SC delivers key ruling on discom regulatory assets; power bills likely to go up across India
The Supreme Court has directed all states and Union Territories to clear power distribution companies' regulatory assets within four years, potentially raising electricity bills nationwide. This ruling addresses the accumulation of over Rs 1.5 lakh crore in regulatory assets, accumulated by discoms like BSES and Tata Power, mandating a roadmap for their recovery and strict audits by regulatory commissions.
Reuters India Power Sector (Image for representation) In a ruling that may have huge impact on consumers across the country, the Supreme Court on Wednesday asked all states and Union Territories (UTs) to clear within four years the regulatory assets of the power distribution companies, including BSES companies and Tata Power Delhi Distribution (TPDDL), a decision that is likely to increase electricity bills across India.
Reliance Infra-backed power distribution utilites BSES Rajdhani Power (BRPL) and BSES Yamuna Power (BYPL) and Tata Power TPDDL had sought amortisation of their 'undisputed' regulatory assets, which according to industry estimates, has exceeded over Rs 1.5 lakh crore across the country.
As on March 31, 2024, the regulatory asset including carrying costs for BRPL is Rs 12,993.53 crore, Rs 8419.14 crore for BYPL and Rs 5,787.70 crore for TPDDL, totally amounting to Rs 27,200.37 crore across all three distribution companies in Delhi.
Regulatory assets, which are costs incurred by discoms but recovered or recovered over a period of time, have been accumulating for decades. A bench comprising Justices PS Narasimha and Atul S Chandurkar while issuing notice to all states with pending regulatory assets asked their state electricity regulatory commissions to submit a time-bound roadmap for recovery of these regulatory assets, while also tasking the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity to supervise the implementation of its directions.
'Regulatory Commissions must provide the trajectory and roadmap for liquidation of the existing regulatory asset which will include a provision for dealing with carrying costs. Regulatory Commissions must also undertake strict and intensive audit of the circumstances in which the distribution companies have continued without recovery of the regulatory asset,' Justice Narasimha, writing the judgment for the Bench.'In case of non-compliance with these directions, the APTEL has the power and duty to call for an explanation, ensure accountability, and monitor compliance by the Regulatory Commissions. Similarly, the APTEL must exercise its powers under Section 121 to ensure that the legal principles on regulatory asset laid down by us are complied with by the Regulatory Commissions, and it must monitor the same. In case of non-compliance, the APTEL must issue such orders, directions, or instructions to the Commissions as may be necessary to hold them accountable,' the top court said.Existing regulatory asset must be liquidated in a maximum of four years starting from April 1, 2024, it said."As a first principle, tariff shall be cost-reflective; the revenue gap between the approved ARR (Aggregate Revenue Requirement) and the estimated annual revenue from approved tariff may be in exceptional circumstances; the regulatory asset should not exceed a reasonable percentage, which percentage can be arrived on the basis of Rule 23 of the Electricity Rules that prescribes 3% of the ARR as the guiding principle; if a regulatory asset is created, it must be liquidated within a period of 3 years, taking Rule 23 as the guiding principle," the judgement stated while laying the broader outline for the commissions.Stating that all such dues must be amortised over four years, the top court said that disproportionate increase and long pending regulatory asset depict a 'regulatory failure'. 'It has serious consequences on all stakeholders and the ultimate burden is only on the consumer. Ineffective and inefficient functioning of the Regulatory Commissions, coupled with acting under dictation can lead to regulatory failure. The commissions are accountable for their decisions, and they are subject to judicial review,' it said.Welcoming the judgment, advocate Shri Venkatesh, appearing for Tata Power Delhi Distribution, told ET that 'the Supreme Court's judgment has decisively unlocked the value chain of electricity regulation while addressing the systemic misuse of the Regulatory Asset mechanism.''For decades, tariff deferments were used as a political and regulatory crutch, distorting the true cost of supply and pushing discoms into unsustainable debt. By mandating a time-bound liquidation plan and empowering APTEL to supervise compliance, the court has enforced long-ignored statutory discipline under the Electricity Act. This judgment not only restores financial credibility to discoms but also reinforces the principle that consumer tariffs must be cost-reflective and grounded in transparent regulatory processes,' Venkatesh said."However, it is possible that the states may not want to pass it down to the consumers as it will raise tariffs. In that case, they may want to take it over. But if that were the case, they could have done it earlier," a central government official said.Vikram V, Vice President & Co-Group Head, ICRA, too termed it as a "positive development for the sector if implemented in the true spirit."He said that "ideally, there should not have been