Chhattisgarh HC terms exclusion of engineering graduates from Sub-Engineer posts 'arbitrary and discriminatory'
The Chhattisgarh High Court has struck down a rule barring engineering graduates from applying for Sub-Engineer positions in the Public Health Engineering Department, deeming it discriminatory and unconstitutional.
The Chhattisgarh High Court has struck down a rule barring engineering graduates from applying for Sub-Engineer positions in the Public Health Engineering Department, deeming it discriminatory and unconstitutional.
The Chhattisgarh High Court has struck down a rule barring engineering graduates from applying for Sub-Engineer positions in the Public Health Engineering Department, deeming it discriminatory and unconstitutional.
The Chhattisgarh High Court has struck down a rule barring engineering graduates from applying for Sub-Engineer positions in the Public Health Engineering Department, deeming it discriminatory and unconstitutional.
1
2
RAIPUR: The Chhattisgarh High Court declared as "ultra vires" a rule that restricted engineering graduates from applying for Sub-Engineer posts in the Public Health Engineering (PHE) Department.
The court stated that Rule 8 (II) Column (5) of Schedule-III, Serial No. 1, of the Chhattisgarh Public Health Engineering Department (Non-Gazetted) (Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 2016, is "illegal and without jurisdiction." Chief Justice Ramesh Sinha and Justice Bibhu Datta Guru delivered a common order on two writ petitions, filed by over two dozen individuals.
The petitioners, holding graduate degrees in engineering, sought to participate in the direct recruitment examination for Sub-Engineer (Civil/Mechanical/Electrical) posts.
The examination was scheduled for 27 April 2025, following an advertisement issued on 7 March 2025.
The petitioners argued that the 2016 rules, which prescribed a three-year diploma as the only educational qualification for direct recruitment to Sub-Engineer posts, were discriminatory. They pointed out that for promotional quotas (5 per cent), both diploma and degree holders were eligible. They further highlighted that other state departments, such as the Public Works Department and CSPDCL, permitted both diploma and degree holders to apply for Sub-Engineer positions.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Providers are furious: Internet access without a subscription!
Techno Mag
Learn More
Undo
The petitioners' counsels Ajay Shrivastava, G P Mathur and Pratibha Sahu contended that an engineering degree is a higher qualification than a diploma, and thus, degree holders should not be barred from applying. They cited the Supreme Court's judgement in the Puneet Sharma & Others v. Himachal Pradesh State Electricity Board Limited & Another case, which directed states to allow degree holders to participate in recruitment processes.
The State, represented by the Deputy Advocate General, argued that the 2016 rules maintained the same qualification criteria as the earlier 1979 and 2012 rules. The State also submitted that the 5% promotion quota for in-service candidates, which includes diploma and degree holders, was a separate provision for existing employees who may have acquired higher qualifications during their service.
The Chhattisgarh Professional Examination Board (CGPEB), the recruiting agency, stated that it acts based on existing rules and departmental requisitions.
The intervenors supported the State's contentions.
The High Court observed that excluding degree holders, who possess superior knowledge and technical skills, was unreasonable and counterproductive to recruiting competent individuals. The court noted that this restriction undermined principles of fairness and equal opportunity, violating Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.
'The exclusion of degree holders, who possess the necessary knowledge and technical skills, from eligibility for the post is arbitrary, unreasonable, and counterproductive to the goal of recruiting competent individuals.
It violates the principles of fairness, equal opportunity, and the fundamental rights under Articles 14, 16, and 21 of the Constitution. Notably, other state departments like Public Works and CSPDCL allow both Diploma and Degree holders for similar posts, making the exclusion in the Public Health and Engineering Department discriminatory,' the court stated.
An interim order was issued on 25 March 2025, allowing degree holders to provisionally apply for the posts, subject to the final outcome of the petitions.
The court clarified that this order would apply to all similarly situated candidates.
