Putin's proposal to end Ukraine war includes land transfers, easing sanctions and more, sources say
would relinquish tiny pockets of occupied
Ukraine
and Kyiv would cede swathes of its eastern land which Moscow has been unable to capture, under peace proposals discussed by Russia's
Vladimir Putin
and
Donald Trump
at
their Alaska summit
, sources briefed on Moscow's thinking said.
The account emerged the day after Mr Trump and Mr Putin met at an air force base in Alaska, the first encounter between a US president and the Kremlin chief since before the start of the Ukraine conflict.
Ukrainian president
Volodymyr Zelenskiy
is due to travel to Washington on Monday to discuss with Mr Trump a possible settlement of the full-scale war, which Mr Putin launched in February 2022.
Although the summit failed to secure the ceasefire he said he had wanted, Mr Trump said in an interview with Fox News' Seán Hannity that he and Mr Putin had discussed land transfers and security guarantees for Ukraine, and had 'largely agreed'.
READ MORE
'I think we're pretty close to a deal,' Mr Trump said, adding: 'Ukraine has to agree to it. Maybe they'll say 'no'.'
The two sources, who requested anonymity to discuss sensitive matters, said their knowledge of Mr Putin's proposals was mostly based on discussions between leaders in Europe, the US and Ukraine, and noted it was not complete.
Mr Trump briefed Mr Zelenskiy and European leaders on his summit discussions early on Saturday.
It was not immediately clear if the proposals by Mr Putin were an opening gambit to serve as a starting point for negotiations or more like a final offer that was not subject to discussion.
At face value, at least some of the demands would present huge challenges for Ukraine's leadership to accept.
[
Russian politicians hail Trump-Putin summit as a victory for Moscow and its narrative on Ukraine war
Opens in new window
]
It is understood Mr Putin's offer ruled out a ceasefire until a comprehensive deal is reached, blocking a key demand of Mr Zelenskiy, whose country is hit daily by Russian drones and ballistic missiles.
Under the proposed Russian deal, Kyiv would fully withdraw from the eastern Donetsk and Luhansk regions in return for a Russian pledge to freeze the front lines in the southern regions of Kherson and Zaporizhzhia, the sources said.
Ukraine has already rejected any retreat from Ukrainian land such as the Donetsk region, where its troops are dug in and which Kyiv says serves as a crucial defensive structure to prevent Russian attacks deeper into its territory.
Russia would be prepared to return comparatively small tracts of Ukrainian land it has occupied in the northern Sumy and northeastern Kharkiv regions, the sources said.
Russia holds pockets of the Sumy and Kharkiv regions that total about 440sq km, according to Ukraine's Deep State battlefield mapping project. Ukraine controls about 6,600sq km of Donbas, which comprises the Donetsk and Luhansk regions and is claimed by Russia.
Although the Americans have not spelt this out, the sources said they knew Russia's leader was also seeking – at the very least – formal recognition of Russian sovereignty over Crimea, which Moscow seized from Ukraine in 2014.
[
Nauseating charade as Putin comes out of international purgatory on Trump's red carpet
Opens in new window
]
It was not clear if that meant recognition by the US government or, for instance, all western powers and Ukraine. Kyiv and its European allies reject formal recognition of Moscow's rule in the peninsula.
They said Mr Putin would also expect the lifting of at least some of the array of sanctions on Russia. However, they could not say if this applied to US as well as European sanctions.
Mr Trump said on Friday he did not immediately need to consider retaliatory tariffs on countries such as China for buying Russian oil – which is subject to a range of western sanctions – but might have to 'in two or three weeks.'
Ukraine would also be barred from joining the Nato military alliance, though Mr Putin seemed to be open to Ukraine receiving some kind of security guarantees, the sources said.
However, they added that it was unclear what this meant in practice. European leaders said Mr Trump had discussed security guarantees for Ukraine during their conversation on Saturday and also broached an idea for an 'Article 5'-style guarantee outside the Nato military alliance.
Nato regards any attack launched on one of its 32 members as an attack on all under its Article 5 clause.
Joining the Atlantic alliance is a strategic objective for Kyiv that is enshrined in the country's constitution.
Russia would also demand official status for the Russian language inside parts of, or across, Ukraine, as well as the right of the Russian Orthodox Church to operate freely, the sources said.
Ukraine's security agency accuses the Moscow-linked church of abetting Russia's war on Ukraine by spreading pro-Russian propaganda and housing spies, something denied by the church which says it has cut canonical ties with Moscow.
