Pro-Palestine online content in UK risks censorship, rights groups warn
Content in support of Palestinians published online could be misconstrued as supporting Palestine Action, a protest group that was proscribed under anti-terrorism laws on July 5, The Guardian reported on Saturday.
Index on Censorship, Open Rights Group and other organizations have written to Ofcom, the UK's independent communications regulator, to request clarification on the matter.
Signatories to the letter also warned that online content objecting to Palestine Action's banning could be misidentified as unlawful support for the group.
Open Rights Group's Sara Chitseko, a pre-crime program manager, told The Guardian: 'Crucial public debate about Gaza is being threatened by vague, overly broad laws that could lead to content about Palestine being removed or hidden online.
'There's also a real danger that people will start self-censoring, worried they might be breaking the law just by sharing or liking posts related to Palestine and nonviolent direct action.
'This is a serious attack on freedom of expression and the right to protest in the UK. We need to ensure that people can share content about Palestine online without being afraid that they will be characterised as supportive of terrorism.'
Major online social media platforms such as Facebook, Instagram and TikTok have been advised by Ofcom that they can avoid concerns about meeting the requirements of the Online Safety Act if they are more stringent with censoring content than is mandated by the act.
The letter sent to Ofcom by the rights groups warned: 'This approach risks encouraging automated moderation that disproportionately affects political speech, particularly from marginalised communities, including Palestinian voices.'
The UK, unlike the EU, lacks a mechanism through which users can appeal the censoring of their online content.
Signatories to the letter — which was also sent to Meta, Alphabet, X and ByteDance, owners of the world's top social media platforms — called for the creation of a British dispute mechanism to discourage the censoring of lawful content.
The letter added: 'We are concerned that the proscription of Palestine Action may result in an escalation of platforms removing content, using algorithms to hide Palestine solidarity posts and leave individuals and those reporting on events vulnerable to surveillance or even criminalisation for simply sharing or liking content that references nonviolent direct action.
'We are also concerned about what platforms understand by their legal duties regarding expressions of 'support' for Palestine Action.'
An Ofcom spokesperson said: 'We have provided detailed guidance to platforms about how to identify the particular types of illegal and harmful material prohibited or restricted by the act, including how to determine whether content may have been posted by a proscribed organisation.
'There is no requirement on companies to restrict legal content for adult users. In fact, they must carefully consider how they protect users' rights to freedom of expression while keeping people safe.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Arab News
4 hours ago
- Arab News
Italian judges dismiss case against Meloni over release of Libyan suspect
ROME: An Italian judicial body has dropped a case against Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, who had been placed under investigation following the release of a Libyan police officer wanted by the International Criminal Court, she said on Monday. Osama Elmasry Njeem was freed in January and flown home in an Italian state aircraft just days after being detained in the northern city of Turin under an ICC arrest warrant for alleged crimes against humanity, including murder, torture and rape. 'The judges dismissed the case only against me,' Meloni said in a post on social media X. She was under investigation for allegedly aiding and abetting a crime and misuse of public funds. Meloni added that based on the document she received, magistrates will pursue the case against Interior Minister Matteo Piantedosi, Justice Minister Carlo Nordio and Cabinet Undersecretary Alfredo Mantovano, who had been placed under investigation with her. 'I maintain that this government acts cohesively under my leadership: every decision, especially one so important, is agreed upon. It is therefore absurd to request that Piantedosi, Nordio and Mantovano stand trial, but not myself, before them,' Meloni wrote on X. The ICC has been investigating allegations of serious crimes committed in Libya since the country's 2011 civil war following a referral by the UN Security Council. Justice Minister Nordio told parliament in February that Italy had no choice but to free Elmasry due to mistakes and inaccuracies in the arrest warrant.
