Players Call for MLB to Avoid Drastic Rule Change
Players Call for MLB to Avoid Drastic Rule Change originally appeared on Athlon Sports.
Major League Baseball fans have spent the past three months demanding the league adopt the Automated Ball-Strike System, perhaps as early as this year's postseason.
Advertisement
We know how the fans and social media users feel, but what about the players themselves?
Great question. The Athletic published a player poll on Wednesday, asking 134 respondents if they're in favor of 'robo-umps' calling balls and strikes. Surprisingly, 63.4% said they're against having technology dictate what is and is not a strike.
'If the umpires leave the game,' an AL starting pitcher said, 'I don't want to be a part of it.'
Added a National League pitcher: 'Why would you remove the human element? The game will fundamentally change in a way that fans are definitely not going to like.'
MLB umpire Shane Livensparger (43) and New York Yankees pitcher Carlos Rodón (55) discuss a call on June 6, 2025John Jones-Imagn Images
More players said that they were unsure (19.4%) about the ABS than they were in favor (17.2%) of the change.
Advertisement
Social media accounts like @UmpireAuditor and @UmpScorecards use data to hold umpires accountable. The @UmpireAuditor page found that umpires blew 954 calls, including 52 strikeouts, from June 2-8.
As is typically the case in player polls, none of the players quoted were named. All quotes were anonymous, allowing players to express their concerns about the ABS and its potential impact.
Some players, naturally, cited the strike zone itself.
'I used it years ago when I was in the Fall League,' a hitter recalled. 'Guys would bounce curveballs that somehow nicked the zone. It hit the plate, but it's a strike somehow?'
Advertisement
Others suggested that the ABS could hurt catchers, especially those who rely on their glove and framing ability to stick around.
'That's our food, stealing strikes,' one catcher said.
Several players even defended umpires, the same ones with whom they clash over controversial calls.
'When that guy's having a good game and we're on the same page and everything's clicking, that's [expletive] baseball,' one NL pitcher said. 'We don't need a freaking robot.'
Related: Outraged Fans Call for Umpire Jordan Baker's Firing After Blue Jays-Twins Game
Related: Fans Outraged at Umpire Over Calls in Phillies-Athletics
This story was originally reported by Athlon Sports on Jun 11, 2025, where it first appeared.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
30 minutes ago
- New York Post
Pete Alonso reveals what has to happen for him to retire with Mets
Access the Mets beat like never before Join Post Sports+ for exciting subscriber-only features, including real-time texting with Mike Puma about the inside buzz on the Mets. Try it free Pete Alonso could see himself playing his entire career in Queens — if one important thing works out. The star Mets first baseman and his dad spoke with The Post's Steve Serby this week, and when asked about finishing his career with the Amazin's, Alonso said it 'could be awesome' if it all works out on the 'business' end of things. Advertisement 'That could be awesome. It's really rare for a guy to spend his whole career with one team — I mean, I've thought about it, for sure,' Alonso said. 'But the business side of things has to work out for that. I love playing here. It's awesome. I hope that the business side works out to be that way. Pete Alonso #20, reacts after hitting a double in the 4th inning. Charles Wenzelberg / New York Post 'I hope that the business side works out to where I don't have to do that [leave].' Advertisement A protracted free agency kept Alonso's Mets future in limbo this past offseason. But he eventually signed a two-year, $54 million contract — with an opt-out after 2024 — shortly before spring training to remain in Queens. So far, it has paid dividends for both Alonso and the Mets, as he's in the midst of a career year. Advertisement Through 70 games, Alonso has a .298/.397/.584 slash line — which would all mark career-bests — with 17 home runs and an MLB-leading 22 doubles and 63 RBIs. His 179 OPS+ also leads all National League hitters. Pete Alonso is in the middle of a career year with the Mets. Corey Sipkin for the NY POST It comes one year after Alonso's rocky contract season, in which he posted a career-low .788 OPS in the regular season before hitting one of the most iconic home runs in franchise history in the ninth inning of the win-or-go-home game of the wild-card series against the Brewers. Advertisement 'I want to see [him] succeed wherever he's at, so it would be great if he retires as a Met,' his dad, Peter, told The Post. 'And, if he doesn't, I wouldn't want to be in the other dugout.'
Washington Post
33 minutes ago
- Washington Post
Twins place Royce Lewis on injured list, Byron Buxton leaves game with elbow injury
HOUSTON — The Minnesota Twins placed third baseman Royce Lewis on the 10-day injured list Saturday with a left hamstring strain. Also on Saturday, center fielder Byron Buxton left the game against the Astros in the seventh inning with a bruised left elbow after being hit by a pitch an inning earlier.
Associated Press
36 minutes ago
- Associated Press
Twins place Royce Lewis on injured list, Byron Buxton leaves game with elbow injury
HOUSTON (AP) — The Minnesota Twins placed third baseman Royce Lewis on the 10-day injured list Saturday with a left hamstring strain. Also on Saturday, center fielder Byron Buxton left the game against the Astros in the seventh inning with a bruised left elbow after being hit by a pitch an inning earlier. Lewis was injured running to first base on a single in the ninth inning of Friday night's 10-3 loss to Houston and had an MRI on Saturday. A team spokesman announced the move during Saturday's game and said they'd have more information after the game. The injury to Lewis comes after he missed the first 35 games of the season with a moderate strain of the same hamstring that occurred running out a ground ball in spring training. Lewis, the first overall pick in the 2017 draft, has been plagued by injuries in his career. He played just 82 games last season while missing time with a severe quadriceps strain and a groin injury. Those injuries came after he tore the ACL in his right knee in both 2021 and 2022. Lewis, who homered Friday night, is hitting .202 with two home runs and nine RBIs in 30 games this season. Houston starter Hunter Brown plunked Buxton on the left elbow to start the sixth inning. He was looked at by a trainer but remained in the game before being replaced in center field by Harrison Bader in the bottom of the seventh. ___ AP MLB:
