'Hypocritical' BBC is accused of damaging the countryside to film Chris Packham's Springwatch
Residents in the Peak District claim the production team for the hugely popular nature programme is destroying an area of the Longshaw Estate.
Live filming for the 20th anniversary series of the programme - fronted by environmental campaigner Chris Packham and Michaela Strachan - is taking place on the estate, which sits within the Peak District National Park, near Sheffield.
But images taken by local resident Christine Laver, supplied to MailOnline, show what some alleged to be hypocritical behaviour on the part of the BBC Natural History Unit, part of BBC Studios, the commercial production arm of the broadcaster.
Steel plates are laid out across part of the estate - which only some vehicles belonging to the production team are parked on, with others in the grass.
Large plates were also laid out across paths and ditches were filled in with bags of stones, topped with plastic mats to widen the roads for larger vehicles such as production lorries.
The BBC and the National Trust both say the site will be restored to its original condition once filming is concluded.
But in a viral social media post Ms Laver said the apparent damage reflected 'the reality of Springwatch at Longshaw'.
Large plates were laid out across paths and ditches were filled in with bags of stones, topped with plastic mats to widen the roads for larger vehicles such as production lorries
She wrote: 'Tons of limestone tipped in a gritstone landscape to facilitate access for huge lorries. Ditches blocked and tracks widened by vehicles they were never designed for.
'A meadow covered in steel plating, just when the wildflowers are coming into bloom and dozens of staff and production vehicles parked there.
'How many tons of CO2 will this lot produce in 3 weeks, Chris Packham?'
The first episode of the latest series of Springwatch, which aired on Monday, opened with Chris and Michaela praising the habitats and the wildlife at the location.
Among Longshaw's fauna are wild hares, herds of deer and birds including short-eared owls and ring ouzels.
But some of those who saw Ms Laver's post fear that the wildlife may have been disrupted. The BBC has denied this is the case.
'Saw a pair of curlews in the field the wagons are in now, probs a week before the arrived, two days in a row,' one said.
'If they had a nest, that'll be trashed now.'
One social media user opined that it was an example of 'hypocrisy and feeding a narrative' on the part of the BBC.
Another, referring to Chris Packham, said: 'The hypocrisy of these environmentalists knows no bounds. Educate and inform by all means but stop the campaigning.'
The BBC and National Trust supplied MailOnline with similar statements outlining how the site would be preserved after production came to an end.
Some have given the broadcaster the benefit of the doubt as production continues.
One said: 'Why not be thankful for the good that comes from this programme? For me personally I think it is fantastic that Springwatch is coming from my own backyard.'
Another commented: 'I like they are trying to [put] wildlife to the forefront of people's attention and get people interested in wildlife and support mental health.
'And all people can do is look at the negative side if things.
'They're not destroying habitats to build homes like the government. They're trying to bring the beautiful side of nature.'
The row comes despite Chris being a prominent environmentalist campaigner and vocal supporter of groups such as Just Stop Oil.
In November last year, he joined thousands of people marching through central London to demand the government cleans up Britain's waterways.
Speaking outside Westminster, he said: 'Rachel Reeves gave a Budget in 2024, whilst Valencia was being flooded and people were losing their lives, and she didn't use the word climate or nature once in that Budget. Now that's scary.'
Pointing at Parliament, Mr Packham added: 'I know there are plenty of MPs and ministers over there who are desperate to do what they need to do and do their job - but they need to be given access to the resources, and part of that is finance.'
Meanwhile in April last year Chris joined Extinction Rebellion protesters as they stormed the Science Museum's new climate gallery over its sponsorship by a mining company.
The criticism centred on the fact the gallery's sponsor – the Adani Group – derives 60 per cent of its revenue from the coal industry.
Speaking to the 30-strong band of young people, scientists and activists, Mr Packham deemed the sponsorship deal 'beyond greenwash – it's grotesque'.
He continued: 'Science tells us that the fossil fuel industry is responsible for the accelerating destruction of our natural world.
'The Science Museum is a place to spark imagination, to provide answers but also to encourage us to ask questions.