Following the declaration of the rule as "ultra vires," the High Court has directed the respondent authorities to proceed with the selection process, ensuring that engineering degree holders are allowed to participate, provided they meet other prescribed criteria in the advertisement.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
14 minutes ago
- Time of India
House panel flags concerns over quality of data for assessing JJM's performance
. NEW DELHI: A parliamentary panel has flagged its concerns over the authenticity of data being fed into the Jal Jeevan Mission's (JJM's) Integrated Management Information System (IMIS), noting that the quality of uploaded information is essential to fill the visible gaps in the ambitious scheme of providing functional tap water connection to every rural household in the country. The panel -- standing committee on water resources headed by BJP Lok Sabha MP Rajiv Pratap Rudy -- in its report tabled in Parliament on Monday also noted the absence of annual assessment of the functionality of tap water connections in 2023. The annual assessment of functionality is vital to ensure long-term source and system sustainability and corrective measures by states/UTs based on its findings. 'Being aware of the fact that actual veracity of uploaded information is essential for realising the actual ground situation and filling the visible gaps, the Committee reiterate its recommendation that the department (of drinking water and sanitation) makes sincere efforts to ensure the authenticity of the data being fed on the IMIS,' said the report. While the panel observed that the department has cited a number of steps being taken by it for water quality monitoring and surveillance, it noted that the govt 'has not furnished specific reply' on ascertaining the veracity of the information uploaded by the states/UTs on JJM-IMIS. On the panel's observation over the absence of annual assessment, the govt, in its reply, told the committee that the department has received the final report of the functionality assessment survey. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Indonesia: Unsold Sofas at Bargain Prices (Prices May Surprise You) Sofas | Search Ads Search Now Undo It said the department's approval of the report is in final stages and will be released and shared with states shortly for requisite course correction. Launched in Aug 2019, the JJM was meant to cover all 19.32 crore (approx) rural households in the country by 2024. However, its deadline has now been extended to 2028.
Time of India
24 minutes ago
- Time of India
We're living in volatile era, 'atmanirbharta' mindset needed to deal with global turbulence: EAM
External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar has said the world is facing a "volatile and uncertain era", having experienced the successive impact of the Covid pandemic, multiple conflicts and "trade upheavals", and asserted that ' atmanirbharta ' (self reliance) is the mindset needed to deal with "global turbulence". In his address at a conclave here on Wednesday, Jaishankar also said that in an era of globalisation and urbanisation, "traditions are often lost with time". But, by nurturing them, "we have made Indian tourism even more attractive", he said. Finance Value and Valuation Masterclass - Batch 4 By CA Himanshu Jain View Program Artificial Intelligence AI For Business Professionals Batch 2 By Ansh Mehra View Program Finance Value and Valuation Masterclass - Batch 3 By CA Himanshu Jain View Program Artificial Intelligence AI For Business Professionals By Vaibhav Sisinity View Program Finance Value and Valuation Masterclass - Batch 2 By CA Himanshu Jain View Program Finance Value and Valuation Masterclass Batch-1 By CA Himanshu Jain View Program Pointing to the theme of the event -- 'Invincible Spirit of India' -- the minister said, "We are a civilisational state, a state, a society that has withstood the tests of time, and nurtured its culture, traditions and heritage." by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Undo "Our real strengths have been our people. Our people and their self-belief. We have overcome adversities and we have addressed multiple challenges in the journey towards progress and prosperity." The event was hosted by the Federation of Associations in Indian Tourism and Hospitality. Live Events "We are definitely living in a volatile and uncertain era, having experienced the successive impact of the Covid pandemic, of multiple conflicts, many of which are still going on, and of trade upheavals," Jaishankar said without naming any country. His comments came in the backdrop of the US slapping an additional 25 per cent tariff on all Indian imports, on top of an existing 25 per cent duty, taking the total to 50 per cent effective August 27. The minister added that nations with robust domestic demand have fared better and will obviously continue to do so. "The value of stronger tourism in such a situation is hard to overstate. After all, it has so many dimensions, including infrastructure