Arab News
7 hours ago
- Arab News
UK's Royal Ballet and Opera cancels Tel Aviv ‘Tosca' after staff protest over stance on Gaza
LONDON: The UK's Royal Ballet and Opera has canceled a planned 2026 production of 'Tosca' at the Israeli Opera in Tel Aviv, after nearly 200 members of staff signed a letter criticizing the organization's ties to Israel amid the war in Gaza, it was reported on Monday. For the latest updates, follow us on Instagram @ Company chief executive officer Alex Beard confirmed the decision in an internal message in which he acknowledged the letter and told staff: 'We have made the decision that our new production of 'Tosca' will not be going to Israel.' A total of 182 members of the Royal Opera and Ballet, including dancers, musicians, singers and technical staff, signed the open letter on Friday denouncing the 'recent actions and decisions taken by the RBO in the context of the ongoing genocide in Gaza.' In particular, they condemned the recent hiring out of the organization's 'Turandot' production to the Israeli Opera for performances that took place last month, The Guardian newspaper reported on Monday. 'The decision cannot be viewed as neutral,' they wrote. 'It is a deliberate alignment, materially and symbolically, with a government currently engaged in crimes against humanity. 'The venue itself, the Israeli Opera, publicly offers free tickets to soldiers of the Israeli Defense Forces 'in recognition of their work,' as stated on their website. 'The RBO is clearly making a strong political statement by allowing its production and intellectual property to be presented in a space that openly rewards and legitimizes the very forces responsible for the daily killings of civilians in Gaza.' The letter demanded that the organization 'withholds our productions from institutions that legitimise and economically support a state engaged in the mass killing of civilians,' and rejects 'any current or future performances in Israel.' It also offered support for performer Daniel Perry, who raised a Palestinian flag on stage during a curtain call on July 19 in what the letter described as 'an act of courage and moral clarity.' It accused the RBO's director of opera, Oliver Mears, of reacting aggressively. 'We witnessed (Mears) attempting to forcibly snatch the flag from the performer, displaying visible anger and aggression in front of the entire audience,' the letter said. 'Far from being a neutral administrative intervention, (his) act was itself a loud political statement. It sent a clear message that any visible solidarity with Palestine would be met with hostility.' Perry has stated that Mears subsequently told him he would 'never work for the Opera House ever again.' The employees who signed the letter also highlighted what they described as a 'deafening' double standard, noting the organization's open support for Ukraine following the invasion by Russia in 2022, adding: 'We understood then that silence was unacceptable. Why is it different now?' In response, Beard said: 'I am appalled by the crisis in Gaza and recognize the deep emotional impact this has had across our community and wider society. On this issue, we acknowledge and respect the full range of views held by our staff, artists and audiences. 'The events at the curtain call on July 19 were without precedent. We have reflected carefully and reviewed our internal protocols. We always endeavor to act with integrity and compassion. We want our stage to remain a space for shared cultural appreciation, free from individual political statements.' The RBO's support for Ukraine was 'aligned with the global consensus at the time,' he added, but global geopolitics had become more complex and so the organization's stance had changed to ensure its actions reflected its 'purpose and values.' The Israeli Opera removed details of the production of 'Tosca' from its website but has not commented on the cancellation.
Al Arabiya
7 hours ago
- Al Arabiya
Police arrest UK far-right figure ‘Tommy Robinson' over serious assault
Police arrested British far-right activist Stephen Yaxley-Lennon, known by the pseudonym Tommy Robinson, on Monday on suspicion of committing assault last week at a London train station. British Transport Police said in a statement they arrested a 42-year-old man at Luton airport, north of London, 'in connection to an assault at St Pancras station on 28 July.' 'The man had been wanted for questioning after leaving the country to Tenerife in the early hours of 29 August following the incident at St Pancras,' it said. Although the statement did not directly name Yaxley-Lennon, he was seen in a video widely shared on social media last week of an incident at Saint Pancras. Yaxley-Lennon is seen walking next to a motionless man laying on the floor, alleging that the man had 'come at me.' He was arrested on Monday after returning to Britain on a flight from Portugal 'on suspicion of ... grievous bodily harm and will now be taken to custody for questioning.' Yaxley-Lennon has become a champion for far-right and anti-immigrant factions. The former football hooligan, who founded the far-right English Defense League in 2009, has repeatedly been convicted for public order and contempt offences. He has also been blamed for helping fuel racially aggravated riots that rocked the country in 2024, which he denies.
