How the world can pressure Pakistan on terrorism
advertisement
First, cessation of military action has held, but the current equilibrium is unstable. The position of the two countries on substantive issues remains widely divergent. In spite of India's stern message, there is a surreal atmosphere of triumphalism in Pakistan. The army has consolidated its position, at least for now. The Pakistanis seem encouraged by the relatively neutral stance of the US, for reasons not yet fully clear, during the recent crisis. Therefore, we need to keep a close eye on Pakistan over the coming weeks and months, while using the communication channel between the DGMOs to impart greater stability to the situation.Second, our political and media discourse has generated unrealistic expectations regarding our goals vis-a-vis Pakistan. This was evident in the widespread disappointment at our government's rational decision to cease military action on May 10 after Pakistan came around to doing so. Let us be clear that Pakistan is not about to collapse or disintegrate, is not a pushover militarily, and a fight to the finish with a nuclear armed country is an extremely dangerous proposition. The intended message having been delivered through Operation Sindoor, we need to eschew jingoism and bring realism in our public discourse on Pakistan.
Third, Pakistani terror against us has gone down significantly from its heyday. Nevertheless, there is no sign of the Pakistani establishment giving up its hostility towards India or its corollary—the instrument of terror. Therefore, our terror grid must remain in top gear. However, a goal of zero terrorism is unrealistic because in spite of their best efforts, security forces cannot prevent the enemy from slipping through our defences occasionally.Fourth, our experience during the recent crisis has shown yet again that the policy of isolating Pakistan has its limitations. The international community is well aware of Pakistan's deep involvement in terrorism, but is wary of a military escalation under the nuclear overhang. While our concerns on terrorism are much better appreciated today than till the turn of the century, other major countries, including Pakistan's partners in the Islamic world, go by their own interests and are not about to abandon it. This should not prevent us from using our growing clout to bring as much international pressure as possible to bear on Pakistan. An obvious area is to work with our partners to bring Pakistan again under greater scrutiny from the Financial Action Task Force.advertisementFifth, calibrated covert punitive activity and grey-zone tactics, with less chance of an escalation, should in general be our preferred response to Pakistani terror. However, for obvious reasons, chest-thumping about such activity is counterproductive. Further, coercion, though indispensable in managing Pakistan, should be a means to an end, with its impact being leveraged at an appropriate stage through dialogue and diplomacy to nudge the adversary to a more reasonable posture. Coercion as an end in itself is prone to heightened violence and volatility.Lastly, though China was not directly a party to the military skirmish with Pakistan, the China-Pakistan nexus was palpable through the crisis. This growing nexus demands an increase in allocation of resources to our armed forces.advertisement—Sharat Sabharwal is a former High Commissioner to PakistanSubscribe to India Today MagazineTune InMust Watch
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
27 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Govt approves maiden cadre restructuring of BSF
New Delhi, The government on Wednesday approved the first-ever cadre review of the Border Security Force in 60 years of its existence enhancing its manpower by about 4,000 personnel between constable and inspector ranks. Govt approves maiden cadre restructuring of BSF A BSF spokesperson said the decision pertaining to the Group B and Group C employees will result in "immediate" promotions to a total of 23,710 personnel. The about 2.65 lakh-strong BSF, raised in 1965, is primarily tasked to guard Indian borders with Pakistan in the west and Bangladesh in the east apart from rendering a variety of duties in the internal security domain of the country. "The Government of India has approved the very first cadre review of BSF Group B and C employees, spanning from constable to inspector and its implementation has already begun," the spokesperson said. The order was issued by the Ministry of Home Affairs after approval from the ministry of finance, and officials said that the cadre restructuring of the two service groups of personnel has led to a net gain of 3,994 posts in the jawan and subordinate officers rank. The spokesperson said this will be a "significant" morale boosting step by the government post Operation Sindoor for "career progression" within the "cutting edge" rank and file. "The review is expected to improve promotion avenues from constable to inspector that will provide significant respite to them from existing stagnation, thereby enhancing overall morale and professional development of force personnel," he said. He also said the decision will lead to a total promotions of 23,710 personnel out of which orders for 8,116 personnel in different ranks were issued by the force headquarters on Wednesday. BSF recruits its personnel from the entry-level of constables who get promoted to the next rank of head constable to the higher posts of assistant sub-inspector, sub-inspector and inspector or subedar major in the B and C group posts. The officers of the force are recruited in the Group A service apart from the Indian Police Service who join the force on deputation. This article was generated from an automated news agency feed without modifications to text.