Ukraine has passed a law banning Russia-linked religious organisations, of which it considers the church to be one. However, it has not yet started enforcing the ban. – Reuters
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
European leaders to discuss potential security guarantees for Ukraine with Donald Trump
The leaders of Ukraine and several other European states will discuss potential future security guarantees for the war-torn country with US president Donald Trump on Monday. The meeting follows a summit held in Alaska on Friday between Mr Trump and Russian president Vladimir Putin, and claims by a White House envoy that Russia has dropped its opposition to the West providing Nato-style defence pledges to Kyiv. Steve Witkoff said: 'We were able to win the following concession: that the United States could offer Article 5-like protection, which is one of the real reasons why Ukraine wants to be in Nato.' The Article 5 clause of Nato's founding treaty enshrines the principle of collective defence, the notion that an attack on a single member is considered an attack on them all. READ MORE He told US television on Sunday that this is a 'game changing decision' and 'the first time we had ever heard the Russians agree to that'. He did not provide details of what was discussed. There are concerns among Ukraine's supporters that Volodymyr Zelenskiy could face significant pressure in Washington on Monday, given his February talks with Mr Trump in the Oval Office descended into a shouting match . However, this time he is expected to be accompanied in Washington by the leaders of Germany, France, Italy, the UK and Finland, along with Nato secretary general Mark Rutte and European Commission president Ursula von der Leyen . Mr Trump's relations with European leaders can be prickly, and it is notable that the group includes several who he reportedly likes: Italy's Giorgia Meloni , Britain's Keir Starmer , Finland's Alexander Stubb and Mr Rutte of Nato. [ The Irish Times view on the Trump-Putin summit: a shameful day in Alaska Opens in new window ] European leaders who make up the 'coalition of the willing' on Sunday agreed Russia would face more sanctions and wider economic measures if it does not stop its bombardment of Ukraine. Speaking after the virtual conference, which was co-chaired by Mr Starmer and French president Emmanuel Macron , Mr Zelenskiy said: 'It is important that America agrees to work with Europe to provide security guarantees for Ukraine.' 'We need security to work in practice like Article 5 of Nato,' he said. Mr Zelenskiy said he also considers EU accession to be 'part of the security guarantees'. Taoiseach Micheál Martin, who also participated in Sunday's conference, said Ukraine needs 'strong, credible, long-term security guarantees', which means EU membership and sustained support from Europe and the US. [ Ukraine has right to make decisions on its territory, says Taoiseach after Trump comments Opens in new window ] Meanwhile, US secretary of state Marco Rubio said there will 'have to be some security guarantees for Ukraine' because 'if this war were to end, they have to make sure this never happens again'. [ Trump pressing Ukraine for a quick deal after failed summit is a clear triumph for Putin Opens in new window ] 'For there (to) be a peace, the Russian side is going to have to accept that Ukraine is a sovereign country that has a right to defend itself and has a right to enter into alliances with other countries to defend itself,' he added. 'What guarantees are built in there that are enforceable, that's what we'll be talking about over the next few days.' Russia's core demands include Ukraine's handover of five regions, agreement to abandon its bid to join Nato and acceptance of other limits on its sovereignty. Kyiv says any such deal would amount to capitulation. The Kremlin has previously rejected the prospect of western peacekeepers overseeing a deal to end the war. The Alaska summit was widely seen as a victory for Mr Putin, because Mr Trump scrapped a threat to impose more heavy sanctions on Russia and dropped demands for an immediate ceasefire in favour of Moscow's call for an overarching agreement to end the war. After the summit, which was lauded by the Kremlin, Mr Trump publicly urged Kyiv to 'make a deal' while reportedly telling Mr Zelenskiy that Russia was demanding the full withdrawal of Ukraine's forces from its Donetsk and Luhansk regions.