a large build-up of regulatory assets. However, large delays in issuance of tariff orders and lack of tariff revision in line with the cost structure led to this situation. Going forward, avoiding such build-up of regulatory assets would require timely pass through of cost variations by the discoms to the consumers. This will also enable the discoms to become self-sustaining."The ruling came on a couple of appeals filed by Delhi-based BSES firms and Tata Power seeking a direction to DERC to provide a roadmap for liquidation of the recognised amount of Revenue Gap/Regulatory Asset within a definite time frame and within a period not exceeding three years at the most.Seeking recognition of the Regulatory Asset and amortization of the Regulatory Asset within a period of 3 years, Tata Power Delhi Distribution had alleged that the Commission had consistently deferred the tariff costs legitimately owed to it by creating 'Regulatory Assets.'The discoms had alleged that the DERC's creation of Regulatory Assets was not only without a legal sanction but also in grave violation of the settled scheme of the Act, the policies and directives issued by the Central Government and the Judgments passed by the Aptel.In addition, while the power purchase cost had increased, there had been no corresponding increase in the tariff for the last nine year, they alleged.According to Justice Narsimha, 'Regulatory failure' occurs due to ineffective functioning of the Regulatory Commissions, excessive governmental interference, or 'regulatory capture'. 'We cannot wish away these real and imminent dangers that affect effective functioning of the Regulatory Commissions. These issues could have the effect of completely eclipsing regulatory functions, thereby losing the very purpose and object of restructuring the electricity sector by unbundling the functions of generation, distribution, and transmission and more importantly, establishing independent regulatory institutions and granting them the exclusive jurisdiction over grant of licenses and tariff determination.'We have affirmed the limits of the creation, continuation and liquidation of the regulatory asset, recognised the obligations of the commissions and directed that they will be accountable and subject to such orders, instructions and directions of the Aptel, and the regulatory regime under the Electricity Act,' the apex court said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Economic Times
14 minutes ago
- Economic Times
Celebrating freedom with reforms: Modi promises advancements in defence, technology, manufacturing, and major development schemes
Narendra Modi government is gearing up for next GST reforms by October. On Independence day, Modi unveiled Rs 1 lakh crore jobs programme. PM also assured the nation that India will become the third-largest economy soon. PM Viksit Bharat Rozgar Yojana will facilitate creation of 35 million jobs. Government will constitute task force to look into next-generation economic reforms. Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Prime Minister Narendra Modi announced a 'Diwali gift' for the people two months ahead of the festival, declaring that the next set of goods and services tax (GST) reforms will be in place by October, besides underscoring a renewed reforms push, emphasising Atmanirbhar (self-reliant) Bharat as the bedrock on which Viksit Bharat will be built by 2047, and unveiling a Rs 1-lakh crore jobs programme, among other his 12th Independence Day speech that lasted 103 minutes, the Prime Minister also assured the nation he will soon declare from the Red Fort that India has become the third-largest economy in the the Opposition's charge of high unemployment, Modi also said the PM Viksit Bharat Rozgar Yojana being launched on Independence Day will facilitate the creation of 35 million Friday, he said, 'This Diwali, you are going to get a big gift. We are coming with the next generation of GST reforms.' The announcement comes close on the heels of parliamentary approval for two key items of legislation — the Income Tax (No 2) Bill and the Taxation Laws (Amendment) Bill — earlier this week. A total of 280 sections have been abolished in the Income Tax Prime Minister said the government has decided to constitute a task force to look into the prospects of next-generation economic reforms within a set time frame. 'Current rules, laws, policies, and procedures must be redrafted to suit the 21st century, to fit the global environment and to align with the vision of making Bharat a developed nation by 2047,' he PM said the policy changes will reduce compliance costs, besides boosting startups and small and cottage industries. Other benefits will include a smoother export process, improved logistics and systems, and the abolition of archaic laws that led to imprisonment for minor matters. Modi urged all sections, including political parties, his rivals and fellow leaders, to take part in the efforts to build a bright future.'I wish to tell my countrymen, everything I am doing, I am doing for the country, not for myself, not to harm anyone,' he said. 'Whether it is structural reforms, regulatory reforms, policy reforms, process reforms, or the need for constitutional reforms, we have made every kind of reform our mission today.'Atmanirbhar Bharat is the bedrock on which Viksit Bharat will be built, he said. He asserted that Operation Sindoor, the Gaganyaan mission and the manufacture of indigenous semiconductors has proved the power of self-reliance.'The greater a nation's reliance on others, the more its freedom comes into question,' he said. 