'The question I'm asking today is a big one, 'why on earth are we allowing a destructive industry to sponsor an educational exhibition whilst simultaneously setting fire to young peoples futures?'
'This is beyond greenwash - it's grotesque.'
A BBC spokesperson said of the Springwatch row: 'At Longshaw the Springwatch team is working in cooperation with the National Trust.
'The field location was confirmed as appropriate for temporary use by local land managers and no wildlife has been displaced.
'All of the surfaces installed and modifications are temporary, and the National Trust will undertake any works that may be needed to reinstate the site once Springwatch has departed.
'This restoration includes reseeding fields, restoring ditches, and reverting any landscape changes.
'Minimising our environmental impact is a top priority and Springwatch is certified by BAFTA Albert, which encourages sustainable TV and film production.
'Whilst on location, our main power source is a green hydrogen fuel cell, dramatically reducing our CO₂ emission.'
In a similarly worded statement, the National Trust said it would 'uphold the highest possible environmental standards' during production.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sky News
13 minutes ago
- Sky News
PM on brink of unwanted small boats milestone - and far faster than his Tory predecessors
The number of people who have illegally crossed the Channel on small boats under the Labour government is on the brink of passing 50,000. Home Office figures show that up to and including Sunday, a total of 49,797 people had arrived since 5 July 2024. Sky News witnessed more migrants being brought ashore at Dover on Monday on a day of exceptional weather, and the Conservatives claim the 50,000 threshold has been hit. Official statistics could confirm the milestone later today. It would mean Sir Keir Starmer - who won power promising to "smash the gangs" behind the crossings - has seen 50,000 crossings on his watch in 401 days. Sky News chief political correspondent Jon Craig said that's "much faster" than under Rishi Sunak, who was in office for 603 days when he hit the unwanted tally. It took some 1,066 days under Boris Johnson, though it's worth remembering his tenure covered the pandemic. Nearly 20,000 migrants crossed the Channel to the UK in the first six months of this year, a rise of almost 50% on the number crossing in 2024 and a new record for the first half of a year. The government is hoping a new "one in one out deal" with France that came into force last week will deter crossings, with some migrants now facing the prospect of being detained and returned. 1:08 Badenoch: People don't feel safe The numbers have further fuelled public anger over the use of hotels to house asylum seekers, with protests taking place across the country this summer. Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch has suggested "camps" be set up instead, saying women and children in her Essex constituency and elsewhere "don't feel safe". Her party are also proposing automatic deportation for any illegal migrants, and have regularly criticised the government for scrapping the Rwanda scheme. Shadow home secretary Chris Philp said "Labour tore up our deterrents before they were even in place". 2:41 A Number 10 spokesperson said crossings "reached all-time highs" under the previous Tory government. "The gangs had six years to set routes," they added, and Labour are determined to tackle the crisis by "hunting down gangs" and "fixing the foundations of a broken asylum system".