development, entrepreneurship, creativity, skills enhancement, or job generation," he said. Indeed, there are a few activities that do more to energise the economy and multiply employment, Jaishankar said. In his address, Jaishankar emphasised the diversity, richness and the wonderful heritage that "our civilisation has nurtured", and said today there is an "enormous effort" to present to the world what really India is. He also said that in recent years, India has made "sustained efforts" to make "our heritage and culture more visible to the world", citing the inscription of multiple Indian heritage sites on the UNESCO World Heritage List in the past several years. "We have so much to be proud of and so much to share with the world," he asserted. "Our approach has long been driven by Vasudhaiva Kutumbakum and Atithi Devo Bhava. While we will always benefit with such openness, it is essential, in times of unpredictability, to stand firmly on our own feet. "Atmanirbharta is, of course, the mindset to deal with global turbulence. But it is also the basis to strengthen our self-confidence, to increase our resilience, and to lay the foundation for Viksit Bharat," he added. In his address, Jaishankar also asserted that more than diplomacy, it is actually tourism that connects any nation to the world. "Your industry helps to prepare a global workforce at a time when international mobility is becoming more common... Every action in this sector helps enhance brand India," the minister said. He recalled that in 2023, during India's presidency of the G20, Prime Minister Narendra Modi was very "determined" that every state of India must get a chance to showcase itself before the world. "As part of a strategy, G20 conferences were therefore held close to heritage sites or naturally beautiful landscapes, and delegates were afforded opportunities for maximum cultural immersion," he said, adding that every state rose to the occasion and put their "best foot forward". The impression the delegates took back with them "will stand us in very good stead" and it is for this reason "we say G20 connected India to the world, and equally the world to India", Jaishankar said.
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
'Appreciate anti-terror effort': US secretary of state Marco Rubio wishes Pakistan on Independence; hails 'trade ties'
Secretary of state Marco Rubio (File photo) United States secretary of state Marco Rubio on Thursday congratulated Pakistan on its Independence Day, "appreciating Islamabad's engagement on counterterrorism and trade". Rubio also reiterated US President Donald Trump's ambition to "explore new areas of economic cooperation in critical minerals and hydrocarbons" between the US and Pakistan. "On behalf of the United States, I extend our warm congratulations to the people of Pakistan as they celebrate their Independence Day on August 14," Rubio said in a statement. He further said: "The United States deeply appreciates Pakistan's engagement on counterterrorism and trade. We look forward to exploring new areas of economic cooperation, including critical minerals and hydrocarbons, and fostering dynamic business partnerships which will promote a prosperous future for Americans and Pakistanis." Rubio's wish for Pakistan Rubio's remarks come amid what observers describe as a noticeable warming in Washington–Islamabad ties under Trump, a shift drawing close attention in New Delhi. Over the past year, the US and Pakistan have expanded their engagement beyond "counterterrorism" and trade to include cryptocurrency ventures, crude oil shipments, and cooperation on rare earth minerals. The renewed camaraderie between both nations follows heightened tensions between India and Pakistan after New Delhi's retaliation for a Pakistan-backed terror attack in Jammu and Kashmir's Pahalgam. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Why Seniors Are Snapping Up This TV Box, We Explain! Techno Mag Learn More Undo Indian forces, acting against cross-border terrorism, destroyed multiple terror infrastructure in Pakistan, including the hotbeds like Bahalwalpur and Muridke. As the tension escalated, the Indian forces stepped up the retaliation -- bombing the Rahim Yar Khan Pakistani Air Force (PAF) base in Pakistan's southern Punjab region and Nur Khan air base in Rawalpindi, which prompted the US to intervene. Notably, the US has also used Nur Khan air base during the the Afghanitan war. Later, Trump, without credible evidence, repeatedly credited himself with easing potential conflict between the two nuclear-armed neighbours, while publicly praising Pakistan's military leadership and advancing trade deals, including Islamabad's first-ever imports of US crude oil. Experts suggest the renewed focus is 'less about oil than access to minerals and rare earths,' which are crucial to the US economy and defence industries. The timing, alongside deeper military cooperation and high-level diplomatic praise, signals that strategic, economic, and geopolitical factors are all in play.
