Industrial Court orders Perak FC to pay RM1.04m to ex-coach Lim Teong Kim for unfair dismissal
Court chairman D Paramalingam said the amount was based on the remaining 16 months of Lim's two-year contract, which was terminated on May 24, 2023, just eight months into his tenure.
The award stated that Lim, 61, would receive RM1,040,000 based on his agreed monthly salary of RM65,000.
'There can be no reinstatement under the circumstances as the said contract had come to an end by effluxion of time,' Paramalingam said in the 60-page decision released this week, as reported by FMT.
He ruled that Perak FC's decision to sack Lim mid-season over poor performance was premature, unjustified and driven by commercial concerns, noting the club's finances had already been affected by its 'dwindling fortunes' before Lim's appointment.
'When the company appointed Lim, they were well aware it was going to be a long and arduous task of restoring glory to Perak football. They sacked him even before he could fully produce the results,' Paramalingam was quoted as saying.
The court also found that allegations of misconduct levelled against Lim were not serious enough to justify termination.
'A final warning was given and Lim was instructed to issue a public apology to the media,' he said, adding that Lim complied, but the company later revisited the same issues to justify dismissal — despite the termination letter only citing unsatisfactory performance.
Paramalingam reportedly said this amounted to 'double punishment', which was 'inequitable and unconscionable'.
Tensions worsened when members of the management allegedly orchestrated a players' mutiny by secretly gathering complaints against Lim at a hotel in Kuala Lumpur on April 11, 2023, the award said.
'That is what the company chose to do when they could no longer find any fault with Lim after he heeded their final warning,' Paramalingam added.
Lim, a former national player capped 60 times between 1982 and 1996, has over two decades of coaching experience, including a long stint with Bayern Munich's youth team from 2000 to 2012.
He also headed Malaysia's National Football Development Programme and coached the national U-16 squad.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
an hour ago
- The Sun
Industrial court orders Perak FC to pay RM1.04m to ex-coach Lim Teong Kim
THE Industrial Court of Malaysia has ruled that Perak FC Sdn Bhd must pay RM1.04 million to former head coach Datuk Lim Teong Kim for prematurely terminating his contract. Court Chairman J. Paramalingam stated in a 60-page judgment that Lim is entitled to compensation for the unexpired portion of his fixed-term employment contract. With 16 months remaining on his contract, Lim's compensation was calculated based on his monthly salary of RM65,000 multiplied by the remaining duration. Lim had also claimed EUR15,477.81 (RM76,471.39) for three business-class return flights from Munich to Kuala Lumpur, as stipulated in his contract. However, the court ruled that this claim should be pursued through a civil suit rather than an unfair dismissal case. Paramalingam noted that Lim's two-year contract, which began on Sept 15, 2022, was terminated on May 24, 2023, just eight months in. He clarified that reinstatement was impossible as the fixed-term contract had expired naturally. The court dismissed Perak FC's claim that Lim was 'ill-equipped' for the role, attributing the team's struggles to the club's mismanagement. Paramalingam deemed the termination premature, stating Perak FC's mid-season performance (11th place) was close to the targeted ninth position. He criticised the club's decision as a knee-jerk reaction, suggesting financial pressures influenced the termination. The court highlighted that Perak FC's financial struggles predated Lim's appointment, undermining their justification for dismissal. Lim's legal team, Edward Andrew Saw Keat Leong and Jerry Low Kok Kiang, represented him, while Perak FC was defended by lawyer Weera Premananda. Lim filed a complaint with the Perak Department of Industrial Relations on June 27, 2023, seeking unpaid salary for the remaining contract period. The ruling underscores the legal protections for fixed-term contracts in Malaysia's employment landscape. - Bernama
Malay Mail
3 hours ago
- Malay Mail
Police detain doctor's wife and sons, seize RM420,000 worth of cannabis at Kelantan home
KOTA BHARU, Aug 10 — Two men, the sons of a doctor, and their mother have been detained in connection with the seizure of 35 kilogrammes of compressed cannabis and a pistol in a raid at a house in Kampung But, Ketereh here yesterday. Kelantan Police chief Datuk Mohd Yusoff Mamat said the stepbrothers, aged 24 and 34, who work as assistants at their father's clinic, and the 46-year-old housewife were picked up at 4.30am. 'Checks at the house found six boxes containing compressed blocks of dried plant material suspected to be cannabis and two bags containing the same drug weighing 35kg, worth about RM299,590. 'Also seized was a Glock pistol with 16 bullets and a casing, estimated to be worth RM5,000,' he told a press conference at the Kelantan Police Contingent headquarters here today. Mohd Yusoff said four vehicles — a BMW 523i, a Mercedes-Benz C200, a Perodua Bezza and a Naza Ria — worth a total of RM116,000 were also confiscated, bringing the total estimated value of the seizures to RM420,000. Mohd Yusoff said the syndicate is believed to have been active since 2023, using the house as storage before distributing the drugs via courier services. The quantity seized could supply about 35,000 addicts. 'The men tested positive for methamphetamine and ketamine while their mother tested negative,' he said, adding that all suspects have been remanded for seven days starting August 6 for investigation under Section 39B of the Dangerous Drugs Act 1952. In a separate case, Mohd Yusoff said the General Operations Force Battalion 7 seized a revolver, 30 live bullets and a casing from a Thai couple at a house in Pengkalan Kubor on July 25. The married couple, aged 40 and 30, did not possess a valid firearms licence and had entered Malaysia illegally. He said they were detained for investigation under the Firearms (Increased Penalties) Act 1971 and the Immigration Act 1959/63.— Bernama
The Star
3 hours ago
- The Star
Ex-Perak coach Teong Kim awarded RM1.04mil in unfair dismissal case
PETALING JAYA: Former Perak coach Datuk Lim Teong Kim has won his unfair dismissal case against Perak FC Sdn Bhd, with the club ordered to pay him RM1.04mil in compensation. Industrial Court chairman D. Paramalingam said the award was based on the remaining 16 months of Teong Kim's two-year contract, which was terminated on May 24, 2023, just eight months into his tenure. The 61-year-old was earning RM65,000 a month and the court ruled that Perak FC's decision to sack him mid-season over poor results was "premature and unjustified". Paramalingam noted that the club's finances were already under strain due to its "dwindling fortunes" even before Teong Kim took charge and that the allegations of misconduct levelled against him were not serious enough to warrant termination. Teong Kim, who earned 60 caps playing for Malaysia from 1982 to 1996, boasts more than two decades of coaching experience. He spent 12 years with Bayern Munich's youth set-up from 2000 to 2012 and later served as the head of Malaysia's National Football Development Programme and coach of the national Under-16 squad.