Times
26 minutes ago
- Times
Nicola Sturgeon: Alex Salmond refused to read independence white paper
Alex Salmond refused to read the SNP's crucial independence blueprint in the run-up to the 2014 referendum, Nicola Sturgeon has claimed. In the latest explosive allegations which have reopened deep rifts within the independence movement, Sturgeon accused Salmond of an 'abdication of responsibility' in the months before the historic vote that could have delivered on the SNP's foundational mission. In an interview with ITV ahead of the publication of her long-awaited memoir, Sturgeon said she had been left in a 'cold fury' when her former mentor said he was going on a trade mission to China without reading a draft of the Scottish government's white paper on independence, a few weeks before it was due to be published. The 670-page document, which was released in November 2013, was then seen as critical to the Yes campaign's prospects of turning around what was then a significant deficit in the polls before the historic September 2014 vote. However, Sturgeon, who was then deputy first minister, claimed that she suffered a 'panic attack' due to the pressure of compiling a document in which her boss showed no interest. 'He really didn't engage in the work of the drafting or the compilation of the white paper at all,' Sturgeon told ITV's News at Ten presenter Julie Etchingham, in a major interview to mark this week's publication of her memoir Frankly. 'He was the leader, he was the first minister, and he hadn't read it. 'He'd maybe read bits. I don't even know if he'd read bits of it. I knew I was going to have to sit him down and say, 'Look, you're going to have to read this, and you're going to have to tell me now if there are bits you want to change, because it has to be signed off'. 'He told me he was going on a trade mission to China. I don't think I'd ever felt as much cold fury at him as I did in that moment. It just seemed to me like an abdication of responsibility.' The suggestion that as first minister, Salmond, who died of a heart attack in October last year, potentially jeopardised the success of the independence campaign led to outrage from his allies. • Alex Salmond obituary: ambitious politician who fought for independence It follows Sturgeon's inflammatory suggestion, published in extracts of Frankly in The Times and Sunday Times, that he may have leaked allegations that he was facing an investigation for sexual misconduct to a tabloid newspaper himself. Sturgeon said that she had become overwhelmed at having to deliver the white paper, which was titled Scotland's Future, which the SNP had promised voters would answer critical questions about how a Scottish state would operate. 'I remember an evening which I just suddenly had this overwhelming sense of impossibility,' she said. 'I can't get this to the point it needs to be at. It's so unwieldy. It's so difficult. 'And I just remember having what I can only describe as a panic attack. I was sobbing on the floor of my office at home and just my heart was racing.' Salmond went on his trade mission to China on November 3, 2013, when the white paper had been in development for several months. It was published 23 days later, with Sturgeon and Salmond launching it side by side. While there were several doubts raised about the claims within the document, not least the projections of lucrative oil revenues which later turned out to have been wildly optimistic, the event was broadly seen as a presentational success. Although Scots voted against independence by a margin of 55 per cent to 45 per cent, the document was seen as a factor in closing the gap in the polls which in late 2013 had shown a far wider lead for the unionist campaign. Sturgeon's claims that Salmond had not been engaged with the contents of the document provoked conflicting accounts from senior figures who were involved in the Yes campaign. One described Sturgeon's allegations as 'mental'. 'What is she talking about? Of course Alex was engaged in it,' one source said. 'There were umpteen meetings in the run up to its publication discussing it.' However another gave credence to Sturgeon's version of events. 'It is not a surprise Nicola is saying this,' the former advisor said. 'Within the narrow confines at the top of the SNP it was talked about, and has been discussed since. It reflects what I heard at the time, there was a disconnect, she was doing all the heavy lifting.' Salmond and Sturgeon were once seen as the closest of political allies but the pair fell out after sexual misconduct allegations against him, which first emerged publicly in 2018. Salmond was later cleared of any criminality following a trial in 2020. In extracts of her book, Sturgeon claimed it would have been 'classic Alex' to have leaked details of the investigation as he was practiced in the 'dark arts' of media manipulation and knew they would have become public anyway. Her remarks provoked a furious backlash among friends and allies of Salmond, who accused Sturgeon of launching unfounded attacks on a man they see as a titan of the independence movement, who is now unable to defend himself. David Clegg, the journalist who broke the story for the Daily Record and is now editor of The Courier, said at the weekend that Sturgeon's claims that Salmond was behind the initial leak were 'not credible'. He maintains he does not know who leaked the story by anonymously sending secret documents to his newspaper. In her ITV interview, Sturgeon said she had been hit by a 'wave of grief' after learning of Salmond's death, at the age of 69, despite the pair having not spoken in years. 'Even today I still miss him in some way — the person that I used to know and the relationship we used to have,' she said. 'But I thought I had made my peace with it, that I'd got to a point where I felt nothing. And then I got a call to tell me that Alex Salmond had died. I started crying on the phone and I just was hit by this wave of grief … and it was complicated because obviously we weren't just no longer friends, we were political enemies. • Sturgeon: I came perilously close to a breakdown 'There was no prospect I was going to be able to go to his funeral or anything like that and it was a kind of strange, strange feeling.' Kenny MacAskill, who served in the SNP cabinet throughout the run up to the referendum, disputed Sturgeon's claims about the white paper. MacAskill succeeded Salmond as leader of the Alba Party, which he set up after his departure from the SNP, following his death. 'The white paper was drafted by a team of civil servants,' MacAskill said. 'All cabinet secretaries were given copies to review. Alex Salmond oversaw every aspect of the government even though he allowed ministers to just get on with their job. 'The issue he kept some responsibility for was the constitution. Alex Salmond was also a master of detail. Many issues in the paper were fraught and complex with much discussion. The idea that he avoided oversight is simply laughable. Alex was in charge and always on top of matters. Yet again Nicola Sturgeon seeks to rewrite history. ' Chris McEleny, a former general secretary of the Alba Party, said Sturgeon's latest claims about independence exposed her book as a work of 'amateur fiction'. 'Alex took us closer to independence than we've ever been, whereas Nicola destroyed the independence movement and has few achievements to look back on,' McEleny, who was close to Salmond during the final years of his life, said. 'That Nicola's upset that Alex went on a trade mission and left her to complete a task she was responsible for sums up her lack of personal political accountability.'