'Misfortune arises when dependency becomes a habit, when we do not even realise it, when we abandon self-reliance and become dependent on others. This habit is fraught with danger, and hence one must remain vigilant every moment to be self-reliant.'Made-in-India weapons and defence systems helped India during Operation Sindoor, the Prime Minister asserted.'The enemy had no inkling of what weapons and capabilities we possessed, what power was destroying them in the blink of an eye,' he said. 'Imagine if we were not self-reliant, could we have executed Operation Sindoor with such swiftness? We would have been plagued by worries over who might supply us, whether we would get the required equipment, and so on.'The Prime Minister also announced the Sudarshan Chakra Mission for creating a complete security cover for all civilian installations across the country in the near the 21st century is a 'technology-driven century,' it is imperative that India does not lag behind, the Prime Minister said, adding that every nation that mastered technology scaled the heights of development and attained new dimensions of economic lamented that although India began the process of building infrastructure for semiconductor manufacture six decades ago, the plan was stalled, delayed and shelved while other countries mastered the technology and strengthened their position.'Today we have freed ourselves from that burden and advanced the work on semiconductors in mission mode,' Modi said. 'Six different semiconductor units are taking shape on the ground, and we have already given the green signal to four new units.'India is becoming self-reliant in space technology as well, the Prime Minister stated.'We are also preparing for Aatmanirbhar Bharat Gaganyaan on our own in space,' he said. 'We are working towards building our own space station. And I am very proud of the reforms done in space recently. More than 300 startups in my country are now working only in the space sector and thousands of youth are working with full potential in those 300 startups.'He expressed satisfaction at the pace with which the National Manufacturing Mission was progressing and reiterated the importance of the 'vocal for local,' 'zero defect, zero effect' and 'lower price, higher value' the need for promoting indigenous products, Modi urged all traders and shopkeepers across the country to put up boards, saying 'Swadeshi goods sold here.'The new jobs programme is expected to create new employment opportunities for approximately 35 million youth.'Today, on August 15th, we are launching and implementing a scheme worth Rs 1 lakh crore for the youth of my country,' he said. 'The Pradhan Mantri Viksit Bharat Rozgar Yojana is being implemented today… Under this scheme, the government will give Rs 15,000 to the youth, to every son or daughter who gets a job in the private sector.'Companies that generate more jobs will also be given incentives under the scheme.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Celebrating freedom with reforms: Modi promises advancements in defence, technology, manufacturing, and major development schemes
Prime Minister Narendra Modi announced a 'Diwali gift' for the people two months ahead of the festival, declaring that the next set of goods and services tax (GST) reforms will be in place by October, besides underscoring a renewed reforms push, emphasising Atmanirbhar (self-reliant) Bharat as the bedrock on which Viksit Bharat will be built by 2047, and unveiling a Rs 1-lakh crore jobs programme, among other initiatives. Independence Day 2025 Modi signals new push for tech independence with local chips Before Trump, British used tariffs to kill Indian textile Bank of Azad Hind: When Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose gave India its own currency In his 12th Independence Day speech that lasted 103 minutes, the Prime Minister also assured the nation he will soon declare from the Red Fort that India has become the third-largest economy in the world. Countering the Opposition's charge of high unemployment, Modi also said the PM Viksit Bharat Rozgar Yojana being launched on Independence Day will facilitate the creation of 35 million jobs. On Friday, he said, 'This Diwali, you are going to get a big gift. We are coming with the next generation of GST reforms.' The announcement comes close on the heels of parliamentary approval for two key items of legislation — the Income Tax (No 2) Bill and the Taxation Laws (Amendment) Bill — earlier this week. A total of 280 sections have been abolished in the Income Tax Act. The Prime Minister said the government has decided to constitute a task force to look into the prospects of next-generation economic reforms within a set time frame. 'Current rules, laws, policies, and procedures must be redrafted to suit the 21st century, to fit the global environment and to align with the vision of making Bharat a developed nation by 2047,' he said. The PM said the policy changes will reduce compliance costs, besides boosting startups and small and cottage industries. Other benefits will include a smoother export process, improved logistics and systems, and the abolition of archaic laws that led to imprisonment for minor matters. Modi urged all sections, including political parties, his rivals and fellow leaders, to take part in the efforts to build a bright future. Atmanirbhar Bharat 'I wish to tell my countrymen, everything I am doing, I am doing for the country, not for myself, not to harm anyone,' he said. 