' he added of her battles with reporters. She joined the Department of Homeland Security during Trump's first term before working for Pence. It was during her time at DHS that she met Stephen Miller. 'Every Trump White House had its divisions, but she was always willing to go to bat to protect the VP's prerogatives,' Pence's Chief of Staff Marc Short told the paper. Following the insurrection, Stephen Miller kept working for Trump, and she remained in Pence's office. While she was placed on Pence's postpresidential payroll, partly because she needed healthcare, according to Pence's advisors, his office subsequently severed connections with her after Stephen Miller began working with then-President Trump. He continued to target his former vice president. After joining the Republican consulting firm P2 Public Affairs following Trump's 2021 departure from office, she subsequently became the top point of contact between Musk and the 2024 Trump campaign. She often joined Musk at events and then began advising Robert F. Kennedy, who later became Secretary of Health, Education, and Welfare, now known as Secretary of Health and Human Services. Pence opposed Kennedy's appointment, and in January of this year, Miller took aim at her former boss, saying that he only had 'family values' when it was 'politically expedient' and called him a 'footnote of American history.'