Times
26 minutes ago
- Times
Nicola Sturgeon: I cried in the toilets after being bullied by MSP
Nicola Sturgeon cried after a male MSP spread unfounded rumours that she had hurt a boyfriend during oral sex. The former first minister revealed in her new book that she was bullied by a male politician from another party who called her 'Gnasher', including to her face, in reference to the claims. She said the behaviour escalated to the point that he would often make 'jokes' about dentists and teeth in her presence. Sturgeon said she broke down in the parliamentary toilets when she first heard the story but only later came to realise in 2017 when filling out a Holyrood survey provoked by the Me Too movement that she had been a victim of misogynistic bullying. She said she had thought 'long and hard' about whether to name the politician, who is still alive. However, she said she had decided not to as 'the thought of his face all over the media, and of the backlash he might try to whip up against me, makes me feel sick'. Sturgeon revealed that when she stood for the SNP leadership in 2004, before aborting the bid and standing on a joint-ticket with Alex Salmond, a former boyfriend had even been doorstepped by a tabloid journalist asking if he had 'been the one'. 'Whether he was the instigator of the story or just enjoyed referencing it to make me feel uncomfortable, I don't know,' Sturgeon writes of her tormentor. 'It was untrue, and the fact I feel the need to say that is in itself horrible, but I was utterly mortified. 'On the day I found out about the story, I cried in one of the toilets in the parliament office complex, wondering how I was ever going to face people.' Sturgeon, who was 28 when she was elected an MSP in 1999, then says the bully's behaviour got 'steadily worse' and that she became 'quite scared of him', with her heart racing whenever she saw him or heard his voice. She said his taunting 'abated eventually' but only after 'months of what felt like torture' with the story continuing to resurface as she became ever more prominent in Scottish politics. 'I thought it was just part or parcel of politics, something I had to endure,' she writes in her memoir Frankly. 'It wasn't until 2017, when I was filling out a survey conducted by the Scottish parliament authorities in the wake of the #MeToo revelations that I realised it had been bullying. 'It was bullying of an overtly sexual nature, designed to humiliate and intimidate, to cut a young woman down to size and put her in her place.' Sturgeon adds: 'Perhaps the fact I have not named this man is another sign that things have not changed as much as I might have hoped. I have thought long and hard about whether I should reveal his identity. 'I worry that in deciding not to, I am being less brave than I should be. But the thought of his face all over the media, and of the backlash he might try to whip up against me, makes me feel sick. 'Even just thinking about it transports me back to the day I cried in the toilet all those years ago. It is for my own sake that I am letting him off the hook. 'But he knows who he is. I can only hope that he has the decency to reflect on how his behaviour made me feel.' The revelations are likely to provoke speculation about the identity of the bully, with several MSPs who were elected in 1999 going on to hold prominent roles in politics and professional life. There are well over 40 male politicians, who were elected to the first term of the Scottish parliament for parties other than the SNP, who are still alive.