The Hindu
27 minutes ago
- The Hindu
India-Russia-China consultation to intensify: Jaishankar to visit Moscow, Wang Yi to visit New Delhi
Against the backdrop of growing uncertainty in trade ties with the United States, India is on track to intensify engagements with Russia and China in the coming days. External Affairs Minister S. Jaishankar is scheduled to visit Russia on August 21 to hold discussion with his Russian counterpart Sergey Lavrov as officials here are preparing to host Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi before that, sources here have confirmed. 'The Ministers will discuss key issues on our bilateral agenda, as well as key aspects of cooperation within international framework,' said the Russian Foreign Ministry announcing Mr Jaishankar's visit to Moscow. Mr Jaishankar's visit is part of the preparatory consultation for the next Russia-India annual summit for which President Vladimir Putin is expected to visit India later this year. The meeting between Mr Jaishankar and Mr Lavrov comes days after National Security Adviser Ajit Doval visited Russia where he met his counterpart Sergey Shoigu and had a special audience with President Putin. Soon thereafter, President Putin and Prime Minister Modi had a telephonic conversation on Friday that Mr Modi described as 'detailed'. India is yet to officially announce the visit of Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi though sources indicated that it is being scheduled ahead of Mr Jaishankar's visit to Moscow. Sources said that the visit is understandably aimed at continuing high level discussion on the India-China border issue and Wang Yi will meet National Security Adviser Ajit Doval and others during his visit. The India-China interaction will be keenly watched as it is being planned three months after Operation Sindoor when India fought a brief war with Pakistan. Lt General Rahul R Singh, Deputy Chief of Army Staff said in July that China provided 'live inputs' to Pakistan during the conflict. It is understood that Wang Yi's interactions in Delhi will also be part of the preparatory meetings before Prime Minister Narendra Modi's expected visit to Tianjin, China for the summit of the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO). However, India will remain cautious while warming up ties with Beijing because of China's strong relationship with Pakistan, sources have hinted. Also read | The new battle challenge of China-Pakistan collusion In the context of fast-moving global developments these interactions on India-China and India-Russia tracks are taking place as Russia and China are also carrying out consultations with other global and regional stakeholders. Russian official news agency, TASS has reported that before reaching New Delhi, Mr Lavrov will travel to Alaska with President Putin for the August 15 summit with U.S. President Trump that India has welcomed. In a statement, Official spokesperson of the Ministry of External Affairs described the summit that comes after more than three years of Russia-Ukraine conflict, as a move that holds the 'promise' of ending the conflict. On August 11, Prime Modi held a telephone conversation with Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelenskyy and emphasised the need for a 'peaceful settlement' of the conflict. In the backdrop of President Donald Trump's imposition of tariffs on India for purchase of Russian oil, India has carried out a number of consultations with partners and stakeholders. Prime Minister Modi has spoken on phone with Brazil's President Lula Da Silva. On August 12, Mr Modi spoke with President Savkat Mirziyoyev of Uzbekistan when the two leaders discussed connectivity and transit projects including the International North-South Corridor that aims to ease overland transport to Russia.
Time of India
41 minutes ago
- Time of India
'Strategic mistake': Former diplomat Vikas Swarup warns US against ties with Pakistan; links Trump's tariffs on India to Brics, Operation Sindoor
Former diplomat Vikas Swarup NEW DELHI: Former diplomat Vikas Swarup on Wednesday cautioned that the United States is making a "strategic mistake" by deepening ties with Pakistan, a country closely aligned with China, which he called a strategic competitor of the US. He also spoke on rising trade tensions, saying Washington's recent tariffs on Indian goods are part of a broader pressure tactic. "I think it's a strategic mistake on the part of the US that you are getting into bed with Pakistan, which is in bed with China. China is the US' strategic competitor," said the former high commissioner to Canada during an interview with ANI. His remarks come after Pakistan Army Chief Gen Asim Munir made provocative statements in Florida, suggesting Pakistan could use nuclear weapons to "take down India and half the world" in an existential crisis. Addressing ongoing trade tensions between New Delhi and Washington, Swarup noted that India had resisted pressure from the US to open its agriculture and dairy markets, describing recent 50% tariffs by US President Donald Trump as part of a broader pressure tactic. Swarup highlighted that President Trump imposed 50% tariffs on Indian goods due to India's BRICS membership and Operation Sindoor . "We have to understand why these tariffs have been imposed. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like How Ken Koh revived ailing family business in S'pore to produce the 'Rolls-Royce' of soya sauce CNA Read More Undo I personally feel that there are three reasons. One, Trump is not happy with India because we are a member of BRICS and somehow, in his head, he has got this notion that BRICS is an anti-America alliance which is hell-bent on creating an alternative currency to the dollar. So, because of that, he feels that India should not be a member of the BRICS. Two, Operation Sindoor and his so-called role in bringing about the ceasefire," Swarup said. Swarup added, "We have been saying right from the beginning that Trump had no role because we do not accept external mediation. This ceasefire was mediated directly between the DGMOs of Pakistan and India at the request of the DGMO of Pakistan. Trump has now said almost 30 times that it was he who got the two countries to stop back from the brink, who stopped a nuclear conflagration in the subcontinent. So, obviously he is miffed that India has not acknowledged his role, whereas Pakistan has not only acknowledged his role but has even nominated him for a Nobel Peace Prize. " India had carried out Operation Sindoor in early May in response to the Pahalgam terror attack and carried out precision strikes on terror infrastructure in Pakistan and PoJK. India had repelled subsequent Pakistani aggression and targeted its airbases. The former diplomat also underscored that the US is pushing India to sign the Bilateral Trade Agreement (BTA) with favourable terms for the US, particularly in dairy, agriculture, and GM crops. He further added that India has not caved in to US pressure, and the tariffs are part of Trump's pressure tactics. "...This is part of his pressure tactics to get India to sign on the dotted line on the maximalist demands that the US is making with regard to access to our dairy and agriculture and GM Crops. We have not caved in and it is also in a way a signal to Russia because he is also frustrated that he has not been able to get President Putin to agree to the ceasefire that Zelenskyy has agreed to," Swarup said, as quoted by ANI. Swarup referred to the summit meeting between President Trump and President Putin in Alaska on August 15 over the Ukraine conflict. He predicted that if the talks yield positive results, Russia's sanctions will likely be lifted, as Putin won't accept a ceasefire while facing economic sanctions. "Now they are meeting in Alaska on 15th August. If there is a positive outcome of the Alaska talks then I am 100% sure that the Russia sanctions will be off the table because Putin is not going to accept a ceasefire and yet be saddled with economic sanctions," he said.