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
Ukrainians in Ireland not optimistic about success of peace talks with Putin
For the Republic's huge Ukrainian community, the outcome of current peace talks will determine many of their futures. Some 100,000 Ukrainians live here, the vast majority of whom arrived since the Russian invasion in February 2022. Many have decided to stay in the Republic; others, though, will return home if peace can be achieved. Most doubt it will happen any time soon. Ukraine Action in Ireland (UAI) chairwoman Lisa Karamushka is in the east of the restive country where the war continues. READ MORE 'I can't see any major optimism here ... Just constant everyday shelling of the cities and soldiers fighting back attack after attack,' she said. Ukraine Action in Ireland chairwoman Lisa Karamushka in her home country. UAI was set up among Ukrainian refugees in Ireland and their supporters to provide medical aid and equipment to the front. So far UAI has sent 32 ambulances and 52 medical evacuation vehicles to Ukraine. Ms Karamushka said the sight of the red carpet being rolled out for Russian president Vladimir Putin in Alaska was 'humiliating and devastating'. 'After all the death and destruction ... Trump still considers him [at the] same diplomatic level of a partner to make negotiations with.' She believes there is nothing new in Putin's demands, which amount to wanting the world to recognise Crimea and Donetsk as part of Russia, while retaining Ukraine as part of Russia's sphere of influence. 'We have heard absolutely nothing we haven't heard before and no indication of a desire to end this war. Yet, Trump claims he has reached success. We don't see any,' she said. She takes some solace in Ukrainian president Volodymyr Zelenskiy travelling on Monday with Europe's most important leaders. 'This gives me hope he will be in stronger position, as Europe has been so far our major supporter. Overall I'm probably not expecting anything to change, probably even hope it won't get worse,' she said. Ukraine's soldiers are the 'sole reason' for its continued independence, democracy and existence, she said. Olena Tregub, who is based in the Republic and works for the Ukrainian non-governmental organisation Nako, said expectations of a successful outcome are 'extremely low'. She believes Mr Trump and his principle negotiator, Steve Witkoff, 'fundamentally misunderstand the Russian president. 'They fail to see that for Putin, this war is not about material interests, nor even about territory. It is an ideological war. It is about the destiny of Ukraine,' she said. 'Putin wants to break Ukraine, to reduce it to a vassal of Russia,' she said. 'That goal has not been achieved. Which means Putin is nowhere near ready for peace.' She believes Mr Trump took a 'reckless gamble' in meeting Mr Putin without any deal agreed in advance. 'In doing so, he gave Putin legitimacy, handed over his own political capital and risked everything only to walk away empty-handed,' she said. 'The visuals from Alaska were disastrous: American soldiers kneeling to roll out the red carpet for Putin's plane, Trump and Putin walking together on that carpet, even riding in Trump's car. 'These images were not only humiliating for the USA internationally, but ... many Americans also saw this as a shameful display.'
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
The Irish Times view on the Trump-Putin summit: a shameful day in Alaska
Ideology and personal idiosyncrasy play a large part in the dynamics of the Trump administration, alongside the urge to create spectacle and dominate the news cycle. That was all on display during Friday's Trump-Putin summit in Alaska. But another recurring theme was also glaringly obvious: the US president's submissive sycophancy towards autocrats in general and the Russian leader in particular. The aftermath has left Ukraine facing the prospect of a peace plan that looks very like capitulation. The day after the meeting, Trump broke with Kyiv and its European allies by backing Putin's proposal for a sweeping settlement based on Ukraine ceding territory it still controls. That is not a path to peace but the validation of conquest. Before the meeting, Trump had insisted a ceasefire was his urgent priority. That stance has been abandoned. He now believes a rapid deal is possible if Ukraine hands over the remainder of the Donbas, including areas not occupied by Russian troops. In exchange, Putin has offered a ceasefire along current battle lines and a written promise never to strike Ukraine or Europe again. History offers ample evidence of the hollowness of such promises. Only days ago, Trump was threatening new economic penalties should Putin walk away from Alaska without a deal. Those threats have now been shelved. Once again, the US has moved at Putin's pace, not its own. READ MORE European leaders have been scrambling to adjust to the new reality. France, Germany and the UK reaffirmed their stance that there could be no discussion of peace until the killing stops. Privately, officials expressed disbelief at Trump's claim that 'all' had agreed to leapfrog a ceasefire. Volodymyr Zelenskiy was excluded from the Anchorage talks, watching from afar as Trump indulged Putin's maximalist demands. European leaders including Emmanuel Macron, Friedrich Merz, Keir Starmer and Ursula von der Leyen will now join Zelenskiy for Monday's meeting with Trump in Washington. Their task is clear but daunting: to re-anchor American policy in the shared Western strategy that Trump has just casually discarded. Their efforts will be especially focused on clarifying the vague and deeply unsatisfactory statements on security guarantees that have emanated from Washington over the past 48 hours. Trump's bowing of the knee to Putin undermines Western unity, weakens Ukraine's negotiating hand and signals to Moscow that aggression yields rewards. That is not diplomacy in the service of peace. It is theatre in the service of vanity. The cost will not be measured in news headlines but in Ukrainian lives and in the further erosion of trust between the US and its allies. What unfolded in Alaska was not statesmanship. It was appeasement.