'Whether it is structural reforms, regulatory reforms, policy reforms, process reforms, or the need for constitutional reforms, we have made every kind of reform our mission today.' Atmanirbhar Bharat is the bedrock on which Viksit Bharat will be built, he said. He asserted that Operation Sindoor, the Gaganyaan mission and the manufacture of indigenous semiconductors has proved the power of self-reliance. 'The greater a nation's reliance on others, the more its freedom comes into question,' he said. 'Misfortune arises when dependency becomes a habit, when we do not even realise it, when we abandon self-reliance and become dependent on others. This habit is fraught with danger, and hence one must remain vigilant every moment to be self-reliant.' Made-in-India weapons and defence systems helped India during Operation Sindoor, the Prime Minister asserted. 'The enemy had no inkling of what weapons and capabilities we possessed, what power was destroying them in the blink of an eye,' he said. 'Imagine if we were not self-reliant, could we have executed Operation Sindoor with such swiftness? We would have been plagued by worries over who might supply us, whether we would get the required equipment, and so on.' The Prime Minister also announced the Sudarshan Chakra Mission for creating a complete security cover for all civilian installations across the country in the near future. Since the 21st century is a 'technology-driven century,' it is imperative that India does not lag behind, the Prime Minister said, adding that every nation that mastered technology scaled the heights of development and attained new dimensions of economic power. He lamented that although India began the process of building infrastructure for semiconductor manufacture six decades ago, the plan was stalled, delayed and shelved while other countries mastered the technology and strengthened their position. 'Today we have freed ourselves from that burden and advanced the work on semiconductors in mission mode,' Modi said. 'Six different semiconductor units are taking shape on the ground, and we have already given the green signal to four new units.' India is becoming self-reliant in space technology as well, the Prime Minister stated. 'We are also preparing for Aatmanirbhar Bharat Gaganyaan on our own in space,' he said. 'We are working towards building our own space station. And I am very proud of the reforms done in space recently. More than 300 startups in my country are now working only in the space sector and thousands of youth are working with full potential in those 300 startups.' He expressed satisfaction at the pace with which the National Manufacturing Mission was progressing and reiterated the importance of the 'vocal for local,' 'zero defect, zero effect' and 'lower price, higher value' themes. Underlining the need for promoting indigenous products, Modi urged all traders and shopkeepers across the country to put up boards, saying 'Swadeshi goods sold here.' The new jobs programme is expected to create new employment opportunities for approximately 35 million youth. 'Today, on August 15th, we are launching and implementing a scheme worth Rs 1 lakh crore for the youth of my country,' he said. 'The Pradhan Mantri Viksit Bharat Rozgar Yojana is being implemented today… Under this scheme, the government will give Rs 15,000 to the youth, to every son or daughter who gets a job in the private sector.' Companies that generate more jobs will also be given incentives under the scheme.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Margao chief officer targets Rs 10 crore recovery
Margao: Newly appointed chief officer of Margao Municipal Council (MMC), Madhu Narvekar, has made revenue recovery his top priority to tackle MMC's financial crisis. Narvekar aims to recover Rs 10 crore in six months from the council's Rs 35-crore dues. Narvekar, who assumed charge last month, acted swiftly to address the MMC's financial crisis to meet its basic obligations, including monthly staff salaries of Rs 2.5 crore. 'The target is achievable through planning and consistent monitoring,' he said. 'We have developed a strategy to target defaulters systematically. The performance of our recovery team will be monitored regularly to ensure objectives are met. ' Narvekar constituted a dedicated team to spearhead the drive. The recovery exercise begins with a Rs 20 lakh weekly target, which will be enhanced based on the results. 'We will tweak our strategy based on results, but I am confident we can recover at least Rs 10 crore within the next six months through constant monitoring and meticulous planning,' Narvekar said. He also identified significant revenue leakage from unlicensed businesses and issues related to the subletting of premises, including shops in municipal markets. According to observers, earlier revenue recovery attempts faced challenges due to political interference, poor implementation, and failure to bring unassessed properties into the tax net, with 40–50% of Margao traders lacking valid licences. Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays , public holidays , and current gold rates and silver prices in your area. Get the latest lifestyle updates on Times of India, along with Happy Krishna Janmashtami Wishes ,, messages , and quotes !
