Waitangi Tribunal hears new plan to improve Māori Health
Photo:
Supplied / Murdoch Ngahau
Māori health leaders want the Waitangi Tribunal to recommend establishing a "new whare" to replace the short-lived, Te Aka Whai Ora, Māori Health Authortiy.
Māori health stalwarts and inquiry claimants Lady Tureiti Moxon and Janice Kuka presented evidence to the Tribunal as part of its weeklong inquiry into what will replace the now Te Aka Whai Ora.
On Wednesday, Deputy Director General of Health Māori John Whaanga
presented evidence
on behalf of the Crown but could not tell the Tribunal what would replace it.
However, he defended the Ministry of Health's on-going work to improve Māori health and said that work would continue, irrespective of the Māori Health Authority's existence.
Roimata Smail, who represents Lady Tureiti Moxon and Janice Kuka, told the Tribunal that based on the evidence submitted, the Crown had no plan to replace the Te Aka Whai Ora.
Counsel also argued the ongoing claim that a single document, the Hauora Māori Strategy, could make a difference and be relevant as the alternative to Te Aka Whai Ora was indefensible and disrespectful.
In their closing submission document given to the Tribunal, Smail said Māori health providers deliver excellent services despite limited support and that Māori want to control the funding of a system designed by and for Māori, the "new whare".
"The claimants are saying 'we'll look after ourselves first, we're tired of propping up the Crown in trying to meet its Treaty obligations… we will be independent, and we will make sure that we're doing our job right, we will monitor.'" Smail told the Tribunal.
The document outlines how the "new whare" would be completely designed and monitored by Māori, in contrast to Te Aka Whai Ora and the Iwi Māori Partnership Boards, which were designed by the Crown.
It also outlines how the funds "hoarded" by the Crown to administer Māori health should be given to Māori.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
23 minutes ago
- RNZ News
Age Concern branch cutting some services as survey shows
Photo: RNZ / Cole Eastham-Farrelly The Wellington Branch of Age Concern says it has had to cut services due to an overall reduction in government funding and increased demand for financial help from service providers. At the same time a sector survey has set out the increasing need for support among the older population. A report by the insurance company, New Zealand Seniors, indicates that 2 out of 5 older people feel their quality of life has declined in the past 2 years. Financial security is said to be a major concern, with 60 percent reporting it as a key factor. The survey, involving 500 New Zealanders over the age of 50, suggests the situation is being worsened by difficulties in accessing timely healthcare and increasing social isolation, which is leading to a decline in mental well-being. Susie is joined by the CEO of Age Concern Auckland Kevin Lamb.
RNZ News
23 minutes ago
- RNZ News
Cautious optimism over changes to human trafficking law
Anti human trafficking advocates are welcoming news that trafficking and people smuggling laws will soon be strengthened - with the hope it will result in more prosecutions. Since 2009, over 50 victims of trafficking have been identified in New Zealand, but only four prosecutions have been undertaken and just two of these prosecutions have led to a conviction. The Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith confirmed the changes would form part of the current reforms being made to the Crimes Act. Rebekah Armstrong is a member of the Human Trafficking Research Coalition and Head of Advocacy and Justice at World Vision New Zealand. Photo: - vimeo - Nancy Kelley
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
'It doesn't cost the government anything' - Wayne Brown calls for bed tax rethink
Auckland mayor Wayne Brown is at odds with the government over a bed night levy. Photo: RNZ / Marika Khabazi Auckland's mayor Wayne Brown is renewing his call for a bed levy for the supercity , as it deals with some serious economic troubles . Its unemployment rate of 6.1 percent is the highest of any region. National Minister and Auckland-based MP Paul Goldsmith told Morning Report on Wednesday there's been a long Covid hangover. "The economy's flat, everybody's feeling it. Of course there's two speeds, down in the south and in rural New Zealand we're getting some growth and some upbeat economic news from the regions but of course it's a real struggle in Auckland so that's what our real focus is on." Brown agreed the government would be focused on the city because it was where the election in a year's time would be decided. He was adamant that what he was advocating for was a bed levy - not a tax - and it wouldn't go to the government. "They [the government] use the word tax so they can say no more taxes. It's just dumb, it's not a tax any more than it would be a targeted rate. The people who've asked for it are the industry it would be collected from." He wanted it to be set at 2.5 percent which would raise $27 million which would be enough to attract the likes of a Taylor Swift concert or a State of Origin match. Cities need around $3 million to $4m to attract concerts by artists such as Taylor Swift, the Auckland mayor says. Photo: AFP Cities needed to pay upfront around $3m-4m to bring in each major event. It would enable Auckland to compete against the likes of Sydney which has a bed night levy, he said. "It doesn't cost the government anything. ... It doesn't make sense ..." When Auckland held large events and the hotels filled up, another $100 could be added to the cost of a hotel room "so noone's gonna miss it". It was also "bollocks" for the government to blame the cost of living crisis, Brown said. Those most affected couldn't afford $500 Taylor Swift concert tickets or to stay at the top hotels. He said the government was focused on tourism but had raised the international tourist levy so it was "cheeky" to deny Auckland a bed levy. Brown believed the government would "cave" on the issue, in part because Auckland was the region that decided the fate of the government at elections. He had built a good working relationship with some of the ministers, such as Chris Bishop and Shane Reti. "We have had a number of wins." He believed it was ACT that was the main handbrake on the government agreeing to the bed levy. Councillor Kerrin Leoni, who is standing against Brown in the city's upcoming mayoral election, said she also supported a bed tax. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
